!
"##$%&'#%()*!+,-$."/%0.!123!4)#.$)-#%()-/!566!78!+"!1239!
!
:(/2!3;<!=(2!>?<!@.A.B&.$!?3?;!
e"-"ISSN$C!2807-8691$|$p-"ISSN$C!2807-839X!
!
$
IJSSR$D-E.!2868
!""#$%&&'()*(+,&-.*/0122&)3$$+*45)--*0-56
This%work%is%licensed%under%a%Attribution-ShareAlike%4.0%International%(CC%BY-SA%4.0)
Intelligence)Analysis:)Delays)in)the)Formation)of)the)
Crime)of)Sexual)Violence)Law)and)It’s)Derivative)
Regulations)
!
Zainuna$Rahayu
1
,$Puspitasari
2
,$Stepi$Anriani
3$
F)%G.$H%#-H!4)I().H%-<!4)I().H%-
1,2,3
!
JB-%/C!$-,-K'2L-%)')-MEB-%/2A(B
1
<!N'HN%#-H-$%>>M'%2-A2%I
2
<!$-O/.H%-2&(I-HMEB-%/2A(B
3%
Keywords$
$
ABSTRACT$
Intelligence"Analysis,"Sexual"
Violence"Law,"Derivative"
Regulations."
!
78$9$6(:6$9;<8=64)(=9>?96)>6@>'(>9$)86!8496)>?+98$9'6$),>)A)?8>"=BC6
+8)$)>,6 8>6 <+,9>"6 >99'6 "(6 +9$#(>'6 "(6 )"$6 )D#8?"*6 E8"86 :+(D6 "!96
F8")(>8=6 7(DD)$$)(>6 (>6 G(D9>6 8>'6 "!96 H)>)$"+B6 (:6 G(D9>I$6
JD#(K9+D9>"68>'67!)='6L+("9?")(>6+9A=9?"68>6)>?+98$96)>6?8$9$6(:6
,9>'9+MN8$9'64)(=9>?96)>6O.O-68>'6O.OO*6P9;<8=64)(=9>?9C6K!)?!6
'(D)>8"9$6 "!96 $"8")$")?$C6 ?(>")><9$6 "(6 +)$96 "!+(<,!6 Q<=B6 O.O5C6
$),>8=)>,686K(++B)>,6"+9> '*6R!96+9$<="$6(:6 "!96@FS@E6$<+49B6)>6O.O.6
!),!=),!"9'6 "!96 #+948=9>?96 (:6 $9;<8=6 4)(=9>?96 )>6 $(?)9"B*6 @>6
+9$#(>$96"(6"!)$6$)"<8")(>C6"!96P9;<8=6T)(=9>?96U8K6VWW6RLXPY6K8$6
9$"8N=)$!9'6 "(6 #+ (4)'96 86 $"+(>,9+6 =9,8=6 : (<>'8")(>*6 Z(K94 9+C6
'9$#)"968=D($"6"K(6B98+$6(:6)"$6=9,8=)[8")(>C6 )"$6)D#=9D9>"8")(>6!8$6
N99>6 !8D#9+9'6 NB6 "!96 $=(K6 9$"8N=)$!D9>"6 (:6 '9+) 48")4 96
+9,<=8")(>$6,(49+>)>,6"!96#+949>")(>C6!8>'=)>,C68>'6+9$"(+8")(>6(:6
"!96+),!"$6(:6"+8:A)?\)>,64)?")D$*6R!96=9,)$=8")496#+(?9$$6(:6"!96RLXP6
U8K6)>4(=4 9'6'9N8"9$C69$#9?)8==B6:+(D6"!96L+($#9+(<$6Q<$")?96L8+"B6
VLXPY6:8?")(>C68>'6"!96D8)>6(N$"8?=9$68:"9+6)"$69>8?"D9>"6)>4(= 49'6
)>8'9]<8"96?((+')>8")(>6N9"K99 >648+)(<$6)>$")"<")(>$68>'686=8?\6
(:6$<##(+")>,6!<D8>6+9$(<+?9$*6S+(D6"!96 +9$<="$6(:6"!96$"<'BC6 )"6
K8$6:(<>'6"!8"6?!8==9>,9$6)>6)D#=9D9>")>,6"!96RLXP6U8K68+96>("6
(>=B6=9,)$=8")4 96)>6>8"<+9C6N<"68=$(6)>?=<'96(+,8>)[8")(>8=68$#9?"$C6
!<D8>6 +9$(<+?9$C6 8>'6 4)?")D6 #+("9?")(>*6 P9+)(<$6 9::(+"$6 8+96
>99'9'6"(69>$<+96"!96$<??9$$:<=6)D#=9D9>"8")(>6(:6"!96RLXP6U8K6
"!+(<,!6)D#+(49'6?((+')>8")(>C6$"+9>,"!9>)>,6!<D8>6+9$(<+?9$C6
8>'68'9]<8"96#+ ( "9?")(>6: ( +68==6#8+")9$6)>4(=49'6)>6!8>'=)>,6$9;<8=6
4)(=9>?96?8$9$*6R!<$C6"!9$96$"9#$6N9?(D968>6)D#(+"8>"69$$9>?96)>6
"!96)D#=9D9>"8")(>6(:6"!)$6=8K6)>6(+'9+6"(6#+(4)'96+98=6#+("9?")(>6
8>'63<$")?96:(+64)?")D$6(:6$9; <8=64)(=9>?96"!+(<,!(<"6@>'(>9$)8*6
$
$
!
