Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Vol.%%03,%No.%12,%December%2023%
e-ISSN:%2807-8691,|,p-ISSN:%2807-839X$
!
IJSSR!!"#$%3104
!""#$%&&'()*(+,&-.*/0122&)3$$+*45)-6*0607
This%work%is%licensed%under%a%Attribution-ShareAlike%4.0%International%(CC%BY-SA%4.0)
Evaluation*of*Occupational*Health*Safety*Management*
System*in*Hospitals*in*Banda*Aceh*City*!
!
Cut!Mutiawati
1
,!Mariana
2
,!Mahidin
3
!
&"'($)%*+%,-./)*-0$-("1%&"-"#$0$-(%2(345%!)*#)"06%7"831(5%*+%!*'(#)"43"($6%25/"9%:3"1"%;-/.$)'/(56%
<-4*-$'/"
1,2,3
%
,0"/1=%83(03(/">?>?@#0"/1A8*0
1
,"0")/"-"@3-'5/"9A"8A/4
2
6%0"9/4/-@3-'5/"9A"8A/4
3%
Keywords)
!
ABSTRACT!
Hospital,"Evaluation,"K3,"
Environment.!
"
8!97 :($"7 '(:);<;"7 !($#)"<=7 <>")4)"?7 <>"(+$7 <"7 +)$@7 (A7
(>>B#<")(;<=7 $<A9"?7 <>>)'9;"$7 CDEF5G7 <+97 !($#)"<=7 9:#=(?99$7
$B>!7 <$7 ;B+$9$H7 cleaning( servicesH7 #<")9;"$7 <;'7 4)$)"(+$*7 8!97
#B+#($97(A7"!)$7$"B'?7I<$7"(794<=B<"97"!97<##=)><")(;7<;'7A<>"(+$7
<AA9>");,7 "!97 ):#=9:9;"<")(;7 (A7 (>>B#<")(;<=7 !9<="!7 <;'7
9;4)+(;:9;"<=7$<A9"?7:<;<,9:9;"7$?$"9:$7<"7'+*7J<);<=7KL)');7
M9,)(;<=7 N9;9+<=7 O($#)"<=H7 E9B+<P<7 O($#)"<=7 <;'7 Q<;'<7 K>9!7
E("!9+7<;'7R!)='7O($#)"<=*78!97'<"<7>(==9>")(;7"9>!;)SB97B$9$7<7
:)P7:9"!('7 "!<"7>(:L);9$7SB<;")"<")497<;'7SB<=)"<")497'<"<7I)"!7
$9SB9;")<=79P#=<;<"(+?7$"+<"9,)9$*78!97=9,<=7L<$)$7)$7T9+:9;@9$7
U(*7007(A76.-0H7<;'7"!97'<"<7I<$7<;<=?V9'7B$);,7"!97W)@9+"7$><=97
:9"!('7 #();"$7 -XY7 "!+(B,!7 DTDD7 49+$)(;7 60*7 8!97 +9$B="$7 (A7
+9$9<+>!7<"7MDZ[JKH7MD\KH7<;'7MDZ[E7Q<;'<7K>9!7$!(I7"!<"7"!97
<##=)><")(;7 (A7 DEF57 )$7 ,(('7 "(7 49+?7 ,(('*7 O(I949+H7 "!9+97 <+97
$949+<=7 );!)L)");,7 A<>"(+$7 "!<"7 ;99'7 "(7 L97 >(;$)'9+9'7 L?7 "!97
!($#)"<=7 );7 (+'9+7 "(7 ):#+(497 "!97 ):#=9:9;"<")(;7 (A7 "!97
]>>B#<")(;<=7D<A9"?7<;'7O9<="!7E<;<,9:9;"7D?$"9:7CDEF5G7<"7
MDZ[JKH7 MD\KH7<;'7 MDZ[E7Q<;'<7 K>9!H7$(:97):#+(49:9;"$7><;7
L97+9>(::9;'9'*7^)+$"H7MDZ[JK7;99'$7"(79;$B+97"!97$"<L)=)"?7(A7
F57A)9='7 (AA)>9+$7<;'7):#+(497"!97: <+@);,7(A7F57$),;$*7\;7<'')")(;H7
"!97B;)A)><")(;7(A7"!97'+B,7+((: 7 I )"!7# !<+: <>?7 9: # =(?99$7: B$"7
L97$9#<+<"9'7"(7L97:(+979AA9>")49*7MD\K7;99'$7"(7(L"<);7LB',9"7
A(+7>9)=);,7+9#<)+$7$(7<$7"(7L=(>@74<+)(B$7$:<==7')+"7A<==);,7A+(:7
+((A7 ,<#$H7 <4()'7 $#=<$!);,7 +<);I<"9+7 A<==);,7 "!+(B,!7 "!97 +((A7
);$B=<"(+$7(+7+9,B=<"(+$7(A7!9<"7<;'7>(='7>(:);,7A+(:7"!97+((AH7
+((A7A+<:97>(49+$7"(7:<@97"!97$#<>97;9<"9+7<;'7>=9<;9+H7$(B;'7
'<:#9+$H7 L("!7 ,9;9+<"9'7 L?7 +<);I<"9+7 <;'7 ("!9+7 $(B;'$7 <;'7
+9<++<;,97 "!97 +),!"7 :<"9+)<=7 #=<>9:9;"*7 MDZ[E7 ;99'$7 "(7
(49+>(:97$(=)'7 I<$"97#)=9$H7):#+(497"!97:<+@);,7 (A7 F57 +((:$H7
<;'7):#+(497"!97<++<;,9:9;"7(A7#<+@);,7<+9<$*7\;7<'')")(;H7)"7)$7
):#(+"<;"7 "(7 !)+97 <'')")(;<=7 $9>B+)"?7 #9+$(;;9=7 );7 "!97 _M*7 K==7
"!9$97 ):#+(49:9;"$7 <+97 9P#9>"9'7 "(7 ):#+(49 7 (>>B#< ")(;<=7
$<A9"?7<;'7!9<="!7>(;')")(;$7);7!($#)"<=$*7
!
!
!
INTRODUCTION%
B% 9$"1(9% '$)./8$% C1"8$6% *)% D$(($)% E-*F-% "'% "% 9*'C/("16% /'% "% 0$4/8"1% D3/14/-#% $G3/CC$4% F/(9%
+"8/1/(/$'%"-4%/-+)"'()38(3)$%(*%'$).$%./'/(*)'%"-4%'3CC*)(%930"-%)$'*3)8$'A%H9$%/-+13$-8$%*+%9*'C/("1'%
*-%'*8/$(5%/'%43"1%"-4%8"-%9".$%D*(9%C*'/(/.$%"-4%-$#"(/.$%/0C"8('%IJ"9"53%et"al.%K>K>L%M"953-/%et"al.%
K>K>NA%O*'C/("1%"8(/./(/$'6%$'C$8/"115%(9*'$%8"))/$4%*3(%D5%$0C1*5$$'%'389%"'%-3)'$'6%81$"-/-#%'$)./8$'6%
C"(/$-('6%"-4%./'/(*)'6%9".$%"%9/#9%)/'E%*+%"88/4$-('%IP"E0"-%et"al.%K>KKNA%H9/'%C*($-(/"1%)/'E%/-.*1.$'%
$-./)*-0$-("1% C*113(/*-% 43$% (*% 9"Q")4*3'% 0$4/8"1% F"'($% (9"(% 8"-% (9)$"($-% 930"-% 1/.$'% ")*3-4% (9$%
9*'C/("1%")$"%I&/-/'()5%*+%O$"1(96%K>>RNA%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research6%%
S3(%&3(/"F"(/
1
6%&")/"-"
2
6%&"9/4/-
3
%
IJSSR!!"#$%3105
O*'C/("1%F*)EC1"8$%"88/4$-('%8"-%D$%()/##$)$4%D5%4"-#$)*3'%F*)E/-#%$-./)*-0$-(%8*-4/(/*-'%
"-4%3-'"+$%930"-%D$9"./*)%I239")(*5*%et" al.% K>KKNA% H9$)$+*)$6%(9$)$%/'%"%-$$4%+*)%'$)/*3'%$++*)('%/-%
0"-"#/-#%*883C"(/*-"1%'"+$(5%"-4%9$"1(9%/-%9*'C/("1'%(*%)$438$%(9$%)/'E%*+%"88/4$-('%"-4%$-'3)$%"%'"+$%
$-./)*-0$-(%+*)%"11%C")(/$'%/-.*1.$4%/-%"8(/./(/$'%I&3(9*9")*9%4"-%M/D*F*%K>K>L%&3+/4"9%K>K?NA%
B88*)4/-#%(*% 4"("%+)*0% T!UB&2P2H,:6% 3-(/1%B3#3'(% K>KK6% (9$)$%F$)$%?V>% (9*3'"-4% 8"'$'%*+%
F*)E%"88/4$-('%F/(9%"%)$8*.$)5%)"($%*+%KWX6%"%4/'"D/1/(5%)"($%*+%YX6%"-4%"-%"88/4$-(%)"($%*+%YX%IT!U26%
K>?ZNA%H9$'$%+/#3)$'%)$+1$8(%"%'/#-/+/8"-(%1$.$1%*+%)/'E%/-%(9$%F*)E%$-./)*-0$-(%"8)*''%4/++$)$-(%'$8(*)'%
IB[<% K>?\L% 2".*5% K>KKNA% H9$)$+*)$6% /(% /'% /0C*)("-(% (*% +*11*F% 3C% D5% /0C1$0$-(/-#% $++$8(/.$% 9*'C/("1%
0"-"#$0$-(%(*%/0C)*.$%'3C$)./'/*-%"-4%$."13"(/*-%*+%(9$%P883C"(/*-"1%2"+$(5%"-4%O$"1(9%&"-"#$0$-(%
25'($0%I2&:YN%/-%9*'C/("1'%I,E"%7/()/"%et"al.%K>?RL%B1"0%et"al.%K>KYL%]/"*%et"al.%K>KYNA%
^**4%0"-"#$0$-(%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%0$"'3)$'%0"5%/-8134$%C1"--/-#6%0*-/(*)/-#6%$."13"(/-#6% "-4%
8*-(/-3*3'15%/0C)*./-#%9*'C/("1%*883C"(/*-"1%'"+$(5%"-4%9$"1(9%C*1/8/$'%IT"'("-/%et"al.%K>K?L%^$("93-%et"
al.%K>KYL%,-4$%et"al.%K>KYNA%H93'6%/(%/'%$_C$8($4%(*%)$438$%(9$%/-8/4$-8$%*+%F*)E%"88/4$-('6%/-8)$"'$%(9$%
83)$% )"($6% "-4% 0/-/0/Q$% (9$% /0C"8(% *+% 4/'"D/1/(5% "-4% +"("1% "88/4$-('A% H9/'% /-/(/"(/.$% -*(% *-15% "/0'% (*%
'"+$#3")4% (9$% F*)E+*)8$`'% F$11aD$/-#6% D3(% "1'*% (*% 8)$"($% "-% *.$)"11% '"+$% "-4% 9$"1(95% F*)E/-#%
$-./)*-0$-(%I:*."8$./8%et"al.%K>KYL%&"'E")/%et"al.%K>KYL%2*-("EE$%et"al.%K>KYNA%%%
2($C'%(*%".*/4%(9$%)/'E%*+%9"Q")4'%/-%9*'C/("1'%/-.*1.$%(9$%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%"-%P883C"(/*-"1%
O$"1(9% 2"+$(5% &"-"#$0$-(% 25'($0% I2&:YN% I[$F/% 4"-% M")4"-/% K>KKL% M/b$'/-#9$% et" al.% K>KYNA%
<0C1$0$-(/-#%P883C"(/*-"1% 2"+$(5% "-4%O$"1(9% I:YN%C*'/(/.$15% /0C"8('% )$438/-#% (9$%-30D$)% *+% F*)E%
"88/4$-('%(*%/0C)*.$%0"_/030%1"D*)%C$)+*)0"-8$%I<D)"9/0%K>?YL%T$-(1$5%et"al.%K>KYL%c/'F"-"(9"-%et"
al.%K>K\NA%:Y%O*'C/("16%"'%C")(%*+%2&:Y6%/'%4$+/-$4%"'%"%9$"1(9%'$)./8$%/-'(/(3(/*-%(9"(%/-.*1.$'%0$4/8"1%
C$)'*--$1%"-4%)$'$")89$)'%F9*%")$%"1'*%)$'C*-'/D1$%+*)%C)*./4/-#%$438"(/*-%I2"1/E3--"%4"-%H*F/4b*b*%
K>??N%
^$-$)"1156% /0C1$0$-(/-#% 2&:Y% /-% 9*'C/("1'% D)/-#'% 8*00/(0$-(% "-4% C*1/8/$'% (*% 8)$"($% "%
8*0+*)("D1$% F*)E% $-./)*-0$-(6% /-8)$"'/-#% 1"D*)% C)*438(/./(5A% ,++*)('% (*% )$438$% F*)E% "88/4$-('%
8*-(/-3$%(*%D$%8"))/$4%*3(%D5%(9$%^*.$)-0$-(%*+%B8$9%"'%*-$%*+%(9$%/-4/8"(*)'%*+%930"-%4$.$1*C0$-(%/-%
(9$%9$"1(9%'$8(*)A%B)(/81$%Y%*+%(9$%J$#31"(/*-%*+%(9$%&/-/'($)%*+%O$"1(9%d30D$)%?W%*+%K>?W%8*-8$)-/-#%
(9$% 8)/($)/"% +*)% 2&:Y% 9*'C/("1'% 8*-'/'('% *+% C1"--/-#6% C*1/85% 4$($)0/-"(/*-6% 0*-/(*)/-#6% $."13"(/*-6%
)$./$F6%"-4%/0C)*.$0$-(%*+%2&:Y%C$)+*)0"-8$A%O*'C/("1%1$"4$)'%")$%/0C*)("-(%/-%'$((/-#%:Y%C*1/8/$'%
"-4%")$%8*00/(($4%(*%/0C1$0$-(/-#%2&:Y%D5%"CC1/8"D1$%1$#"1%C)*./'/*-'A%
H9/'%'(345%+*83'$'%*-%$."13"(/-#%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%(9)$$%B8$9%C)*./-8$%9*'C/("1'=%[)A%
e"/-"1% BD/4/-% J$#/*-"1% ^$-$)"1% O*'C/("1% IJ2;[eBN6% &*(9$)% "-4% S9/14% O*'C/("1% IJ2<BN6% "-4% &$3)"_"%
J$#/*-"1% ^$-$)"1% O*'C/("1% IJ2;[&NA% T5% 3-4$)'("-4/-#% 83))$-(% P883C"(/*-"1% 2"+$(5% "-4% O$"1(9% I:YN%
C)"8(/8$'6% /4$-(/+5/-#% *D'("81$'% /-% 2&:Y% /0C1$0$-("(/*-6% "-4% "-"15Q/-#% (9$% /0C"8(% *+% 9*'C/("1%
