Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Vol.%%04,%No.%01,%January%2024%
e-ISSN:%2807-8691,|,p-ISSN:%2807-839X$
!
IJSSR!!"#$%127!
!""#$%&&'()*(+,&-.*/0122&)3$$+*4/).-*0056
This%work%is%licensed%under%a%Attribution-ShareAlike%4.0%International%(CC%BY-SA%4.0)
Implementation+of+the+Modernization+Policy+of+the+Main+
Equipment+of+the+National+Maritime+Defense+Weapon+
System+(Study+on+Minimum+Essential+Force+Phase+II+2015-
2019)+
%
Gracia!Sarah!Armadani1,!Meidi!Kosandi2#
&"'()*+%,-%.,'/")%"01%!,)/*/'")%.'/$0'$23%40/5$62/*"2%%701,0$2/"3%701,0$2/"1,2%
89"/):%#6"'/";2"6"<=(/;"';/113%9$/1/;>,2"01/=(/;"';/12%%
Keywords$
,
ABSTRACT,
!"#$"%&"'()#*+,%-+.%/,+0(1233/#.4(
5630/7""(5,*+*"6",.4(5630/7""(
!"#8/#6+,$"4(1%,*+3/#"(
9/&"#,6",.(:*",$%";4(<=+%0+,'(
9/&"#,6",.(:*",$%";4(>,'/,";%+,(
9/&"#,6",.(:*",$%";?(
!
!
7!)$6 $"8'96 :;#<(+:$6 "!:6 )=#<:=:>"?")(>6 (@6 "!:6 A?49B$6 =?)>6
C:?#(>6$9$":=6=(':+>)D?")(>6#(<)E96)>6"!:6E(>":;"6(@6=::")>,6"!:6
F)>)=8=6 G$$:>")?<6 H(+E:$6 IFGHJ6 K!?$:6 LL6 @(+6 "!:6 M.-5NM.-26
#:+)('O6 C!($:6 =?)>6 @(E8$6 )$6 "(6 (4:+E(=:6 "!+:?"$6 "(6 >?")(>?<6
$:E8+)"9*67!:6#8+#($:6(@6"!:6$"8'96)$6"(6:;#<?)>6"!:6)=#<:=:>"?")(>6
#+(E:$$6 (@6 "!:6 A?49B$6 ':@:>$:6 :P8)#=:>"6 =(':+>)D?")(>6 #(<)E96
+:<?":'6"(6FGH6?>'6?>?<9D:6#(<)E96@?E"(+$6"!?"6?@@:E"6"!:6+:$8<"$6(@6
)"$6 )=#<:=:>"?")(>*6 Q$)>,6 ':@:>$:6 #(<)E96 '?"?6 ?>'6 "!:(+9O6 "!:6
$"8'96)':>")@):'6(R$"?E<:$6$8E!6?$6R8',:"6E(>$"+?)>"$O6')@@:+:>E:$6
)>68>':+$"?>')>,6R:"C::>6#(<)E96?E"(+$O6<:$$6(#")=?<6$8#:+4)$)(>O6
?>'6"!:6+(<:6(@6"!:6':@:>$:6)>'8$"+96"!?"6!?$6>("6R::>6=?;)=)D:'*6
S(E8=:>"6 :4?<8?")(>O6 )>":+4):C$O6 ?>'6 =(>)"(+)>,6 R96 ':@:>$:6
:;#:+"$6$!(C6"!?"6"!:6=?)>6E(>$"+?)>"6)$6>("638$"6+:<?":'6"(6<)=)":'6
+:$(8+E:$O6 R8"6 +?"!:+6 "(6 "!:6 )=R?<?>E:6 (@6 #(<)")E?<6 C)<<6 (@6 #(<)E96
?E"(+$*6 T(>$)$":>E96 (@6 )=#<:=:>"?")(>O6 E(==)"=:>"6 "(6
"+?>$#?+:>E9O6 ?EE(8>"?R)<)"9O6 ?>'6 )=#+(4:=:>"6 (@6 +:$(8+E:6
E?#?R)<)"):$6 "!+(8,!6 #+)(+)"96 $E?<:6 ?>'6 :=#(C:+=:>"6 (@6 "!:6
':@:>$:6 )>'8$"+96 +:P8)+:6 "!:6 $8##(+"6 (@6 #(<)")E?<6 C)<<*6 7!:6
E(>"+)R8")(>6(@6"!)$6+:$:?+E!6)>E<8':$6"!:6':4:<(#=:>"6(@6#(<)")E?<6
$E):>E:O6#?+")E8<?+<96)>6"!:6E(>":;"6(@6':@:>$:6?>'6$:E8+)"96#(<)")E$*6
7!:6 +:$8<"$6 E?>6 R:6 ?6 +:@:+:>E:6 @(+6 @8"8+:6 +:$:?+E!:+$6 C!(6 ?+:6
)>":+:$":'6 )>6 8>':+$"?>')>,6 "!:6 )$$8:6 (@6 ':@:>$:6 :P8)#=:>"6
=(':+>)D?")(>*6 7!:6 $8EE:$$@8<6 )=#<:=:>"?")(>6 (@6 "!)$6 #(<)E96 )$6
:;#:E":'6 "(6 !?4:6 ?6 $),>)@)E?>"6 )=#?E"6 (>6 >?")(>?<6 ':@:>$:6 ?>'6
>?")(>?<6 $:E8+)"96 #(<)E):$O6 C)"!6 "!:6 $8##(+"6 (@6 #(<)")E?<6 C)<<6
)':>")@):'6?$6"!:6=?)>6U:96"(6=)>)=)D)>,6E(>@<)E"$6(@6)>":+:$"6?>'6
)>E+:?$)>,6"!:6:@@:E")4:>:$$6(@6FGH6)=#<:=:>"?")(>O6=?)>"?)>)>,6
>?")(>?<6$:E8+)"9*6
,
,
INTRODUCTION,
?<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%0"*/,0")%1$-$02$%"/92%*,%1$-$01%0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*2%-6,9%"))%-,692%,-%*<6$"*2;%
A"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*2%"6$%#$0$6"))+%')"22/-/$1%/0*,%'"*$#,6/$2%"'',61/0#%*,%*<$/6%)$5$)%,-%(6#$0'+;%?</2%/2%1,0$%*,%
$02(6$%*<$%-,69()"*/,0%,-%1$-$02$%@,)/'/$2%/0%"'',61"0'$%B/*<%*<$%*<6$"*2%-"'$1%*,%*<$%0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*2%*,%
C$% 1$-$01$1;% D'',61/0#% *,% E"6*9"03% *<$% 0"*/,0")% /0*$6$2*% /2% 1/5/1$1% /0*,% *B,% 2*"#$2:% 5/*")% 0"*/,0")%"01%
2$',01"6+%0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*2;%F/*")%0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*2%"6$%C"2/'%*</0#2%*<"*%9(2*%C$%-()-/))$1%C$'"(2$%*<$+%
',0'$60%*<$%$G/2*$0'$%,-%"%2*"*$3%2('<%"2%/01$@$01$0'$3%/0*$#6/*+3%"01%2$'(6/*+%,-%'/*/H$02;%.$',01"6+%0"*/,0")%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research3%%
I6"'/"%."6"<%D69"1"0/13%J$/1/%K,2"01/2%
IJSSR !"#$%128%
/0*$6$2*%/2%"0%$G*$02/,0%,-%*<$%',9@6,9/2$1%5/*")%0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*3%9$"0/0#%*<"*%/*%B/))%0,*%*<6$"*$0%*<$%
2*"*$L2%$G/2*$0'$%2*"*$%/-%*<$+%"6$%0,*%-()-/))$1%MN(1</2*+6"%O%A(#6,<,3%PQRST;%%
70%U"B%A(9C$6%V%,-%PQPP%',0'$60/0#%.*"*$%W$-$02$3%/*%/2%2*"*$1%*<"*%2*"*$%1$-$02$%/2%"))%$--,6*2%*,%
1$-$01%2*"*$%2,5$6$/#0*+3%*<$%*$66/*,6/")%/0*$#6/*+%,-%*<$%40/*"6+%.*"*$%,-%*<$%X$@(C)/'%,-%701,0$2/"3%"01%*<$%
2"-$*+%,-%*<$%$0*/6$%0"*/,0%-6,9%*<6$"*2%"01%1/2*(6C"0'$2%*,%*<$%/0*$#6/*+%,-%*<$%0"*/,0%"01%2*"*$%MY<$0%$*%");3%
PQPVZ%W/6<"92+"<%$*%");3%PQPPT;%X$#"61/0#%*<$%701,0$2/"0%W$-$02$%[</*$%!"@$63%*<$%*<6$$%*</0#2%9"01"*$1%
C+% *<$% ',(0*6+L2% 1$-$02$% )"B% "6$% "C2,)(*$% 0"*/,0")% /0*$6$2*2%M.(@6/+"*0,3% PQRST;% 70% )/0$% B/*<% *<$%
')"22/-/'"*/,0%,-%0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*23%*<$%701,0$2/"0%W$-$02$%[</*$%!"@$6%1/5/1$2%*<$9%/0*,%*<6$$%'"*$#,6/$2:%
"C2,)(*$%0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*23%5/*")%0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*23%"01%/9@,6*"0*%0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*2%MJ/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$3%
PQR\T;%?<$%0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*%'"*$#,6+%/2%*<$%/0*$6$2*%/0%0"*/,0")%2$'(6/*+3%B</'<%',0'$602%2*"*$%2,5$6$/#0*+3%
*$66/*,6/")%/0*$#6/*+3%"01%*<$%2"-$*+%,-%*<$%$0*/6$%0"*/,0%-6,9%"))%-,692%,-%*<6$"*2%MA/01+"%O%DC/++"3%PQPPT;%%
?,%1$-$01% *<$% ',(0*6+3% ,0$% ,-% *<$% @6,C)$92% *<"*% "6/2$2% /2% *<$% $G/2*$0'$% ,-% *<6$"*2% *<"*% "6$% 0,*%
C")"0'$1%B/*<%*<$%',01/*/,0%,-%1$-$02$%@,2*(6$%"01%C(1#$*%MX/-"/%$*%");3%PQPPT;%W$-$02$%@,2*(6$%9"0/-$2*2%
*<$% "@@$"6"0'$% ,-% 2*6$0#*<3% '"@"C/)/*+3% "01% 1$@),+9$0*% ,-% 0"*/,0")% 6$2,(6'$2% )"/1% ,(*% /0% *<$% ',(0*6+L2%
1$-$02$%2+2*$9;%W$-$02$%@,2*(6$%/2%9/)/*"6+%@$62,00$)3%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*3%"01%2(@@,6*/0#%-"'/)/*/$2%"01%
/0-6"2*6('*(6$%M^($#$6%O%U/$C$*6"(3%PQPVZ%I_)'"0%O%86#/0$63%PQPVZ%J,6$/6"%$*%");3%PQPVT;%X$")/H/0#%*</2%#,")%
6$](/6$2%*<$%',(0*6+L2%',99/*9$0*%*,%C(/)1%"%9/0/9(9%1$-$02$%@,2*(6$3%"22(9/0#%/*%'"0%,5$6',9$%"'*(")%
*<6$"*2;%`0$%-,69%,-%*<$%#,5$609$0*L2%',99/*9$0*%*,%C(/)1/0#%1$-$02$%@,2*(6$%2*6$0#*<%/2%*,%-,69()"*$%"%
0"*/,0")%1$-$02$%@,2*(6$%1$5$),@9$0*%@,)/'+3%B</'<%B/))%C$%/9@)$9$0*$1%"2%"%J/0/9(9%822$0*/")%&,6'$%
MJ8&T%-6,9%PQRQ%*,%PQPS;%
J8&%/2%"%C"2/'%"01%9/0/9(9%-,6'$%2*"01"61%,-%*<$%?A73%B</'<%/2%"C2,)(*$)+%@6$@"6$1%"2%*<$%9"/0%
"01% -(01"9$0*")% @6$6$](/2/*$% -,6% $--$'*/5$)+% /9@)$9$0*/0#%*<$% 9"/0% *"2>2% "01% -(0'*/,02% ,-% *<$% ?A7% /0%
1$")/0#%B/*<%"'*(")%*<6$"*2%MD-$0+,%O% Y"$2"63%PQPVZ%E"0% $*%");3%PQPVZ%?(0'$6%O%Y/6@"03%PQPVT;% 7-%C6/$-)+%
(01$62*,,13%J8&%/2%"%#6"1(")%@6,'$22%*,%9$$*%*<$%9/0/9(9%2*"01"612%,-%*<$%',(0*6+L2%1$-$02$%2+2*$9%*<"*%
-,'(2$2%,0%*<$%',9@)$*$0$22%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*3%2('<%"2%$--,6*2%*,%9,1$60/H$%*<$%J"/0%8](/@9$0*%,-%*<$%
[$"@,0%.+2*$9%M1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*T;%?<$%-/62*%@6/,6/*+%-,6%*<$%6$")/H"*/,0%,-%J8&%/2%*,%/0'6$"2$%*<$%9,C/)/*+%
'"@"C/)/*/$2%,-%*<$%701,0$2/"0%D/6%&,6'$%M?A7%D4T3%A"5+%M?A7%DUT3%"01%?A7%D69+%M?A7%DWT%*,%2(@@,6*%*<$%
/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%*<$%9"/0%*"2>2%,-%*<$%?A7%*<6,(#<,(*%*<$%0"*/,0")%*$66/*,6+%M."6a/*,%$*%");3%PQRbZ%[/1,1,3%
PQRbT;%
J8&%!<"2$%7%B"2%@6$@"6$1%/0%*<$%PQRQcPQRS%2*6"*$#/'%@)"03%J8&%!<"2$%77%/0%*<$%PQR\cPQRb%2*6"*$#/'%
@)"03%"01%J8&%!<"2$%777%/0%*<$%PQPQcPQPS%2*6"*$#/'%@)"0;%J8&%',5$62%2$5$6")%"2@$'*23%/0')(1/0#%1$-$02$%
$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,03%9"/0*$0"0'$3%,6#"0/H"*/,0")%"01%/0-6"2*6('*(6$3%@6,-$22/,0")/293%B$)-"6$3%"01%
*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+;%?<$%*$69%J8&%/*2$)-%/2%(2$1%#/5$0%*<$%2$'(6/*+%',01/*/,02%*<"*%"6$%5()0$6"C)$%*,%*<6$"*2%
B</)$%*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%/2%)/9/*$1;%[/*<%*<$2$%',01/*/,023%*<$%1$-$02$%@,2*(6$%@,)/'+%)$"12%*,%*<$%-()-/))9$0*%
,-%9/0/9")%2*6$0#*<%B/*<%*<6$$%9"/0%"2@$'*23%0"9$)+%*<$%9,1$60/H"*/,0%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*3%9"/0*$0"0'$%
"01%9"/0*$0"0'$%M=+#@+.A%"01%/0-6"2*6('*(6$%M;+#3#+;A%"2%"%@6/,6/*+%MD)]"<*"0/%$*%");3%PQPVZ%E"6*,0,3%PQPRZ%
d/"0G/0#%$*%");3%PQPPZ%U$$%O%!"6>3%PQPQT;%%
J/0/2*$6%,-%W$-$02$%X$#()"*/,0%A(9C$6%P%,-%PQRQ%',0'$60/0#%*<$%J/0/9(9%822$0*/")%&,6'$%MJ8&T%
J"/0%Y,9@,0$0*%,-%*<$%701,0$2/"0%D69+%2*"*$2%*<"*%*<$%@,)/'+%/2%0,*%1/6$'*$1%"*%*<$%',0'$@*%,-%"0%"692%6"'$%
"01%1$5$),@9$0*%2*6"*$#+%*,%B/0%*,*")%B"6%C(*%"2%"%-,69%,-%C"2/'%-,6'$%*<"*%9$$*2%'$6*"/0%2*"01"612%"01%<"2%
"%1$*$66$0'$%$--$'*%ME"6*,0,3%PQPRT;%D2%"%@6/,6/*+%"#$01"%/0%J8&3%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0%6$-$62%
*,%*<$%"'</$5$9$0*%*"6#$*2%/0%$"'<%2*6"*$#/'%@)"0%*,%9$$*%*<$%9/0/9(9%2*6$0#*<;%?</2%@6,#6"9%1$5$),@2%
1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*% *<6,(#<% @6,'(6$9$0*% "01% $9@,B$62%*<$% 1$-$02$% /01(2*6+% *,% C(/)1% /01$@$01$0'$;%
701,0$2/"%"@@)/$2%*<$%',0'$@*%,-%'"@"C/)/*+cC"2$1%1$-$02$%/0%@)"00/0#%*<$%1$5$),@9$0*%,-%"%1$-$02$%-,6'$%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% <**@2:ee/a226;6/1B"0/02*/*(*$;',;/1e%
IJSSR!!"#$%129%
"2%/9@)$9$0*$1%/0%*<$%J8&%@6,#6"9;%Y"@"C/)/*+cC"2$1%1$-$02$%1$5$),@2%9/)/*"6+%@,B$63%/0')(1/0#%1$-$02$%
$](/@9$0*%-,6%/1$0*/-+/0#%C(1#$*"6+%'"@"C/)/*+cC"2$1%*<6$"*2%MK,5"'%$*%");3%PQRVT;%
?<$%9"/0%,Ca$'*/5$%,-%*</2%2*(1+%/2%*,%/1$0*/-+%"01%"0")+H$%*<$%/9C")"0'$%C$*B$$0%*<$%*<6$"*2%-"'$1%
"01%*<$%2*"*$%,-%1$-$02$%@,2*(6$3%"2%B$))%"2%*<$/6%/9@"'*%,0%*<$%',(0*6+L2%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%M&"a6/0"%$*%");3%
PQPQT;% 70% "11/*/,03% *</2% 2*(1+% "/92% *,% @6,5/1$% @,)/'+% 6$',99$01"*/,02% *,% ,@*/9/H$% 1$-$02$% @,2*(6$%
"'',61/0#% *,% "'*(")% "01% @,*$0*/")% *<6$"*2;% ?<$% 6$2()*2% ,-% *</2% 2*(1+% "6$% $G@$'*$1% *,% ',0*6/C(*$% *,% *<$%
1$5$),@9$0*% ,-% *<$% ',(0*6+L2% 1$-$02$% @,)/'+% *<"*% /2% 9,6$% "1"@*/5$% *,% *<6$"*% 1+0"9/'2;% ?<$% @,2/*/5$%
/9@)/'"*/,0%/2%/0'6$"2$1%$--$'*/5$0$22%/0%9/*/#"*/0#%6/2>2%"01%9"/0*"/0/0#%0"*/,0")%2$'(6/*+%C+%*<$%"C2,)(*$%
0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*;%
!