$
INTRODUCTION$
6-H.H! (O! H.P'-/! G%(/.)A.!-$.! ().!(O! #,.!A-H.H! #,-#!,-G.! %)A$.-H.I!H%E)%O%A-)#/K<! I-#-!O$(B! #,.!
=-#%()-/!6(BB%HH%()!O($!Q(B.)!5Komnas"Perempuan9!%)!?3?>!H-R!-!HN%0.!%)!A-H.H!(O!E.)I.$*&-H.I!
G%(/.)A.<! )-B./K! ;;S<1TU! A-H.H! $.A($I.I<! R,%A,! %H! -/B(H#! V3W! (O! ?3?32! @-#-! O$(B! #,.! X%)%H#$K! (O!
Q(B.)YH!JBN(R.$B.)#!-)I!6,%/I!D$(#.A#%()!H#-#.H!#,-#!#,.$.!R.$.!>><3>U!A-H.H!(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!%)!
?3??2!
+.P'-/!:%(/.)A.!#(NH! #,.!/%H#!-H!#,.! #KN.!(O!G%(/.)A.!(O#.)! .PN.$%.)A.I!&K! G%A#%BH!#,$('E,('#!
?3??<!#,.!I-#-!,-H!%)A$.-H.I!-E-%)!%)!?3?;!&K!>1<ZVT!A-H.H!R%#,!?<SSS!A-H.H!(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!-E-%)H#!
B.)!-)I!>;<>U?!A-H.H! (O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!-E-%)H#! R(B.)2![,.!I-#-!H,(RH!-!H%E)%O%A-)#!%)A$.-H.! O$(B!
?3??!#(!\'/K!?3?;<!R,%A,!%H!;<1Z;!A-H.H2!4=]4@!H'$G.K.I!?<?>3!$%.HN%()I%.)!#,$('E,('#!4)I%()%.H%-!%)!
X%.%*\'/K!?3?32!+'$G%.%!%H!N.$O($B.I!G%-!#%./%.N%()!R%#,!B%.#%(I%.!B'/#%H#-E%.!A/'H#%.$!H-BN/%)E!(Chan
& Sachs, 2023; Jewkes & Dartnall, 2023)2!!
International$Journal$of$Asian$Education$<!
^-%)')-!_-,-K'
1
<!D'HN%#-H-$%
2
<!+#.N%!")$%-)%
3
!
IJSSR$D-E.!2869!
]$(B!#,.!I.HA$%N#%()!-&(G.<!H.P'-/!%)#.$A('$H.!%H!-!A-H.!(O!%).`'-/%#K!#,-#!,-H!-!/-$E.!I.E$..!(O!
&%-H2!aO!#,.!)'B&.$!(O!N-$#%A%N-)#H!B.)#%().I<!UV2>W!(O!$.H.-$A,.$H!-IB%##.I!#(!,-G%)E!.PN.$%.)A.I!
H.P'-/! %)#.$A('$H.2! "H! B-)K! -H! ?Z21W! (O! $.HN()I.)#H! ,-G.! .PN.$%.)A.I! O($A.I! B-$$%-E.2! >?2;W! (O!
$.HN()I.)#H!,-I!.G.$!&..)!O($A.I!#(!'H.!A()#$-A.N#%()2![,.)<!-H!B-)K!-H!>?2?W!(O!$.HN()I.)#H!,-I!
$.A.%G.I!O($A.I!-&($#%()2![,.$.!R.$.!S21W!(O!$.HN()I.)#H!R,(!-IB%##.I!#(!.)E-E%)E!%)!H.P'-/!-A#%G%#%.H!
&.A-'H.!#,.K!R.$.!,-$B.I2!"!H%B%/-$!)'B&.$!R-H!H..)!%)!R(B.)!R,(!-IB%##.I!#(!.)E-E%)E!%)!H.P'-/!
-A#%G%#%.H!-)I!R.$.!#,$.-#.).I!R%#,!,-$B2!"H!B-)K!-H!Z2>W!(O!$.HN()I.)#H!.)E-E.I!%)!H.P'-/!-A#%G%#%.H!
&.A-'H.!#,.K!R.$.!/'$.I2!U2;W!(O!$.HN()I.)#!.)E-E.I!%)!H.P'-/!-A#%G%#%.H!&.A-'H.!#,.K!R.$.!#,$.-#.).I!
R%#,!)(#!,-G%)E!-!/%G%)E!R-E.2!X.-)R,%/.<!UW!(O!.BN/(K..H!%)G(/G.I!%)!H.P'-/!-A#%G%#%.H!R.$.!#,$.-#.).I!
R%#,!&.%)E!O%$.I<!I%G($A.I<!.PN.//.I!O$(B!HA,((/<!.#A!57'HH<!?3?;b!c%.&.$#%H<!?3?;b!d-A$(%P!.#!-/2<!?3?3b!
_.%IK!.#!-/2<!?3?;92!
[,.! .H#-&/%H,B.)#! (O! #,.! +.P'-/! :%(/.)A.! J/%B%)-#%()! 7%//! 5_FF! De+9! R-H! B(#%G-#.I! &K! #,.!
%)A$.-H%)E!)'B&.$!(O!G%A#%BH!(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!A$%B.H!%)!4)I().H%-!5Q%HB-K-)#%!.#!-/2<!?3>T<!?3?>92!
D$%($!#(!#,.!.)-A#B.)#!(O!#,.!+.P'-/!:%(/.)A.!d-R!5[De+!d-R9<!R,.)!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!A-H.H!(AA'$$.I<!