"88)$4/("(/*-% *-% 2&:Y% /0C1$0$-("(/*-6% (9/'% )$'$")89% '$$E'% (*% C)*./4$% /-'/#9('% "-4% $_"0C1$'% +*)%
'()$-#(9$-/-#%P883C"(/*-"1%2"+$(5%"-4%O$"1(9%'("-4")4'%/-%(9$%9$"1(9%'$)./8$%'$8(*)A%
H9)*3#9% (9/'% )$'$")896% 4$$C$)% /-'/#9('% 8"-% D$% *D("/-$4% *-% (9$% $++$8(/.$-$''% *+% 2&:Y%
/0C1$0$-("(/*-% /-% 9*'C/("1'% "-4% C)*./4$% "% +*3-4"(/*-% +*)% /0C)*.$0$-('% (9"(% 0"5% D$% -$$4$4A% H9/'%
$."13"(/*-% /'% "1'*% 4/)$8($4% (*% C)*./4$% $_"0C1$'% "-4% 1$''*-'% 1$")-$4% +*)% *(9$)% 9*'C/("1'% /-% (9$%
'3))*3-4/-#%")$"%(*%'()$-#(9$-%P883C"(/*-"1%2"+$(5%"-4%O$"1(9%'("-4")4'%/-%(9$%9$"1(9%'$)./8$%'$8(*)A%
%
METHODS,
H9/'% '(345% 3'$'% "% 0/_$4% 0$(9*4% F/(9% "% '$G3$-(/"1% $_C1"-"(*)5% "CC)*"89% (*% $."13"($% (9$%
/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%(9$%P883C"(/*-"1%2"+$(5%"-4%O$"1(9%&"-"#$0$-(%25'($0%I2&:YN%/-%(9)$$%9*'C/("1'%
/-%T"-4"%B8$9%S/(56%-"0$15%[)A%e"/-*$1%BD/4/-%J$#/*-"1%^$-$)"1%O*'C/("1%IJ2;[eBN6%&*(9$)%"-4%S9/14%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research!% 9((C'=ff/b'')A)/4F"-/-'(/(3($A8*A/4f%
IJSSR!!"#$%3106
O*'C/("1%IJ2<BN6%"-4%&$3)"_"%J$#/*-"1%^$-$)"1%O*'C/("1%IJ2;[&NA%H9/'%0$(9*4%8*0D/-$'%G3"-(/("(/.$%
"-4%G3"1/("(/.$%4"("%F/(9%"%1$#"1%D"'/'%/-%(9$%+*)0%*+%!$)0$-E$'%d*A%WW%*+%K>?WA%
H9$%*Db$8(%*+%(9$%'(345%/-.*1.$4%(9$%(9)$$%9*'C/("1'6%F/(9%4"("%8*11$8(/*-%($89-/G3$'%8"))/$4%*3(%
(9)*3#9%/-($)./$F'%"-4%4/)$8(%*D'$)."(/*-%/-%(9$%+/$14A%<-+*)0"(/*-%+)*0%'$8(/*-%9$"4'%"-4%$0C1*5$$'%
)$1"($4%(*%P883C"(/*-"1%2"+$(5%"-4%O$"1(9%I:YN%"-4%9*'C/("1%$-./)*-0$-("1%0"-"#$0$-(%/'%*D("/-$4A%
!)/0")5% 4"("% 8*11$8(/*-% ($89-/G3$'% /-.*1.$% *D'$)."(/*-"1% 4"("6% /-($)./$F'6% G3$'(/*--"/)$'6%
4*830$-("(/*-6%"-4%"34/*%)$8*)4/-#'A%H9/'%C)/0")5%4"("%F"'%*D("/-$4%D5%4/)$8(15%*D'$)./-#%"8(/./(/$'%
/-%(9$%+/$146%8*-438(/-#%/-($)./$F'6%"-4%4/'()/D3(/-#%G3$'(/*--"/)$'%(*%)$C)$'$-("(/.$'%*+%:Y%$0C1*5$$'%
"-4%$-./)*-0$-("1%0"-"#$0$-(%$0C1*5$$'%/-%(9$%(9)$$%9*'C/("1'A%
!)/0")5% 4"("% 8*11$8(/*-% /-8134$'% C9*(*% 4*830$-("(/*-% *+% )$'$")89% "8(/./(/$'% "'% $./4$-8$% *+%
/0C1$0$-("(/*-% "883)"85A% &$"-F9/1$6% '$8*-4")5% 4"("% F$)$% *D("/-$4% +)*0% 1/($)"(3)$% '(34/$'% "-4%
$_/'(/-#%"40/-/'()"(/.$%4"("%)$1"($4%(*%(9$% /0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%(9$%9*'C/("1A%2$8*-4")5%4"("%"1'*%
/-8134$'%(9$%-30D$)%*+%F*)E%"88/4$-(%8"'$'%/-%K>KK%I23#/")(*%K>KKNA%
H9$% )$'$")89% .")/"D1$'% 8*-'/'(% *+% 4$C$-4$-(% .")/"D1$'6% -"0$15% (9$% -30D$)% *+% F*)E% "88/4$-(%
8"'$'%/-% (9$%(9)$$%9*'C/("1'6%"-4%/-4$C$-4$-(%.")/"D1$'6%-"0$15%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%D5%4$("/1/-#%
C*1/8/$'6% C1"--/-#6% /0C1$0$-("(/*-6% 0*-/(*)/-#6% "-4% $."13"(/*-6% "'% F$11% "'% )$./$F/-#% "-4% /0C)*./-#%
:YJ2%C$)+*)0"-8$A%
["("%"-"15'/'%($89-/G3$'%3'$%"%G3"-(/("(/.$%"CC)*"89%F/(9%4$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%0$(9*4'A%H9$%
"-"15'/'% /-.*1.$'% ."1/4/(5% ($'('6% )$1/"D/1/(5% ($'('6% -*)0"1/(5% ($'('6% 031(/8*11/-$")/(5% ($'('6%
9$($)*'8$4"'(/8/(5% ($'('6% 031(/C1$% 1/-$")% )$#)$''/*-% ($'('6% 95C*(9$'/'% ($'('6% 4$($)0/-"(/*-% 8*$++/8/$-(%
($'('6%"-4%'8*)/-#%0$(9*4'A%["("%C)*8$''/-#%/'%8"))/$4%*3(%3'/-#%2!22%'("(/'(/8"1%'*+(F")$%.$)'/*-%KWA%
H93'6% (9/'% '(345% 8*.$)'% .")/*3'% "'C$8('6% +)*0% +/$14% 4"("% 8*11$8(/*-% (*% '("(/'(/8"1% "-"15'/'6% +*83'/-#% *-%
$."13"(/-#%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%'$1$8($4%9*'C/("1'A%
%
RESULTS!
Evaluation!of!the!Application!of!SMK3!in!RSUDZA,!RSIA!and!RSUDM!in!Banda!Aceh!City!
;-4$)% (9$% )$+$)$-8$% C")"0$($)'% *+% !$)0$-E$'% d*AWW% *+% K>?W% *D("/-$4% +)*0% 4"("% C)*8$''/-#% /-% (9$%
2("(/'(/8"1% !)*#)"0% +*)% 2*8/"1% 28/$-8$'% I2!22N% c$)'/*-% KW% 0$(9*4A% O$)$% ")$% '*0$% 4$("/1'% *+% (9$%
C$)8$-("#$%."13$%*+%(9$%$."13"(/*-%"''$''0$-(%*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%*D("/-$4%+)*0%(9$%G3"-(/("(/.$%
G3$'(/*--"/)$%/-'()30$-(%4"("%C)*8$''/-#%/-%H"D1$%?%"-4%7/#3)$%KA%
%
Table!1.!Percentage!Instrument!Questionnaire!with!Likert!Scale!Interval!Method!
No!
Questionnaire!
Answers!
Value!Score!
Categories!
?%
2()*-#15%B#)$$%I22N%
g%
,_8$11$-(%
K%
B#)$$%I2N%
\%
^**4%
Y%
d$3()"1%IdN%
Y%
,-*3#9%
\%
[/'"#)$$%IH2N%
K%
d*(%#**4%
g%
2()*-#15%[/'"#)$$%I2H2N%
?%
T"4%
%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research6%%
S3(%&3(/"F"(/
1
6%&")/"-"
2
6%&"9/4/-
3
%
IJSSR!!"#$%3107
%
Figure!1.!Percentage!chart!of!questionnaire!instrument!with!Likert!scale!interval!method!point!
5!
T"'$4%*-%7/#3)$%?A%*+%(9$%#)"C9%"D*.$6%(9$%D13$%8*1*)%0$"-'%(9$%C$)8$-("#$%."13$%'(")(/-#%+)*0%
(9$%'0"11$'(%C$)8$-(6%"-4%(9$%*)"-#$%8*1*)%/'%(9$%C$)8$-("#$%."13$%(*%(9$%9/#9$'(%1/0/(%3'$4%/-%)$'$")89%
F/(9%(9$%]/E$)(%'8"1$%0$(9*4%C*/-('%?agA%
1. Descriptive!Statistical!Test!
H9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%4$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%$_C1"/-%D)/$+15%"-4%81$")15%"11%(9$%"-'F$)%C*/-('%
+)*0%(9$%)$'$")89%/-4/8"(*)'%*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%"(%J2;[eBA%H9$)$%")$%V%)$'$")89%/-4/8"(*)'%
8*-'/'(/-#%*+%g%.")/"D1$%h%/-4/8"(*)'%I/-4$C$-4$-(N%"-4%Y%.")/"D1$%i%/-4/8"(*)'%I4$C$-4$-(NA%c")/"D1$%
h% /-4/8"(*)'% ")$% (9$% /0C1$0$-("(/*-% *+% :YJ2% C*1/8/$'%"-4% C1"--/-#A% :YJ26% /0C1$0$-("(/*-% *+% (9$%
:YJ2% C1"-6% 0*-/(*)/-#6% "-4% $."13"(/*-% *+% :YJ2% C$)+*)0"-8$6% )$./$F% "-4% /0C)*.$0$-(% *+% 2&:Y%
C$)+*)0"-8$6%F9/1$% .")/"D1$%i%/4$-(/+/$'%F*)E%"88/4$-(%8"'$'%"(%J2;[eB6%J2<B% "-4%J2;[&%T"-4"%
B8$9A%H9$%4$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%"-"15Q$'%G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("%D5%($'(/-#%4$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8'%*-%
2&:Y%.")/"D1$'%"88*)4/-#%(*%)$+$)$-8$'%/-%!$)0$-E$'%d*AWW%*+%K>?W%D5%1**E/-#%"(%(9$%#$-$)"1%4"("%
4$'8)/C(/*-%'389%"'%(9$%".$)"#$%."13$%I0$"-N6%9/#9$'(%I0"_N6%1*F$'(%I0/-N%"-4%'("-4")4%4$./"(/*-%*+%
$"89%)$'$")89%.")/"D1$A%H9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%$."13"(/*-%*+%(9$%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%
"-4%J2;[&%T"-4"%B8$9%")$%'$$-%/-%H"D1$%KA%
%
Table!2.!Results!of!Descriptive!Statistical!Test!at!RSUDZA,!RSIA!and!RSUDM!in!Banda!Aceh!City%
[$'8)/C(/.$%2("(/'(/8'%SPSS"KW%
%
<-4/8"(*)'%
J2<B%
O*'C/("1%
&/-%
&"_%
&$"-%
2(4A%
[$.%
&/-%
&"_%
&$"-%
2(4A%
[$.%
&/-%
&"_%
&$"-%
2(4A%
[$.%
:/-4%
^$-4$)%
?%
K%
?Ag>%
Ag>g%
?%
K%
?A>Z%
KZ\%
?%
K%
?Ag>%
Ag?\%
B#$%
K%
V%
WAWg%
?AZRY%
g%
V%
RA\?%
??VK%
\%
V%
WAYY%
?AV?g%
]$-#(9%*+%M*)E%
?%
g%
\A?R%
?AYR\%
K%
g%
\ARY%
RWR%
K%
g%
YAgW%
?A>ZR%
!")(%
F*)E%
?%
K%
?AgW%
Ag>?%
?%
K%
?Agg%
g?>%
?%
K%
?Ag>%
Ag?\%
]$.$1%
,++$8(/.$-$''%
g%
\%
?A?R%
AYRR%
\%
g%
\A\?%
g>Y%
\%
g%
\AgW%
Ag??%
!*1/85%
,-+*)8$0$-(%
:Y%
??%
?g%
?YA\>%
?A\\>%
V%
?g%
??AYK%
KAKY\%
?K%
?g%
?YA?R%
?AKZg%
!1"--/-#%
:Y%
V%
?>%
ZAgK%
AWV\%
W%
?>%
RAVK%
?AKK>%
V%
?>%
ZA>>%
?A>KZ%
<0C1$0$-("(/*-%
:Y%C1"-%
Y>%
\>%
YRAR?%
KA\?\%
\\%
W>%
gKAKY%
\AZ\R%
YK%
\>%
YgAVZ%
YAYgZ%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
120%
Sangat Setuju (5) Setuju (4) Netral (3) Tidak Setuju (2) Sangat Tidak
Setuju (1)
Percentage of Questionnaire Instruments
Nilai Persentase < Nilai Persentase >
!"#$%&'()*&#++)
*&#++),-.)
/$%0")*&#++),1.)