METHODS,
?</2%6$2$"6'<%"1,@*2%"%](")/*"*/5$%"@@6,"'<3%C+%*<$%1$-/0/*/,0%,-%Y6$2B$))%MPQRPT3%B</'<%2*"*$2%*<"*%
"%](")/*"*/5$%"@@6,"'<%/2%"%@6,'$22%,-%6$2$"6'<%"01%(01$62*"01/0#%C"2$1%,0%"%9$*<,1,),#+%*<"*%/05$2*/#"*$2%
2,'/")%@<$0,9$0"%"01%<(9"0%@6,C)$92;%?<$%6$2$"6'<%9$*<,1%'<,2$0%/2%"%'"2$%2*(1+3%B</'<%-,'(2$2%,0%"0%
/0c1$@*<%"0")+2/2%,-%"%@"6*/'()"6%'"2$%/0%',0*$9@,6"6+%)/-$;%?</2%6$2$"6'<%)/9/*2%/*2%'"2$%*,%*<$%701,0$2/"0%
A"5+L2%MJ8&T%W$-$02$%8](/@9$0*%J,1$60/H"*/,0%@,)/'+%/0%PQR\cPQRb;%
?<$% 6$2$"6'<% ,Ca$'*% /0')(1$2% 5"6/,(2% @"6*/$2% 6$)"*$1% *,% /9@)$9$0*/0#%J8&% @,)/'+3% /05,)5/0#% *<$%
#,5$609$0*3%(2$62%M?A7%DUT3%2(@$65/2,62%"01%$5")("*,62%MY,99/22/,0%7%,-%*<$%E,(2$%,-%X$@6$2$0*"*/5$2T3%
"01%1$-$02$%"01%9/)/*"6+%,C2$65$62;%?<$%)/2*%,-%6$2$"6'<%/0-,69"0*2%/0')(1$1%J"6/0$%Y,),0$)%MET%W6;%.*$5$0%
?,"6% ."9C,(B3% J"6/0$% U/$(*$0"0*% Y,),0$)% D01/% .(6+"3% ?A7% &/62*% J"62<")% U"*/-% D/0()% N"]/03% ?A7% X$"6%
D19/6")% W6;% 7B"0% 720(B"0*,3% J$(*+"% E"-/13% "01% W6;% Y,00/$% X"<">(01/0/% ^">6/$;% ?<$% 1$*$69/0"*/,0% ,-%
/0-,69"0*2% /2% '"66/$1% ,(*% @(6@,2/5$)+3% ',02/1$6/0#%*<"*% *<$+% <"5$% 6$)$5"0'$% "01% 6$)$5"0*% /0-,69"*/,0%
6$)"*$1%*,%*<$%6$2$"6'<;%
?</2%2*(1+L2%9"/0%1"*"%',))$'*/,0%*$'<0/]($%B"2%*<$%/0c1$@*<%/0*$65/$B3%B</'<%B"2%',01('*$1%(2/0#%
2$9/c2*6('*(6$1%/0*$65/$B%#(/1$)/0$2;%?</2%"@@6,"'<%")),B2%6$2$"6'<$62%*,%#"/0%"%1$$@%(01$62*"01/0#%,-%*<$%
@6,'$22% ,-% 16"-*/0#% "01% /9@)$9$0*/0#% J8&% @,)/'/$2;% 70% "11/*/,03% *</2% 2*(1+% ")2,% (2$1% 2$',01"6+% 1"*"%
,C*"/0$1% *<6,(#<% 1,'(9$0*% 2$"6'<3% C+%Y6$2B$))L2% MPQRPT%2(##$2*/,0% *<"*% 1,'(9$0*2% '"0% C$% "% 5")("C)$%
2,(6'$%,-%/0-,69"*/,0%/0%](")/*"*/5$%6$2$"6'<;%
?<$% 1"*"% "0")+2/2% @6,'$22% (2$2%*<$% J/)$2% "01% E(C$69"0% J,1$)3% B</'<% /05,)5$2% 1"*"% 6$1('*/,03%
@6$2$0*"*/,03% "01% 5$6/-/'"*/,0;% W"*"% 6$1('*/,0% /2% 1,0$%C+% 2(99"6/H/0#% "01% 2$)$'*/0#% /9@,6*"0*% @,/0*2%
"1a(2*$1% *,% *<$% 9/)/*"6+% "01% @,)/*/'")% *<$,6/$2;% ?<$% @6$2$0*"*/,0% ,-% 1"*"% /2% '"66/$1% ,(*% 0"66"*/5$)+% "01%
1$2'6/@*/5$)+;%70%',0*6"2*3%5$6/-/'"*/,0%/2%'"66/$1%,(*%*<6,(#<%1"*"%*6/"0#()"*/,0%C+%',9@"6/0#%*<$%6$2()*2%,-%
/0*$65/$B2%B/*<%1"*"%-6,9%,C2$65"*/,023%',01/*/,023%"01%@$62@$'*/5$2%,-%/0-,69"0*2%B/*<%*<$%5/$B2%,-%*<$%
#$0$6")%@(C)/'%"01%</#<)+%$1('"*$1%@"6*/$2%"01%',9@"6/0#%*<$%6$2()*2%,-%/0*$65/$B2%B/*<%,*<$6%6$)$5"0*%
2$',01"6+%1"*"%2,(6'$2%M.(#/+,0,3%PQQfT;%?</2%1"*"%"0")+2/2%/2%*<$%C"2/2%-,6%',0')(1/0#%6$2$"6'<%-/01/0#2%
,0%/9@)$9$0*/0#%J8&%@,)/'/$2%/0%PQR\cPQRb;%
%
RESULTS,
Implementation!of!Sea!Defense!Equipment!Modernization!Policy!to!Fulfill!the!Minimum!Essential!
Force!(MEF)!
1. Budget!Realization!
?<$% J/0/2*6+% ,-% W$-$02$% "01% *<$% ?A7% 2"/1% *<"*3% /0% #$0$6")3% *<$% 6$"2,0% -,6%0,*% "'</$5/0#% *<$%
1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0%*"6#$*%/0%*<$%*B,%J8&%2*"#$2%/2%C(1#$*%',02*6"/0*2;%?<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%
W$-$02$%")2,%6$5$")$1%*<"*%*<$%/0'6$"2$%/0%*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%/0%*<$%)"2*%*$0%+$"62%1,$2%0,*%0$'$22"6/)+%
9$$*% 2@$01/0#% ,0% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*% C$'"(2$3%',9@"6$1% *,% ,*<$6% ',(0*6/$23% *<$% @$6'$0*"#$% ,-%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research3%%
I6"'/"%."6"<%D69"1"0/13%J$/1/%K,2"01/2%
IJSSR !"#$%130%
701,0$2/"L2%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%*,%IW!%/2%2*/))%6$)"*/5$)+%),B;%?</2%/2%$5/1$0'$1%C+%"0%/0*$65/$B%B/*<%J"6/0$%
U/$(*$0"0*%Y,),0$)%D01/%.(6+"3%B<,%2"/1%*<"*%*<$%9"/0%@6,C)$9%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%@6,'(6$9$0*%
@6,'$22% /0% *<$% *B,% 2*"#$2% ,-% J8&% 0,*% 9$$*/0#%*<$% *"6#$*% /2% C(1#$*% ',02*6"/0*2;% ?</2% /2% C$'"(2$%
701,0$2/"L2%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%/2% 2*/))% 6$)"*/5$)+%29"))%',9@"6$1%*,% ,*<$6%',(0*6/$23%*<(2% </01$6/0#%*<$%
J/0/2*6+% ,-% W$-$02$% "01% ?A7% -6,9% '"66+/0#% ,(*% *<$% @6,'$22% ,-% @(6'<"2/0#% *<$% 0$'$22"6+% 1$-$02$%
$](/@9$0*;%
^"2$1% ,0% 1"*"% -6,9% *<$% .*,'><,)9% 70*$60"*/,0")% !$"'$% X$2$"6'<% 702*/*(*$% M.7!X7T% /0% PQRb3%
701,0$2/"L2%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%*,%IW!%/0%PQQbcPQRg%/2%2*/))%C$),B%Rh3%,6%C$),B%*<$%"5$6"#$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%
/0%D.8DA%',(0*6/$2;%^"2$1%,0%^!.%1"*"3%IW!%C"2$1%,0%'(66$0*%@6/'$2%/0%PQRb%B"2%7WX%R\3gVV;b%*6/))/,0%
M?/"0%$*%");3%PQPQT;%?</2%2<,B2%*<"*%PQRb%*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%")),'"*/,0%B"2%,0)+%Q;igh%,-%IW!;%70%*<$%
2*6"*$#/'%@)"0%,-%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$%"01%?A7%-,6%PQR\cPQRb3%/*%/2%2*"*$1%*<"*%*<$6$%/2%"%*"6#$*%*,%
/0'6$"2$%*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%*,%R;\h%,-%IW!;%^(*%(0*/)%0,B3%/*%<"2%0,*%C$$0%"'</$5$1;%
D% 1/--$6$0*% ,@/0/,0% B"2% ',05$+$1% C+% Y,00/$% X"<">(01/0/% ^">6/$3% B<,% 2"/1% *<"*% C(1#$*%
',02*6"/0*2%B$6$%0,*%*<$%9"/0%'"(2$%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0%0,*%6$"'</0#%*<$%*"6#$*3%C(*%
6"*<$6% 1$-$02$% 9"0"#$9$0*e1$-$02$% #,5$60"0'$3%B</'<% B"2% 2*/))% (0')$"6;% ?<$% "C2$0'$% ,-% "% #6"01%
2*6"*$#+% -,6% 701,0$2/"L2% 1$-$02$% /2% *<$% 6$"2,0% -,6%0,*% "'</$5/0#% J8&L2% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*%
9,1$60/H"*/,0%*"6#$*;%?</2%/2%")2,%C$'"(2$%J8&%/2%2*/))%2$$0%,0)+%"2%"%@,)/'+%B<,2$%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%
@6,'(6$9$0*%*"6#$*%9(2*%C$%9$*%/0%$"'<%@$6/,13%0,*%,0%*<$%@6/,6/*+%,-%*<6$"*2%*,%701,0$2/"L2%1$-$02$;%%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
Figure!1.!Development!of!the!Defense!Budget!for!2015-2019!(in!trillions)!
.,(6'$:%J$9,6"01(9%,-%&/0"0'$%"01%.*"*$%^(1#$*%PQPQ3%J/0/2*6+%,-%&/0"0'$%
%
X$#"61/0#%*<$%2*"*$%C(1#$*%@,2*(6$3%*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%/0%/9@)$9$0*/0#%J8&%!<"2$%77%/0%PQR\c
PQRb%<"2%/0'6$"2$1%2/#0/-/'"0*)+%',9@"6$1%*,%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%J8&%!<"2$%7%/0%PQRQcPQRS;%^"2$1%
,0%"%-/0"0'/")%9$9,6"01(9%6$)$"2$1%C+%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%&/0"0'$3%*<$%PQR\%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%"9,(0*$1%*,%
X@%RQR;f%*6/))/,0Z%/0%PQRi3%/*%"9,(0*$1%*,%X@%bg;P%?6/))/,0Z%/0%PQRf3%"9,(0*$1%*,%X@%RRf;i%*6/))/,0Z%/0%
PQRg3%/*%"9,(0*$1%*,%X@%RQi;f%*6/))/,0Z%"01%/0%PQRb3%"9,(0*$1%*,%X@%RR\;S%?6/))/,0;%?<$%*,*")%1$-$02$%
C(1#$*%1$6/5$1%-6,9%*<$%PQR\%*,%PQRb%2*"*$%C(1#$*%"9,(0*$1%*,%\Vb%*6/))/,03%<$6$/0"-*$6%6$-$66$1%*,%"2%
*<$%2,(6'$%,-%*<$%@(6$%6(@/"<%MXJT%C(1#$*;%^"2$1%,0%1"*"%,C*"/0$1%-6,9%J8&%$5")("*/,0%1,'(9$0*23%
XJL2%C(1#$*%/2%(2$1%,0)+%Pb;bh%-,6%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0;%70%,*<$6%B,6123%"C,(*%fQh%,-%
*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%1$6/5$1%-6,9%*<$%2*"*$%C(1#$*%/2%(2$1%-,6%6,(*/0$%$G@$02$2;%?,%9$$*%*<$%)"'>%,-%
C(1#$*%/01/'"*/,02%MC"2$1)/0$T3%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0%(2$2%-(012%1$6/5$1%-6,9%W,9$2*/'%
U,"02%M!WAT%"01%&,6$/#0%U,"02%M!UAT%B/*<%8G@,6*%Y6$1/*%M8YT%9$'<"0/292;%%
Defense&Budget&
Growth&
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% <**@2:ee/a226;6/1B"0/02*/*(*$;',;/1e%
IJSSR!!"#$%131%
70-,69"*/,0%,C*"/0$1%-6,9%*<$%W/6$'*,6"*$%I$0$6")%,-%W$-$02$%!)"00/0#%2*"*$2%/9@)/'/*)+%*<"*%
*<$%)/9/*$1%C(1#$*%"5"/)"C)$%/0%@(6$%6(@/"<%/2%,0$%,-%*<$%-"'*,62%'"(2/0#%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%J8&%0,*%
*,%2(''$$1%/0%"'</$5/0#%*<$%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0%*"6#$*;%J,6$,5$63%*<$%A"5+L2%1$-$02$%
$](/@9$0*% /2% 9('<% 9,6$% $G@$02/5$%"01%,-*$0% (2$1% *<"0% !WA% ,6% !UA;% &6,9% 1"*"% @6,5/1$1% C+% *<$%
W/6$'*,6"*$% I$0$6")% ,-% W$-$02$% !)"00/0#3% *<$% @$6'$0*"#$% ,-% 1$*"/)$1% 2,(6'$2% ,-% -(012% -,6% 1$-$02$%
$](/@9$0*% 9,1$60/H"*/,0% *<6,(#<% J8&% @<"2$% 77% /0% PQR\cPQRb% /2% !UA% Pb;\\h3% !WA% gR;V\h3% XJ!%
VV;fgh3%"01%XJ%PR;bbh;%
[/1a"1a"0*,% 2"/1% *<"*% ,0$% ,-% *<$% 6$"2,02% *<"*% 9">$2% /*% 1/--/'()*% -,6% 701,0$2/"% *,% 1$5$),@% "%
9,1$60%"01%6$2/)/$0*%1$-$02$%@,2*(6$%/2%*<$%@)"'$9$0*%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%"2%"%1$*$69/0"0*%,-%*<$%
1$5$),@9$0*% ,-% 701,0$2/"L2% 1$-$02$% @,2*(6$;% W$-$02$% C(1#$*2% 2<,()1% C$% 5/$B$1% "2% "% 1$@$01$0*%
5"6/"C)$3% 0,*% "0% /01$@$01$0*% ,0$;% ?<$% @)"'$9$0*% ,-% *<$2$% -6$$% 5"6/"C)$2% '"(2$2% 1$5/"*/,02% "01%
(*/)/H"*/,0%,-%0,0cD!^A%-(01%-),B23%B</'<%1"9"#$%*<$%#,5$60"0'$%,-%1$-$02$%C(1#$*/0#3%B<,2$%2,(6'$2%
9(2*%',9$%-6,9%*<$%#,5$609$0*%*<6,(#<%*<$%D!^A;%%?<$%$0"'*9$0*%,-%1$@$01$0*%5"6/"C)$2%B/))%-,6'$%
*<$%2*"*$%*,%-,69()"*$%"%1$-$02$%@,)/'+%"'',9@"0/$1%C+%1$*$69/0/0#%*<$%"9,(0*%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*3%
0,*%5/'$%5$62"3%*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%*<"*%1/6$'*2%1$-$02$%@,)/'+%M[/1a"a"0*,3%PQRQT;%
Y,9@)$*/0#%[/1a"a"0*,L2%2*"*$9$0*3%Y,),0$)%.*$5$0%"6#($1%*<"*%*<$%"C2,6@*/,0%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%
C(1#$*%")),'"*/,0%B"2%#6$"*$6%-,6%6,(*/0$%',2*2;%?<$%)"6#$2*%")),'"*/,0%,-%6,(*/0$%$G@$02$2%/2%2")"6/$23%
B</)$%*<$%H$6,%#6,B*<%@,)/'+%/0%*<$%?A7%/2%0,*%/9@)$9$0*$1;%j$6,%#6,B*<%@,)/'+%/2%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%
,-%*<$%"''$@*"0'$%,-%?A7%@$62,00$)%B/*<%2$5$6")%6$*/6$1%?A7%@$62,00$);%7*%"/92%*,%6$1('$%*<$%1$-$02$%
C(1#$*%")),'"*/,0%-,6%6,(*/0$%',2*2%2('<%"2%2")"6/$2%"01%@$62,00$)%")),B"0'$2%2,%*<"*%*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%
'"0%C$%")),'"*$1%9,6$%-,6%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0;%%
70%"11/*/,0%*,%*<$%@6,C)$9%,-%6,(*/0$%',2*2%"01%H$6,%#6,B*<3%*<$%@6$@"6"*/,0%,-%"%C)($@6/0*%-,6%