/-R!.)O($A.B.)#!O(A'H.I!()!.P%H#%)E!$.E'/-#%()H<!H'A,!-H! #,.! 6$%B%)-/!6(I.!5eFcD9<!#,.!d-R!()!#,.!
D$(#.A#%()!(O!:%A#%BH!(O!@(B.H#%A!:%(/.)A.!5d-R!='B&.$!?;!(O!?3319<!#,.!d-R!()! [$-OO%A0%)E!%)!D.$H()H!
5d-R!='B&.$!?>!(O!?33Z9<!-)I!d-R!='B&.$!;V!(O!?3>1!A()A.$)%)E!6,%/I!D$(#.A#%()!5=!\-B-/! .#! -/2<!
?3>Tb!['$).$!.#!-/2<!?3??92!"AA($I%)E!#(!"$K-)%!5?3?>9<!#,.!N(/.B%A!-E-%)H#!#,%H!&%//!-$%H.H!&.A-'H.<!R,.)!
G%.R.I!O$(B!#,.!O-A#H<!%#!I(.H!)(#!H..B!#(!f'H#%OK!%O!#,.!I$-O#!/-R!#,-#!%H!.PN.A#.I!#(!O%//!#,.!/.E-/!G-A''B!
$./-#.I!#(!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!%H!%E)($.I!(Franklin & Herek, 2022; Nurbayani et al., 2022; Suh, 2023)2!!
4)!4)I().H%-<!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!A$%B.H!-$.!$.E'/-#.I!%)!#,.!=%(B%($!d-R!>?!(O!?3??!A()A.$)%)E!
+.P'-/!:%(/.)A.!6$%B.H!5[De+!d-R92![,.![De+!d-R!%H!-!).R!/-R!#,-#!R-H!N-HH.I!()!+%./-H-<!"N$%/!>?!
?3??<!R,%A,!R-H!I$-O#.I!%)!?3>U2![,.!N-HH%)E!(O!#,.![De+!d-R!R,%A,!R-H!A-$$%.I!('#!&K!#,.!E(G.$)B.)#!
H.$G.I!-H!-!/.E-/!'B&$.//-!O($!#,.!N$(#.A#%()!(O!H.P'-/!$./-#%()H!%)!4)I().H%-2![,.![De+!d-R!A()H%H#H!(O!
S!A,-N#.$H!R,%A,!A()#-%)!T;!-$#%A/.H!$.E-$I%)E!N$.G.)#%()<!#$.-#B.)#!-)I!N')%H,B.)#!%)!A-H.H!(O!H.P'-/!
G%(/.)A.!R%#,!N.$HN.A#%G.!()!G%A#%BH!5")E$%-)%!.#!-/2<!?3?;92!
"AA($I%)E!#(!='$B-/-H-$%!5?3??9<![,.![De+!d-R!$.E'/-#.H!#R(!-HN.A#H!R,%A,!-$.!%)A/'I.I!%)!%#<!
)-B./K!#,.!$.E'/-#%()!(O!f'H#%A.!-)I!#,.!N$(#.A#%()!(O!G%A#%BH!H(!#,-#!/-R!.)O($A.B.)#!(OO%A%-/H!,-G.!/.E-/!
H#-)I%)E!#(!#-0.!-A#%()!-E-%)H#!N.$N.#$-#($H!(O!R$()EI(%)E!-)I!#,.$.!%H!-!H.N-$-#%()!(O!N'&/%A!%)#.$.H#H!
O$(B!N$%G-#.!%)#.$.H#H!H(!#,-#!H.P'-/!O$..I(BH<!H.P'-/!I.G%-#%()H!-)I!H.P'-/!-&'H.H!A-)!&.!$.E'/-#.I!%)!
$.E'/-#%()2!!
4)!-II%#%()<!-AA($I%)E!#(!X',-BB-I!5?3??9<!#,.!A()H#$'A#%()!(O!G%A#%BHY!$%E,#H!-H!$.E'/-#.I!%)!
#,.![De+!d-R!N$(G%I.H!E'-$-)#..H!(O!f'H#%A.<!/.E-/!A.$#-%)#K!-)I!$.N-$-#%()!O($!G%A#%BH!(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!
R,%A,!')#%/!$.A.)#/K!I%I!)(#!,-G.!-!H#$()E!/.E-/!&-H%H2![,.!.P%H#.)A.!(O!-!$.O($B'/-#%()!(O!#,.!$.E'/-#%()!
(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!%)!4)I().H%-!%)!#,.![De+!d-R!,-H!&.A(B.!#,.!&-H%H!O($!/.E%#%B-AK!O($!/-R!.)O($A.B.)#!
-)I!$./-#.I!N-$#%.H!%)!N$(G%I%)E!/.E-/!A.$#-%)#K<!N$(#.A#%()!-)I!$.H#($-#%()!(O!#,.!$%E,#H!(O!G%A#%BH!(O!
H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!5c-0%B!.#!-/2<!?3?3b!=(.$!.#!-/2<!?3?>92!
d-R!='B&.$!>?!(O!?3??!A()A.$)%)E!+.P'-/!:%(/.)A.!5[De+!d-R9<!R,%A,!R-H!N-HH.I!-/B(H#!#R(!
K.-$H!-E(<!&$.-#,.H!).R!/%O.!-O#.$!.OO($#H!B-I.!&K!G-$%('H!N-$#%.H!#(!$-%H.!#,.!%HH'.!(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!#(!