Strongly)
Disagree)
2+#3+%"4&+)54'6+)
2+#3+%"4&+)54'6+)
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research!% 9((C'=ff/b'')A)/4F"-/-'(/(3($A8*A/4f%
IJSSR!!"#$%3108
&*-/(*)/-#%
"-4%
$."13"(/*-%
:Y%
C$)+*)0"-8$%
Z%
?g%
?\AYY%
?A>RV%
?>%
?g%
?YAYK%
?AVVR%
?K%
?g%
?YAYY%
?AYRK%
!$)+*)0"-8$%
)$./$F%"-4%
/0C)*.$0$-(%
2&:Y%
%
V%
%
?>%
%
ZAWK%
%
AW>W%
%
W%
%
?>%
%
VAZ?%
%
?AY>W%
%
V%
%
?>%
%
VARV%
%
?A>>Y%
<4$-(/+/8"(/*-%
*+%8"'$'%*+%
F*)E%
"88/4$-('%/-%
9*'C/("1'%
IiN%
%
%
?K%
%
%
?g%
%
%
?\AKg%
%
%
AZ??%
%
%
?>%
%
%
?g%
%
%
?KA\?%
%
%
?AgYK%
%
%
?K%
%
%
?g%
%
%
?YAYY%
%
%
?AYKV%
c"1/4%d%
I1/'(F/'$N%
KK%)$'C*-4$-('%
?V%)$'C*-4$-('%
%
T"'$4%*-%(9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%4$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%*+%(9$%)$'$")89%4"("%"D*.$6%"%+*11*Fa3C%
($'(%F"'%8"))/$4%*3(6%-"0$15%"%+)$G3$-85%4$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%/-%4$("/1%"-4%(9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%
4"("%"-"15'/'%F$)$%/-($)C)$($4%"'%+*11*F'=%%
"A [$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%*+%)$'C*-4$-('`%+)$G3$-85%D"'$4%*-%#$-4$)A%
H9$%+*11*F/-#%/'%"%4$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%*+%)$'C*-4$-('`%+)$G3$-85%D5%#$-4$)%8"-%D$%'$$-%
/-%("D1$%Y%"-4%+/#3)$%KA%
%
Table!3.!Results!of!descriptive!statistical!test!of!respondent!frequency!(Gender)!
%%^$-4$)%
J2;[eB%
J2<B%
O*'C/("1%
&"-%
K\%
K>%
Z%
M*0"-%
K\%
K%
Z%
H*("1%
\V%
KK%
?V%
%
H9$% )$'31('% *+% (9$% 4$'8)/C(/.$% ($'(% *+% (9$% #$-4$)% +)$G3$-85% *+% )$'C*-4$-('% "(% J2;[eB%
*D("/-$4%(9$%-30D$)%*+%)$'C*-4$-('%\V%C$*C1$%8*-'/'(/-#%*+%K\%0$-%"-4%K\%F*0$-6%/-%J2<B%(9$%
-30D$)%*+%)$'C*-4$-('%KK%C$*C1$%8*-'/'(/-#%*+%K>%0$-%"-4%K%F*0$-%"-4%/-%J2;[&%(9$%-30D$)%
*+%)$'C*-4$-('%?V%C$*C1$%8*-'/'(/-#%*+%Z%0$-%"-4%Z%F*0$-A%H9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%4$'8)/C(/.$%($'(%*+%
)$'C*-4$-('`%'$_%+)$G3$-85%"(%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4% J2;[&%8"-% D$% '$$-% /-% (9$% +*11*F/-#%#)"C9/8%
/0"#$=%
%
Figure!2.!Graph!of!respondent!frequency!by!Gender!
%
RSUDZA
RSIA
RSUDM
Descriptive Graph of Respondent Frequency
RSUDZA RSIA RSUDM
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research6%%
S3(%&3(/"F"(/
1
6%&")/"-"
2
6%&"9/4/-
3
%
IJSSR!!"#$%3109
T"'$4%*-%(9$%("D1$%"-4%#)"C9/8%"D*.$6%(9$%-30D$)%*+%)$'$")89%)$'C*-4$-('%+)*0%$0C1*5$$'%
*+% J2;[eB6% J2<B% "-4% J2;[&% '$8(/*-'% :Y% "-4% <!]J2AF/(9% 0"1$% #$-4$)% /'% #)$"($)% (9"-% +$0"1$%
)$'C*-4$-('A%
DA [$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%*+%)$'C*-4$-('`%+)$G3$-85%D"'$4%*-%"#$%
H9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%4$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%*+%)$'C*-4$-('`%+)$G3$-85%D"'$4%*-%"#$%8"-%D$%
'$$-%/-%("D1$%\6%+/#3)$'%Ya\%"-4%gA%
%
Table!4.!Results!of!descriptive!statistical!test!of!respondents'!frequency!based!on!age!
%
%
%
%
%
!
%
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
Figure!3.!Graph!of!respondents'!frequency!by!age!
!
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%Y?aYYAZ%5)'%
%%%%%%%%%%%YRaYZAZ%5)'%
%
%
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
j%k%\>%5)'%
Figure!4.!Graph!of!Respondents'!Frequency!by!Age!in!RSIA!
!
KZaY>6Z%
%
%
j%k%\>%
%%%%%%%%%%%Y?aYY6Z%
%
%
Y\aYW6Z%
Figure!5.!Graph!of!respondents'!frequency!by!age!at!RSUDM!
Age!of!Respondents%
%J2;[eB%
J2<B%
O*'C/("1%
KKaK\AZ%5)'%
Y%
>%
>%
KgaKRAZ%5)'%
?%
>%
>%
KZaY>AZ%5)'%
W%
>%
g%
Y?aYYAZ%5)'%
\%
\%
K%
Y\aYWAZ%5)'%
>%
>%
K%
YRaYZAZ%5)'%
W%
?%
>%
j%k%\>%5)'%
KV%
?R%
Z%
H*("1%
\V%
KK%
?V%
22-24,9
25-27,9
3%
1%
29-30,9
7%
31-33,9
4%
37-39,9
6%
>=40!
29%!
50%!
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research!% 9((C'=ff/b'')A)/4F"-/-'(/(3($A8*A/4f%
IJSSR!!"#$%3110
%
T"'$4%*-%("D1$'%"-4%4$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%#)"C9'6%(9$%+)$G3$-85%*+%)$'C*-4$-('%D"'$4%*-%
(9$%/-($)C)$("(/*-%*+%(9$%"#$%*+%)$'C*-4$-('%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%")$%0*)$%4*0/-"-(%"#$4%
"#$4%j\>%5$")'%"'%0"-5%"'%g\%C$*C1$6%F9/1$%(9*'$%"#$4%KKaK\AZ%5$")'%"'%0"-5%"'%Y%C$*C1$6%F9/89%
0$"-'%(9"(%0*)$%)$'C*-4$-('%")$%*14$)%(9"-%5*3-#$)A%
8A [$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%*+%)$'C*-4$-('`%+)$G3$-85%D"'$4%*-%1$-#(9%*+%F*)E%
H9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%4$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%*+%)$'C*-4$-('`%+)$G3$-85%D"'$4%*-%1$-#(9%*+%
F*)E%8"-%D$%'$$-%/-%("D1$%g6%+/#3)$'%WaR%"-4%VA%
%
Table!5.!Results!of!Descriptive!Statistical!Test!of!Respondents'!Frequency!Based!on!
Length!of!Work!
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%l%?%i)%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%?aY%i)%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%\aW%i)'%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%RaZ%5)'%
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%?>a?Y%5)'%
%
% % %
%?aY%i)% %\aW%i)'%% %RaZ%5)'%% %?>a?Y%5)'%
Figure!6.!Graph!of!respondents'!frequency!based!on!length!of!work!at!RSUDZA!
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%?aY%i)%
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%\X%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%\aW%5)%gX%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%?>a?Y%5)'%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%RaZ%5)%gX%
%?aY%i)% %\aW%i)'%% %RaZ%5)'%% %?>a?Y%5)'%
Figure!7.!Respondent!Frequency!Graph!Based!on!Length!of!Work!at!RSIA!
!
?>a?Y%5)'% ?aY%i)%
%
%
%
%
\aW%i)'%
RaZ%5)'%
%?aY%i)% %\aW%i)'%% %RaZ%5)'%% %?>a?Y%5)'%
]$-#(9%*+%M*)E%
J2;[eB%
J2<B%
O*'C/("1%
l%?%i)%
g%
?%
>%
?aY%i)%
Y%
>%
\%
\aW%i)'%
K%
?%
\%
RaZ%5)'%
R%
?%
W%
?>a?Y%5)'%
Y?%
?Z%
\%
H*("1%
\V%
KK%
?V%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research6%%
S3(%&3(/"F"(/
1
6%&")/"-"
2
6%&"9/4/-
3
%
IJSSR!!"#$%3111
Figure!8.!Graph!of!Respondents'!Frequency!Based!on!Length!of!Work!at!RSUDM!
T"'$4% *-% ("D1$'% "-4% 4$'8)/C(/.$% '("(/'(/8"1% #)"C9'% *+% )$'C*-4$-('`% +)$G3$-85% D"'$4% *-% (9$%
/-($)C)$("(/*-%*+%)$'C*-4$-('`%1$-#(9%*+%F*)E%"(%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&6%/(%8"-%D$%8*-8134$4%
(9"(%(9$%/-($-'/(5%*+%F*)E/-#%(/0$%C$)%$0C1*5$$%/'%#)$"($)%(9"-%?Y%5$")'%"'%0"-5%"'%g\%C$*C1$A%
4A [$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%*+%)$'C*-4$-('`%+)$G3$-85%D"'$4%*-%C")(%*+%(9$%F*)E%
H9$% )$'31('% *+% (9$% 4$'8)/C(/.$% '("(/'(/8"1% ($'(% *+% )$'C*-4$-('`% +)$G3$-85% D"'$4% *-% (9$% F*)E%
'$8(/*-%8"-%D$%'$$-%/-%("D1$%WA%
%
Table!6.!The!output!results!of!SPSS!26!descriptive!statistical!tests!of!the!frequency!of!work!
parts!in!RSUDZA,!RSIA!and!RSUDM.!
!")('%*+%(9$%F*)E%
J2;[eB%
J2<B%
O*'C/("1%
:Y%
K?%
?>%
Z%
<!]%
KR%
?K%
Z%
H*("1%
\V%
KK%
?V%
%
T"'$4%*-%(9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%+)$G3$-85%4$'8)/C(/.$%'("(/'(/8"1%($'(%"D*.$6%/(%/'%/-($)C)$($4%(9"(%(9$%
)$'C*-4$-('`%F*)E%/-%(9$%$."13"(/*-%)$'$")89%*-%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%
J2;[&%/'%0*)$%4*0/-"-(%/-%(9$%+/$14%*+%$-./)*-0$-("1%0"-"#$0$-(%"#$-8/$'%(*("1/-#%\V%C$*C1$6%
8*0C")$4%(*%(9$%:Y%'$8(/*-%)$'C*-4$-('%(*("1/-#%\>%C$*C1$A%%
2. Data!Quality!Test!
H9$%4"("%G3"1/(5%($'(%*+%(9$%$."13"(/*-%*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%
T"-4"%B8$9%F"'%8"))/$4%*3(%D5%C)*8$''/-#%G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("%(9)*3#9%(9$%2!22%0$(9*4%F/(9%."1/4/(5%
($'('%"-4%)$1/"D/1/(5%($'('A%H9$%+*11*F/-#%")$%(9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%G3"1/(5%($'(%*+%)$'$")89%4"("%$."13"(/-#%
(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%"(%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%T"-4"%B8$9=%%
"A c"1/4/(5%H$'(%
c"1/4/(5%($'(/-#%/'%($'($4%C$)%G3$'(/*--"/)$%"-4%(*("1%4"("%(*%*D("/-%."1/4%4"("%3'/-#%%2!22%
(**1'%/-8134/-#%analyze,"correlate,"bivariateA%H9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%4"("%8*))$1"(/*-%")$%($'($4%F/(9%
(9$%+*11*F/-#%8"1831"(/*-%)%+*)031"=%
%
%
%
%
1. H9$%h?%.")/"D1$%."1/4/(5%($'(%I"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%:YJ2%0"-"#$0$-(N%*D("/-$4%"%."1/4%($'(%)$'31(%
*3(C3(% /-% "88*)4"-8$% F/(9%(9$% C)*./'/*-'% *+% (9$% ."13$% +)*0% (9$% )% ("D1$% 8"1831"($% >A>gX% /-%
J2;[eB% /-% "88*)4"-8$% F/(9% (9$% )% ."13$% *+% 8"1831"($% j% KV\Ag% C)*438$4% 2!22% *3(C3(% \gg6%
Y??AWY\%"-4%/-%J2<B%F/(9%"%8"1831"($4%."13$%*+%>A\YY%C)*438$4%2!22%*3(C3(%\YY6%VRg6%WYY%"-4%
/-%J2;[&%F/(9%"%8"1831"($4%."13$%*+%>A\WV%C)*438$4%2!22%*3(C3(%V?Y6%%WZ\6%\WVA%
2. H9$% ."1/4/(5% ($'(% *+% .")/"D1$% hK% IC1"--/-#% :YJ2N% *D("/-$4% "% ."1/4% ($'(% )$'31(% *3(C3(% /-%
"88*)4"-8$%F/(9%(9$%C)*./'/*-'%*+%(9$%."13$%+)*0%(9$%)%("D1$%8"1831"($%>A>gX%/-%J2;[eB%/-%
"88*)4"-8$%F/(9%(9$%8"1831"($4%)%."13$%*+%j%KV\Ag%C)* 438$4%2!22%*3(C3(%*+%V>> 6%RVW6%?% "-4% /-%
J2<B%F/(9%"%8"1831"($4%."13$%*+%>A\YY%C)*438$4%2!22%*3(C3(%*+%Z\?6%g\>6%?%"-4%/-%J2;[&%F/(9%
"%8"1831"($4%."13$%*+%>A\WV%C)*438$4%2!22%*3(C3(%*+%?>>>6%%?>>>6%?A%%%
3. H9$%."1/4/(5%($'(%*+%.")/"D1$%hY%I/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%:YJ2%C1"--/-#N%*D("/-$4%"%."1/4%($'(%)$'31(%
*3(C3(%/-%"88*)4"-8$%F/(9%(9$%C)*./'/*-'%*+%(9$%."13$%+)*0%(9$%)%("D1$% 8"1831"($%>A>gX6%/-%
J2;[eB%"88*)4/-#%(*%(9$%8"1831"($4%."13$%/-%J2;[eB%/'%KV\Ag%/-%J2<B% >A\YY%"-4%/-%J2;[&%/'%
>A\WVA%
4. H9$%h\%.")/"D1$%."1/4/(5%($'(%I0*-/(*)/-#%"-4%$."13"(/*-%*+%:YJ2%C$)+*)0"-8$N%*D("/-$4%"%
."1/4% ($'(% )$'31(% *3(C3(% /-% "88*)4"-8$% F/(9% (9$% C)*./'/*-'% *+% (9$% ."13$% +)*0% (9$% )% ("D1$%
*r hitung : df = n-2 ( n adalah jumlah data )
*t hitung : df = n-k-1 (n adalah jumlah data, k adalah jumlah variabel bebas / x )
*f hitung : df1 = k-1 ( k adalah jumlah keseluruhan variabel / x+y),
df2 = n-k (n adalah jumlah data, k adalah jumlah keseluruhan variabel / x+y)
Rumus r hitung
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research!% 9((C'=ff/b'')A)/4F"-/-'(/(3($A8*A/4f%
IJSSR!!"#$%3112
8"1831"($%>A>gX6%/-% J2;[eB% "88*)4/-#% (*%(9$%8"1831"($4% ."13$% /-%J2;[eB%/'%KV\Ag%/-% J2<B%
>A\YY%"-4%/-%J2;[&%/'%>A\WVA%
5. H9$% hg%.")/"D1$% ."1/4/(5% ($'(%I)$./$F% "-4%C$)+*)0"-8$% /0C)*.$0$-(% *+% 2&:YN%*D("/-$4% "%
."1/4% ($'(% )$'31(% *3(C3(% /-% "88*)4"-8$% F/(9% (9$% C)*./'/*-'% *+% (9$% ."13$% +)*0% (9$% )% ("D1$%
8"1831"($%>A>gX6%/-% J2;[eB% "88*)4/-#% (*%(9$%8"1831"($4% ."13$% /-%J2;[eB%/'%KV\Ag%/-% J2<B%
>A\YY%"-4%/-%J2;[&%/'%>A\WVA%
6. H9$% ."1/4/(5%($'(% *+%.")/"D1$% i% I/4$-(/+/8"(/*-% *+% F*)E%"88/4$-(% 8"'$'N% *D("/-$4%"% ."1/4% ($'(%
)$'31(%*3(C3(%/-%"88*)4"-8$%F/(9%(9$%C)*./'/*-'%*+%(9$%."13$%+)*0%(9$%)%("D1$%8"1831"($4%>A>gX6%
/-%J2;[eB%"88*)4/-#%(*%(9$%8"1831"($4%."13$%/-%J2;[eB%/'%KV\Ag%/-%J2<B%>A\YY%"-4%/-%J2;[&%
/'%>A\WVA%
T"'$4% *-% (9$% *3(C3(% *+% (9$% .")/"D1$% ."1/4/(5% ($'(% h?6% hK6% hY6% h\6% hg6% i% /-% J2;[eB6% J2<B% "-4%
J2;[&%#)$"($)%(9"-%(9$%8"1831"($4%)%."13$6%/(%/'%'"/4%(*%D$%."1/4%"-4%(9$%G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("%/'%4$81")$4%
F*)(95%*+%)$'$")89A%%
DA J$1/"D/1/(5%H$'(%
J$1/"D/1/(5%($'('%*-%(9$%$."13"(/*-%G3$'(/*--"/)$%*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%
"-4%J2;[&%/-%T"-4"%B8$9%S/(5%F$)$%3'$4%(*%4$($)0/-$%(9$%."13$%of"alpha"cronbachs"/-%2!22%*)%
"1F"5'%0$"'3)$%(9$%1$.$1%*+%/-4/8"(*)'%*+%)$1/"D1$%)$'$")89%.")/"D1$'%+*)%G3$'(/*--"/)$%"-'F$)'%
+)*0%)$'C*-4$-('%8*-'/'($-(%"-4%'("D1$A%H9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%*3(C3(%)$1/"D/1/(5%($'(%*+%(9$%$."13"(/*-%
G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("%+*)%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%"(%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%T"-4"%B8$9%9".$%
D$$-%."1/4%F/(9%cronbachs"alpha"values"j%>AWA%
%
Table!7.!SPSS!output!results!Reliability!Test!of!SMK3!Application!Indicators!at!RSUDZA,!