1$-$02$%C(1#$*%9"0"#$9$0*%-6,9%*<$%.*"*$%^(1#$*%2<,()1%C$%")),'"*$1%*,%-()-/))%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%,0%
"%</#<c@6/,6/*+%2'")$;%.*/))3%*<$%-"'*%/2%*<"*%*<$%2@$'/-/$1%@6,'(6$9$0*%/2%0,*%*<$%9"/0%0$$1;%W"*"%/0%*<$%
J8&%$5")("*/,0%1,'(9$0*%2<,B2%*<"*%*<$%C(1#$*%-6,9%*<$%2*"*$%C(1#$*%/2%")),'"*$1%-,6%*<$%@6,'(6$9$0*%
,-% C())$*@6,,-% <$)9$*2% *,% *"0>% '<"/023% B</'<% /2% 0,*% "% @6/,6/*+% 0$$1;% ?</2% /2% $5/1$0*% -6,9% *<$%
"'</$5$9$0*2%,-%*<$%D69+%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*3%B</'<%/2%-"6%9,6$%*<"0%*<$%A"5+%"01%D/6%&,6'$%C$'"(2$%
/*%/2%9$0*/,0$1%*<"*%)"01%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%'"0%C$%2"/1%*,%C$%'<$"@$6%"01%$"2/$6%*,%,C*"/0;%`0%*<$%,*<$6%
<"013%Y,00/$%X"<">(01/0/%^">6/$%")2,%6$5$")$1%*<"*%*<$6$%<"2%C$$0%0,%@6,@,6*/,0")%C(1#$*%")),'"*/,0%
1($%*,%*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%9"0"#$9$0*%C)($@6/0*%0,*%C$/0#%C+%*<$%0$$12%,-%@6/,6/*+%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*;%%
^"2$1%,0%^">6/$L2%2*"*$9$0*3%/*%'"0%C$%2"/1%*<"*%*<$%-()-/))9$0*%,-%*<$%A"5+L2%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%
<"2%0,*%6$"'<$1%*<$%*"6#$*%1($%*,%C(1#$*%',02*6"/0*2;%E,B$5$63%*<$%9"/0%@6,C)$9%)/$2%0,*%/0%*<$%)"'>%,-%
C(1#$*% C(*% /0% 1$-$02$% #,5$60"0'$;% % X$#"61/0#% *<$% @6/,6/*+% 2'")$%-,6% *<$% -()-/))9$0*% ,-% 1$-$02$%
$](/@9$0*3% "% 2*"*$9$0*% -6,9% !6$2/1$0*% d,>,% [/1,1,% ")2,% $9@<"2/H$1% *<"*% *<$% ?A7% ',02/1$62% *<$%
@6/,6/*+%2'")$%C$-,6$%C(+/0#%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*3%"01%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%2@$01/0#%9(2*%C$%1,0$%B/2$)+3%
C,*<%/0%2/H$%"01%")),'"*/,0;%?</2%/2%"0%/01$@$01$0*%5"6/"C)$%/0%*<$%(2$%,-%C(1#$*23%2,%/9@)$9$0*$62%0$$1%
*,%',9@/)$%C)($@6/0*2%"2%"%C"2/2%-,6%1$'/2/,0c9">/0#%/0%9"0"#/0#%C(1#$*2%,(*2/1$%,-%6,(*/0$%',2*2;%%
W$'/2/,0c9">/0#% 6$#"61/0#% 1$-$02$% C(1#$*% 9"0"#$9$0*% ")2,% 6$](/6$2% "@@6,5")% -6,9%
Y,99/22/,0%7%,-%*<$%E,(2$%,-%X$@6$2$0*"*/5$23%B</'<3%/0%-"'*3%2(@@,6*2%*<$%@6,'(6$9$0*%,-%?A7%1$-$02$%
$](/@9$0*%*,%"'</$5$%*"6#$*2;%?</2%2(@@,6*%'"0%C$%@6,5$0%C+%"@@6,5/0#%"%2/#0/-/'"0*%/0'6$"2$%/0%1$-$02$%
C(1#$*;%E,B$5$63%*<$6$%"6$%")2,%"))$#"*/,02%,-%',0-)/'*2%,-%/0*$6$2*%B<$0%*<$%1$'/2/,02%*">$0%"6$%0,*%C+%
0$$123% 2(@@,6*$1% ")2,% C$'"(2$% *<$% @6,'(6$9$0*% ,-% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*% 2*/))% (2$2% *<$% 2$65/'$2% ,-%
/0*$69$1/"6/$2% MC6,>$62T% B<,% "6$% )$22% *6"02@"6$0*3% '"(2/0#% $G@$02$2% *,% 2B$));% .('<% /0*$69$1/"6/$2%
,-*$0%/0-)($0'$%#,5$609$0*%@,)/'+%6$#"61/0#%2*6,0#%@,)/*/'")%',00$'*/,02%*,%'$6*"/0%@"6*/$2;%?<$%-(012%
B"2*$1% *,% </6$% /0*$69$1/"6+% 2$65/'$2% "6$% (0C")"0'$1% "01% '"0% C$% 2$$0% /0% *<$% /0"1$]("*$% ](")/*+% ,-%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research3%%
I6"'/"%."6"<%D69"1"0/13%J$/1/%K,2"01/2%
IJSSR !"#$%132%
1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*;% D2% "% 6$2()*3% 9"0+% "''/1$0*2% "6$% '"(2$1% C+% ,C2,)$*$% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*3% ,0$%
$G"9@)$%/2%*<$%KX7%A"0##")"%SQP%.(C9"6/0$%B</'<%2"0>%M2(C2(0>T%/0%PQPR;%E,B$5$63%*</2%/2%'$6*"/0)+%
1$0/$1%C+%Y,99/22/,0%73%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$3%"01%*<$%?A7;%
2. Different!views!of!policy!actors!on!the!MEF!
!?<6,(#<% /0*$65/$B2% B/*<% Y,),0$)% .*$5$0% /*% B"2% 6$5$")$1% *<"*% *<$6$% /2% "% 1/--$6$0*%
(01$62*"01/0#%,-%J8&%"9,0#%@,)/'+%"'*,62;%?<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$%"01%*<$%?A7%1$-/0$%J8&%"2%*<$%
9,1$60/H"*/,0% ,-% ?A7% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*% B/*<% 2(@@,6*/0#% -"'/)/*/$2% "01% /0-6"2*6('*(6$3% B</)$% *<$%
J/0/2*6+%,-%&/0"0'$%"01%^"@@$0"2%(01$62*"01%J8&%"2%)/9/*$1%*,%@6,'(6/0#%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%B/*<,(*%
2(@@,6*/0#%-"'/)/*/$2%"01%/0-6"2*6('*(6$;%?<$%1/--$6$0'$%/0%(01$62*"01/0#%")2,%"--$'*2%C(1#$*%@,)/'+%"01%
6$2()*2%/0%*<$%C(1#$*%"@@6,5$1%C+%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%&/0"0'$%,0)+%@6,'(6/0#%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*3%2,%*<"*%
1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%@6,'(6$9$0*%/2%,-*$0%'<"0#$1%,6%'"0'$)$1;%%
%D2%@6$5/,(2)+%$G@)"/0$13%^"@@$0"2%X7%9">$2%"1a(2*9$0*2%C$*B$$0%*<$%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%
0$$12% @)"0% C$*B$$0% X!d!A3% X!dJA3% "01% *<$% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*% 2<,@@/0#% )/2*% 2(C9/**$1% C+% *<$%
701,0$2/"0%J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$%"01%*<$%?A7;%`0%*<$%,*<$6%<"013%"2%*<$%2*"*$%*6$"2(6$63%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%
&/0"0'$%<"2%*<$%6/#<*%*,%")),'"*$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*2%-6,9%*<$%2*"*$%C(1#$*%"01%1$*$69/0$%*<$%9$'<"0/29%
,-%1,9$2*/'%),"02%"01%$G@,6*%'6$1/*2;%7-%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%&/0"0'$%"01%^"@@$0"2%1,%0,*%")),'"*$%"%C(1#$*%
*,%C(/)1%1$-$02$%/0-6"2*6('*(6$3%*<$%A"5+%"22(9$2%*<"*%*<$%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%@6,'(6$9$0*%@6,'$22%
'"00,*%',0*/0($;%%
&6,9% *<$% D26$0"% ?A7% DU3% D19/6")% 7B"0% 720(B"0*,% 2"/1% *<"*% 1$5$),@/0#%-"'/)/*/$2% "01%
/0-6"2*6('*(6$% B/*</0% *<$% A"5+% /2% 0,% )$22% /9@,6*"0*% *<"0% *<$% 9,1$60/H"*/,0% ,-% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*%
/0')(1$1%/0%*<$%J8&%2*6"*$#/'%@)"0;%?<$%9,1$60/H"*/,0%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9(2*%C$%C")"0'$1%B/*<%/*2%
/0-6"2*6('*(6$%"01%5/'$%5$62";%&,6%$G"9@)$3%*<$%*6"02-$6%,-%*<$%A"5+%!/$6%/0%E"),0#%F/))"#$%<"1%*,%C$%
9,5$1% *,% *<$% A"5+% !/$6% /0% ?"B/6/% F/))"#$3% D9C,0% ^"+% D6$"3% J")(>(3%C$'"(2$% *<$% A"5+L2% *,00"#$%
B"62</@2%B$6$%C),'>$1%-6,9%)$"0/0#%"-*$6%*<$%',02*6('*/,0%,-%*<$%X$1%"01%[</*$%^6/1#$%C+%*<$%J/0/2*6+%
,-%!4!X;%^(*%"0,*<$6%@6,C)$9%/2%*<"*%*<$%0$B%@/$6%/2%0,*%)"6#$%$0,(#<%*,%C$%"%C"2$3%9">/0#%*<$%]($($%
,-%2</@2%),0#%$0,(#<%*,%)$"0%,0;%?</2%/2%,0$%$G"9@)$%,-%<,B%C(+/0#%2</@2%*,%9$$*%*"6#$*2%/2%/9@,22/C)$%
B/*<,(*%',0*/0(,(2%2(@@,6*/0#%-"'/)/*/$2;%
70% "11/*/,0% *,% 1/--$6$0'$2% /0% 5/$B2% ,0% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*% "01% 2(@@,6*/0#% -"'/)/*/$2% "01%
/0-6"2*6('*(6$%C$*B$$0%6$)"*$1%/02*/*(*/,023%*<$6$%"6$%")2,%1/--$6$0'$2%/0%5/$B2%,0%*<$%9,1$60/H"*/,0%,-%
1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%B/*</0%*<$%?A7;%D2%"%9/)/*"6+%"01%1$-$02$%,C2$65$63%Y,00/$%X"<">(01/0/%^">6/$%2$$2%
*<"*%2*6('*(6")%@6,C)$92%</01$6%6$")/H/0#%"0%/0*$#6"*$1%2+2*$9;%?</2%C"2/'%*</0#%*<$0%C$'"9$%"%@6,C)$9%
/0%/9@)$9$0*/0#%*<$%9,1$60/H"*/,0%,-%2$"%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*3%B</'<%1/1%0,*%#,%B$));%?<$6$%9(2*%C$%"%
',9@)$*$%(01$62*"01/0#%"01%',99,0%@$6'$@*/,0%,-%J"6/*/9$%W$-$02$;%%
?<$%@6/,6/*+%,-%-()-/))/0#%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%'$6*"/0)+%5"6/$2%"'',61/0#%*,%*<$%/0*$6$2*2%,-%*<$%
9"*6"3%C(*%*<$2$%1/--$6$0'$2%"6$%*,,%/01/'"*/5$%,-%2$'*,6")%$#,%/0*$6$2*2;%?</2%,@/0/,0%B"2%',05$+$1%C+%
Y,),0$)%.*$5$03%B<,%2*"*$1%*<"*%*<$%1/--$6$0*%(01$62*"01/0#%,-%J8&%"9,0#%*<$2$%/02*/*(*/,02%',0'$602%
2$'*,6")%$#,2;%.$'*,6")%$#,%/2%,0$%,-%*<$%,C2*"')$2%*,%/9@)$9$0*/0#%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0%
@,)/'+;%7*%/2%")2,%2"/1%*<"*%/*%<"2%C$',9$%0,69")%/-%*<$6$%/2%"%2$'*,6")%$#,%1+0"9/'3%C(*%/*%/2%0,*%'"66/$1%
,(*%C+%"#$0'/$2%2*6('*(6"))+%C(*%C+%/01/5/1(")2;%D)*<,(#<%2,9$%"2@$'*2%,-%*<$%@,)/'+%<"5$%C$$0%B$))%
6$#()"*$13%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%/2%,-*$0%C$+,01%@)"00$1;%E,B$5$63%/0%*<$%J/0/2*$6%,-%W$-$02$%X$#()"*/,0%
0(9C$6%RR%,-%PQPV3%*<$%"/6%"01%2$"%C(1#$*%/2%#/5$0%"%)"6#$6%@,6*/,0%/0%*<$%J8&%@,)/'+%"2@$'*;%70%"11/*/,0%
*,%9$$*/0#%*<$%J8&%*"6#$*3%*</2%/2%1,0$%*,%6$")/H$%701,0$2/"L2%5/2/,0%"2%*<$%B,6)1L2%9"6/*/9$%"G/2;%
`0% *<$% ,*<$6% <"013% Y,00/$% X"<">(01/0/% ^">6/$% C$)/$5$2% *<"*% /0% 2,9$% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*%
-()-/))9$0*% @)"023% *</2% 2$'*,6")% $#,% @6,C)$9% /2% "'*("))+% (2$1% "2% "0% $G'(2$% *,% '<"0#$% *<$% 1$-$02$%
$](/@9$0*%@(6'<"2$%@)"0;%?<$%6$"2,0%-,6%0,*%C$/0#%"@@6,5$1%C+%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%&/0"0'$%"01%^"@@$0"2%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% <**@2:ee/a226;6/1B"0/02*/*(*$;',;/1e%
IJSSR!!"#$%133%
/2%*<"*%*<$%@)"0%*,%@(6'<"2$%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%/2%,-*$0%"0%,@@,6*(0/*+%*,%'<"0#$%*<$%@(6'<"2$%,-%,*<$6%
1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%0,*%/0%*<$%2*6"*$#/'%@)"0;%?</2%',01/*/,0%/2%"%),,@<,)$%-,6%*<$%$0*6+%,-%$0*6(2*9$0*2%
,-%/0*$6$2*2%-6,9%"692%C6,>$62;%%
^">6/$L2%2*"*$9$0*%/))(2*6"*$2%"%-,69%,-%"**6"'*/,0%,-%/0*$6$2*%"9/1%@,)/'+%"'*,62%*,%'<"0#$%*<$%
?A7%DU%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%2<,@@/0#%)/2*%-,6%'$6*"/0%/0*$6$2*2;%85$0%2,%-"63%*<$%$G/2*$0'$%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%
9"-/"%,6%"692%C6,>$62%<"2%C$$0%',02/1$6$1%"0%,@$0%2$'6$*3%"01%9"0+%@"6*/$2%>0,B%/*;%?<$%),B%$--,6*%*,%
-/01%"%B"+%,(*%,-%2$'*,6")%$#,2%2<,B2%2*">$<,)1$62L%"C2$0'$%,-%@,)/*/'")%B/))%/0%*<$%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%
9,1$60/H"*/,0% "#$01";% ?<$% 1$'/2/,0% *,% '<"0#$% *<$% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*%@(6'<"2$% @)"0% 0,*% C+%J8&L2%
,Ca$'*/5$2%/2%')$"6)+%0,*%6"*/,0");%766"*/,0")%1$'/2/,02%*<"*%"6$%*<$0%@"22$1%-,6%$G$'(*/,0%"6$%$5/1$0'$%,-%
'$6*"/0%/0*$6$2*2;%7*%")2,%6$)"*$2%*,%"'*,62%B<,%@)"+%"%6,)$%/0%2(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,);%%