#,.!N-$/%-B.)#-$K!/.G./!O($!K.-$H2!"/#,('E,!#,.!.)-A#B.)#!(O!#,.![De+!d-R!-H!-!/-R!%H!-!H%E)%O%A-)#!H#.N<!
%#H!%BN/.B.)#-#%()!,-H!)(#!K.#!&..)!O'//K!$.-/%L.I2![,%H!%H!N$%B-$%/K!I'.!#(!#,.! -&H.)A.! (O! I.$%G-#%G.!
$.E'/-#%()H! E(G.$)%)E! #,.! N$.G.)#%()<! ,-)I/%)E<! -)I! $.H#($-#%()! (O! #,.! $%E,#H! (O! #$-OO%A0%)E! G%A#%BH!
(Bentivegna & Patalay, 2022; Logie et al., 2023)2!
[,.! 0.K! I.O%)%#%()H! (O! A($.! -)-/KH%H! -$.! H#'IK! I..N.)%)E<! ,K(/%H#%A! O'#'$%H#%A! G%H%()! -)I!
N$.N-$-#%()<!-)I! #,.!N'$N(H.! (O!'H%)E!#,.!$.H'/#H!(O!#,.!-)-/KH%H!-H!-)!-A#%G.!N%.$%.)A-)--)!&-H%H!O($!#,.!
O'#'$.2!]'$#,.$B($. <!XA@%(R%.//!5?33T9!.BN,-H%L.I!#,-#!%)#%./%f%.)!-)-/KH%H!%H!#,.!#.$B!'H.I!#(!I.HA$%&.!
#,.!`'-/%#K!(O!$.H.-$A,!-)I!-)-/KH%H!N$-A#%A.2!JBN,-H%L.H!#,-#!A($.!%)#.//%E.)A.!-)-/KH%H!%H!-!#.$B!'H.I!
#(!I.HA$%&.!#,.!#KN.!(O!%)#.//%E.)A.!-)I!N$-A#%A.!(O!-)-/KH%H2!+'NN(H.!-//!#%.$.I!%)#.//%E.)A.!-A#%G%#%.H!-$.!
International$Journal$of$Social$Service$and$Research!! ,##NHCgg%fHH$2$%IR-)%)H#%#'#.2A(2%Ig!
IJSSR$D-E.!2870!
$./-#.I!#(!N$(&/.B!-)-/KH%H!H(!#,-#!N$.I%A#%()H!A-)!&.!B-I.2!4)!#,-#!A-H.<!%)#.//%E.)A.!A($.!-)-/KH%H!#-0. H!
-! #%.$.I! N.$HN.A#%G.<! R,%A,! -%BH! #(! N$(G%I.! -! #KN.! (O! -)-/KH%H! #,-#! %H! I%$.A#/K! $./.G-)#! #(! -A,%.G%)E!
H#$-#.E%A!($E-)%L-#%()-/<! A($N($-#.!-)I! E(G.$)B.)#-/!(&f.A#%G.H!(Cheek et al., 2023; Mishori et al.,
2023; Yemane & Sokkary, 2022)2!
"AA($I%)E! #(! +'N()(! 5?33T9<! %)! I-#-! N$(A.HH%)E<! %)#.//%E.)A.! B'H#! &.! A()A.N#'-/! -)I!
A(BN/.B.)#!R,-#!%H!%BN/%.I!%)!#,.!O-A#H!#,$('E,!#$-A%)E!(#,.$!H('$A.H2![,.!N$(A.HH!(O!I-#-!N$(A.HH%)E!
-)I! N$.H.)#-#%()! (O! %)#.//%E.)A.!N$(I'A#H! $.O.$H!#(! #,.!%)#.//%E.)A.! A%$A/.!HA,.B.<! R,%A,!%H! E.).$-//K!
I%G%I.I! %)#(! O('$! B-%)! ./.B.)#H<! )-B./KC! 5>9! N/-))%)EgI%$.A#%)E<! 5?9! A(//.A#%)E! ($! .P#$-A#%)E!
%)O($B-#%()<!5;9!-)-/KH%H!($!N$(A.HH%)E!-)I!N$(I'A#%()!(O!$.N($#H<!-)I!519!N(/%AK!B-0%)E2!
a).!(O!#,.!B-%)!A,-//.)E.H!#,.![De+!d-R!O-A.H!%H!#,.!')-G-%/-&%/%#K!(O!I.$%G-#%G.!$.E'/-#%()H!#,-#!
A-)!N$(G%I.! -!A()A$.#.! &-H%H!O($! %BN/.B.)#%)E!#,%H! /-R!%)!#,.! O%./I2![,%H!-B&%E'%#K! A-)!&.!O./#! B($.!
H,-$N/K!%)!/.HH!-AA.HH%&/.!-$.-H<!R,.$.!-AA.HH!#(!/.E-/!H.$G%A.H!-)I!N$(#.A#%()!O($!G%A#%BH!A-)!&.!B($.!
I%OO%A'/#2!
4)!#,%H!A()#.P#<!%)#.//%E.)A.!-)-/KH%H!A-)!%I.)#%OK!-)I!.G-/'-#.!O-A#($H!A()#$%&'#%)E!#(!#,.!I./-K!
%)!N-HH%)E!#,.!+.P'-/!:%(/.)A.!6$%B.!7%//!5[De+9!-)I!#,.!O($B-#%()!(O!I.$%G-#%G.!$.E'/-#%()H2!h%G.)!#,.!