RSIA!and!RSUDM!in!Banda!Aceh!City!
Reliability!Statistics!
Indicators!
Cronbach's!Alpha!
N!of!Items!
J2;[eB%
J2<B%
O*'C/("1%
h?%
R?W%
YYK%
YYY%
Y%
hK%
\>Z%
>AW%
?>>>%
Y%
hY%
\R?%
>6W%
VR>%
V%
h\%
YK?%
>AW%
VV>%
Y%
hg%
YVK%
>AR%
?>>>%
K%
i?%
YRW%
RW\%
Z?R%
Y%
<-+*)0"(/*-=%
%S)*-D"89`'%"1C9"=%j%>AW>%I1*F$)%1/0/(%*+%(9$%)$1/"D/1/(5%."13$%*+%"%8*-'()38(N%
d%*+%/($0%=%d30D$)%*+%G3$'(/*-'%
%
T"'$4% *-% (9$% )$'31('%*+% (9$% )$1/"D/1/(5% ($'(% 4"("% *+% )$'$")89% /-4/8"(*)'%+*)% (9$% "CC1/8"(/*-% *+%
2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%/-%T"-4"%B8$9%S/(5%")$%8*-'/4$)$4%'3++/8/$-(%"-4"'"(/'+"8(*)5%
D$8"3'$%m% >A>R% (9$%)$1/"D/1/(5% ($'(%4"("% /'% ."1/4%/-% "88*)4"-8$% F/(9%(9$% S)*-D"89% "1C9"%."13$% j%
>A>W>A%H9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%)$1/"D/1/(5%($'(%4"("%*-%)$'$")89%/-4/8"(*)'%*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%
J2;[eB6% J2<B% "-4% J2;[&% /-% T"-4"% B8$9% S/(5% "11% )$1/"D1$% /($0'% ")$% 8*-'/'($-(15% )$1/"D1$% F/(9%
'()*-#%)$"1/"D/1/(5%."13$'A%
3. Classical!Assumption!Test!
H9$%81"''/8"1%"''30C(/*-%($'(%F/(9%2!22%/-%$."13"(/-#%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-% J2;[eB6%
J2<B% "-4% J2;[&% T"-4"% B8$9% F"'% 8"))/$4% *3(% +*)% G3$'(/*--"/)$% 4"("% "-"15'/'% F/(9% G3"-(/("(/.$%
0$(9*4'A% H9$% )$'31('% *+% (9$% 81"''/8"1% "''30C(/*-% ($'(% *+% (9$% G3$'(/*--"/)$% 4"("% $."13"(/*-% *+% (9$%
"CC1/8"(/*-% *+% 2&:Y% /-% J2;[eB6% J2<B% "-4% J2;[&% T"-4"% B8$9% F$)$% 8"))/$4% *3(% F/(9% '$.$)"1%
-*)0"1/(5%($'('A%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research6%%
S3(%&3(/"F"(/
1
6%&")/"-"
2
6%&"9/4/-
3
%
IJSSR!!"#$%3113
H9$%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%/'%"% ($'(%*+%(9$%-*)0"1/(5%*+% (9$%4/'()/D3(/*-%*+%)$'$")89%4"("%D5%($'(/-#%(9$%
0*'(%C")"0$()/8%'("(/'(/8"1%"-"15'/'A%H9$%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%/'%'"/4%(*%D$%#**4%/+%(9$% )$#)$''/*-%"-"15'/'%/'%
-*)0"115%4/'()/D3($4A%H9$%)$'31('%*+%-*)0"1/(5%($'('%"(%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%3'$%#)"C9%"-"15'/'%
"-4%'("(/'(/8"1%"-"15'/'%/-%(9$%+*)0%*+%9/'(*#)"0'%"-4%!a!%!1*('A%
"A d*)0"1/(5%H$'(%"(%J2;[eB%
H9$% )$'31('% *+% (9$% Kolmogogrov" Smirnov" one" sample" normality" test" *-% (9$% $."13"(/*-%
)$'$")89%*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%"(%J2;[eB%8"-%D$%'$$-%/-%7/#3)$%ZA%
%
%%%% %
Figure!9.!SPSS!normality!test!histogram!at!RSUDZA!and!Normality!test!graph!P_P!plot!in!
RSUDZA!
%
H9$% -*)0"1/(5% ($'(% )$'31('% /-% +/#3)$% ZA% "(% J2;[eB% ")$% '"/4% (*% D$% ."1/4% "-4% -*)0"16% (9$%
#)"C9/8"1%4/'C1"5%*+%+)$G3$-85%("D31"(/*-%/-%(9$%+*)0%*+%#)"C9/8%D")'%F/(9%'500$()/8"1%D$11a'9"C$4%
83).$% 1/-$'% /'% -*(%1$"-/-#% (*% (9$% )/#9(% *)% 1$+(A% H9$%G3$'(/*--"/)$% 4"("%"883031"($4% "11% '"0C1$'6%
'9*F-% /-% (9$% )/#9(% 9/'(*#)"0% #)"C9% /0"#$% '9*F/-#% (9$% ."13$% *+% d% k% \V% 0$"-/-#% (9"(% "11%
G3$'(/*--"/)$'%F$)$%4/'()/D3($4%(*%(9$%C*C31"(/*-%/-%J2;[eB%F9/89%"0*3-($4%(*%\V%)$'C*-4$-('A%
73)(9$)0*)$6%+*)%(9$%*3(C3(%)$'31(6%(9$%'("-4")4%4$./"(/*-%."13$%'9*F'%"%."13$%*+%>AZ\g6%F9/89%
0$"-'%j%>A>g%0$"-'%(9"(%(9$%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%/'%'"/4%(*%D$%-*)0"115%4/'()/D3($4A%%
H9$%D")%#)"C9/8%/-%(9$%)$'$")89%9/'(*#)"0%"(%J2;[eB%/-($)C)$($4%(9$%4$'8$-4/-#%C*15#*-%
*-%(9$%"D'8/''"%*)%D"'$%"_/'%aK%F9/89%0$"-'%(9"(%(9$%.")/"D1$'%hK6%hY%"-4%hR%9".$%4$8)$"'$4%(9$%
."13$% *+% (9$% G3$'(/*--"/)$% /-% (9$% '3++/8/$-(% 8"($#*)5% F/(9% "% C$)8$-("#$% ."13$% *+% W>X6% F9$)$%
"88*)4/-#% (*% +"8(*)'% "++$8(/-#% (9$% /0C1$0$-("(/*-% *+% 2&:Y% "(% J2;[eB% -$$4'% 4$.$1*C0$-('%
)$#")4/-#%(9$%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%(9$%:Y%*)#"-/Q"(/*-"1%'()38(3)$%+*)%hK6%:Y%D34#$(%0"-"#$0$-(%
+*)%hY%"-4%$."13"(/*-%*+%(9$%C)*./'/*-%*+%0*)$%'$83)/(5%*++/8$)'%+*)%hRA%H9$%'("-4")4%4$./"(/*-%
."13$%*+%>AZ\g%/-%(9$%D")%#)"C9/8%+)$G3$-85%*)4/-"($%)/'$'%(*%0$"-%?%F/(9%(9$%9/#9$'(%D")%#)"C9/8%
9"./-#%"-%$++$8(%F/(9%"%.")/"D1$%."13$%/-%(9$%G3$'(/*--"/)$%"-'F$)'%*-%".$)"#$%VZA\ZX%F/(9%"%.$)5%
#**4%8"($#*)5A%%
H9$%#)"C9%*+%(9$%*3(C3(%)$'31('%*+%(9$%!a!%C1*(%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%"(%J2;[eB%"'%'9*F-%/-%+/#3)$%
?>%'9*F'% (9"(% (9$% C1*(% C*/-('% ")$% 'C)$"4%81*'$%(*%(9$%0*4$1%*)%'()"/#9(%1/-$6%'*%(9$%4"("%*+%(9$%
$."13"(/*-%)$'$")89%G3$'(/*--"/)$%+*)%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB%/'%'"/4%(*%D$%-*)0"115%
4/'()/D3($4A%O*F$.$)6%"(%*)4/-"($'%>A\%"-4%>AW%(9$%C*/-('%D$#/-%(*%'C)$"4%'1/#9(15%"-4%"F"5%+)*0%
(9$%4/"#*-"1%1/-$%43$%(*%"%4$8)$"'$%/-%(9$%."13$%*+%(9$%G3$'(/*--"/)$%"-'F$)%.")/"D1$'%"(%hK6%hY%
"-4%hRA%
DA d*)0"1/(5%H$'(%"(%J2;[eB%
H9$% )$'31('% *+% (9$% Kolmogogrov" Smirnov" one" sample" normality" test" in" the" % $."13"(/*-%
)$'$")89%*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%"(%J2<B%8"-%D$%'$$-%/-%7/#3)$%?>A%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research!% 9((C'=ff/b'')A)/4F"-/-'(/(3($A8*A/4f%
IJSSR!!"#$%3114
%%%%% %%% %
Figure!10.!SPSS!normality!test!histogram!in!RSIA!Figure!and!Normality!test!graph!P_P!plot!in!
RSIA!