3. Supervision!and!Control!Not!Optimal!
?<$%J8&%@<"2$%77%$5")("*/,0%1,'(9$0*%-,6%PQR\cPQRb%2*"*$1%*<"*%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%<"1%0,*%
9$*%*<$%X!d!A%*"6#$*%1($%*,%)$22%*<"0%,@*/9")%2(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%,-%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%J8&%
1$5$),@9$0*;%.(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%/0')(1$%*<$%@)"00/0#%@6,'$22%*,%@,)/'+%$G$'(*/,0;%?<$%6$2()*2%,-%
*<$%/0*$65/$B%B/*<%Y,),0$)%.*$5$0% ")2,% ',0-/69$1% *<"*% /0% "11/*/,0% *,%*<$% C(1#$*% "01%2$'*,6")% $#,23%
2(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%*<"*%B$6$%0,*%,@*/9")%B$6$%*<$%9"/0%'"(2$2%,-%'<"0#$2%/0%*<$%?A7%2<,@@/0#%
)/2*%/0%*<$%9/11)$%,-%*<$%'(66$0*%-/0"0'/")%+$"6;%.(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%*<"*%"6$%0,*%'"66/$1%,(*%@6,@$6)+%
B/))%6$2()*%/0%',02/2*$0'+%0,*%C$/0#%'"66/$1%,(*%/0%$G$'(*/0#%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%@6,'(6$9$0*;%.,9$%
2<,@@/0#%)/2*%'<"0#$2%"6$%0,*%"1a(2*$1%*,%*<$%J8&%"01%X!d!A%C,,>2;%[<"*%<"@@$02%/2%*<"*%'<"0#$2%/0%
*<$%A"5+L2%2<,@@/0#%)/2*%/0%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%J8&%*$01%*,%C$%1/--$6$0*%-6,9%*<,2$%@6,a$'*$1%,0%*<$%
/0/*/")% )/2*;% 70% "11/*/,03% *<$2$% '<"0#$2% "6$% ")2,% ,-*$0% 0,*% ',,61/0"*$1% *<,6,(#<)+% C+%*<$% $G/2*/0#%
C(6$"('6"'+;%
?<$% 9"/0% @,/0*% ,-% *<$% ?A7L2% J8&% @,)/'+% /2% *<"*%"))% 2*">$<,)1$62% 2(@$65/2$% "01% ',0*6,)%J8&%
1$5$),@9$0*%/0*$60"))+%"01%$G*$60"))+;%?<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$3%J/0/2*6+%,-%&/0"0'$3%^"@@$0"23%?A7%
Y,99"01$63%"01%Y</$-%,-%&,6'$%.*"--%@)"+%"%6,)$%/0%2(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%C+%*<$/6%6$2@$'*/5$%)$5$)2%,-%
"(*<,6/*+;%.(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%@,)/'/$2%,0%J8&%1$5$),@9$0*%"6$%@6/,6/*/H$1%*,:%%
"; `@*/9/H/0#%9,0/*,6/0#%/0%2(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%,-%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%J8&%1$5$),@9$0*%C+%
/05,)5/0#%"))%2*">$<,)1$62;%
C; `@*/9/H$%*<$%',9@)$*/,0%,-%6$',99$01"*/,02%-6,9%$"'<%-/01/0#%,-%*<$%6$2()*2%,-%2(@$65/2/,0%"01%
',0*6,)3%C,*<%/0*$60")%"01%$G*$60");%
'; 79@6,5$%*<$%@"**$60%,-%2(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%*<"*%6$-$62%*,%*<$%0$B%@"6"1/#93%0"9$)+Z%!6$%D(1/*3%
Y(66$0*%D(1/*3%"01%!,2*%D(1/*%MJ/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$0'$3%PQR\T;%
E,B$5$63%/0%/*2%/9@)$9$0*"*/,03% 2(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%"6$%0,*%,@*/9");% 70%*<$%J/0/2*$6% ,-%
W$-$02$%0(9C$6%Rf%,-%PQRS%',0'$60/0#%*<$%79@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%W$-$02$%8](/@9$0*%!6,'(6$9$0*%/0%*<$%
J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$%"01%*<$%?A73%*<$%?A7%/2%"(*<,6/H$1%*,%2(C9/*%"%2<,@@/0#%)/2*%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%
*,% *<$% W/6$'*,6"*$% I$0$6")% ,-% W$-$02$% !)"00/0#;% 7-% *<$% C(1#$*% /2% "5"/)"C)$3% *<$% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*%
2<,@@/0#%)/2*%/2%2(C9/**$1%*,%*<$%W/6$'*,6"*$%I$0$6")%,-%W$-$02$%&,6'$%*,%2+0'<6,0/H$%B/*<%*<$%0$$12%
@)"0% @6$@"6$1% /0% *<$% J8&% C,,>;% D-*$6% *<$% @)"0% 1$')"6$2% *<$% 2<,@@/0#% )/2*3% *<$% $G$'(*/,0% @6,'$22% /2%
<"01$1%,5$6%*,%*<$%W$-$02$%&"'/)/*/$2%"01%70-6"2*6('*(6$%D#$0'+%M^"6"0"<"0%K$9<"0T;%`0%*<$%,*<$6%
<"013%J"6/0$%U/$(*$0"0*%Y,),0$)%D01/%.(6+"%2*"*$1%*<"*%*<$%@6,'(6$9$0*%,-%A"5+%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%
/0%PQRQcPQRf%"))$#$1)+%<"1%"0%$9@*+%#"@%-,6%2+0'<6,0/H/0#%*<$%2<,@@/0#%)/2*%2(C9/**$1%B/*<%*<$%0$$12%
@)"0%C+%*<$%J8&%C,,>;%?<$%$9@*+%#"@%/2%*<$%"**/*(1$%,-%@"22/0#%*<$%2*"#$2%,-%*<$%@6,'$1(6$%"2%"%B<,)$;%
E$0'$3%/*%1$@$012%,0%<,B%"@@6,@6/"*$%,6%1$5/"*$1%*<$%A"5+L2%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%-()-/)9$0*%/0%*<"*%+$"6;%%
70%)/0$%B/*<%*</2%2*"*$9$0*3%*<$%"'*,6%B<,%@)"+2%"0%/9@,6*"0*%6,)$%/0%2(@$65/2/0#%"01%',0*6,))/0#%
1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*% 9,1$60/H"*/,0% @,)/'/$2% *<6,(#<% J8&% /2% Y,99/22/,0% 7% ,-% *<$% E,(2$% ,-%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research3%%
I6"'/"%."6"<%D69"1"0/13%J$/1/%K,2"01/2%
IJSSR !"#$%134%
X$@6$2$0*"*/5$2%,-%*<$%X$@(C)/'%,-%701,0$2/";%?<6,(#<%"0%/0*$65/$B%B/*<%*<$%Y<"/69"0%,-%Y,99/22/,0%
7%-,6%*<$%PQRbcPQPS%@$6/,13%J$(*+"%E"-/1%6$5$")$1%*<"*%*<$%',0*6,)%6,)$%'"66/$1%,(*%C+%Y,99/22/,0%7%
<"2%C$$0%6(00/0#%B$))%C$'"(2$%',99(0/'"*/,0%C$*B$$0%Y,99/22/,0%7%"01%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$%"01%
*<$%?A7%<"2%")B"+2%C$$0%'"66/$1%,(*;%%
J$(*+"% E"-/1L2% 2*"*$9$0*% 2<,B2% *<"*% Y,99/22/,0% 7% ,-% *<$% E,(2$% ,-% X$@6$2$0*"*/5$2% ,-% *<$%
X$@(C)/'% ,-% 701,0$2/"% ',0*6,)2%$5$6+% @6,'$22% ,-% /9@)$9$0*/0#% 9,1$60/H"*/,0% @,)/'/$2;% ?<$%
2*">$<,)1$62L%1$'/2/,0%*,%'<"0#$%*<$%?A7%DU%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%2<,@@/0#%)/2*%/2%")2,%/02$@"6"C)$%-6,9%
*<$% "@@6,5")% ,-% Y,99/22/,0% 7% ,-% *<$% E,(2$% ,-% X$@6$2$0*"*/5$2;% ?<$% /0*$65/$B% $G'$6@*2%2<,B%*<"*%
Y,99/22/,0%7%"@@6,5$1%*<$%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%2<,@@/0#%)/2*%'<"0#$%1($%*,%*<$%(0"5"/)"C)$%C(1#$*;%`0%
*<$%,*<$6%<"013%6$2$"6'<$62%*6/$1%*,%1/#%9,6$%/0*,%*<$%@"6"9$*$62%(2$1%C+%Y,99/22/,0%7%*,%"@@6,5$%*<$%
1$'/2/,0;%%
^"2$1%,0%J$(*+"%E"-/1L2%2*"*$9$0*3%/*%'"0%C$%2"/1%*<"*%2*">$<,)1$6%1$'/2/,02%*<"*%"6$%0,*%C+%*<$%
0$$12%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%")B"+2%-/01%"%9/11)$%B"+%*,%"@@6,5$%*<$9;%`0%*<$%,*<$6%<"013%Y,00/$%
X"<">(01/0/% ^">6/$% $G@)"/0$1% *<"*% *<$% 2(@$65/2/,0% '"66/$1% ,(*% C+% Y,99/22/,0% 7% ,-% *<$% E,(2$% ,-%
X$@6$2$0*"*/5$2% ,-% *<$% X$@(C)/'% ,-% 701,0$2/"% <"2% 0,*% C$$0% $--$'*/5$% 1($% *,% *<$% 0$#,*/"*/,0% "01%
',,61/0"*/,0% @6,'$22;% ?<$% "@@6,5")% C+% Y,99/22/,0% 7% B"2% ,C*"/0$1% *<6,(#<% ',,61/0"*/,0% "01%
0$#,*/"*/,03% B</)$% *<$% 2(@$65/2/,0% @6,'$22% 2<,()1% 0,*% ")),B% ',,61/0"*/,0% "01% 0$#,*/"*/,0;% 70% *<$%
@6,'$22%,-%2(@$65/2/,03%*<$6$%"6$%,-*$0%'),2$1c1,,6%9$$*/0#2%C+%Y,99/22/,0%73%B</'<%*<$0%6$2()*2%/0%
*<$%"@@6,5")%,-%1$'/2/,02%0,*%C+%@,)/'+%,Ca$'*/5$23%@6,5/0#%*<"*%*<$6$%"6$%'$6*"/0%/0*$6$2*2;%%
?</2% )"'>% ,-% 2(@$65/2/,0% "01% ',0*6,)% ,@$02% ),,@<,)$2% -,6% "C(2$% ,-% "(*<,6/*+% "9,0#%
2*">$<,)1$62;%.,%*<"*%*<$%$5")("*/,0%0$$1$1%*,%/9@6,5$%*<$%1$-$02$%2$'*,6%/2%,(*2/1$%*<$%,@$6"*/,03%
/0-,69"*/,0% "C,(*% *<$% B$"@,02% @6,'(6$9$0*% @6,'$22% 2<,()1% 0,% ),0#$6% C$% (2$1% "2% "% 2*"*$% 2$'6$*;%
Y<"0#$2%9(2*%2*"6*%-6,9%Y,99/22/,0%R%,-%*<$%E,(2$%,-%X$@6$2$0*"*/5$2%,-%*<$%X$@(C)/'%,-%701,0$2/"3%
B</'<%9(2*%'"66+%,(*%C(1#$*%*6"02@"6$0'+%-,6%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%@(6'<"2$2;%
4. Domestic!Defense!Industry!Not!Optimal!
!?<$% 1$5$),@9$0*% ,-% *<$% 1$-$02$% /01(2*6+% /2% "0% /0*$#6"*$1% @"6*% ,-% 2*6"*$#/'% @)"00/0#% /0%
9"0"#/0#%0"*/,0")%6$2,(6'$2%-,6%*<$%C$0$-/*%,-%0"*/,0")%1$-$02$%*,%@6,1('$%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%"01%
9"/0*$0"0'$%2$65/'$2%*,%2(@@,6*%*<$%J8&;%?<$%"5"/)"C/)/*+%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%2,%-"6%<"2%0,*%C$$0%
-())+%2(@@,6*$1%C+%*<$%1,9$2*/'%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%,@*/9"))+3%2,%*<$6$%/2%2*/))%1$@$01$0'$%,0%-,6$/#0%
1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%@6,1('*2;%?<$%J8&%1,'(9$0*%/0%*<$%X$#()"*/,0%,-%*<$%J/0/2*$6%,-%W$-$02$%0(9C$6%
Vb% ,-% PQR\% 2*"*$2% *<"*% -,(6% /9@,6*"0*% *</0#2% "6$%,-% ',0'$60% /0% 6$")/H/0#% *<$% $9@,B$69$0*% "01%
$9@,B$69$0*% ,-% *<$% 1,9$2*/'% 1$-$02$% /01(2*6+;% &/62*3% '6,22c2$'*,6")% ',,@$6"*/,0% *,% 9$$*% 1$-$02$%
0$$12Z% 2$',013% *<$% 9"0"#$6/")% "2@$'*2% ,-% 701<"0% M^4JAe^4J.T% '"0% C$% 9"0"#$1% @6,@$6)+Z% *</613%
9$$*/0#%C(1#$*%0$$12%"01%"1$]("*$%<(9"0%6$2,(6'$%'"@"C/)/*/$2Z%-,(6*<3%*<$%"5"/)"C/)/*+%,-%-"'/)/*/$2%
"01%/0-6"2*6('*(6$%*<"*%2(@@,6*%29,,*<%1$5$),@9$0*%MJ/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$3%PQR\T;%%
?<$%/01$@$01$0'$%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%/2%"0%$--,6*%*,%/9@6,5$%*<$%"C/)/*+%,-%*<$%0"*/,0")%
/01(2*6+3%B</'<%/2%2(@@,6*$1%C+%*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+3%B</'<%<"2%</#<%*$'<0,),#/'")%'<"6"'*$6/2*/'2%"01%
</#<%"''(6"'+%"01%/2%-,)),B$1%C+%*<$%1$5$),@9$0*%,-%2(@@,6*/0#%/01(2*6/$2%,6%,*<$6%0"*/,0")%/01(2*6/$2;%
?<$6$-,6$3%*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%9(2*%C$%/0*$#6"*$13%/0')(1/0#%/0%*$692%,-%9"2*$6+%,-%*$'<0,),#+3%*,%
2*6$0#*<$0% *<$% /01(2*6/")/H"*/,0% @6,'$22% C6,"1)+;% ?<$6$% "6$% 2$5$6")% $--,6*2% *,% 1$5$),@% *<$% 1$-$02$%
/01(2*6+;%E$6$%"6$%*<$%2*$@2%C"2$1%,0%*<,2$%)/2*$1%/0%*<$%?A7%J8&%1,'(9$0*%PQR\cPQRb%MJ/0/2*6+%,-%
W$-$02$3%PQR\T:%
a. Strengthening!Regulations!and!Utilization!of!Alpalhankam!Procurement!from!Abroad.!!
U"B%A(9C$6%Ri%,-%PQRP%',0'$60/0#%*<$%W$-$02$%701(2*6+%C$',9$2%"%)$#")%(9C6$))"%-,6%*<$%W$-$02$%
701(2*6+;% 7*% 2/9()*"0$,(2)+% C6/0#2%'$6*"/0*+% "C,(*% *<$% 5/2/,03% 9/22/,03% "01% 1/6$'*/,0% ,-% *<$%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% <**@2:ee/a226;6/1B"0/02*/*(*$;',;/1e%
IJSSR!!"#$%135%
1$5$),@9$0*% ,-% *<$% W$-$02$% 701(2*6+;% 79@)$9$0*"*/,0% X()$2% "2% "% 1$6/5"*/5$% @6,1('*% ,-% U"B%
A(9C$6%Ri%,-%PQRP%<"5$%C$$0%@6$@"6$1%"01%6"*/-/$1%"2%!!%,6%!$6@6$2;%.*6$0#*<$0/0#%6$#()"*/,02%
B/))%',0*/0($%*,%C$%@(62($1%*,%"'</$5$%*<$%/01$@$01$0'$%,-%*<$%W$-$02$%701(2*6+;%7-%*<$%1$-$02$%
/01(2*6+%'"00,*%@6,1('$%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%"2%0$$1$13%/*%'"0%C$%9$*%*<6,(#<%@6,'(6$9$0*%-6,9%
"C6,"1%B/*<%*<$%',01/*/,0%,-%*6"1$3%),'")%',0*$0*3%,6%,--2$*;%%
b. Foreign!Cooperation!in!the!Field!of!Defense!Industry.!!
Y,,@$6"*/,0%B/*<%',(0*6/$2%,6%/01(2*6/$2%*<"*%,B0%*$'<0,),#+%'"0%C$%/0%*<$%-,69%,-%9">/0#%a,/0*%
1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*% Md,/0*% !6,1('*/,0T3% a,/0*% 1$5$),@9$0*% ,-% 0$B% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*% Md,/0*%
W$5$),@9$0*T3%,6%$2*"C)/2</0#%"%a,/0*%C(2/0$22%/0%701,0$2/"%Md,/0*%F$0*(6$T;%?</2%$--,6*%9(2*%C$%
'"66/$1%,(*%$"60$2*)+%2,%*<"*%*$'<0,),#+%/01(2*6+%,B0$62%<"5$%',0-/1$0'$%/0%1,9$2*/'%701<"0L2%
*$'<0,),#+%*6"02-$6%B,6*<;%!
c. Industrial!and!Technology!Mapping!and!Sustainability!of!Defense!Industry!Development.!