%)A$.-H%)E!A-H.H!(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!%)!4)I().H%-<!#,.!'$E.)AK!#(!')I.$H#-)I!-)I!-II$.HH!(&H#-A/.H!%)!#,.!
/.E%H/-#%G.!N$(A.HH!,-H!&.A(B.!%)A$.-H%)E/K!%BN($#-)#2!
+#$-#.E%A!%)#.//%E.)A.!-)-/KH%H!A-)!,./N!')A(G.$!#,.!N(/%#%A-/<!H(A%-/<!-)I!A'/#'$-/!IK)-B%AH!#,-#!
%)O/'.)A.! I.A%H%()*B-0%)E! N$(A.HH.H! -#! #,.! E(G.$)B.)#! -)I! N-$/%-B.)#-$K! /.G./H! 5")R-$<! ?3>>92!
[,$('E,!%)#.//%E.)A.!-)-/KH%H<!%#!%H!.PN.A#.I!#(!%I.)#%OK!#,.!%)#.$.H#H!(O!A.$#-%)!E$('NH<!$.H%H#-)A.!O$(B!
G-$%('H!N-$#%.H<! ($!/-A0!(O! ')I.$H#-)I%)E!-&('#!#,.! %HH'.!(O!H.P'-/! G%(/.)A.!#,-#!B-K!H/(R! I(R)!#,.!
/.E%H/-#%G.!N$(A.HH2!
]'$#,.$B($.<!#,.!-)-/KH%H!-/H(!.G-/'-#.I!#,.!%BN-A#!(O!#,%H!I./-K!()!G%A#%BH!(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.2!
[,$('E,! -)! %)#.//%E.)A.! -NN$(-A,<! $.H.-$A,.$H! R%//! .P-B%).! ,(R! #,.H.! I./-KH! %BN-A#! #,.! /.E-/!
N$(#.A#%()! -)I! H'NN($#! G%A#%BH! )..I2! [,%H! %)A/'I.H! ')I.$H#-)I%)E! ,(R! #,.H.! I./-KH! -OO.A#! N'&/%A!
N.$A.N#%()!-)I!#$'H#!%)!#,.!/.E-/!HKH#.B<!-H!R.//!-H!#,.!N(#.)#%-/!O($!-)!%)A$.-H.!%)!A-H.H!(O!')$.N($#.I!
G%(/.)A.!I'.!#(!-!/-A0!(O!/.E-/!N$(#.A#%()H2!
!
METHODS-
[,.!$.H.-$A,!B.#,(I!'H.I!%)!#,%H!H#'IK!%H!-!A-H.!H#'IK!B.#,(I!R%#,!-!I.HA$%N#%G.!`'-/%#-#%G.!
-NN$(-A,2! "AA($I%)E! #(! 6$.HR.//! 5?3>39<! `'-/%#-#%G.! $.H.-$A,! .PN/($.H! -)I! ')I.$H#-)IH! B.-)%)E! %)!
H.G.$-/!%)I%G%I'-/H!($!E$('NH!(O!N.(N/.!I.$%G.I!O$(B!H(A%-/!N$(&/.BH2!
!i'-/%#-#%G.! $.H.-$A,<! %)! E.).$-/<! A-)! &.! 'H.I! #(! $.H.-$A,! N.(N/.YH! /%G.H<! ,%H#($K<! &.,-G%($<!
A()A.N#H! ($! N,.)(B.)-<! H(A%-/! N$(&/.BH<! -)I! (#,.$H2! a).! (O! #,.! $.-H()H! R,K! 'H%)E! -! `'-/%#-#%G.!
-NN$(-A,!%H!#,.!.PN.$%.)A.!(O!$.H.-$A,.$H!R,.$.!#,%H!B.#,(I!A-)!O%)I!-)I!')I.$H#-)I!R,-#!%H!,%II.)!
&.,%)I!N,.)(B.)-!#,-#!-$.!H(B.#%B.H!I%OO%A'/#!#(!')I.$H#-)I2!!
[,%H! $.H.- $A,! 'H.H! /%#.$-#'$.! H#'I%.H! - H! -! &-H%H! O($! I-#-! A(//.A#%()2! ! ! "AA($I%)E! #(! 6$.HR./ /!
5?3>39<!I-#-!A(//.A#%()!#,$('E,!/%#.$-#'$.!H#'IK!-)I!I(A'B.)#-#%()!&K!`'(#%)E!-)I!$.-I%)E!B-#.$%-/!
(&#-%).I!I%$.A#/K!($!%)I%$.A#/K!O$(B!G-$%('H!/%# .$-#'$.!H('$A.H!$./-#.I!#(!H./.A#%)E!$.H.-$A,!#(N%AH!-)I!
N$(&/.BH!'H%)E!#,.!%)#.$$./-#%()H,%N!(O!%)O($B-#%()!A-#.E($%.H2!
d%#.$-#'$.!H#'I%.H!-$.!'H.I!%)!#,%H!H#'IK!#(!-HH%H#!$.H.-$A,.$H!%)!')I.$H#-)I%)E!#,.!A()A.N#'-/!
O$-B.R($0!(O! #,.! $.H.-$A,!#(N%A2! [,$('E,!-! /%#.$-#'$.!$.G%.R<! $.H.-$A,.$H!A-)! %I.)#%OK!$./.G-)#! -)I!