%
H9$% -*)0"1/(5% ($'(% )$'31('% *-% (9$% 9/'(*#)"0% /0"#$% "(% J2<B%'9*F% "% #)"C9/8"1% 4/'C1"5% *+%
+)$G3$-85%("D31"(/*-%/-%(9$%+*)0%*+%"%D")%#)"C9/8%F/(9%'500$()/8"1%D$11a'9"C$4%83).$%1/-$'%-*(%
1$"-/-#%(*%(9$%)/#9(%*)%1$+(6%'*%(9$%)$'31('%*+%(9/'%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%")$%'"/4%(*%D$%."1/4%"-4%-*)0"1A%H9$%
G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("%"883031"($4%"11%'"0C1$'6%'9*F-%/-%(9$%)/#9(%9/'(*#)"0%#)"C9%/0"#$%'9*F/-#%
(9$%."13$%*+%d%k%KK%0$"-'%(9"(%"11%G3$'(/*--"/)$'%F$)$%4/'()/D3($4%(*%(9$%C*C31"(/*-%/-%J2<B%F9/89%
"0*3-($4%(*%KK%)$'C*-4$-('A%
73)(9$)0*)$6%+*)%(9$%*3(C3(%)$'31(6%(9$%'("-4")4%4$./"(/*-%."13$%'9*F'%"%."13$%*+%>AVRY6%
F9/89%0$"-'%j%>A>g6%F9/89%0$"-'%(9$%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%/'%'"/4%(*%D$%-*)0"115%4/'()/D3($4A%H9$%D")%
#)"C9/8%/-%(9$%)$'$")89%9/'(*#)"0%"(%J2<B%/-($)C)$($4%(9$%4$'8$-4/-#%C*15#*-%*-%(9$%"D'8/''"%*)%
D"'$%"_/'%K%F9/89%0$"-'%(9$%.")/"D1$'%hY6%hR6% hZ 6%h??6%h?K6%h?\6%h?g%"-4%h?W%4$8)$"'$4%(9$%."13$%
*+%(9$%G3$'(/*--"/)$%/-%(9$%'3++/8/$-(%8"($#*)5%F/(9%"%C$)8$-("#$%."13$%*+%W>X6%F9$)$%"88*)4/-#%
(*% +"8(*)'% "++$8(/-#% (9$% /0C1$0$-("(/*-% *+% 2&:Y% /-% J2<B% /(% /'% -$8$''")5% (*% $."13"($% (9$%
4$($)0/-"(/*-% *+% +/-"-8/"1% '3CC*)(6% +"8/1/(/$'% "-4% /-+)"'()38(3)$% +*)% hY6% % $."13"(/*-% *+% (9$%
C)*83)$0$-(%*+% "44/(/*-"1% '$83)/(5% *++/8$)'%+*)%hR6%$."13"(/*-%*+%TY%F"'($%0"-"#$0$-(%+*)%hZ6%
$."13"(/*-%*+%:Y%/-+)"'()38(3)$%0"-"#$0$-(%+*)%h??6%$."13"(/*-%*+%0$4/8"1%4$./8$%0"-"#$0$-(%
/-%"'C$8('%*+%:Y%+*)%h?K6%$."13"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%"34/(%+*)%h?\%"-4%$."13"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%"34/(%)$C*)(%+*)%
h?gA%%%
H9$%'("-4")4%4$./"(/*-%."13$%*+%>AVRY%/-%(9$%D")%#)"C9/8%+)$G3$-85%*)4/-"($%)*'$%(*%"%0$"-%
*+% aY% F/(9% (9$% D")% #)"C9/8% ."13$% 4$8)$"'/-#% "% 1*(% D$8"3'$% /(% "++$8($4% (9$% .")/"D1$% ."13$% /-% (9$%
G3$'(/*--"/)$%"-'F$)%*-%".$)"#$%WRA\RX%F/(9%"%#**4%8"($#*)5A%
H9$%#)"C9%*+%(9$%*3(C3(%)$'31('%*+%(9$%!a!%C1*(%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%"in"RSIA"%'9*F'%(9"(%(9$%C1*(%
C*/-('%")$%'C)$"4%81*'$%(*%(9$%0*4$1%*)%'()"/#9(%1/-$6%'*%(9$%G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("%+*)%(9$%$."13"(/*-%
*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2<B%/'%'"/4%(*%D$%-*)0"115%4/'()/D3($4A%O*F$.$)6%/-%(9$%*)4/-"($%
(9$)$%")$%'*0$%C*/-('%'(")(/-#%(*%'C)$"4%'1/#9(15%"-4%"F"5%+)*0%(9$%4/"#*-"1%1/-$6%(9/'%/'%43$%(*%"%
4$8)$"'$%/-%(9$%."13$%*+%(9$%.")/"D1$6%"-4%(9/'%/'%'(/11%-*(%(**%4$./"($4%+)*0%(9$%0*)$%4*0/-"-(%
#)"C9%+*)06%(9$%!a!%Plot""points"")$%81*'$%(*%(9$%4/"#*-"1%1/-$6%"-4%(9/'%/'%'"/4%(*%D$%-*)0"1A%
8A d*)0"1/(5%H$'(%"(%J2;[&%
H9$% )$'31('% *+% % (9$% Kolmogogrov" Smirnov" one" sample" normality" test" in" the" % $."13"(/*-%
)$'$")89%*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%"(%J2<B%8"-%D$%'$$-%/-%7/#3)$%??A%
%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research6%%
S3(%&3(/"F"(/
1
6%&")/"-"
2
6%&"9/4/-
3
%
IJSSR!!"#$%3115
%%%%%% %%%%%%%%%%% %
Figure!11.!SPSS!normality!test!histogram!at!RSUDM!Figure!and!Normality!test!graph!P_P!
plot!in!RSUDM!
%
H9$%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%)$'31('%*-%(9$%9/'(*#)"0%/0"#$%"(%J2;[&%'9*F%"%#)"C9/8"1%4/'C1"5%*+%
+)$G3$-85%("D31"(/*-%/-%(9$% +*)0% *+% #)"C9/8%D")'%F/(9%'500$()/8"1%D$11a'9"C$4% 83).$%1/-$'%-*(%
1$"-/-#%(*%(9$%)/#9(%*)%1$+(6%'*%(9$%)$'31('%*+%(9/'%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%")$%'"/4%(*%D$%."1/4%"-4%-*)0"1A%H9$%
G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("%"883031"($4%"11%'"0C1$'6%'9*F-%/-%(9$%)/#9(%9/'(*#)"0%#)"C9%/0"#$%'9*F/-#%
(9$%."13$%*+%d%k%?V%0$"-'%(9"(%"11%G3$'(/*--"/)$'%F$)$%4/'()/D3($4%(*%(9$%C*C31"(/*-%/-%J2;[&%
F9/89%"0*3-($4%(*%?V%)$'C*-4$-('A%73)(9$)0*)$6%+*)%(9$%*3(C3(%)$'31('6%(9$%'("-4")4%4$./"(/*-%
."13$%'9*F'%"%."13$%*+%>AV\>%F9/89%0$"-'%j>A>g%F9/89%0$"-'%(9$%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%/'%'"/4%(*%D$%
-*)0"115% 4/'()/D3($4A% % H9$% D")% #)"C9/8% /-% (9$% )$'$")89% 9/'(*#)"0% "(% J2;[&% /-($)C)$($4% (9$%
4$'8$-4/-#%C*15#*-%*-%(9$%"D'8/''"%*)%D"'$%"_/'%aK%F9/89%0$"-'%(9"(%(9$%.")/"D1$'%hY%"-4%hR%9".$%
4$8)$"'$4% G3$'(/*--"/)$% ."13$'% /-% (9$% #**4% 8"($#*)5% F/(9% "% C$)8$-("#$% ."13$% *+% W>X6% F9$)$%
"88*)4/-#% (*% +"8(*)'% "++$8(/-#% (9$% /0C1$0$-("(/*-% *+% 2&:Y% "(% J2;[&% -$$4% (*% D$% $."13"($4%
)$#")4/-#% (9$% 4$($)0/-"(/*-% *+% +/-"-8/"1% '3CC*)(6% +"8/1/(/$'% "-4% /-+)"'()38(3)$% +*)% hY% "-4%
$."13"(/*-%*+%(9$%C)*83)$0$-(%*+%"44/(/*-"1%'$83)/(5%*++/8$)'%+*)%hRA%H9$%'("-4")4% 4$./"(/*-%."13$%
*+%>AV\>%/-%(9$%D")%#)"C9/8%+)$G3$-85%*)4/-"($%4)*CC$4%4)"0"(/8"115%"(% (9$%aK%8**)4/-"($%D$8"3'$%
/(%"++$8($4%(9$%.")/"D1$%."13$'%*+%hY%"-4%hR%F/(9%"-%".$)"#$%G3$'(/*--"/)$%."13$%*+%VWA\VX%F/(9%
.$)5%#**4%8"($#*)/$'A%
H9$%#)"C9%*+%(9$%*3(C3(%)$'31('%*+%(9$%!a!%C1*(%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%"at"RSUDM"shows"that"(9$%C1*(%
C*/-('%")$%'C)$"4%81*'$%(*%(9$%0*4$1%*)%'()"/#9(%1/-$6%'*%(9$%G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("%+*)%(9$%$."13"(/*-%
*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%"at"RSUDM" %/'%'"/4%(*%D$%-*)0"115%4/'()/D3($4A%O*F$.$)6%/-%(9$%*)4/-"($%
(9$)$%")$%'*0$%C*/-('%'(")(/-#%(*%'C)$"4%'1/#9(15%"-4%"F"5%+)*0%(9$%4/"#*-"1%1/-$6%(9/'%/'%43$%(*%"%
4$8)$"'$%/-%(9$%."13$%*+%(9$%.")/"D1$6%"-4%(9/'%/'%'(/11%-*(%(**%4$./"($4%+)*0%(9$%0*)$%4*0/-"-(%
#)"C9%+*)06%(9$%!a!%Plot""points"")$%81*'$%(*%(9$%4/"#*-"1%1/-$6%"-4%(9/'%/'%'"/4%(*%D$%-*)0"1A%%
H9$%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%/-%(9$%$."13"(/*-%'(345%*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%
J2;[&%/-%T"-4"%B8$9%S/(5%9"'%"%4/++$)$-(%+*)0%*+%9/'(*#)"0%#)"C9%"-4%!a!%!1*(%#)"C9%F/(9%D")%
#)"C9'%(9"(%#*%3C%"-4%4*F-%"88*)4/-#%(*%(9$%'("($%*+%(9$%.")/"D1$%."13$'%$."13"($4%"(%$"89%)$'$")89%
'/($6%D$8"3'$%$"89%9*'C/("1%9"'%4/++$)$-(%+"8(*)'%(9"(%"++$8(%4/++$)$-(%)$'$")89A%H9$%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%
8*-(/-3$4%4"("%C)*8$''/-#%F/(9%'("(/'(/8"1%4"("%($'('%F/(9%(9$%:*10*#*)*.%20/)-*.%($'(%(*%/-8)$"'$%
(9$%"883)"85%*+%(9$%"-"15'/'%*+%)$'$")89%G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("A%H9$%)$'31('%*+%"44/-#%-*)0"1/(5%($'(%
4"("%(*%(9$%$."13"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%)$'$")89%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%-"0$15%D5%D)/-#/-#%3C%(9$%"
value"of"one"sample"Kolmogorov"–"Smirnov"test%F/(9%"%'/#-/+/8"-(%"'50C%."13$%03'(%D$%j%>A>g%8"-%
D$%'$$-%/-%H"D1$%VA%
%
Table!8.!Kolmogorov!one!sample!normality!test!–!Smirnov!test!
One-Sample!Kolmogorov-Smirnov!Test!
Unstandardized!Residual!
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research!% 9((C'=ff/b'')A)/4F"-/-'(/(3($A8*A/4f%
IJSSR!!"#$%3116
J2;[eB%
J2<B%
O*'C/("1%
d%
\V%
KK%
?V%
d*)0"1%!")"0$($)'
a,b
%
&$"-%
A>>>>>>>%
A>>>>>>>%
A>>>>>>>%
2(4A%[$./"(/*-%
AZZR>V?\V%
A?AWRKY>YV>%
A\ZZ\WgKR%
%
&*'(%,_()$0$%[/++$)$-8$'%
BD'*13($%
A?\K%
A?YY%
AK\?%
!*'/(/.$%
A>Wg%
A>VW%
A?gZ%
d$#"(/.$%
aA?\ K%
aA?Y Y%
aAK\ ?%
H$'(%2("(/'(/8'%
A?\K%
A?YY%
AK\?%
B'50CA%2/#A%IKa("/1$4N%
A>?R8%
AK>>8%
A>>R8%
"A%H$'(%4/'()/D3(/*-%/'%d*)0"1A%
DA%S"1831"($4%+)*0%4"("A%
8A%]/11/$+*)'%2/#-/+/8"-8$%S*))$8(/*-A%
Source":"P3(C3(%2!22%KW%*-$%'"0C1$%-*)0"1/(5%"test"Kolmogorov"–"Smirnov"test"
%
H9$%*3(C3(%)$'31('%*+%(9$%Kolmogorov"–"Smirnov"one"sample"normality"test"%*-%(9$%)$'$")89%
G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("%"(%J2;[eB%9".$%"%."13$%*+%>?R
%c,%in%RSIA%the%value%of%200
%8%%J2;[&%/'%>A>R
%
8A%H9$%*3(C3(%
)$'31('% % *+% Kolmogorov's" one" sample" normality" test" in" this" % '(345% 9".$% D$$-% '"/4% (*% D$% -*)0"1%
D$8"3'$% /(% C)*438$'% "% '/#-/+/8"-(% "'50C% ."13$% *+% j% >A>g6% (9/'% 9"'% "-'F$)$4% (9"(% (9$% )$'$")89%
G3$'(/*--"/)$%/'%-*)0"115%4/'()/D3($4%(*%)$'C*-4$-('6%'*%(9$%)$'$")89%4"("%9"'%0$(%(9$%-*)0"1/(5%
/-%(9$%81"''/8"1%"''30C(/*-%($'(A%
4A &31(/8*11/-$")/(5%H$'(%
H9$% 81"''/8"1% "''30C(/*-% ($'(% F"'% (9$-% 8"))/$4% *3(% F/(9% "% 031(/8*11/-$")/(5% ($'(% *-% (9$%
G3$'(/*--"/)$% 4"("% $."13"(/-#% (9$% "CC1/8"(/*-% *+% 2&:Y% /-% J2;[eB6% J2<B% "-4% J2;[&% F/(9% (9$%
C)*./'/*-% (9"(% (9$% c<7% ."13$% 03'(% D$% l% ?>% "-4% (*11$)"-8% j% >A?% (9$-% /(% /'%'"/4% (9"(%(9$)$% ")$%-*%
'50C(*0'%*+%031(/8*11/-$")/(5A%H9$%+*11*F/-#%)$'31('%*+%(9$%031(/8*11/-$")/(5%($'(%/-%(9$%$."13"(/*-%
)$'$")89%*-%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%")$%'9*F-%/-%("D1$%ZA%
%
Table!9.!SPSS!Output!Results!26!Multicollinearity!Test!
Multicollinearity!Test!
%
H5C$%
S*11/-$")/(5%2("(/'(/8'%
RSUDZA!
RSIA!
Hospital!