?<$% 1$5$),@9$0*% ,-% *<$% 1$-$02$% /01(2*6+% /2% '),2$)+% 6$)"*$1% *,% *$'<0,),#/'")% 1$5$),@9$0*2;%
701(2*6/")%6$)"*/,02%"6$%0,*%,0)+%'"66/$1%,(*%5$6*/'"))+3%B</'<%/0')(1$%*<$%9"/0%',9C/0$6%/01(2*6+%
M)$"1%/0*$#6"*,6T3%9"/0%',9@,0$0*%/01(2*6+3%',9@,0$0*%/01(2*6+3%"01%6"B%9"*$6/")%/01(2*6+%C(*%
")2,%C(/)1%<,6/H,0*")%6$)"*/,02</@2%-6,9%"%*$'<0,),#+%-"9/)+3%B</'<%/0')(1$2%@6,@()2/,0%2(@@,6*3%
B</'<%/2%1/5/1$1%/0*,%U"01%J"*6"%!)"*-,693%.$"%J"*6"%!)"*-,693%D/6%J"*6"%!)"*-,69;%J"2*$6+%,-%
*$'<0,),#+%/2%(2$1%-,6%9$"2(6$9$0*%*<6,(#<%*<$%)$5$)%,-%9"2*$6+%,-%*$'<0,),#+%,6%?$'<0,),#+%
X$"1/0$22%U$5$)%M?XUT3%B</'<%/0')(1$2%',9@,0$0*2%/0')(1/0#%1$2/#0%"01%1$2/#0%'"@"C/)/*/$23%*<$%
"C/)/*+% *,% *6"02)"*$% 1$2/#02% /0*,% @6,1('*/,0% )/0$23% *<$% "C/)/*+% ,-% *$'<0,),#/'")% /0-6"2*6('*(6$3%
$1('"*/,0")% '"@"C/)/*/$23% "01% EX% 2>/))23% *<$% $G/2*$0'$% ,-% '$6*/-/'"*/,0% "01% 2*"01"61/H"*/,03%
9"/0*$0"0'$%"01%9"/0*$0"0'$%'"@"C/)/*/$2;%
70% "11/*/,0% *,% 1$2/#0/0#% $--,6*2% *,% 1$5$),@% *<$% 1$-$02$% /01(2*6+% B/*<% *<$2$% 2*$@23% /*% /2% ")2,%
0$'$22"6+%*,%2+0'<6,0/H$%"01%<"69,0/H$%C$*B$$0%*<$%-()-/))9$0*%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%0$$12%"01%*<$%
1$5$),@9$0*%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%2,%*<"*%*<$+%',9@)$9$0*%"01% 2*6$0#*<$0%$"'<%,*<$6;%E$6$%"6$%
@6,a$'*/,02%,-%9$$*/0#%*<$%0$$12%,-%?A7%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%*<6,(#<%*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%/0%*<$%J8&:%
"; ?<$%1$5$),@9$0*%,-%J8&%!<"2$%73%B</'<%/2%*<$%/0/*/")%2*"#$%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*3%/2%"'',9@"0/$1%
C+%*<$%1$5$),@9$0*%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%B/*<%"0%,6/$0*"*/,0%*,B"612%@6,#6"9%1$*$69/0"*/,03%
2*"C/)/H"*/,0%"01%,@*/9/H"*/,0%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+3%@6$@"6"*/,0%,-%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%6$#()"*/,023%
"01%@6$@"6"*/,0%,-%0$B%-(*(6$%@6,1('*2;%
C; ?<$% ',02*6('*/,0% ,-% J8&% !<"2$% 773% *<$% 0$G*% 2*"#$% ,-% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*% 1$5$),@9$0*3% )$"12% *,%
@,2*(6$3%"'',9@"0/$1%C+%*<$%1$5$),@9$0*%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+3%B</'<%/2%-,'(2$1%,0%2(@@,6*/0#%
J8&3%/0'6$"2/0#%@6,1('*/,0%',,@$6"*/,0%'"@"C/)/*/$23%"01%0$B%@6,1('*%1$5$),@9$0*;%
'; ?<$% 1$5$),@9$0*% ,-% J8&% !<"2$% 7773% B</'<% /2% *<$% *6"02/*/,0% 2*"#$% ,-% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*%
1$5$),@9$0*% *,B"612% *<$% /1$")% @,2*(6$3% /2% "'',9@"0/$1% C+% *<$% 1$5$),@9$0*% ,-% *<$% 1$-$02$%
/01(2*6+3%B</'<% /2% -,'(2$1% ,0% 2(@@,6*/0#% *<$% /1$")% @,2*(6$3% /01(2*6+% #6,B*<% M9$1/(9c*$69%
@6,1('*2T3% "01% 0$B% @6,1('*% 1$5$),@9$0*c"15"0'$% *$'<0,),#+% M/0'6$"2/0#% /0*$60"*/,0")%
',,@$6"*/,0T;%
1; ?<$%1$5$),@9$0*%,-%*<$%/1$")%@,2*(6$%"-*$6%*<$%J8&%/2%"'</$5$13%"'',9@"0/$1%C+%*<$%1$5$),@9$0*%
,-% *<$% 1$-$02$% /01(2*6+% *<"*% )$"12% *,% 2/#0/-/'"0*% 1$-$02$% /01(2*6+% /01$@$01$0'$3% *<$% "C/)/*+% *,%
',))"C,6"*$%/0*$60"*/,0"))+3%"01%2(2*"/0"C)$%1$5$),@9$0*;%
70%*<$%PQR\cPQRb%J8&%$5")("*/,0%1,'(9$0*%"01%/0-,69"*/,0%,C*"/0$1%*<6,(#<%/0*$65/$B2%B/*<%
Y,),0$)%.*$5$03%/*%/2%/9@)/$1%*<"*%*<$%1,9$2*/'%/01(2*6+%<"2%0,*%C$$0%"C)$%*,%2(@@,6*%*<$%-()-/))9$0*%,-%
1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%"2%0$$1$13%2,%*<$%9,1$60/H"*/,0%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%*<"*%<"2%,''(66$1%2,%-"6%
*$012%*,%1$@$01%,0%-,6$/#0%/01(2*6/$2;%?</2%'"(2$2%*<$%',2*2%/0'(66$1%*,%9$$*%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%0$$12%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research3%%
I6"'/"%."6"<%D69"1"0/13%J$/1/%K,2"01/2%
IJSSR !"#$%136%
*,%C$%9,6$%$G@$02/5$;%70%"11/*/,0%*,%</#<%@6/'$23%*<$%@6,'(6$9$0*%@6,'$22%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%")2,%
C$',9$2%5$6+%),0#%C$'"(2$%/*%/2%"1a(2*$1%*,%*<$%',0-)/'*%2/*("*/,0%/0%*<$%',(0*6+;%
`0% *<$% ,*<$6% <"013% "0% /0*$65/$B% ',01('*$1% B/*<% 9/)/*"6+% "01% 1$-$02$% ,C2$65$6% Y,0/$%
X"<">(01/0/%^">6/$%2*"*$1%*<"*%"'*("))+%*<$%<,@$%*,%6$")/H$%*<$%/01$@$01$0'$%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%
2<,()1% C$% "1"@*$1% *,% *<$% '(66$0*% #),C")% 2/*("*/,03% "01% J8&% /2% 0,*% *<$% ,0)+% B"+% *,% "'</$5$% *<$%
/01$@$01$0'$%,-%*<$%701,0$2/"0%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+;%%
^">6/$L2%2*"*$9$0*%2<,B2%*<"*%*<$%)"'>%,-%,@*/9")%',0*6/C(*/,0%,-%*<$%1,9$2*/'%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%
*,%2(@@,6*%*<$%9,1$60/H"*/,0%,-%?A7%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%*<6,(#<%J8&%/2%")2,%6$)"*$1%*,%*<$%',02/2*$0'+%
,-%*<$%@$6@$*6"*,62;%?<$%1,9$2*/'%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%2<,()1%C$%"C)$%*,%1$5$),@%"01%$5$0%"15"0'$3%/-%*<$6$%
/2%2*6('*(6")%6$5"9@/0#%-6,9%"C,5$;%.,%*<$%@6,'(6$9$0*%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%/2%0,*%,0)+%',02/1$6$1%
"2%"%B"2*$%,-%C(1#$*%"01%-,6%'$6*"/0%/0*$6$2*2;%?<$%$G/2*$0'$%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9"-/"%")2,%'"(2$2%
*<$%1,9$2*/'%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%*,%C$%2*/))%0,*%,@*/9");%?<$%"C2$0'$%,-%#,5$609$0*%',99/*9$0*%/0%*<$%
',0*$G*%,-%1$-$02$%6$@6$2$0*$1%C+%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$%,@$02%*<$%#"@%/0%*<$%$0*6+%,-%,*<$6%@"6*/$2L%
/0*$6$2*2%/0%*<$%@6,'(6$9$0*%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%C$'"(2$%*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%/2%(0"C)$%*,%9$$*%
1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%0$$12;%
Factors!affecting!the!implementation!of!the!Navy's!defense!equipment!modernization!policy!in!the!
minimum!essential!force!phase!II!of!2015-2019!
1. Content!Variables!Affecting!the!Implementation!of!TNI!AL!Defense!Equipment!Modernization!
Policy!in!MEF!Phase!II!2015-2019!!
I6/01)$%2"/1%*<"*%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%/2%"0%$--,6*%*,%6$")/H$%*<$%@,)/'+%,Ca$'*/5$2%2*"*$1%/0%
@,)/'+%-,69()"*/,0%"2%@,)/'+%2*"*$9$0*2%/0*,%@,)/'+%,(*',9$2%*<"*%"6/2$%-6,9%#,5$609$0*%"'*/5/*/$2;%?<$%
2(''$22%,-%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%/2%/0-)($0'$1%C+%*B,%9"/0%5"6/"C)$2:%1$#6$$2%,-%"C/)/*+%/0%*<$%@,)/'+%
/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%@6,'$22;%?<$2$%5"6/"C)$2%/0')(1$%@,)/'+%',0*$0*%M',0*$0*%,-%@,)/'+T%"01%@,)/'+%',0*$G*%
M',0*$G*%,-%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0T;%
Y,0*$0*%,6%2(C2*"0'$%,-%@,)/'/$2%*<"*%"6$%',0*6,5$62/")3%0,0c@,@()/2*3%"01%*,('<%,0%-(01"9$0*")%
'<"0#$%"6$%#$0$6"))+%6$2@,01$1%*,%2*6,0#)+%C+%*<$%@(C)/';%?<$%2(C2*"0'$%,-%*<$%@,)/'+%/2%")2,%0,*%$"2/)+%
/9@)$9$0*$1% C+% /9@)$9$0*$623% 2,% /*% B/))% C$% 1/--/'()*% *,% "'</$5$% 2(''$22% *"6#$*2;% D2@$'*2% ,-% @,)/'+%
',0*$0*% /0')(1$% *<$% @(C)/'%/0*$6$2*% *,% C$% *"6#$*$13% C$0$-/*23% *"6#$*2% ,-% '<"0#$3% *<$% @,2/*/,0% ,-%
@,)/'+9">$62%,6%),'"*/,0%,-%1$'/2/,0c9">/0#3%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*$623%"01%6$2,(6'$2%MI6/01)$3%PQRfT;%%
?<$%"2@$'*%,-%@(C)/'%/0*$6$2*%*<"*%/2%*"6#$*$1%/2%"%9$"2(6$%,-%*<$%/9@"'*%,-%*<$%2(C2*"0'$%,-%*<$%
@,)/'+%,0%*<$%/0*$6$2*2%,-%*<$%*"6#$*%#6,(@%M*"6#$*%#6,(@T;%?<$%C$0$-/*%"2@$'*%/2%*<$%2/H$%,-%*<$%C$0$-/*2%
6$'$/5$1% C+% *<$% *"6#$*% #6,(@% "01% *<$% #$0$6")% @(C)/';% ?<$% C$0$-/*2% /0% ]($2*/,0% 6$"'<% 9"0+% /0*$6$2*%
#6,(@2%"01%B/))%C$%/0'6$"2/0#)+%2(@@,6*$13%9">/0#%/*%$"2+%*,%/9@)$9$0*;%?<$%*"6#$*%"2@$'*%,-%'<"0#$%/2%
*<$%"9,(0*%,-%'<"0#$%6$2()*/0#%-6,9%*<$%@,)/'+%2(C2*"0'$;%7-%*<$%6$2()*/0#%'<"0#$%/2%C/#%"01%6$"'<$2%
-(01"9$0*")%*</0#23%*<$0%/*2%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%B/))%C$%9,6$%1/--/'()*3%"01%5/'$%5$62";%%
D2@$'*2% ,-% *<$% @,2/*/,0% ,-% @,)/'+9">$62%,6% 1$'/2/,0c9">/0#% @"6*/$2% 6$)"*$1% *,% *<$% 1$'/2/,0c
9">/0#%9,1$)%,-%*<$%0(9C$6%,-%@"6*/$2%/05,)5$1;%?<$%9,6$%@"6*/$2%/05,)5$13%*<$%9,6$%1/--/'()*%/*%/2%*,%
9">$% 1$'/2/,02;% ?<$% "2@$'*% ,-% @,)/'+% /9@)$9$0*$62% ,6% @6,#6"9% /9@)$9$0*$62% /2% "% 9$"2(6$% ,-%
2*">$<,)1$6%',9@$*$0'$%/0%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0;%?<$%6$2,(6'$%"2@$'*%/2%"%9$"2(6$%,-%/0-6"2*6('*(6$%
2(@@,6*%/0%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0;%?<$%6$2,(6'$2%/0%]($2*/,0%"6$%/0-)($0'$1%C+%*<$%'<,/'$%,-%2*6"*$#/$2%
"01%/02*6(9$0*2%(2$1%/0%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0;%%
?<$% J8&% 1$5$),@9$0*% *"6#$*% @6,5$2% *<"*% *<$% /0*$6$2*2% "'',99,1"*$1% *<6,(#<% *<$%
/9@)$9$0*"*/,0% ,-% *<$% J8&% *,('<% *<$% 0"*/,0")% /0*$6$2*3% B</'<% /2% "C2,)(*$% C$'"(2$% /*% ',0'$602% *<$%
/0*$6$2*2%,-%*<$%0"*/,0%"01%2*"*$3%2,%/*%'"0%C$%2"/1%*<"*%*<$%*"6#$*$1%@(C)/'%/0*$6$2*%"2@$'*2%B/))%<"5$%"%
1/6$'*%/9@"'*;%X$#()"*/,0%,-%*<$%J/0/2*$6%,-%W$-$02$%0(9C$6%Vb%,-%PQR\%',0'$60/0#%*<$%1$5$),@9$0*%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% <**@2:ee/a226;6/1B"0/02*/*(*$;',;/1e%
IJSSR!!"#$%137%
,-%?A7%J8&%2*"*$2%*<"*%*<$%,Ca$'*/5$%,-%*<$%J8&%@,)/'+%/2%*,%9$$*%*<$%9/0/9(9%2*"01"612%,-%1$-$02$%
2*6$0#*<%/0%',01/*/,02%,-%"%)/9/*$1%1$-$02$%C(1#$*;%%
?,%6$")/H$%*<$2$%#,")23%J8&%77%1$5$),@9$0*%*"6#$*2%/0')(1$%MJ/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$3%PQR\T:%%
?* ?<$%6$")/H"*/,0%,-%2*6$0#*<%"01%1$-$02$%'"@"C/)/*/$2%*<"*%'"0%-"'$%5"6/,(2%*<6$"*2;%%
R* ?<$%,6#"0/H"*/,0%,-%*<$%1$5$),@9$0*%,-%*<$%?A7%J8&%B</)$%2*/))%-,'(2/0#%,0%*<$%9,1$60/H"*/,0%,-%
1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%/2%2(@@,6*$1%C+%/0'6$"2/0#%*<$%5")($%"01%1$5$),@9$0*%,-%,6#"0/H"*/,02%"01%
/0-6"2*6('*(6$3%*">/0#%/0*,%"'',(0*%C(1#$*%"5"/)"C/)/*+%C+%*<$%2*6"*$#/'%@)"0%-,6%*<$%1$5$),@9$0*%,-%
*<$%',(0*6+L2%1$-$02$%-,6'$;%%
E* ?<$% 6$")/H"*/,0% ,-% *<$% 1$5$),@9$0*% ,-% *<$% 0"*/,0")% 1$-$02$% /01(2*6+% *<6,(#<% 9"2*$6+% ,-%
*$'<0,),#+3%',,@$6"*/,0%/0%*$'<0,),#+%1$5$),@9$0*%"01%*$'<0,),#+%*6"02-$63%"2%B$))%"2%@6,1('*/,0%
',,@$6"*/,0% '"66/$1% ,(*% /0% "0% /0*$#6"*$1% "01% 2(2*"/0"C)$% 9"00$6% -,6% *<$% C$0$-/*% ,-% 0"*/,0")%