N(#.)#%-/!I-#-!H('$A.H!O($!#,.%$!$.H.-$A,2![,%H!,./NH!K('!N/-)!I-#-!A(//.A#%()!B($.!.OO%A%.)#/K2!
!
RESULTS-
4)!#,.!$.H'/#H!(O!#,%H!H#'IK<!$.H.-$A,.$H!-)-/KL.I!#,.!N$(A.HH!(O!O($B%)E!$.E'/-#%()H!I.$%G.I!O$(B!
#,.!+(A%-/!:%(/.)A.!6$%B%)-/!d-R!#(!$.G.-/!-)I!')I.$H#-)I!#,.!I./-KH!#,-#!(AA'$$.I!%)!#,.!/.E%H/-#%G.!
N$(A.HH2! @-#-!-)I! %)O($B-#%()! E-#,.$.I! O$(B! G-$%('H! H('$A.H<! %)A/'I%)E! HA%.)#%O%A! f('$)-/H! -)I! /.E-/!
International$Journal$of$Asian$Education$<!
^-%)')-!_-,-K'
1
<!D'HN%#-H-$%
2
<!+#.N%!")$%-)%
3
!
IJSSR$D-E.!2871!
I(A'B.)#H<!N$(G%I.!-!A(BN$.,.)H%G.!N%A#'$.!(O!#,.!IK)-B%AH!(O!O($B%)E!I.$%G-#%G.!$.E'/-#%()H2!!
@'$%)E! #,.! N$(A.HH! (O! #,.! De+! 7%//<! #,.! D$(HN.$('H! \'H#%A.! D-$#K! 5De+9! O-A#%()! N$.H.)#.I!
$.H%H#-)A.!#,-#!/-H#.I!')#%/!#,.!#%B.!R,.)!#,.![De+!7%//!R-H!O%)-//K!N-HH.I!-H!/-R2!!!4)!-II%#%()<!#,.!De+!
D-$#K!-/H(!A$%#%A%L.I!#,.!A()#.)#!(O!#,.!-A-I.B%A!#.P#!(O!#,.!&%//!#,-#!I%HA'HH.H!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!&-H.I!()!
I%OO.$.)#!H.P'-/!($%.)#-#%()H2![,.K!-/H(!(NN(H.!-$#%A/.H!$./-#%)E!#(!O($A.I!-&($#%()!-)I!O($A.I!B-$$%-E.2!!
[,.!$.-H()!R,K!#,.!]*De+!$.O'H.I!#(!.)-A#!#,.![De+!7%//!-H!-)!%)%#%-#%G.!R-H!&.A-'H.!#,.!#%.$!
I$-O#!I%I!)(#! %)A/'I.!A$%B%)-/!-A#H!(O! %BB($-/%#K!%)!-!A(BN$.,.)H%G.!B-)).$<!R,%A,!%)A/'I.I!H.P'-/!
%$$.E'/-$%#K<!-I'/#.$K<!-)I!H.P'-/!I.G%-#%()2!
]*De+!,-H!-/H(!N$(N(H.I!#,-#!#,.![De+!7%//!H,('/I!&.!-If'H#.I!#(!#,.!_eFcD<!.HN.A%-//K!-&('#!
#,.!)($BH!N$(,%&%#%)E!-I'/#.$K!-)I!H.P'-/!I.G%-#%()2![,.!$.E'/-#%()!(O!#,.!6$%B.!(O!"I'/#.$K!A-)!&.!
.PN-)I.I!-)I!#,.!HA(N.!(O!#,.!-I'/#.$K!$'/.H!#,-#!,-G.!&..)!$.E'/-#.I!%)!-$#%A/.!?S1!(O!#,.!6$%B%)-/!
6(I.<!&K!-II%)E!%)O($B-#%()!#,-#!-I'/#.$K!%H!A(BB%##.I!&.#R..)!-!B-)!-)I!-!R(B-)<!R,.#,.$!B-$$%.I!
($!)(#2!
Figure$1.$Timeline$of$TPKS$Law$
$
]$(B!#,.!#%B./%).!(O!#,.![De+!d-R<!%#!A-)!&.!H..)!#,-#!%)!#,.!>3!K.-$H!(O!%#H!O($B-#%()!N$(A.HH<!
#,.![De+!d-R!,-H!.PN.$%.)A.I!G-$%('H!(&H#-A/.H2!4)!#,.!?3>T*?3?1!N.$%(I<!#,.!De+!7%//!%H!%)A/'I.I!%)!
#,.!D$%($%#K!=-#%()-/!d.E%H/-#%()!D$(E$-B2!c(R.G.$<!%)!#,.!I%HA'HH%()!(O!#,.!?3?3!N$%($%#K!D$(/.E)-H<!
#,.!De+!7%//!R-H!R%#,I$-R)!O($!$.-H()H!(O!I%OO%A'/#!I%HA'HH%()2!
"AA($I%)E!#(!#,.!6,-%$B-)!(O!6(BB%HH%()!:444!(O!#,.!c('H.!(O!_.N$.H.)#-#%G.H!(O!#,.!_.N'&/%A!
(O! 4)I().H%-<!8-)I$%! +'H-)#(! 5?3>S9<!I%HA'HH%)E! #,.!De+! 7%//!%H! I%OO%A'/#!&.A-'H.!(O! H,-$N!I%OO.$.)A.H!
&.#R..)!O-A#%()H!#,-#!$.f.A#!($!H'NN($#2![,%H!%H!&.A-'H.!B-)K!H.)H%#%G.!N(%)#H!-$.!I%HA'HH.I!-&('#!H.P'-/!