H*1$)"-8$%
c<7%
H*1$)"-8$%
c<7%
H*1$)"-8$%
c<7%
<0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%
:YJ2%!*1/85%
AVgg%
?A?WZ%
AYVZ%
KAgR>%
YWg%
KARYV%
:YJ2%!1"--/-#%
AVKK%
?AK?R%
AYZg%
KAgY>%
A?K>%
VAYgR%
<0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%(9$%
C1"-%
:YJ2%
ARRW%
?AKVZ%
AVW\%
?A?gV%
A>V\%
??AVZZ%
&*-/(*)/-#%"-4%
$."13"(/*-%
:YJ2%C$)+*)0"-8$%
AZ>R%
?A?>Y%
AVKW%
?AK?>%
A?Yg%
RAYVR%
!$)+*)0"-8$%)$./$F%
2&:Y%
AV?\%
?AKKZ%
AV>K%
?AK\W%
AY>Z%
YAKY?%
%
H9$%*3(C3(% )$'31('%*+%(9$%2!22%031(/8*11/-$")/(5%($'(%$."13"(/*-%)$'$")89%*-%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%
*+% 2&:Y% /-% J2;[eB6% J2<B% "-4% J2;[&% *D("/-$4% ."1/4% ($'(% )$'31('% "-4% -*% '50C(*0'% *+%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research6%%
S3(%&3(/"F"(/
1
6%&")/"-"
2
6%&"9/4/-
3
%
IJSSR!!"#$%3117
031(/8*11/-$")/(5% *883))$4% D$8"3'$% (9$% )$G3/)$0$-('% +*)% C"''/-#% (9$% 031(/8*11/-$")/(5% ($'(% *+%
G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("%03'(%9".$%"%(*1$)"-8$%."13$%*+%j%>A?A%
$A O$($)*'8$4"'(/8/(5%H$'(%
H9$%*3(C3(%)$'31('%*+%(9$%9$($)*'8$4"'(/8/(5%($'(%*+%(9$%$."13"(/*-%4"("%+*)%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%
*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&% T"-4"%B8$9%9".$%.")/"D1$%.")/"-('%/-%(9$%)$#)$''/*-%0*4$1%
(9"(%")$%-*(%(9$%'"0$%"'%(9$%C*/-('%'C)$"4%+")%+)*0%(9$%h%"-4%i%"_$'A%!1*(%#)"C9'%F/(9%4*(%C"(($)-'%
/-% )$#)$''/*-% '8"(($)% C1*('% ")$% *D("/-$4% +)*0% 2("-4")4/Q$4% !)$4/8($4% c"13$% Ie!J,[N% "-4%
2(34$-(/Q$4%J$'/43"1%I2J,2<[N%F9$)$%C)$4/8(/*-'%+)*0%(9$%i%"_/'%"-4%)$'/43"1'%+)*0%(9$%h%"_/'A%%
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%%%%% %%
%
Figure!12.!Heteroscedasticity!test!graph!in!RSUDZA!Figure,!Heteroscedasticity!test!graph!
in!RSIA!and!Heteroscedasticity!test!graph!at!RSUDM!
%
T"'$4%*-%(9$%9$($)*'8$4"'(/8/(5%($'(%#)"C9%/-%+/#3)$'%?Wa?R%nL%?V%'9*F/-#%'8"(($)$4%C*/-('%
"D*.$%"-4%D$1*F%(9$%>%*)4/-"($%*-%(9$%i%"_/'6%0$"-/-#%(9"(%(9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%9$($)*'8$4"'(/8/(5%
($'(% F/(9% 2!22% 9".$% -*% '50C(*0'%*+% 9$($)*'8$4"'(/8/(56% /(% 8"-% D$% 8*-8134$4% (9"(% (9$)$% ")$% -*%
'50C(*0'%*+%9$($)*'8$4"'(/8/(5%*)%O*%/'%"88$C($4%"-4%8"-%D$%8*-(/-3$4%(*%(9$%-$_(%G3$'(/*--"/)$%
4"("%C)*8$''/-#6%-"0$15%(9$%#1$b'$)%9$($)*'8$4"'(/8/(5%($'(A%%
%
Table!10.!SPSS!26!output!result!Glejser!Heteroscedasticity!Test!
S*$++/8/$-('"%
H5C$%
2/#-/+/8"-(%
RSUDZA!
RSIA!
Hospital!
%
%
%
?%
IS*-'("-(N%
>AW>?%
>AVYK%
A>Vg%
<0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%:YJ2%!*1/85%
>AZgW%
>AVZ>%
A>ZZ%
:YJ2%!1"--/-#%
>AZ>g%
>AZ>?%
A>W>%
<0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%:YJ2%C1"-%
>AWKW%
>AgKW%
A>g\%
:YJ2%C$)+*)0"-8$%0*-/(*)/-#%"-4%
$."13"(/*-%
>AV??%
>AW>>%
A>RY%
J$./$F%"-4%/0C)*.$0$-(%*+%2&:Y%
C$)+*)0"-8$%
>A>Wg%
>ARKY%
A>gY%
"A%[$C$-4$-(%c")/"D1$=%BTJ,2<H%
%
%
%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research!% 9((C'=ff/b'')A)/4F"-/-'(/(3($A8*A/4f%
IJSSR!!"#$%3118
T"'$4% *-% H"D1$% ?>A% /(% 8"-% D$% 8*-8134$4% (9"(% (9$% *3(C3(% )$'31('% *+% (9$% )$#)$''/*-% ($'(%
9$($)*'8$4"'(/8/(5% ($'(% 9".$% "% '/#-/+/8"-(% ."13$% *+% j% >A>g6% '*% (9$% 8*-813'/*-% /'% (9"(% (9$%
9$($)*'8$4"'(/8/(5%($'(%4*$'%-*(%$_C$)/$-8$%'50C(*0'%*+%9$($)*'8$4"'(/8/(5%'*%(9"(%"11%81"''/8"1%
"''30C(/*-%($'('%9".$%D$$-%+3115%+31+/11$4A%
4. Multiple!Linear!Regression!Analysis!Test%
H9$% ($'(% )$'31('% *+% 031(/C1$% 1/-$")% )$#)$''/*-% "-"15'/'% *-15% +*83'% *-% (9$% ."13$% *+% T% /-% (9$%
3-'("-4")4/Q$4%8*130-%"-4%8*-'("-4%)*F%C$)%.")/"D1$A%H9$%+*11*F/-#%)$'31('%*+%031(/C1$%)$#)$''/*-%
"-"15'/'%($'('%/-%(9$%$."13"(/*-%)$'$")89%*-%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%")$%
'9*F-%/-%H"D1$%??A%%
%
Table!11.!SPSS!output!result!26!Multiple!Linear!Regression!Analysis!Test!
Coefficientsa!
%
H5C$%
RSUDZA!
RSIA!
Hospital!
;-'("-4")4/Q$4%S*$++/8/$-('%
T%
T%
T%
%
%
%
?%
IS*-'("-(N%
?AY\Z%
A\\>%
Ag>\%
<0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%:YJ2%!*1/85%
aA>? Z%
A>?R%
A>VK%
:YJ2%!1"--/-#%
?A>gY%
A>YR%
AV??%
<0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%:YJ2%C1"-%
A>ZZ%
A>>\%
A?g>%
:YJ2%C$)+*)0"-8$%0*-/(*)/-#%"-4%
$."13"(/*-%
aA>g W%
A>\g%
A?>>%
J$./$F%"-4%/0C)*.$0$-(%*+%2&:Y%
C$)+*)0"-8$%
A>K?%
A>?Z%
aAKW >%
"A%[$C$-4$-(%c")/"D1$=%<-.$'(/#"(/*-%*+%F*)E%"88/4$-(%8"'$'%/-%9*'C/("1'%
%
H9$%)$'31('% *+%(9$% 031(/C1$% 1/-$")% )$#)$''/*-% "-"15'/'% ($'(% IH"D1$%\A?RN6% -"0$15%(9$% *3(C3(%
)$'31('%C)*.$%(9$%/-.*1.$0$-(%*+%(F*%*)%0*)$%4$C$-4$-(%.")/"D1$'%IiN%"-4%/-4$C$-4$-(%.")/"D1$'%
IhNA%
5. Test!the!hypothesis!
O5C*(9$'/'%($'(/-#%*+%G3$'(/*--"/)$%4"("%/'%8"))/$4%*3(%/-%(F*%'("#$'6%-"0$15%95C*(9$'/'%($'(6%
(%($'(%"-4%"-*."%95C*(9$'/'%($'(6%+%($'(A%H9$%+*11*F/-#%/'%(9$%(%95C*(9$'/'%($'(%"-4%+%95C*(9$'/'%($'(%/-%
)$'$")89%*-%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%"(%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&=%
"A H$'(%95C*(9$'/'%(%
H9$%(%95C*(9$'/'%($'(%/'%($'(/-#%)$'$")89%4"("%+)*0%(9$%(%8*130-%"-4%'/#%(%."13$'%j%(%("D1$%
Io%."13$N%p%(%8*3-(%03'(%l%(%("D1$%I."13$%aN%(9$-%(9$%'/#-/+/8"-(%."13$%03'(%D$%l%>A>gA%H9$%+*11*F/-#%
8"-% D$% '$$-% /-% ("D1$% ?K% *+% (9$% )$'31('% *+% (9$% 95C*(9$'/'% ($'(% /-% (9$% $."13"(/*-% )$'$")89% *-% (9$%
"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%"'%+*11*F'=%
%
Table!12.!SPSS!output!result!26!Hypothesis!Test!t!
Coefficientsa!
H5C$%
J2;[eB%
J2<B%
O*'C/("1%
%
%
%
?%
IS*-'("-(N%
?A>Y?%
>ARKR%
AV>V%
<0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%:YJ2%!*1/85%
aA\\ W%
>AV?K%
AWZR%
:YJ2%!1"--/-#%
??AYRK%
>AWZ>%
\AZ>Z%
<0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%:YJ2%C1"-%
YAWWW%
>AW\Z%
YA>\K%
:YJ2%C$)+*)0"-8$%0*-/(*)/-#%"-4%
aAZZ g%
>AZ>K%
AZZZ%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research6%%
S3(%&3(/"F"(/
1
6%&")/"-"
2
6%&"9/4/-
3
%
IJSSR!!"#$%3119
$."13"(/*-%
J$./$F%"-4%/0C)*.$0$-(%*+%2&:Y%
C$)+*)0"-8$%
AK>?%
>ARY?%
aKAZY\%
"A%[$C$-4$-(%.")/"D1$=%/-.$'(/#"(/*-%*+%F*)E%"88/4$-(%8"'$'%/-%9*'C/("1'%
%
T"'$4%*-%H"D1$%?KA%"D*.$6%(9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%(a($'(%95C*(9$'/'%($'(%)$'31('%*+%4"("%"-"15'/'%
'9*F$4% '/#-/+/8"-(% 4"("% )$'31('% *+% l% >A>g6% (9$-% (9$% )$'31('% *+% (9$% /-4/./43"1% C")(/"1% )$#)$''/*-%
8*$++/8/$-(%($'(%/-%(9$%2&:Y%"CC1/8"(/*-%$."13"(/*-%)$'$")89%G3$'(/*--"/)$%"(%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%
J2;[&% 03(3"115% /-+13$-8$4% D$(F$$-% .")/"D1$% h% "-4% .")/"D1$% i% "-4% ."1/4% /-% (9$% ."13$% *+% 2!22%
*3(C3(%'/#-/+/8"-8$%KWA%
DA B-*."%H$'(%O5C*(9$'/'%H$'(%H$'(%+%
H9$% +*11*F/-#% )$'31('% *+% (9$% "-*."% 95C*(9$'/'% +% ($'(% /-% (9$% $."13"(/*-% )$'$")89% *+% (9$%
"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%")$%'9*F-%/-%H"D1$%?YA%
%
Table!13.!SPSS!Output!Results!26!Anova!Test!Hypothesis!Test!f!Test!
ANOVAa!RSUDZA!
H5C$%
230%*+%
2G3")$'%
[+%
&$"-%
2G3")$%
7%
2/#A%
%
?%
J$#)$''/*-%
YKA\RK%
g%
W?>A\Z\%
K\?ARVW%
A>>>
D%
J$'/43"1'%
WAgKV%
\K%
A?gg%
%
%
H*("1%
YZA>>>%
\R%
%
%
%
ANOVAa!RSIA!
K%
J$#)$''/*-%
\ZA>KZ%
g%
ZAV>W%
g\KA\gZ%
A>>>D%
%
J$'/43"1'%
AKVZ%
?W%
A>?V%
%
%
%
H*("1%
\ZAY?V%
K?%
%
%
%
ANOVAa!RSSUDM!
Y%
J$#)$''/*-%
KZA\WV%
g%
gAVZ\%
?YKAZKW%
A>>>D%
%
J$'/43"1'%
AgYK%
?K%
A>\\%
%
%
%
H*("1%
Y>A>>>%
?R%
%
%
%
"A%[$C$-4$-(%c")/"D1$=%<-.$'(/#"(/*-%*+%F*)E%"88/4$-(%8"'$'%"(%J2;[&%
DA%!)$4/8(*)'=%IS*-'("-(N6%J$./$F%"-4%/0C)*.$0$-(%*+%2&:Y%C$)+*)0"-8$6%0*-/(*)/-#%"-4%
$."13"(/*-%
2&:Y%C$)+*)0"-8$6%:YJ2%C1"-%C1"--/-#6%!*1/85%/0C1$0$-("(/*-6%:YJ2%C1"-%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%
T"'$4%*-%H"D1$%?YA%"D*.$6%(9$%*3(C3(%*+%(9$%+%($'(%95C*(9$'/'%($'(%*D("/-$4%"%8"1831"($4%+%
."13$%/-%J2;[eB%K\?ARVW6%/-%J2<B%g\KA\gZ%"-4%/-%J2;[&%?YKAZKW6%(9$-%(9$%+%."13$%/'%'"/4%(*%D$%
/-+13$-(/"1%"-4%'/#-/+/8"-(%D$8"3'$%(9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%+%($'(%95C*(9$'/'%($'(%l%>A>gA%
6. Determination!Coefficient!Test!
H9$%C)*8$''/-#%*+%)$'$")89%4"("%*-%(9$%"4b3'($4%J%4$($)0/-"(/*-%8*$++/8/$-(%($'(%/'%8*-(/-3*3'%
F/(9%(9$%"89/$.$0$-(%*+%(9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%(%($'(%"-4%+%($'(%F9/89%")$%*+%'/#-/+/8"-(%."13$A%H9$%+*11*F/-#%
($'(%)$'31('%*+%(9$%$++$8(%*+%(9$%4$($)0/-"(/*-%8*$++/8/$-(%($'(%*-%(9$%$."13"(/*-%*+%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%
2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB%")$%'9*F-%/-%H"D1$%?\A%
%
Table!14.!SPSS!Output!Results!26!Effect!Test!of!Determination!Coefficient!Test!