1$-$02$;%%
'* ?<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%/0*$60"*/,0")%',,@$6"*/,0%*,%C(/)1%*<$%',(0*6+L2%1$-$02$%'"@"C/)/*/$2%"01%
1$-$02$%1/@),9"'+%'"@"'/*+3%"2%B$))%"2%9(*(")%*6(2*%"01%(01$62*"01/0#%C$*B$$0%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%
W$-$02$%"01e,6%*<$%D69$1%&,6'$2;%%
:* ?<$%-()-/))9$0*%,-%*<$%1/2@"*'<%,-%@6,-$22/,0")%*6,,@2%"01%2(@@,6*$1%C+%"1$]("*$%$](/@9$0*%"01%
/0-6"2*6('*(6$%/0%*<$%"'*/5/*/$2%,-%B,6)1%@$"'$>$$@/0#%9/22/,02%C+%*<$%0$$12%"01%6$]($2*2%,-%*<$%
40/*$1%A"*/,02;%%
@* ?<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%1$-$02$%"6$"%$9@,B$69$0*%*,%/0'6$"2$%*<$%2$'(6/*+%,-%)"01%"6$"2%"01%)"01%
C,61$62%*<6,(#<%*<$%',0'$@*%,-%"0%/0*$#6"*$1%2$'(6/*+%C$)*%"01%/0'6$"2$1%2$'(6/*+%,-%29"))%/2)"012%
"2%701,0$2/"L2%-,6$9,2*%e%,(*$69,2*%6$#/,0;%%
,* ?<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%*<$%1$@),+9$0*%,-%2$"%@,B$6%"01%"/6%@,B$6%*,%/0'6$"2$%9"6/*/9$%2$'(6/*+%
"01%"$6,2@"'$%2$'(6/*+%/0%*<$%"6$"%,-%0"*/,0")%a(6/21/'*/,0;%%
!* ?<$%6$")/H"*/,0%,-%/0'6$"2/0#%*<$%'"@"'/*+%,-%1$-$02$%X$2$"6'<%"01%W$5$),@9$0*%',,@$6"*/,0%B/*<%
(0/5$62/*+%XOW%"01%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%XOW%/0%*<$%-6"9$B,6>%,-%"0%/01$@$01$0*%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+;%%
)* ?<$% /9@)$9$0*"*/,0% ,-% $--$'*/5$3% $--/'/$0*3% "01% "'',(0*"C)$% "22$*% "01% C(1#$*% 9"0"#$9$0*% /0%
"'</$5/0#%*<$%?A7L2%J8&%1$5$),@9$0*%#,")2;%%
3* ?<$% 6$")/H"*/,0% ,-% /0*$))/#$0'$% 2*6$0#*<$0/0#% *<6,(#<% /9@6,5/0#%*<$% 2*"*$% 1$-$02$% /0-,69"*/,0%
2+2*$9%M./2/0-,<"00$#T%C"2$1%,0%'+C$6%1$-$02$%"01%/0'6$"2$1%@6,-$22/,0")/29;%%
U* ?<$%6$")/H"*/,0%,-%$--$'*/5$%"01%2+0$6#/2*/'%,6#"0/H"*/,0")%2*6('*(6/0#%/0%1$")/0#%B/*<%*<6$"*2%/0%P%
M*B,T%*6,(C)$%2@,*2%/0%V%M*<6$$T%1$-$02$%"6$"2;%%
?<$% C$0$-/'/")% "2@$'*2% ,-% J8&% /9@)$9$0*"*/,0% "6$%/02$@"6"C)$% -6,9% *<$% *+@$% ,-% /0*$6$2*2%
"'',99,1"*$1;%7-%*<$%/0*$6$2*%,-%*<$%@,)/'+%2(C2*"0'$%',0'$602%*<$%"C2,)(*$%0"*/,0")%/0*$6$2*3%*<$0%*<$%
C$0$-/*% /2% *<$% 2$'(6/*+3% 2"-$*+3% "01% /0*$#6/*+% ,-% *<$% 0"*/,0% "01% 2*"*$;% ?,% ',02/1$6% *<$% "2@$'*2% ,-%
"'',99,1"*$1%/0*$6$2*2%"01%@$6'$/5$1%C$0$-/*23%/*%'"0%C$%2"/1%*<"*%*<$%J8&%@,)/'+%2<,()1%<"5$%*<$%-())%
2(@@,6*%,-%"))%@"6*/$2%*,%C$%/9@)$9$0*$1;%%
?<$%?A7%J8&%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%"/92%*,%C(/)1%"%9/)/*"6+%-,6'$%"01%'"@"C/)/*+%*<"*%'"0%"0*/'/@"*$%
5"6/,(2%*<6$"*2%/0%*B,%*6,(C)$%2@,*2%"01%,0$%6$2$65$%-,6'$;%?<$%*"6#$*%,-%*</2%'"@"C/)/*+%2<,B2%*<"*%*<$%
1$5$),@9$0*%,-%*<$%?A7%J8&%/2%-(6*<$6%,6/$0*$1%*,B"612%*<$%6$")/H"*/,0%,-%*<6$$%1$-$02$%"6$"2;%?<(23%
,6#"0/H"*/,0")% 1$5$),@9$0*% /2% 0$$1$1% C,*<% '$0*6"))+% "01% 6$#/,0"))+% *<6,(#<% K,*"9"% ?A7L2%
1$5$),@9$0*%C+%@6/,6/*/H/0#%*<$%70*$#6"*$1%?6/9"*6"%',0'$@*%MJ/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$3%PQR\T;%?<$%*"6#$*%
1,$2%0,*%*,('<%-(01"9$0*")%9"**$623%2,%*<$%@,*$0*/")%-,6%6$a$'*/,0%-6,9%9"0+%@"6*/$2%'"0%C$%9/0/9/H$1;%%
`0%*<$%,*<$6%<"013%*,%9$$*%*<$2$%*"6#$*23%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%")),'"*/,0%*"6#$*2%"6$%@6$@"6$1%/0%*<$%
1$-$02$%C(1#$*%C"2$)/0$;%70%0,0cB"6%2/*("*/,023%)"6#$%C(1#$*2%"6$%,-*$0%9$*%B/*<%6$2/2*"0'$%-6,9%*<$%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research3%%
I6"'/"%."6"<%D69"1"0/13%J$/1/%K,2"01/2%
IJSSR !"#$%138%
@(C)/';%?<$%J8&%@,)/'+%2(C2*"0'$%2<,()1%")2,%C$%,C)/#"*,6+%*,%@(C)/2<%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%")),'"*/,02%2@$0*%
,0%B$"@,02%"01%,*<$6%@(6'<"2$2%2,%*<"*%*<$%@(C)/'%'"0%2(@@,6*%*<$%',0*$0*%,-%*<$%@,)/'+;%%
!$6'$0*"#$%,-%*<$%J/0/2*$6%,-%W$-$02$%0(9C$6%Rf%,-%PQRS%',0'$60/0#%*<$%79@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%
W$-$02$% 8](/@9$0*% !6,'(6$9$0*% B/*</0% *<$% J/0/2*6+% ,-% W$-$02$% "01% *<$% ?A73% 2*"*$2% *<"*% *<$%
/9@)$9$0*$62% ,-% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*% 9,1$60/H"*/,0% @,)/'/$2% *<6,(#<% J8&% ',02/2*% ,-% @"6$0*%
,6#"0/H"*/,02% "01% @6,'(6$9$0*% ,6#"0/H"*/,02;% ?<$% @,2/*/,0% ,-% *<$% @"6$0*% "01% @6,'(6$9$0*%
,6#"0/H"*/,02%/01/'"*$2%*<"*%*<$%</#<$2*%1$'/2/,0c9">/0#%@,2/*/,0%/2%*<$%J/0/2*$6%,-%W$-$02$%"2%*<$%42$6%
,-%*<$%^(1#$*;%`0%*<$%,*<$6%<"013%*<$%@6,'(6$9$0*%9$'<"0/29%-,6%?A7%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%/2%'"66/$1%
,(*% C,**,9% (@;% 8"'<% -,6'$L2% !)"00/0#% D22/2*"0*% MD26$0"T% 1$*$69/0$2% *<$% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*%
9,1$60/H"*/,0% @)"00/0#% 1,'(9$0*3% B</)$% *<$% U,#/2*/'2eY,99(0/'"*/,0% D22/2*"0*% @6$@"6$2% *<$%
@,*$0*/")% @6,5/1$6% "@@,/0*9$0*% 1,'(9$0*;% &,6% @,)/'+% /9@)$9$0*$623% *<$2$% 1$'/2/,0c9">/0#%
9$'<"0/292%9">$%1$'/2/,0c9">/0#%6$)"*/,02</@2%9,6$%1/--/'()*;%
D2@$'*2% ,-% @,)/'+% /9@)$9$0*$62L% ',9@$*$0'$% /0% J8&% /9@)$9$0*"*/,0% '"0% C$% 9$"2(6$1% /0%
2$5$6")% '"*$#,6/$2% C"2$1% ,0% *<$/6% -(0'*/,02% "01% *"2>2;% ?<$% $5")("*/,0% ,-% J8&% !<"2$% 77% PQR\cPQRb%
/0')(1$2%-/5$%*</0#2:%*<6$"*%',9@)$G/*+3%/0*$6,@$6"C/)/*+3%'"@"C/)/*+%,Ca$'*/5$23%#(/1$)/0$2%/0%*<$%J8&%
C,,>3%"01%,@*/9/H"*/,0%,-%2(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%MJ/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$%,-%*<$%X$@(C)/'%,-%701,0$2/"3%
PQRbT;% &/62*3% *<$% ',9@)$G/*+% ,-% *<6$"*2% /2% "22,'/"*$1% B/*<% 1$5$),@/0#%"% </#<)+% 1+0"9/'% 2*6"*$#/'%
$05/6,09$0*%*<"*%9">$2%*<6$"*2%/0'6$"2/0#)+%',9@)$G%"01%1/--/'()*%*,%@6$1/'*;%?</2%',01/*/,0%6$](/6$2%
*<"*%*<$%',(0*6+L2%1$-$02$%@,)/'+3%/0')(1/0#%*<$%?A7L2%J8&%1$5$),@9$0*%@,)/'+3%C$%',02*"0*)+%6$5/$B$1%
*,%"1a(2*%*,%*<$%*<6$"*2;%%
.$',013%*<$%1$5$),@9$0*%,-%*<$%?A7%J8&%/2%#(/1$1%C+%*<$%',0'$@*%,-%"0%/0*$#6"*$1%?6/9"*6"3%
B</'<% 6$](/6$2% /0*$6,@$6"C/)/*+% C$*B$$0% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*3% (0/*23% "01%9"*6";% E,B$5$63% /0%
/9@)$9$0*/0#%J8&%1$5$),@9$0*3%-()-/))/0#%*<$2$%6$](/6$9$0*2%<"2%0,*%C$$0%"'',99,1"*$1%"01%<"2%
0,*%C$',9$%"%@6/,6/*+;%.,3%/0%/9@6,5/0#%*<$%"C/)/*+%-6,9%',99"013%',0*6,)3%',99(0/'"*/,03%',9@(*$623%
"01%/0-,69"*/,0%MKS7T3%*<$6$%"6$%2*/))%2$5$6")%,C2*"')$2;%?</2%/2%")2,%2/9/)"6%*,%$--,6*2%*,B"612%0$*B,6>c
'$0*6/'%B"6-"6$e,@$6"*/,0%MAY[eAY`T%'"@"C/)/*/$2%,6%0$*B,6>cC"2$1%B"6-"6$e,@$6"*/,02%*<"*%'"00,*%
*">$%@)"'$%$--$'*/5$)+%1$2@/*$%*<$%,0#,/0#%9,1$60/H"*/,0%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*;%?</2%@6,C)$9%"6/2$2%
1($%*,%*<$%"C2$0'$%,-%2*"01"61/H"*/,0%"01%*$'<0,),#/'")%#"@2%C$*B$$0%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%/0%*<$%KS7%
2+2*$9;%%
?</613%'"@"C/)/*+%,Ca$'*/5$2%<"5$%0,*%C$$0%')$"6)+%1$-/0$1;%?<$%?A7L2%J8&%2*6"*$#/'%@6,1('*23%
B</'<% <"5$% (01$6#,0$% 2$5$6")% 6$5/2/,02% "01% ")/#09$0*23% <"5$% ',02/2*$0*)+% (2$1% '"@"C/)/*+cC"2$1%
1$-$02$%"01%'"@"C/)/*+cC"2$1%@)"00/0#%"@@6,"'<$2;%E,B$5$63%'"@"C/)/*+%#,")2%<"5$%0,*%C$$0%')$"6)+%
-,69()"*$1%"2%#(/1$)/0$2%/0%1$5$),@/0#%*<$%?A7%J8&;%&,(6*<3%*<$%?A7%J8&%C,,>%<"2%0,*%C$$0%-())+%(2$1%
"2%"%#(/1$)/0$%/0%1$5$),@/0#%*<$%?A7%@,2*(6$;%?<$%?A7%J8&%C,,>3%B</'<%',0*"/02%"%1$*"/)$1%)/2*%,-%?A7%
J8&%1$5$),@9$0*%"'*/5/*/$2%"'',61/0#%*,%*<$%2*"#$2%,-%/*2%/9@)$9$0*"*/,03%<"2%0,*%C$$0%-())+%(2$1%"2%"%
#(/1$)/0$%/0% /*2% /9@)$9$0*"*/,0;% 70% -"'*3% *<$%"'*/5/*+%@6,#6"92%/0%*<$%C,,>% <"5$% C$$0%@6$@"6$1%"01%
"#6$$1% (@,0% a,/0*)+% C+% *<$% J/0/2*6+% ,-% W$-$02$3% ?A7% E$"1]("6*$623% "01% *<$% &,6'$3% 2,% *<$+% 2<,()1%
',02/2*$0*)+%C$%(2$1%"2%6$-$6$0'$2%"01%#(/1$)/0$2%/0%-()-/))/0#%*<$%?A7%J8&;%%
&/-*<3% 2(@$65/2/,0% "01% ',0*6,)% 9$'<"0/292% <"5$% 0,*% C$$0% /9@)$9$0*$1% ,@*/9"))+;% ?<$%
/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%2(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%*<"*%<"2%C$$0%$2*"C)/2<$1%*<6,(#<%"%9,0/*,6/0#%*$"9%<"2%
0,*% C$$0% $--$'*/5$;% ?<$% 2',@$% ,-% ?A7% J8&% 1$5$),@9$0*% /2% 6$)"*/5$)+% C6,"13% "01% /*2% @<"2/0#% ,5$6% "%
6$)"*/5$)+% ),0#% @$6/,1% ,-% */9$% 6$](/6$2% /0*$02/5$% "01% /0*$#6"*$1% 2(@$65/2/,0% "01% ',0*6,)% /0% /*2%
9"0"#$9$0*3%2,%/*%/2%$G@$'*$1%*<"*%*<$%@6,#6"9%*<"*%<"2%C$$0%1$*$69/0$1%'"0%6(0%"'',61/0#%*,%@)"0%
"01%"'</$5$e9$$*%*"6#$*2;%%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% <**@2:ee/a226;6/1B"0/02*/*(*$;',;/1e%
IJSSR!!"#$%139%
.,9$%,-%*<$2$%$5")("*/,02%@6,5$%*<"*%*<$%',9@$*$0'$%,-%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*$62%/2%2*/))%)"'>/0#3%
2('<%"2%/0*$6,@$6"C/)/*+3%*"6#$*/0#%'"@"C/)/*/$23%"01%9,0/*,6/0#%"01%',0*6,)%9$'<"0/292;%?<$%<"9@$6$1%
/0*$6,@$6"C/)/*+%/2%1($%*,%',9@$*$0'$%"9,0#%,@$6"*/,0")%2*"--%/0%9"2*$6/0#%*$'<0,),#+3%2,%*<$6$%/2%"%
#"@%C$*B$$0%2+2*$92;%70%"11/*/,03%*<$%1$*$69/0"*/,0%,-%'"@"C/)/*+%*"6#$*23%B</'<%/2%*<$%6$2@,02/C/)/*+%
,-%*<$%16"-*$62%,-%*<$%?A7%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%0$$12%@)"0%2('<%"2%*<$%W/6$'*,6"*$%I$0$6")%,-%K("*<"0%
"01% ?A7% U,#/2*/'2% .*"--% /0% $"'<% -,6'$3% @6,5$2% *<"*% *<$% "C/)/*+% ,-% /9@)$9$0*$62% *,% *6"02)"*$% *<6$"*%
',01/*/,02%B/*<%@)"00/0#%<"2%0,*%C$$0%'"66/$1%,(*%,@*/9"))+;%.(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%"6$%2@$'/-/'"))+%
6$)"*$1% *,% @,)/*/'")% B/))3% C(*% /0% /*2% 9"0"#$9$0*% 6$)"*$1% *,% *<$% ',9@$*$0'$% @,22$22$1% C+% @,)/'+%
/9@)$9$0*$62;%?<$2$%*<6$$%"2@$'*2%,-%$5")("*/,0%@6,5$%*<"*%*<$%B$">%',9@$*$0'$%,-%/9@)$9$0*$62%/2%"%
-"'*,6%*<"*%</01$62%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%J8&%-6,9%"'</$5/0#%/*2%#,")2;%%
?<$%6$2,(6'$%"2@$'*2% /0% J8&% /9@)$9$0*"*/,0%"6$%*<$%C(1#$*%"01% *<$% 1$-$02$% /01(2*6+;%?<$%
6$")/H"*/,0%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%C(1#$*%0$5$6%6$"'<$1%*<$%@6$c@)"00$1%C"2$)/0$;%70'6$"2/0#%*<$%'"@"C/)/*+%,-%
*<$% 1$-$02$% /01(2*6+% "01% ',"'</0#% /2% ")2,% 0,*% 6(00/0#% ,@*/9"))+% B</)$% $9@,B$6/0#%*<$% 1$-$02$%
/01(2*6+%/2%,0$%,-%*<$%$--,6*2%*,%6$1('$%*<$%C(61$0%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0%',2*2;%%
2. Context!Variables!Affecting!the!Implementation!of!the!Navy's!Defense!Equipment!
Modernization!Policy!in!MEF!Phase!II!2015-2019!