($%.)#-#%()!-)I!dh7[2!
4)! -)-/KH%)E!#,.! H/(R! O($B-#%()!(O! #,.! +.P'-/! :%(/.)A.! d-R!5[De+! d-R9<!N/'$-/%HB! #,.($K! %H!
$./.G-)#!R,.)!/((0%)E!-#!#,.!IK)-B%AH!%)G(/G%)E!#,.!O($B-#%()!(O!I.$%G-#%G.!$'/.H!(O!#,.![De+!d-R2![,.!
I.&-#.! H'$$(')I%)E! #,.! [De+! 7%//! %//'H#$-#.H! H%E)%O%A-)#! I%OO.$.)A.H! (O! (N%)%()! -B()E! #,.! N-$#%.H!
• National Commission on
Violence Against Women
Initiates PKS Bill
2012
• National Commission on
Violence Against Women
prepares academic texts
• The PKS Bill is included in
the priority National
Legislation Program
2016
• The PKS Bill was agreed to
as a DPR initiative
• The PKS Bill articles were
cut from 152 to 50 articles
2017
• A DPR Commission VIII
Working Committee was
formed to gather opinions
• The PKS Bill has been
postponed until 2019
2018
• Demonstrations supporting and
rejecting the PKS Bill
• The PKS Bill was not passed by
the DPR for the 2014-2019 period
2019
• The PKS Bill was excluded from
the 2020 Prolegnas list
2020
• The PKS Bill was included in the
DPR's National Legislation
Program list and was replaced
with the TPKS Bill
• Not included in the Plenary
agenda
2021
• Baleg holds first plenary meeting
of TPKS Bill
• April 12 officially passed the TPKS
Law
2022
International$Journal$of$Social$Service$and$Research!! ,##NHCgg%fHH$2$%IR-)%)H#%#'#.2A(2%Ig!
IJSSR$D-E.!2872!
%)G(/G.I2! [,.! D$(HN.$('H! \'H#%A.! D-$#K! 5De+9! O-A#%()<! -H! ().! (O! #,.! B-%)! N/-K.$H! %)! #,.! /.E%H/-#%G.!
N$(A.HH<!N'#!O($R-$I!-!$.H%H#-)A.!#,-#!/-H#.I!O($!H.G.$-/!H#-E.H<!A$.-#%)E!-!IK)-B%A!N/'$-/%#K!(O!G%.RH!
$.E-$I%)E!#,.!&%//YH!A()#.)#2![,%H!O-A#%()!H,(RH!#,-#!#,.!N/'$-/%#K!(O!G%.RH!%H!)(#!()/K!/%B%#.I!#(!N(/%AK!
-HN.A#H<! &'#! -/H(! %)A/'I.H! A.$#-%)! %I.(/(E%A-/! I%B.)H%()H! -)I! G-/'.H! #,-#! %)#.$H.A#! R%#,! #,.! %HH'.! (O!
H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.2!
d-R!='B&.$!>?!(O!?3??!A()A.$)%)E!+.P'-/!:%(/.)A.!5[De+!d-R9!R-H!N-HH.I!-/B(H#!#R(!K.-$H!
-E(2![,.! .)-A#B.)#!-H!-!/-R!E%G.H!).R!HN%$%#!-O#.$!G-$%('H!N-$#%.H!,-G.!&..)!#$K%)E!#(!&$%)E!#,.!'$E.)AK!
(O!#,.!%HH'.!(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!#(!N-$/%-B.)#!O($!K.-$H2!c(R.G.$<!%)!$.-/%#K<!%BN/.B.)#%)E!#,.![De+!d-R!
A-))(#! &.! A-$$%.I! ('#! %BB.I%-#./K2! [,%H! %H! I'.! #(! #,.! -&H.)A.! (O! I.$%G-#%G.! $.E'/-#%()H! E(G.$)%)E!
B.-H'$.H!$./-#.I!#(!#,.!N$.G.)#%()<!,-)I/%)E<!-)I!$.H#($-#%()!(O!#,.!$%E,#H!(O!#$-OO%A0%)E!G%A#%BH2!
c.-I! (O! Komnas" Perempuan! ")IK! 8.)#$%K-)%! 5?3?;9<! H-%I! #,-#! %BN/.B.)#%)E! #,.! [De+! d-R!
R('/I!&.!H/%E,#/K!,-BN.$.I!I'.!#(!#,.!H/(R!O($B-#%()!(O!I.$%G-#%G.!$.E'/-#%()H2!"HH%H#-)#!@.N'#K!-/H(!
-E$..I!R%#,!#,%H!O($!Q(B.)YH!+.$G%A.H!O($!:%A#%BH!(O!:%(/.)A.!-#!#,.!X%)%H#$K!(O!DDD"<!X-$E-$.#,!_(&%)!
e($R-! 5?3?;9<! R,(! H-%I! #,-#! #,.! I.$%G-#%G.! $'/.H! R.$.! H#%//! &.%)E! I%HA'HH.I! -A$(HH! B%)%H#$%.H! (O!
%)H#%#'#%()H2!D$.G%('H/K<!V!h(G.$)B.)#!_.E'/-#%()H!-)I!V!D$.H%I.)#%-/!_.E'/-#%()H!R('/I!&.!B-I.!-H!
B-)I-#.H!O$(B!#,.![De+!d-R2!c(R.G.$<!#,.!h(G.$)B.)#!-E$..I!#(!H%BN/%OK!#,.!O($B-#%()!(O!I.$%G-#%G.!