Model!Summary
b
!
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research!% 9((C'=ff/b'')A)/4F"-/-'(/(3($A8*A/4f%
IJSSR!!"#$%3120
H5C$%
J%
J%2G3")$%
B4b3'($4%J%2G3")$%
2(4A%,))*)%*+%i)$%,'(/0"($%
RSUDZA!
AZ?K"%
AVYY%
AV?Y%
AYZ\%
RSIA!
AZZR"%
AZZ\%
AZZK%
AYZ\%
Hospital!
AZ?K"%
AVYY%
AV?Y%
AYZ\%
%
H9$%)$'31('% *+% (9$% $++$8(% ($'(% *+% (9$%8*$++/8/$-(% 4$($)0/-"(/*-% *+%(9$% "4b3'($4%."13$% *+%J% "(%
J2;[eB%V?Y6%"(%J2<B%ZZK%"-4%J2;[%V?Y6%(9$-%(9$%."13$%*+%(9$%8*$++/8/$-(%4$($)0/-"(/*-%*+%J%'G3")$%
/'%81*'$%(*%(9$%."13$%*+%?>>X%'/#-/+/8"-(%4"("A%H9$%"4b3'($4%."13$%*+%J%F/(9%"%."13$%*+%>?%/+%.")/"D1$%_%
/'%*-15%?%*)%K%/'%3'$4%)K%/+%.")/"D1$'%h%j%K%")$%3'$4%"4b3'($4%J)KA%
7. Results!of!Scoring!Method!Calculation!
H9$% )$'31('% *+% (9$% C$)8$-("#$% ($'(% *+% (9$% '8*)/-#% 0$(9*4% 8"1831"(/*-% C$)% .")/"D1$% /-% (9$%
)$'$")89%G3$'(/*--"/)$%$."13"(/-#%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%T"-4"%B8$9%
8"-%D$%'$$-%/-%("D1$%?\A%%
T"'$4%*-%(9$%)$'31('%*+%'8*)/-#%C$)8$-("#$%4"("%/-%H"D1$%?\6%(9$%$++$8(/.$-$''%)"($%*+%2&:Y%
"CC1/8"(/*-%9"'%"-%".$)"#$%C$)8$-("#$%."13$%+*)%)$'$")89%"(%J2;[eB%VZA\ZX6%"(%J2<B%WRA\RX%"-4%"(%
J2;[&%VWA\VXA%H9$%)$'31('%*+%(9$%]/E$)(%'8"1$%/-($)."1%/-%J2;[eB%"-4%J2;[&%")$%"(%"%."13$%*+%V?Xa
?>>X%F9/89%0$"-'%(9"(%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%'9*F'%"%.$)5%#**4%8"($#*)56%F9/1$%(9$%]/E$)(%'8"1$%
/-($)."1%/-%J2<B%/'%"(%"%."13$%*+%W?XaV>X%F9/89%0$"-'%(9"(%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%'9*F'%"%#**4%
8"($#*)5A%
8. Percentage!of!Effectiveness!of!K3RS!Management!Implementation!%
H9$%+/)'(%'("#$%*+%2&:Y%$."13"(/*-%)$'$")89%/'%(*%$."13"($%(9$%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%:Y%C*1/85%/-%
J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[%&$3)"_"%T"-4"%B8$9%)$+$))/-#%(*%!$)0$-E$'%d*A%WW%*+%K>?W%D5%)$./$F/-#%
:Y%C*1/85%C*/-('%'$$-%/-%H"D1$%?gA%
%
Table!15.!Results!of!Percentage!Calculation!Per-item!Questions!
Percentage!of!Effectiveness!Rate!Calculation!
No!
Variable!
RSUDZA!
RSIA!
Hospital!
X=∑mxn
%
𝟏𝟎𝟎%
Interval!
Likert!scale!
X=∑mxn
%
𝟏𝟎𝟎%
Interval!
Likert!scale!
X=∑mxn
%
𝟏𝟎𝟎%
Scale!Interval!
Likert!
?%
ZW6KgX%
,_8$11$-(%
RV6?VX%
^**4%
VR6RRX%
,_8$11$-(%
K%
W>X%
,-*3#9%
Wg6\gX%
^**4%
VR6RRX%
,_8$11$-(%
Y%
gZ6gVX%
,-*3#9%
\V6?VX%
,-*3#9%
WR6RRX%
^**4%
\%
ZgX%
,_8$11$-(%
W\6g\X%
^**4%
Z>X%
,_8$11$-(%
g%
Zg6\?X%
,_8$11$-(%
Rg6\gX%
^**4%
Z>X%
,_8$11$-(%
W%
Z\6gVX%
,_8$11$-(%
RW6YWX%
^**4%
VW6WWX%
,_8$11$-(%
R%
gZ6?WX%
,-*3#9%
W>X%
,-*3#9%
WK6KKX%
^**4%
V%
ZW6WWX%
,_8$11$-(%
Rg6\gX%
^**4%
ZY6YYX%
,_8$11$-(%
Z%
ZW6WWX%
,_8$11$-(%
W>X%
,-*3#9%
VV6VVX%
,_8$11$-(%
?>%
ZR6Z?X%
,_8$11$-(%
RW6YWX%
^**4%
VV6VVX%
,_8$11$-(%
??%
VV6RgX%
,_8$11$-(%
W>X%
,-*3#9%
Z?6??X%
,_8$11$-(%
?K%
Zg6VYX%
,_8$11$-(%
W>X%
,-*3#9%
Z>X%
,_8$11$-(%
?Y%
Zg6VYX%
,_8$11$-(%
RWAYWX%
^**4%
Z>X%
,_8$11$-(%
?\%
ZW6KgX%
,_8$11$-(%
W>X%
,-*3#9%
Z>X%
,_8$11$-(%
?g%
Z\6?WX%
,_8$11$-(%
W>X%
,-*3#9%
VV6VVX%
,_8$11$-(%
?W%
ZW6KgX%
,_8$11$-(%
W>X%
,-*3#9%
VR6RRX%
,_8$11$-(%
?R%
Z\6gVX%
,_8$11$-(%
V>X%
,_8$11$-(%
VR6RRX%
,_8$11$-(%
?V%
ZR6Z?X%
,_8$11$-(%
RV6?VX%
^**4%
VV6RRX%
,_8$11$-(%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research6%%
S3(%&3(/"F"(/
1
6%&")/"-"
2
6%&"9/4/-
3
%
IJSSR!!"#$%3121
Flat!
flat!
89,49%!
Excellent!
67,47%!
Good!
86,48%!
Excellent!
%%
T"'$4%*-% H"D1$% ?gA%/(%'9*F'%(9"(% (9$%$."13"(/*-%*+%(9$%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%:YJ2%C*1/8/$'%/-%
J2;[eB6%J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%9"'%"%#**4%C$)8$-("#$%/-%"88*)4"-8$%F/(9%(9$%)$'31('%*+%G3$'(/*--"/)$%
4"("% C)*8$''/-#% F/(9% (9$% 2!22% KW% 0$(9*4A% &$"-F9/1$6% (9$% )$'31('% *+% (9$% )$'$")89$)'`% $."13"(/*-%
)$#")4/-#%(9$%8*0C1$($-$''%*+%'3CC*)(/-#%4*830$-('%+*)%(9$%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%J2;[eB6%
J2<B%"-4%J2;[&%/-%T"-4"%B8$9%S/(5%")$%'(/11%-*(%C$)+$8(15%"."/1"D1$%"-4%'(/11%-$$4%(*%D$%8*0C1$($4%"'%
"%+*11*Fa3C%$++*)(%(*%'3CC*)(%(9$%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%(9$%:Y%F*)E%C)*#)"0%(*%D$%D$(($)6%/-8134/-#=%
"N P)#"-/Q"(/*-"1%'()38(3)$%4*830$-('%"(%J2;[eB%"-4%J2<B%-$$4%(*% 4$($)0/-$%(9$%-"0$6%"11*8"(/*-%
*+%43(/$'%f"jobdesk%"-4%-*(%4*%double"jobs"(*%+*83'%*-%(9$%"CC1/8"(/*-%*+%2&:Y%9*'C/("1'A%I?N%
DN :Y% *++/8$)'%"(%J2;[eB%"-4%J2<B%-$$4%(*%D$%4$($)0/-$4%"-4%"CC)*.$4%D5%(9$%9*'C/("1%4/)$8(*)%I?N%
8N :Y%*++/8$)'% "(% J2;[eB%"-4% J2<B% "88*)4/-#%(*%(9$%:Y%*)#"-/Q"(/*-"1% '()38(3)$% "CC*/-($4%03'(%
9".$%"%:Y%$_C$)(%1/8$-'$%I?N%
4N H9$%8*0C1$($-$''%*+%(9$% '()38(3)$%*+%(9$%P883C"(/*-"1%2"+$(5%"-4% O$"1(9% B4./'*)5%S*00/(($$%
I!K:YN% "(% J2;[eB6% J2<B% "-4% J2;[&% ")$% :Y% $_C$)('% F9*% "''/'(% 9*'C/("1% 1$"4$)'% +*)% (9$%
/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%9*'C/("1'%IKN%
9. Factors!Affecting!the!Application!of!SMK3!in!RSUDZA,!RSIA!and!RSUDM!
T"'$4% *-% (9$% )$'31('% *+% (9$% $."13"(/*-% *+% (9$% /0C1$0$-("(/*-% *+% 2&:Y6% (9$)$% ")$% '$.$)"1%
+"8(*)'%(9"(%"++$8(% (9$%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%2&:Y% /-% J2;[eB6%J2<B% "-4%J2;[&%/-%T"-4"%B8$9% S/(56%
/-8134/-#%(9$%+*11*F/-#=%
%
Table!16.!Factors!that!affect!the!implementation!of!SMK3!in!RSUDZA,!RSIA!and!RSUDM!in!
Banda!Aceh!City!
No!
RSUDZA!
RSIA!
Hospital!
?%
H9$%1"8E%*+%:Y%+/$14%*++/8$)'%/-%
"''/'(/-#% (9$% 8*0C1$(/*-% *+%
(9$% /0C1$0$-("(/*-% *+% :Y%
F*)E% /'% $./4$-8$4% D5% (9$%
"D'$-8$%*+%(9$%4$($)0/-"(/*-%
*+%(9$% -"0$%*+% (9$% *++/8$)%/-%
(9$% :Y% *)#"-/Q"(/*-"1%
'()38(3)$%F/(9%
H9$% )$"'*-% F95% (9$% *++/8$)'%
89"-#$4%C$)'*--$1%
H9$%1"8E%*+%"%D"))/$)%D$(F$$-%
(9$% :Y% +/$14% *++/8$)`'% )**0%
"-4% *(9$)% +/$14'% '*% (9"(% (9$%
F*)E'C"8$% '$$0'% -"))*F%
"-4%3-8*0+*)("D1$%"-4%$.$-%
1**E'%1/E$%"%F")$9*3'$%
F")$9*3'$A%
H9$%1"8E%*+%'/#-'%"-4%-"0/-#%
*+% (9$% :Y% )**0% '*% (9"(% (9$%
F*)E'C"8$% 1**E'% 1/E$%
$0C1*5$$% 9*3'/-#% F/(9*3(%
4/)$8(/*-'A%
%
K%
H9$% 1"8E% *+% :Y% '/#-'% /-% (9$%
9*'C/("1% ")$"% '389% "'%
4/)$8(/*-'%/-%(9$%1"5*3(%0"C%
/-% (9$% ")$"% *3('/4$% (9$%
9*'C/("1% 0"E$'% /(% $"'/$)% +*)%
9*'C/("1% ./'/(*)'% (*% +/-4% (9$%
-$8$''")5%)**0%
?A H9$% /-"883)"($% C1"8$0$-(% *+%
(9$%:Y%($"0%)**0%'9*314%D$%
/-%+)*-(%*+%(9$%D3/14/-#%'*%(9"(%
/(% D$8*0$'% (9$% +)*-(% 1/-$% /-%
*.$)8*0/-#% F*)E% "88/4$-('%
"-4%$0$)#$-85%)$'C*-'$%
$0$)#$-85A%
H9$% 1"8E%*+%C")E/-#%")$"%'/#-'%
0"E$'% (9$% C")E/-#% ")$"%
3-(/45A%
Y%
H9$% 1"8E% *+% /-+*)0"(/*-%
C")(/$'% /-% $"89% 9*'C/("1%
D3/14/-#%0"E$'%/(%$"'/$)%(*%
C)*./4/-#% /-+*)0"(/*-%
'$)./8$'%
?A H9$% 1"8E% *+% D34#$(% /-%
)$C"/)/-#%9*'C/("1%"''$('%"-4%
1"8E% *+% 8*-8$)-% "D*3(%
4"0"#$4% :Y% '*% (9"(% 0"-5%
4"0"#$4% 8$/1/-#'% 9".$% -*(%
D$$-%)$C"/)$4A%
H9$% 1"8E% *+% '$83)/(5%
C$)'*--$1%+*)%(9$%,0$)#$-85%
;-/(%I,JN%")$"%'*%(9"(%"88$''%
/-% "-4% *3(% *+% C"(/$-('% "-4%
$.$-% ./'/(*)'% /'% /))$#31")% f%
+)$$6% (9/'% 8"3'$'% "% )$438(/*-%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research!% 9((C'=ff/b'')A)/4F"-/-'(/(3($A8*A/4f%
IJSSR!!"#$%3122
/-% (9$% 1$.$1% *+% 9*'C/("1%
'$83)/(5A%
\%
]"8E% *+% /-+)"'()38(3)$% '389%
"'% C"(/$-(% F"/(/-#% )**0'% '*%
(9"(% (9$)$% ")$% '(/11% C"(/$-('%
"-4% C"(/$-(% #3")4'% )$'(/-#%
3-4$)% (9$% '("/)'6% 3-4$)%
F/-4*F'% "-4% 8*))/4*)'% *+%
(9$%C"(/$-(%)**0A%H9/'%8"3'$'%
'130'% "-4% 8"-% 8"3'$% "%
8*00*(/*-%
?A H9$% 1"8E% *+% /-+*)0"(/*-%
*++/8$)'% "(% '$.$)"1% C*/-('% /-%
(9$% 9*'C/("1% '*% (9"(%
"44/(/*-"1% /-+*)0"(/*-%
*++/8$)'% ")$% -$$4$4% /-% (9$%
D3/14/-#%
%
g%
H9$%1"8E%*+%'$1$8(/*-%D$(F$$-%
(9$% C9")0"85% F*)E'C"8$%
"-4%(9$%4)3#%)**0%"++$ 8('%(9$%
9$"1(9%*+%$0C1*5$$'%F9*%")$%
8*-+/-$4% /-% (9$% C9")0"85%
)**0%+*)%"%1*-#%(/0$%
%
%
!