79@)$9$0*"*/,0%',0*$G*%/2%"%5"6/"C)$%(2$1%*,%9$"2(6$%*<$%C$<"5/,6%,-%@,)/'+%"'*,62%*<"*%"--$'*%
@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0;%?<$%C$<"5/,6%,-%*<$%@,)/'+%"'*,62%/0%]($2*/,0%/2%*<"*%,-%/01/5/1(")2%B<,%1,%0,*%
$2'"@$%*<$/6%@$62,0")%/0*$6$2*2;%?<$%',0*$G*%,-%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%/2%"%5"6/"C)$%6$@6$2$0*/0#%*<$%
$05/6,09$0*%/0%B</'<%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%B/))%,''(63%B</'<%'"0%C$%/0*$6@6$*$1%"2%"%@,)/*/'")%@6,'$22;%
D2@$'*2%/0%*<$%',0*$G*%,-%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%/0')(1$%*<$%@,B$6%,-%"'*,62%B<,%<"5$%/0*$6$2*23%*<$%
'<"6"'*$6/2*/'2% ,-% *<$% 6$#/9$% ,6% /02*/*(*/,03% "01%*<$% )$5$)% ,-% ',9@)/"0'$% "01% 6$2@,02$% ,-% @,)/'+%
/9@)$9$0*$62;%%
?<$%@,B$6%"2@$'*%,-%"'*,62%B/))%/0-)($0'$%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%C"2$1%,0%*<$/6%@,B$6%@,2/*/,02%
"01%2*6"*$#/$2%(2$1%*,%6$")/H$%*<$/6%@$62,0")%/0*$6$2*2;%`0%*<$%,*<$6%<"013%*<$%6$#/9$L2%'<"6"'*$6/2*/'2%
B/))%/0-)($0'$%@,)/'+%"'*,62L%C$<"5/,6%/0%*<$%@6,'$22%,-%/9@)$9$0*/0#%@,)/'/$2;%?<$%'<"6"'*$6/2*/'2%,-%*<$%
6$#/9$%'"0%")2,%C$%9$"2(6$1%-6,9%*<$%@,)/*/'")%2+2*$9%*,%B</'<%/*%6$-$62;%D%1$9,'6"*/'%6$#/9$%B/))%
9/0/9/H$%/0*$65$0*/,0%/0%@,)/'+%/0%$5$6+%/02*/*(*/,03%"01%,0%*<$%',0*6"6+3%"0%"(*<,6/*"6/"0%6$#/9$%B/))%
'$0*6")/H$%"01%/0*$65$0$%2*6,0#)+%/0%@,)/'+%/0%$5$6+%/02*/*(*/,0;%?<$0%6$#"61/0#%"2@$'*2%,-%*<$%)$5$)%,-%
',9@)/"0'$%"01%6$2@,02/5$0$22%,-%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*$62%B/))%"--$'*%',02/2*$0'+%/0%/9@)$9$0*/0#%@,)/'/$2%
"'',61/0#%*,%@6,'$1(6$2%"01%*<$%6$2@,02/5$%"C/)/*+%,-%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*$62;%%
?<$% @,B$6% "2@$'*% ,-% "'*,62% B<,% <"5$% /0*$6$2*2% /2% "% -"'*,6% *<"*% #6$"*)+% /0-)($0'$2% *<$%
/9@)$9$0*"*/,0% ,-% J8&% @,)/'/$2;% !,2/*/,02% ,-% @,B$6% *<"*% @6,5/1$% "0% ,@$0/0#% -,6% *<$% $0*6+% ,-% 2$)-c
/0*$6$2*%$G/2*%"*%$5$6+%)$5$)%,-%@,B$63%-6,9%*<$%</#<$2*%)$5$)%,-%@,B$6%*,%*<$%9/11)$%)$5$);%?<$%),,@<,)$%
-,6%"C(2$%,-%@,B$6%-,6%@$62,0")%/0*$6$2*2%"*%*<$%</#<$2*%)$5$)%,-%@,B$6%/2%/0%*<$%@,2/*/,0%,-%*<$%^(1#$*%
42$6%"01%*<$%!,B$6%,-%*<$%^(1#$*%42$63%0"9$)+%*<$%J/0/2*$6%,-%W$-$02$3%*<$%.$'6$*"6+%I$0$6")%,-%*<$%
J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$3%*<$%Y,99"01$6%,-%*<$%?A7%"01%*<$%Y</$-%,-%.*"--%/0%$"'<%-,6'$;%?</2%/2%C$'"(2$%$5$6+%
1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%@6,'(6$9$0*%"01%9"/0*$0"0'$%@6,'$22%*<"*%6$](/6$2%-/0"0'/0#%9(2*%#$*%"@@6,5")%
-6,9%*<$%^(1#$*% 42$6% "01% *<$% !,B$6% ,-%^(1#$*%42$6;% 70% "11/*/,03% *<$% ',99"01%'()*(6$% B/*</0% *<$%
J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$%"01%*<$%?A7%'"(2$2%*<$%@,22/C/)/*+%,-%@,)/'+%"'*,62%"*%*<$%9/11)$%"01%),B$2*%)$5$)2%
,-%@,B$6%"'*/0#%(00,*/'$1%C+%,--/'/")2%"*%*<$%</#<$2*%)$5$)2%,-%@,B$6;%
`0%*<$%,*<$6%<"013%*<$%2*6"*$#+%(2$1%C+%"'*,62%/0*$6$2*$1%/0%/9@)$9$0*/0#%J8&%@,)/'/$2%/2%*,%
>$$@% @(C)/'% "''$22% "B"+% -6,9% @)"00/0#3% /9@)$9$0*/0#3% "01% $5")("*/0#% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*%
9,1$60/H"*/,0% @,)/'/$2;% `-*$03% 1$-$02$% /22($2% *$01% *,% C$% ',5$6$1% (@% C"2$1% ,0% 2*"*$% 2$'6$*23% B</)$%
C(1#$*2%9(2*%C$%*6"02@"6$0*3%/0')(1/0#%1$-$02$%C(1#$*2;%D'*,62%B<,%<"5$%@6/5"*$%/0*$6$2*2%*$01%*,%*">$%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research3%%
I6"'/"%."6"<%D69"1"0/13%J$/1/%K,2"01/2%
IJSSR !"#$%140%
"15"0*"#$%,-%D6*/')$%Rf%/0%U"B%A(9C$6%RS%,-%PQQg%',0'$60/0#%!(C)/'%70-,69"*/,0%`@$00$223%B</'<%
$G')(1$2%2$5$6")%'"*$#,6/$2%,-%/0-,69"*/,0%/0%*<$%1$-$02$%2$'*,6%"2%@(C)/'%/0-,69"*/,0;%!,/0*%Y%/0%"6*/')$%
Rf%,-%*<$%K7!%U"B%2*"*$2%*<"*%*<$%$G')(2/,0%,-%@(C)/'%/0-,69"*/,0%/0%*<$%1$-$02$%"01%2$'(6/*+%2$'*,6%
/0')(1$2%2$5$0%*</0#23%0"9$)+:%%
"; 70-,69"*/,0%,0%2*6"*$#/$23%/0*$))/#$0'$3%,@$6"*/,023%*"'*/'23%"01%*$'<0/]($2%6$)"*$1%*,%*<$%',(0*6+L2%
1$-$02$%"01%2$'(6/*+%2+2*$923%',5$6/0#%*<$%@)"00/0#3%/9@)$9$0*"*/,03%"01%$5")("*/,0% 2*"#$2% /0%
6$)"*/,0%*,%*<6$"*2%-6,9%B/*</0%"01%,(*2/1$%*<$%',(0*6+;%%
C; ?<$%1,'(9$0*%',0*"/02%2*6"*$#/$23%/0*$))/#$0'$3%,@$6"*/,023%*"'*/'2%"01%*$'<0/]($2%6$)"*$1%*,%*<$%
',(0*6+L2% 1$-$02$% "01% 2$'(6/*+% 2+2*$93% ',5$6/0#% *<$% @)"00/0#3% /9@)$9$0*"*/,0% "01% $5")("*/,0%
2*"#$2;%%
'; ?<$%0(9C$63%',9@,2/*/,03%1/2@,2/*/,0%,6%1/2),'"*/,0%,-%-,6'$2%"01%'"@"C/)/*/$2%/0%"19/0/2*6"*/0#%
*<$%',(0*6+L2%1$-$02$%"01%2$'(6/*+%2+2*$9%"01%/*2%1$5$),@9$0*%@)"0;%%
1; 79"#$2%"01%1"*"%"C,(*%*<$%2/*("*/,0%"01%2*"*$%,-%9/)/*"6+%C"2$2%"01e,6%/02*"))"*/,02;%
$; W"*"% ,0% $2*/9"*$2% ,-% *<$% 9/)/*"6+% "01% 1$-$02$% '"@"C/)/*/$2% ,-% ,*<$6% ',(0*6/$2% "6$% )/9/*$1% *,% "))%
"'*/,02%"01e,6%/01/'"*/,02%,-%*<"*%',(0*6+%*<"*%9"+%$01"0#$6%*<$%2,5$6$/#0*+%,-%*<$%40/*"6+%.*"*$%
,-% *<$% X$@(C)/'% ,-% 701,0$2/"% "01e,6% 1"*"% 6$)"*$1% *,% 9/)/*"6+% ',,@$6"*/,0% B/*<% ,*<$6% ',(0*6/$2%
"#6$$1%/0%*<$%"#6$$9$0*%"2%',0-/1$0*/")%,6%</#<)+%',0-/1$0*/");%%
-; .*"*$%'/@<$6%2+2*$9;%%
#; .*"*$%/0*$))/#$0'$%2+2*$9;%%
?<$2$%2$5$0%'"*$#,6/$2%,-%@(C)/'%/0-,69"*/,0%$G')(2/,02%"6$%,-*$0%(2$1%"2%"%6$"2,0%*,%'),2$%"))%
"''$22%*,%/0-,69"*/,0%/0%*<$%1$-$02$%2$'*,6;%?<$%?A7%J8&%W$5$),@9$0*%D00$G%W,'(9$0*%"01%*<$%?A7%
J8&%D)/#09$0*%W,'(9$0*%"6$%',0-/1$0*/")%1,'(9$0*2%*<"*%*<$%@(C)/'%'"00,*%"''$223%B</)$%*<$%1$-$02$%
C(1#$*%")),'"*/,0%-,6%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0%0$$12%*,%C$%>0,B0%*,%*<$%@(C)/'%',02/1$6/0#%
*<$% )"6#$% "9,(0*% ,-% 1$-$02$% C(1#$*% "01% ',66(@*/,0% '"2$2% *<"*% <"5$% ,''(66$1% C$-,6$;% W/2'(22/,0%
9$$*/0#2%B/*<%Y,99/22/,0%7%,-%*<$%E,(2$%,-%X$@6$2$0*"*/5$2%,-%*<$%X$@(C)/'%,-%701,0$2/"%"6$%")2,%,-*$0%
<$)1%C$</01%'),2$1%1,,62;%?</2%9">$2%*<$%@(C)/'%',02/1$6%*<$%1$-$02$%/22($%/2%"0%$)/*$%/22($3%2,%/*%'"00,*%
C$%9,0/*,6$1;%
!,)/'+% "'*,62L% ',0'$602% "C,(*% 1/22$9/0"*/0#%/0-,69"*/,0% -,6% -,6$/#0% ',(0*6/$2% *,% 9"@%
701,0$2/"L2% 1$-$02$% ',01/*/,02% "6$% ")9,2*% /9@,22/C)$% *,% ',0*"/0% /0% *<$% '(66$0*% $6"% ,-% /0-,69"*/,0%
1/2'),2(6$;% ?<$% @(6'<"2$% ,-% B$"@,02% B/*<% *<$% I% *,% I% MI,5$609$0*% *,% I,5$609$0*T% 9$'<"0/29%
"(*,9"*/'"))+%,@$02%(@%@)"02%-,6%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%0$$12%"01%701,0$2/"L2%C(1#$*%"5"/)"C/)/*+%*,%,*<$6%
',(0*6/$23% ")*<,(#<% 0,*% ',9@6$<$02/5$)+;% 70% "11/*/,0% *,% *<$% I% *,% I% 9$'<"0/293% /0% *<$% @6,'$22% ,-%
@(6'<"2/0#%B$"@,023%"%*$01$6%9$'<"0/29%'"0%C$%-,)),B$1%C+%@"6*0$6%',9@"0/$2%-6,9%@6/5"*$%"692%
9"0(-"'*(6$62%"01%1/2*6/C(*,62%2,%*<"*%*<$2$%'/6')$2%'"0%,C*"/0%2/9/)"6%/0-,69"*/,0;%.(@@,2$%2$5$6")%
#6,(@2%,(*2/1$%*<$%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*$6%'"0%,C*"/0%/0-,69"*/,0%"C,(*%*<$%@)"0%-,6%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%
0$$12%"01%C(1#$*%"5"/)"C/)/*+;%70%*<"*%'"2$3%*<$6$%/2%0,%6$"2,0%*,%'),2$%*<$%/0-,69"*/,0%*,%*<$%@(C)/';%
^"2$1%,0%6$2$"6'<%/0*$65/$B2%',01('*$13%/*%/2%>0,B0%*<"*%*<$%@6,'$22%,-%@(6'<"2/0#%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%
/2%0,*%',0-/1$0*/");%?<$%2$'6$*%/2%B<$6$%*<$%/*$9%/2%(2$13%B<$6$%/*%B/))%C$%(2$13%<,B%/*%B/))%C$%(2$13%C+%
B<,9%/*%B/))%C$%(2$13%"01%*<$%1$*"/)2%,-%*<$%B$"@,0%2+2*$9;%?<(23%/-%*<$%-(6*<$6%@(C)/'%"''$22%*,%$0#"#$%
/0%2(@$65/2/,03%*<$%#6$"*$6%*<$%@,*$0*/")%-,6%"C(2$%,-%@,B$6%-,6%@$62,0")%/0*$6$2*2;%%
D2@$'*2%,-%6$#/9$%,6%/02*/*(*/,0%'<"6"'*$6/2*/'2%*<"*%"--$'*%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%J8&%'"0%C$%
9$"2(6$1%-6,9%*<$%@,)/*/'")%2+2*$9%*,%B</'<%/*%/2% 6$-$6$0'$1;%W$9,'6"*/H"*/,03%B</'<%<"2%,''(66$1%
2/0'$%*<$%-"))%,-%*<$%A$B%`61$6%6()$3%<"2%$0',(6"#$1%6$-,692%/0%9"0+%2$'*,623%/0')(1/0#%'/5/)/"0%9/)/*"6+%
',0*6,);%Y6,/22"0*%2*"*$2%*<"*%-/5$%"6$"2%,-%2*"*$%@,)/'+%'"0%C$%(2$1%"2%/01/'"*,62%,-%'/5/)/"0%',0*6,)%,5$6%
*<$%9/)/*"6+%(Croissant%&%Wurster,%2013);%?<$%-/5$%"6$"2%"6$%$)/*$%6$'6(/*9$0*3%@(C)/'%@,)/'+3%1,9$2*/'%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% <**@2:ee/a226;6/1B"0/02*/*(*$;',;/1e%
IJSSR!!"#$%141%
2$'(6/*+3%0"*/,0")%1$-$02$%"01%9/)/*"6+%,6#"0/H"*/,0;%&,6%',(0*6/$2%*<"*%<"5$%a(2*%$0*$6$1%*<$%2*"#$%,-%
1$9,'6"*/'%*6"02/*/,03%,0)+%*<6$$%,-%*<$9%',0*6/C(*$%#6$"*)+%*,%*<$%](")/*+%,-%1$9,'6"'+3%2,%/*%9(2*%C$%
',0*6,))$1% C+% '/5/)/"02;% ?<$2$% *<6$$% "6$% $)/*$% 6$'6(/*9$0*3% @(C)/'% @,)/'+3% "01% 1,9$2*/'% 2$'(6/*+;%
J$"0B</)$3%*<$%"6$"%,-%0"*/,0")%1$-$02$%"01%9/)/*"6+%,6#"0/H"*/,0%1/1%0,*%1/6$'*)+%/9@"'*%*<$%2(65/5")%
,-%*<$%0$B)+%$9$6#/0#%1$9,'6"*/'%6$#/9$;%?</2%9$"02%*<"*%9/)/*"6+%@6$6,#"*/5$2%"6$%2*/))%0$$1$1%/0%
C,*<%"6$"2;% 70% )/0$% B/*<% Y6,/22"0*L2% ,@/0/,03% *<$% 1$-$02$% 2$'*,6% /0% 701,0$2/"% /2% 2*/))% 9"0"#$1% B/*<%
9/)/*"6+%1,9/0"0'$;%`0%*<$%,*<$6% <"013%*</2%<"2%)$1%*,% "%C/"2%C$*B$$0%*<$%1$9,'6"*/'%C(6$"('6"*/'%
9,1$)%"01%*<$%@"*$60")/2*/'%0"*(6$%,-%*<$%9/)/*"6+%/0%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$;%%
7-%9$"2(6$1%C+%*<$%6$#/9$L2%/0-)($0'$%,0%1$-$02$%@,)/'+3%*<$%$6"%,-%!6$2/1$0*%d,>,%[/1,1,L2%
)$"1$62</@%',()1%0,*%/0*$65$0$%/0%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%*<$%J8&;%?</2%/2%$5/1$0'$1%C+%*<$%5/2/,0%,-%*<$%
B,6)1%9"6/*/9$%"G/2%/02@/6$1%C+%!6$2/1$0*%d,>,%[/1,1,3%B<,%9"1$%*<$%A"5+%"%6$2@$'*$1%"69$1%-,6'$%
/0%*<$%6$#/,0%2,%*<"*%/1$"))+3%*<$%A"5+L2%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%2@$01/0#%B/))%#$*%*<$%)"6#$2*%@,6*/,0%,-%
1$-$02$%2@$01/0#;%E,B$5$63%/0%@6"'*/'$3%*<$%")),'"*/,0%,-%A"5+%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%$G@$01/*(6$2%<"2%0,*%
/0'6$"2$1%2/#0/-/'"0*)+%"01%/2%2*/))%'"66/$1%C+%)"01;%?</2%2<,B2%*<"*%*<$%'<"6"'*$6/2*/'2%,-%"%1$9,'6"*/'%
6$#/9$%*<"*%1,%0,*%<"5$%*<$%@,)/*/'")%@,B$6%*,%/0*$65$0$%/0%6$2,)5/0#%,C2*"')$2%',9/0#%-6,9%9/)/*"6+%
@$62,00$)% "6$% ,0$% ,-% *<$% '"(2$2% ,-% *<$% 0,0c,@*/9")% /9@)$9$0*"*/,0% ,-% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*%
9,1$60/H"*/,0%@,)/'/$2%*<6,(#<%J8&;%%
D2@$'*2%,-%*<$%)$5$)%,-%',9@)/"0'$%"01%6$2@,02/5$0$22%/0%J8&%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%'"0%C$%9$"2(6$1%
-6,9%*<$%',02/2*$0'+%"01%6$2@,02/5$0$22%,-%@,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*$62;%?<$%6$2()*2%,-%*<$%$5")("*/,0%/0%J8&%
@<"2$% 77% ',0*"/0$1% /0% *<$% PQRb% J8&% D)/#09$0*% !,)/'+% 1,'(9$0*% "01% *<$% .*6"*$#/'% W$-$02$% X$5/$B%
1,'(9$0*%2*"*$1%*<"*%*<$%/9@)$9$0*$6%<"2%0,*%C$$0%-())+%#(/1$1%C+%*<$%?A7%J8&%^,,>3%0"9$)+%*<$%
"00$G%1,'(9$0*%,-%*<$%J/0/2*$6%,-%W$-$02$%0(9C$6%Vb%,-%PQR\%',0'$60/0#%*<$%W$5$),@9$0*%,-%*<$%?A7%
J8&%PQR\cPQRb;%?</2%/2%C$'"(2$%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0%/0%J8&%/2%
0,*% C+%*<$% @)"00$1% 0$$12% 1$*$69/0$1% /0% *<$% 2*6"*$#/'% @)"0;% ^"2$1% ,0% /0*$65/$B2% ',01('*$1% C+%
6$2$"6'<$62%"01% 6$2,(6'$% @$62,02% -6,9% *<$% W/6$'*,6"*$% I$0$6")% ,-% X$0<"0% K$9<"03% W/6$'*,6"*$%
I$0$6")%,-%K("*<"0%K$9<"03%"01%D26$0"%K.DU3%*<$%?A7%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%2<,@@/0#%)/2*%,-*$0%'<"0#$2%
/0%*<$%9/11)$%,-%*<$%'(66$0*%-/2'")%+$"6;%Y<"0#$2%/0%*<$%2<,@@/0#%)/2*%,-%A"5+%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%"6$%
,-*$0%0,*%$5$0%C+%*<$%0$$12%,-%*<$%A"5+%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%@6$@"6$1%/0%*<$%0$$12%@)"0%1,'(9$0*;%
70%"11/*/,03%*<$6$%"6$%2$5$6")%'<"0#$2%*,%*<$%2<,@@/0#%)/2*%,-%A"5+%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%*<"*%"6$%
0,*%',,61/0"*$1%B/*<%"))%@"6*/$2Z%/0%,*<$6%B,6123%*<$+%,0)+%/05,)5$%2$5$6")%@"6*/$2;%X$#()"*/,0%,-%*<$%
J/0/2*$6%,-%W$-$02$%0(9C$6%Rf%,-%PQRS%',0'$60/0#%*<$%79@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%*<$%!6,'(6$9$0*%,-%J"/0%
8](/@9$0*%,-%[$"@,0%.+2*$92%B/*</0%*<$%J/0/2*6+%,-%W$-$02$%"01%*<$%?A7%")2,%2*/@()"*$2%*<$%@"6*/$2%
/05,)5$1%/0%*<$%9,1$60/H"*/,0%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%"01%*<$%@6,'(6$9$0*%9$'<"0/29%,-%?A7%1$-$02$%
$](/@9$0*;%D%2<,@@/0#%)/2*%,-%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%2(C9/**$1%C+%*<$%?A7%*,%*<$%W/6$'*,6"*$%I$0$6")%,-%
W$-$02$% !)"00/0#% *,% "1a(2*% C(1#$*% "5"/)"C/)/*+;% 7-% *<$% C(1#$*% /2% "5"/)"C)$3% *<$% 1$-$02$% $](/@9$0*%
2<,@@/0#%)/2*%/2%2(C9/**$1%*,%*<$%W/6$'*,6"*$%I$0$6")%,-%K("*<"0%*,%2+0'<6,0/H$%B/*<%*<$%0$$12%@)"0%
@6$@"6$1%/0%*<$%J8&%C,,>;%D-*$6%*<$%@)"0%1$')"6$2%*<$%2<,@@/0#%)/2*3%*<$%$G$'(*/,0%@6,'$22%/2%<"01$1%
,5$6%*,%*<$%W$-$02$%&"'/)/*/$2%"01%70-6"2*6('*(6$%D#$0'+%M^"6"0"<"0%K$9<"0T;%%
?</2%@6,5$2%*<"*%/9@)$9$0*/0#%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%9,1$60/H"*/,0%/0%J8&%/2%0,%),0#$6%C+%*<$%
$22$0'$%,-%J8&%/*2$)-3%B</'<%6$-$62%*,%*<$%1$*$66$0'$%-(0'*/,0;%!,)/'+%/9@)$9$0*$62%B<,%1,%0,*%',9@)+%
B/*<%-,)),B/0#%@6,'$1(6$23%)"B23%"01%6$#()"*/,02%6$)"*$1%*,%J8&%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%0,*%,0)+%6$2()*%/0%*<$%
,Ca$'*/5$2%,-%*<$%J8&%1$5/"*/0#%-6,9%*<$%,6/#/0")%#,")%C(*%")2,%,@$0%*<$%#"@%-,6%*<$%$9$6#$0'$%,-%"C(2$%
,-%@,B$6%,6%"C(2$%,-%@,B$63%B</'<%'"(2$2%*<$%9,1$60/H"*/,0%,-%?A7%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%*<6,(#<%J8&%
<"2%0,*%6$"'<$1%*<$%*"6#$*%*,%1"*$;%
!
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research3%%
I6"'/"%."6"<%D69"1"0/13%J$/1/%K,2"01/2%
IJSSR !"#$%142%
CONCLUSION,
?<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%,-%*<$%9,1$60/H"*/,0%,-%A"5+%1$-$02$%$](/@9$0*%*<6,(#<%J8&%!<"2$%77%PQR\c
PQRb%<"2%0,*%,@*/9"))+%"'</$5$1%*<$%1$2/6$1%*"6#$*;%&"'*,62%2('<%"2%)/9/*$1%1$-$02$%C(1#$*2%*<"*%"6$%0,*%C+%
@6$5/,(2% @)"00/0#% 0$$123% 1/--$6$0'$2% /0% (01$62*"01/0#% C$*B$$0% @,)/'+% "'*,62% ,-% J8&3% )$22% ,@*/9")%
2(@$65/2/,0%"01%',0*6,)%/0%*<$%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0%@6,'$223%"01%*<$%6,)$%,-%*<$%1,9$2*/'%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%*<"*%
<"2%0,*%C$$0%,@*/9")%"6$%*<$%9"/0%,C2*"')$2;%85")("*/,0%,-%1,'(9$0*23%/0*$65/$B2%B/*<%2*">$<,)1$623%"01%
9,0/*,6/0#% -6,9% 1$-$02$% "01% 9/)/*"6+% $G@$6*2% 2<,B% *<"*% *<$% 9"/0% ',02*6"/0*% )/$2% 0,*% ,0)+% /0% )/9/*$1%
6$2,(6'$2% C(*% 6"*<$6% 1$*$69/0$1% C+% *<$% @,)/*/'")% B/))% ,-% @,)/'+% "'*,62;% Y,02/2*$0'+% /0% /9@)$9$0*"*/,0%
"'',61/0#% *,% @)"00$1% 0$$123% ',99/*9$0*% *,% *6"02@"6$0'+% "01% "'',(0*"C/)/*+3% "01%/0'6$"2/0#% 6$2,(6'$%
'"@"'/*+%*<6,(#<%@6/,6/*+%2'")$%"01%$9@,B$69$0*%,-%*<$%1$-$02$%/01(2*6+%"6$%"2@$'*2%*<"*%6$](/6$%@,)/*/'")%
B/))%2(@@,6*%*,%9/0/9/H$%',0-)/'*2%,-%/0*$6$2*%"01%/0'6$"2$%*<$%$--$'*/5$0$22%,-%J8&%/9@)$9$0*"*/,0;%
!
REFERENCES,
D-$0+,3%J;3%O%Y"$2"63%U;%W;%MPQPVT;%J"6/*/9$%'+C$62$'(6/*+%*<6$"*2:%I"@2%"01%1/6$'*/,02%-,6%-(*(6$%6$2$"6'<;%
)$"+,(+,'(B/+;.+0(C+,+*"6",.3%DEF;%<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;RQRied;`Y8Y`DJDA;PQPV;RQiSbV%
D)]"<*"0/3%&;3%.$)5/"6/1/23%K;3%O%.*$5$02,03%J;%MPQPVT;%?<$%$--$'*/5$0$22%,-%@$6-,69"0'$cC"2$1%',0*6"'*/0#%/0%
*<$%1$-$0'$%2$'*,6:%D%2+2*$9"*/'%)/*$6"*(6$%6$5/$B;%G/2#,+0(/8(!2#$=+;%,*(+,'(123307(C+,+*"6",.3%
DHM\T;%<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;RQRied;!4X.4!;PQPV;RQQgff%
^($#$63%Y;3%O%U/$C$*6"(3%?;%MPQPVT;%Y6/*/'")%9"6/*/9$%/0-6"2*6('*(6$%@6,*$'*/,0:%[<"*k2%*<$%*6,(C)$l%C+#%,"(
!/0%$73%IJJ3%RQ\ffP;%<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;RQRied;JDX!`U;PQPV;RQ\ffP%
Y<$03%j;3%E,0#3%W;3%Y(/3%[;3%m($3%[;3%["0#3%N;3%O%j<,0#3%d;%MPQPVT;%X$2/)/$0'$%$5")("*/,0%"01%,@*/9")%1$2/#0%-,6%
B$"@,0%2+2*$9%,-%2+2*$92%B/*<%1+0"9/'%6$',0-/#(6"*/,0;%K"0%+L%0%.7(5,*%,""#%,*(+,'(17;."6(1+8".73%
DEM;%<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;RQRied;X8..;PQPV;RQbSQb%
Y6$2B$))3%d;%[;%MPQRPT;%K";"+#$=('";%*,N(3",'"O+.+,(O2+0%.+.%84(O2+,.%.+.%84('+,(6%P"';%
Y6,/22"0*3%D;3%O%[(62*$63%.;%MPQRVT;%!$6-,69"0'$%"01%@$62/2*$0'$%,-%"(*,'6"'/$2%/0%',9@"6/2,0:%/0*6,1('/0#%
/22($2%"01%@$62@$'*/5$2;%B/,."63/#+#7(!/0%.%$;3%IHMRT3%RnRg;%
W/6<"92+"<3%W;3%49"93%.;3%O%D6/-/03%j;%MPQPPT;%J"6/*/9$%)"B%$0-,6'$9$0*:%701,0$2/"k2%$G@$6/$0'$%"#"/02*%
/))$#")% -/2</0#;% )$"+,( +,'( B/+;.+0( C+,+*"6",.3% DDH;%
<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;RQRied;`Y8Y`DJDA;PQPP;RQiVQS%
&"a6/0"3%D;%A;3%X,H/]/03%D;3%O%./</1/3%7;%?;%MPQPQT;%.*(1/%I$,@,)/*/>%U"(*%Y</0"%.$)"*"0:%W"*"%W"0%D0")/2/2%J$1/"%
.,2/");%G2#,+0(Q"6=+,,+;(K>3%RMPT3%RR\nRVQ;%
I6/01)$3%J;%.;%MPQRfT;%!/0%.%$;(+,'(3/0%$7(%630"6",.+.%/,(%,(.="(<=%#'(S/#0'%MF,);%SggQT;%!6/0'$*,0%40/5$62/*+%
!6$22;%
I_)'"03% ?;% D;3%O% 86#/0$63% K;% 8;% MPQPVT;%A"*/,0")% "01%/0*$60"*/,0")% 9"6/*/9$% 2/*("*/,0")%"B"6$0$22% 9,1$)%
$G"9@)$2% "01% *<$% $--$'*2% ,-% A,6*<% .*6$"9% !/@$)/0$2% 2"C,*"#$;% >,."#,+.%/,+0( G/2#,+0( /8( B#%.%$+0(
>,8#+;.#2$.2#"(!#/."$.%/,3%TD;%<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;RQRied;7dY7!;PQPV;RQQiPS%
E"03%o;3%!"0#3%^;3%U/3%.;3%U/3%A;3%I(,3%!;%2,0#3%&"03%Y;%)/3%O%U/3%[;%9/0;%MPQPVT;%85")("*/,0%9$*<,1%"01%,@*/9/H"*/,0%
2*6"*$#/$2%,-%6$2/)/$0'$%-,6%"/6%O%2@"'$%1$-$02$%2+2*$9%,-%2+2*$92%C"2$1%,0%>/))%0$*B,6>%*<$,6+%"01%
/9@6,5$1% 2$)-c/0-,69"*/,0% ]("0*/*+;% U"8",$"( <"$=,/0/*73% DI3% PRbnPVb;%
<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;RQRied;W?;PQPV;QR;QQ\%
E"6*,0,3%D;%.;%MPQPRT;%40/5$62")%["6%.*6"*$#+%.(@@,6*$1%!,)/*/'")%70*$#6"*/,0%X$5/$B$1%-6,9%?<$%?</61%./)"%
!"0'"2/)"Z% ?<$% 40/*+% ,-% 701,0$2/";% G/2#,+0( /8( 1/$%+0( 1$%",$"3% DMVT3% PPgnPVS;%
<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;Sifbbea22;5P/V;RPf%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% <**@2:ee/a226;6/1B"0/02*/*(*$;',;/1e%
IJSSR!!"#$%143%
d/"0G/0#3%I;3%!$/+("03%W;3%d/"6(/3%j;3%o("03%U;3%O%N(2<"03%I;%MPQPPT;%D%A$*B,6>%.*6('*(6$%`@*/9/H"*/,0%J$*<,1%
-,6% K$+% !)"'$% D/6% W$-$02$% .+2*$9;% >V:BW!+3"#;),Q%,"3% JJMVT3% PRVnPRg;%
<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;RQRied;7&DY`U;PQPP;Q\;QVf%
K,5"'3%J;3%.*,a>,5/'3%W;3%O%J/*/'3%F;%MPQRVT;%Y"@"C/)/*+%C"2$1%1$-$0'$%1$5$),@9$0*%@)"00/0#c,@*/9")%,@*/,0%
2$)$'*/,0%-,6%'"@"C/)/*+%1$5$),@9$0*;%X>(Y+0O+,(B/,8"#",$"(/,()3"#+.%/,+0(K"$+#$=(ZY:QB)KWD[IEA4(
B/,8"#",$"3%\\Rn\\g;%
U$$3% d;% I;3% O% !"6>3% J;% d;% MPQPQT;% 85")("*/,0% ,-% *$'<0,),#/'")% ',9@$*$0'$% "01% ,@$6"*/,02% $--/'/$0'+% /0% *<$%
1$-$02$% /01(2*6+:% ?<$% 2*6"*$#/'% @)"00/0#% ,-% .,(*<% K,6$";% 5&+02+.%/,( +,'( !#/*#+6( !0+,,%,*3% MH;%
<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;RQRied;8FDU!X`I!UDA;PQRb;RQRff\%
J,6$/6"3%J;%p;%U;3%1$%.,(H"3%I;%F;%!;3%1$%D6"qa,%Y,2*"3%7;%!;3%d(0/,63%[;%?;3%&r5$6,3%U;%!;3%1,2%."0*,23%J;3%O%I,9$23%
Y;% &;% .;% MPQPVT;% W$-$02$% !$6'$@*/,0% /0% *<$% I$,@,)/*/'")% .',@$:% D0% $G@),6"*,6+% 2*(1+% *<6,(#<%
(02(@$65/2$1% 9"'</0$% )$"60/0#;% !#/$"'%+( B/632."#( 1$%",$"3% DDI3% igbnibi;%
<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;RQRied;!X`Y.;PQPV;Qg;QVb%
A/01+"3%D;%!;3%O%DC/++"3%X;%D;%MPQPPT;%!$0#"6(<%D4K4.%*$6<"1"@%.*"C/)/*"2%701,c!"2/-/>%1"0%./>"@%701,0$2/"%
s?<$%70-)($0'$%,-%D4K4.%*,%701,c!"'/-/'%X$#/,0")%.*"C/)/*+%"01%701,0$2/"k2%.*"0'$t;%G2#,+0(!/0%.%$+(
U%,+6%O+(C+;+0+=(!/0%.%O(U+0+6(\"*"#%(U+,(]2L2,*+,(>,."#,+;%/,+03%IEMRT3%ifngS;%
X/-"/3%J;3%?(*(3%D;3%J()+"0/3%J;3%.(06"3%D;3%O%!6/<"0*,6,3%K;%MPQPPT;%!8AIDX4E%DAIIDXDA%!8X?DEDADA%
WDA% J7A7J4J% 8..8A?7DU% &`XY8% WDUDJ% J8AIEDWD!7% DAYDJDA% A`A% J7U7?8X:M.*(1/% 1/%
W/6$>*,6"*%d$01$6")%K$>("*"0%!$6*"<"0"0T;%B%.%-",N(G2#,+0(>06%+=(C20.%'%;%30%,(>,'/,";%+3%DMRT3%RgVn
Rbg;%
."6a/*,3%D;3%D)/3%N;3%O%[/a"+"3%D;%&;%MPQRbT;%8-$>*/5/*"2%K$C/a">"0%J/0/9(9%822$0*/")%&,6'$%K,9@,0$0%4*"9"%
?$0*"6"% A"2/,0")% 701,0$2/"% D0#>"*"0% U"(*;% C+,+^"6",( !"#.+=+,+,N( G2#,+0( !"6%O%#+,( U+,(
!","0%.%+,(C+,+^"6",(!"#.+=+,+,3%TMPT;%
.(#/+,0,3%!;%MPQQfT;%1.+.%;.%O+(_,.2O(!","0%.%+,4(Y+,'2,*N(B`;%D)-"C$*";%
.(@6/+"*0,3%J;%MPQRST;%<",.+,*(%062(3"#.+=+,+,;%N"+"2"0%!(2*">"%`C,6%701,0$2/";%
?/"03% A;3% K(/9,5"3% D;3% U,@$2% W"% ./)5"3% W;3% [$H$9"03% !;3% O% [$H$9"03% .;% MPQPQT;% <#",';( %;( S/#0'( C%0%.+#7(
5P3",'%.2#"4(D[IH?(1./$O=/06(>,."#,+.%/,+0(!"+$"(K";"+#$=(>,;.%.2.";%
?(0'$63%`;3%O%Y/6@"03%E;%D;%MPQPVT;%D1"@*/5$%-(HH+%C"2$1%*<6$"*%$5")("*/,0%9$*<,1%-,6%"/6%"01%9/22/)$%1$-$02$%
2+2*$92;%>,8/#6+.%/,(1$%",$";3%FTE;%<**@2:ee1,/;,6#eRQ;RQRied;7A.;PQPV;RRbRbR%
[/1a"a"0*,3%D;%MPQRQT;%85,)(2/%1,>*6/0%@$6*"<"0"0%701,0$2/";%!#%;6+3%DHMRT3%VnPQ;%
[/1,1,3%.;%MPQRbT;%79@)$9$0*"2/%K$C/a">"0%!$9C"0#(0"0%K$>("*"0%!$6*"<"0"0%41"6";%G2#,+0(>06%+=(CW
!#/*#";;3%HMPT;%
N(1</2*+6"3%[;%7;3%O%A(#6,<,3%8;%MPQRST;%U/9"%J$*,1$%!$6$0'"0""0%.*6"*$#/2%./2*$9%70-,69"2/%W"0%?$>0,),#/%
70-,69"2/% 40*(>% !$0#$9C"0#"0% 8cI,5$69$0*;% 1"6%,+#( \+;%/,+0( <"O,/0/*%( >,8/#6+;%( U+,(
a/62,%O+;%3%PVinPSS;%
Copyright!holder:!
I6"'/"%."6"<%D69"1"0/3%J$/1/%K,2"01/#MPQPST!
!
First!publication!rights:!
70*$60"*/,0")%d,(60")%,-%.,'/")%.$65/'$%"01%X$2$"6'<%M7d..XT%
!
This!article!is!licensed!under:!
!
!
!
%