CONCLUSION,
H9$%8*-813'/*-%*+%(9$%$."13"(/*-%*+%(9$%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%(9$%P883C"(/*-"1%2"+$(5%"-4%O$"1(9%
&"-"#$0$-(% 25'($0% I2&:YN% "(% J2;[eB6% J2<B6% "-4% J2;[&% T"-4"% B8$9% '9*F$4% #**4% (*% .$)5% #**4%
)$'31('6% F/(9% "-% ".$)"#$% $++$8(/.$-$''% ."13$% *+% VZA\ZX% "(% J2;[eB6% WRA\RX% "(% J2<B6% "-4% VWA\VX% "(%
J2;[&A%O*F$.$)6%(9$'$%."13$'%9".$%-*(%+3115%0$(%(9$%'("-4")4'%)$#31"($4%/-%!$)0$-E$'%d*AWW%*+%K>?WA%
7"8(*)'%(9"(%"++$8(%(9$%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-.*1.$%'$.$)"1%C)*D1$0'%/-%(9$%:Y%+/$146%'389%"'%1"8E%*+%
:Y% C$)'*--$16% /-$++$8(/.$% 4)3#% )**0% 0"-"#$0$-(6% 1"8E% *+% C"(/$-(% F"/(/-#% )**0% +"8/1/(/$'6% (*% '$83)/(5%
C)*D1$0'%/-%(9$%,0$)#$-85%[$C")(0$-(A%H9/'%+/-4/-#%/'%"-%/0C*)("-(%D"'/'%+*)%9*'C/("1%0"-"#$0$-(%/-%
/0C)*./-#%"-4%4$.$1*C/-#%(9$%/0C1$0$-("(/*-%*+%2&:Y%/-%(9$%+3(3)$A%
%
REFERENCES%
B[<%&A%K>?\A%!$-#")39%T34"5"%P)#"-/'"'/%H$)9"4"C%:3"1/("'%!$1"5"-"-%[/%J30"9%2"E/(A%
B1"0%dO6%7")3G3$%B26%B'9)"+%O6%S9/'(/%&U6%B90$4%H6%231("-"%&6%:9"1$G3QQ"0"-%&6%B1/%26%B90$4%26%d"')/-%
26%et"al.%K>KYA%,++$8(/.$-$''6%'"+$(5%"-4%$8*-*0/8%./"D/1/(5%*+%4"58")$%.$)'3'%3'3"1%9*'C/("1%8")$%
0"-"#$0$-(%*+%'$.$)$%C-$30*-/"%F/(9%*)%F/(9*3(%0"1-3()/(/*-%/-%89/14)$-%3'/-#%(9$%$_/'(/-#%
9$"1(9% '5'($0% *+% T"-#1"4$'9=% "% 813'($)% )"-4*0/'$4% 8*-()*11$4% ()/"1A% EClinicalMedicineA%
W>A4*/=?>A?>?WfUA,S]<d&AK>KYA?>K>KYA%%
T"'("-/%!6%&*9"00"4C*3)% &6% T"90"$/% U6%J"."-#")4%J6% &$9)"1/"-% ^A% K>K?A%O*'C/("1%0"-"#$0$-(%D5%
9$"1(9% '$)./8$'% 0"-"#$0$-(% #)"43"($'=% (9$% 89"-#$% C")"4/#0% /-% <)"-A% HeliyonA%
RI??NA4*/=?>A?>?WfUAO,]<iPdAK>K?A,>V\?\A%%
T$-(1$5%HB6%S"C*-$889/"%S6%P--/'%]%"--6%T)3-$((*%i6%7"))aM9")(*-%T6%S"(("-/%&6%d$(*%B6%c"''/1$5%BA%K>KYA%
B%'5'($0'%0*4$1%+*)%(9$%4$'/#-%*+%*883C"(/*-"1%9$"1(9%"-4%'"+$(5%0"-"#$0$-(%'5'($0'%/-813'/.$%
*+% F*)Ea+)*0a9*0$% "))"-#$0$-('A% Appl" ErgonA%
?>Z=?>YZWWA4*/=?>A?>?WfUAB!,J^PAK>KYA?>YZWWA%%
[$F/% B<6% M")4"-/% ,A% K>KKA% P883C"(/*-"1% 9$"1(9% "-4% '"+$(5% 0"-"#$0$-(% '5'($0% "-4% F*)Ea)$1"($4%
"88/4$-('%"0*-#%9*'C/("1%-3)'$'A%Enferm"ClinA%YK=2Wp2?>A4*/=?>A?>?WfUA,d7S]<AK>KKA>YA>>VA%%
,E"% 7/()/"% ,76% BD/4"9% d3)% Bd6% d$115% &")/''"% d&6% d3)% J"0"49"-% dJA% K>?RA% :")"E($)/'(/E% ;1E3'%
[/"D$(/E30% C"4"% !$-4$)/("% [/"D$($'% &$11/(3'% 4/% J2;[% 4)A% e"/-"1% BD/4/-% 4"-% J2;[% &$3)"_"%
T"-4"%B8$9%ISOBJBSH,J<2H<S2%P7% ; ]S ,J%B&Pd^%[<BT,H,2%&,]]<H;2%!BH<,dH%<d%J2;[%4)A%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research6%%
S3(%&3(/"F"(/
1
6%&")/"-"
2
6%&"9/4/-
3
%
IJSSR!!"#$%3123
eB<dB]%BT<[<d%Bd[%J2;[%&,;JBhB%TBd[B%BS,ONA%Buletin"Penelitian"KesehatanA%\gIYN=?gYp
?W>A%
,-4$% ,6% 231"/0"F"-% [6% 2"'("./"-"% [6% ]$'(")/-/-#'/9% &6% J*Q"--"% &6% &")/*% B6% &"9034"9% 26%
T"5349/)#"-(")"%,&6%U*9"--$'%J6%&"))5%7A%K>KYA%&"-"b$0$-%'30D$)%4"5"%0"-3'/"A%
^$("93-%^:6%T/)9"-3%:6% &/-5/93-%BA%K>KYA%H/0$%0"-"#$0$-(%C)"8(/8$%"-4%"''*8/"($4%+"8(*)'%"0*-#%
9$"1(9%C)*+$''/*-"1'%F*)E/-#%/-%C3D1/8%9*'C/("1'%*+%B44/'%BD"D"6%,(9/*C/"6%K>KKA%Int"J"Afr"Nurs"
SciA%?VA4*/=?>A?>?WfUA<UBd2AK>KYA?>>ggRA%%
<D)"9/0%BA%K>?YA%:*'"%:"("%<-4$E'A%
:*."8$./8% ]6% d"/E% J6% ]3#*a!"1"8/*'% [^6% B'9)"+/"-% O6% &*''/"1*'% ,6% [")Q/% BA% K>KYA% H9$% /0C"8(% *+%
8*11"D*)"(/.$%*)#"-/'"(/*-"1%0*4$1'%"-4%#$-$)"1%C)"8(/8$%'/Q$%*-%C"(/$-(%'"+$(5%"-4%G3"1/(5%*+%
8")$% /-% (9$% ,-#1/'9% d"(/*-"1% O$"1(9% 2$)./8$=% B% '5'($0"(/8% )$./$FA% Health" Policy" (New" York)A%
?YV=?>\Z\>A4*/=?>A?>?WfUAO,B]HO!P]AK>KYA?>\Z\>A%%
]/"*%]6%]/"*%:6%M$/%d6%i$%i6%]/%]6%M3%eA%K>KYA%B%9*1/'(/8%$."13"(/*-%*+%$)#*-*0/8'%"CC1/8"(/*-%/-%9$"1(96%
'"+$(56% "-4% $-./)*-0$-(% 0"-"#$0$-(% )$'$")89% +*)% 8*-'()38(/*-% F*)E$)'A% Saf" SciA%
?WgA4*/=?>A?>?WfUA22S<AK>KYA?>W?ZVA%%
&"'E")/%e%B]6%H"/%B%B]6%:/-4/%O%B]6%T3'"/4/%B%B]6%&"00")/%:%B]6%293E)/%<%B]6%O"'9"0/%O%B]6%&"'E")/%d%
B]6%M"/1/%T%B]A%K>KYA%O$"1(9%8")$a"''*8/"($4%0$"'1$'%*3(D)$"E%/-%C$4/"()/8%F")4'%/-%"%($)(/")5%
8")$%9*'C/("1=% S9"11$-#$'%"-4% 2F/''% 89$$'$% 0*4$1% $-+*)8$0$-(%+*)% C"(/$-(% '"+$(5A%Am" J"Infect"
ControlA%g?I??N=?KRKp?KRVA4*/=?>A?>?WfUABU<SAK>KYA>KA>??A%%
&3+/4"9%;A%K>K?A%,."13"'/%!$-$)"C"-%2/'($0%&"-"b$0$-%:$'$1"0"("-%["-%:$'$9"("-%:$)b"%I2&:YN%[/%
J30"9%2"E/(%H#EA%S9/E%[/(/)*%2/#1/A%
&3(9*9")*9% [Bd6% M/D*F*% [BA% K>K>A% J$(3)-% (*% M*)E% '$D"#"/% T$-(3E% U"0/-"-% :$8$1"E""-% :$)b"% 4/%
T"4"-% !$-5$1$-##")"% U"0/-"-% 2*'/"1% IT!U2N% :$($-"#"E$)b""-A% Jurnal" Hukum" Lex" GeneralisA%
?IKN=?pK?A4*/=?>AgWYR>fb91#A.?/KAVKA%
P"E0"-% U6% :/-'0"-% d6% ^**4$% dA% K>KKA% B% 2HB&!% "-"15'/'% *+% (9$% '("++% '"+$(5% 0"-"#$0$-(% '5'($0% /-%
)$'/4$-(/"1%B#$4%S")$A%Saf"SciA%?\WA4*/=?>A?>?WfUA22S<AK>K?A?>ggWYA%%
J"9"53% &6% i3'(/"-"% &6% U31/"-/% MA% K>K>A% !,JBdSBd^Bd% [Bd% <&!],&,dHB2<% :,2,]B&BHBd% [Bd%
:,2,OBHBd% :,JUB% I:YN% 4/% !H!d% V% !,J:,T;dBd% S<BH,JaUBMB% TBJBHA% Charity:" Jurnal"
Pengabdian"MasyarakatA%YI?NA4*/=?>AKg?K\f89")/(5A.Y/?AK>R>A%
2"1/E3--"%dB6%H*F/4b*b*%c[A%K>??A%!$-$)"C"-%'/'($0%0"-"b$0$-%E$'$9"("-%4"-%E$'$1"0"("-%E$)b"%4/%
J30"9%2"E/(%T$)'"1/-%!$)(/F/%&"E"''")A%BiocelebesA%gI?NA%
2".*5%&]A%K>KKA%25'($0'aT"'$4%!)"8(/8$%/-%S9)*-/8%!"/-%&"-"#$0$-(A%Primary"Care"-"Clinics"in"Office"
PracticeA%\ZIYN=\Vgp\ZWA4*/=?>A?>?WfUA!P!AK>KKA>?A>>\A%%
2*-("EE$%&6%PEC"-30%U6%i$)/0"9%],6%J$D0"--%B6%^9*'9%26%M"5-$%T$G3$(($%TA%K>KYA%[$8/'/*-%0"E/-#%
+*)% '"+$ (5% "-4% )/'E% /-% 9$"1(98")$% "-4% C)*8$''% '5'($0'A% Chem" Eng" SciA%
KRRA4*/=?>A?>?WfUAS,2AK>KYA??VVWWA%%
23#/")(*%<A%K>KKA%Metodologi"penelitian"bisnisA%!$-$)D/(%B-4/A%
239")(*5*% 7&6% 230"0C*3F% PU6% J"0C$-#"-% dOA% K>KKA% P883C"(/*-"1% B88/4$-('% "0*-#% 7/'9$)0$-% /-%
&"-"4*6%d*)(9%231"F$'/A%e-CliniCA%?>I?N=?pZA4*/=?>AYgRZ>f$81A.?>/?AYRY??A%
c/'F"-"(9"-%:6%U*9-'*-%&26%H*++$1%&MA%K>K\A%[*%'"+$(5%0"-"#$0$-(%'5'($0%'("-4")4'%/-4/8"($%'"+$)%
*C$)"(/*-'q%,./4$-8$%+)*0%(9$%PO2B2%?V>>?%*883C"(/*-"1%9$"1(9%"-4%'"+$(5%'("-4")4A%Saf"SciA%
?R?=?>WYVYA4*/=?>A?>?WfUA22S<AK>KYA?>WYVYA%%
M"953-/%<6%<'0"/1%d6%<QQ/"9%<A%K>K>A%O*'C/("1%+/)$%'"+$(5%/0C)*.$0$-(%$++*)(%I'(345%8"'$%J30"9%2"E/(%<D3%
4"-%B-"E6%T"-4"%B8$9NA%[/%4"1"0=%IOP"Conference"Series:"Materials"Science"and"EngineeringA%c*1A%
ZYYA%<P!%!3D1/'9/-#A%910A%>?K>gVA%
M/b$'/-#9$% [6% U"5"E30")% c6% ^3-")"(9-$% d6% 2"034)"#$% [A% K>KYA% <0C1$0$-(/-#% 9$"1(9% "-4% '"+$(5%
'()"($#/$'% +*)% D3'/-$''% '3'("/-"D/1/(5=% H9$% 3'$% *+% 0"-"#$0$-(% 8*-()*1'% '5'($0'A% Saf" SciA%
?W\=?>W?VYA4*/=?>A?>?WfUA22S<AK>KYA?>W?VYA%%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research!% 9((C'=ff/b'')A)/4F"-/-'(/(3($A8*A/4f%
IJSSR!!"#$%3124
%%
Copyright!holder:!
S3(%&3(/"F"(/6%&")/"-"6
%
&"9/4/-%IK>KYN!
!
First!publication!rights:!
<-($)-"(/*-"1%U*3)-"1%*+%2*8/"1%2$)./8$%"-4%J$'$")89%I<U22JN%
!
This!article!is!licensed!under:!
!
!
%