$'/.H! %)#(!;! h(G.$)B.)#! _.E'/-#%()H! -)I!1! D$.H%I.)#%-/! _.E'/-#%()H2! [,.!O%G.! I.$%G-#%G.! $.E'/-#%()H!
%)%#%-#.I!&K!#,.!X%)%H#$K!(O!DDD"!-$.!-H!O(//(RHC!!
>2 _DD!()!D$.G.)#%()!(O![$-OO%A0%)E!-)I!c-)I/%)E<!D$(#.A#%()<!-)I!_.A(G.$K!(O![$-OO%A0%)E!:%A#%BHb!
?2 _DD! ()! 6(($I%)-#%()! -)I! X()%#($%)E! (O! #,.! 4BN/.B.)#-#%()! (O! D$.G.)#%()! -)I! c-)I/%)E! (O!
[$-OO%A0%)E!:%A#%BHb!
;2 _D.$N$.H!()!#,.!4BN/.B.)#-#%()!(O!4)#.E$-#.I!+.$G%A.H!%)!c-)I/%)E<!D$(#.A#%()<!-)I!_.A(G.$K!-#!
#,.!6.)#.$b!
12 _D.$N$.H!()!#,.![.A,)%A-/!4BN/.B.)#-#%()!F)%#!(O!#,.!Q(B.)!-)I!6,%/I$.)!D$(#.A#%()!"$.-b!-)I!
V2 _D.$N$.H!=-#%()-/!D(/%AK!()!#,.!J$-I%A-#%()!(O![De+2!
]'$#,.$B($.<!-O#.$!#,.![De+!7%//!R-H!N-HH.I!%)#(!/-R<!#,.!N$(A.HH!(O!O($B%)E!I.$%G-#%G.!$'/.H!
O-A.I!).R!A,-//.)E.H2!@%HA'HH%()H!-A$(HH!B%)%H#$%.H!-)I!%)H#%#'#%()H!H,(R!#,.!A(BN/.P%#K!-)I!I%G.$H%#K!
(O!%)#.$.H#H!%)!E(G.$)B.)#2!@%OO.$.)#!B%)%H#$%.H!-)I!-E.)A%.H!,-G.!I%OO.$.)#!I'#%.H!-)I!$.HN()H%&%/%#%.H<!
-)I!.-A,!A-)!,-G.!I%OO.$.)#!N.$HN.A#%G.H!()!%BN/.B.)#%)E!#,.![De+!d-R2!6(($I%)-#%()!-B()E!#,.B!
&.A(B.H! 0.K! #(!,-$B()%L%)E! I%OO.$.)#! G%.RH! -)I! .)H'$%)E! #,-#!#,.! $.H'/#%)E! I.$%G-#%G.! $'/.H! $.O/.A#!
A(BB()!)..IH!-)I!E(-/H2!
4)!#,.!A()#.P#!(O!N/'$-/%HB!#,.($K<!#,.!H/(R!O($B-#%()!(O!I.$%G.I!$'/.H!A-)!&.!')I.$H#((I!-H!#,.!
$.H'/#! (O! ).E(#%-#%()H! -)I! A(BN$(B%H.H! &.#R..)! I%OO.$.)#! E$('NH! -)I! %)H#%#'#%()H2! [,%H! N$(A.HH!
$.`'%$.H!I%HA'HH%()!-)I!).E(#%-#%()!-#!#,.!/.E%H/-#%G.!/.G./!-)I!%)G(/G.H!.P.A'#%G.!-A#($H!R,(!,-G.!-)!
%BN($#-)#! $(/.! %)! H,-N%)E! #,.! I.$%G-#%G.! $.E'/-#%()H2! [,.! I%OO%A'/#K! (O! $.-A,%)E! -! A(BN$.,.)H%G.!
-E$..B.)#!%//'H#$-#.H!-!A(BN/.P!N/'$-/%#K!(O!G%.RH!-)I!%)#.$.H#H!%)!H(A%.#K!-)I!E(G.$)B.)#2!
X.-)R,%/.<!7-/.E<!-!X.B&.$!(O!#,.!c('H.!(O!_.N$.H.)#-#%G.H!(O!#,.!_.N'&/%A!(O!4)I().H%-<!d'/'0!
='$!c-B%I-,!5?3?;9<!H-%I!#,-#!#,.!E(G.$)B.)#!,-H!)(#!H,(R)!%#H!H.$%('H).HH!-O#.$!N$(B'/E-#%)E!#,.!
[De+!d-R2!d'/'0!-/H(!`'.H#%().I!H(A%-/%L-#%()!-)I!#.A,)%A-/!E'%I./%).H!R,.)!#,.!E(G.$)B.)#!,-I!)(#!
%HH'.I!$.E'/-#%()H!I.$%G.I!O$(B!#,.![De+!d-R2![,%H!R%//!A()O'H.!#,.!O%./I!O($!/-R!.)O($A.B.)#!(OO%A%-/H!
%)!B-0%)E!#,.![De+!d-R!-!$.O.$.)A.!O($!,-)I/%)E!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!A-H.H2!
"AA($I%)E!#(!#,.!6%G%/!+(A%.#K!=.#R($0!O($!#,.!h'-$I%-)!(O!#,.!+.P'-/!:%(/.)A.!d-R!-#!-)!()/%).!
N$.HH!A()O.$.)A.!()!X()I-K<!=(G.B&.$!?Z<!?3?;<!#,.!/-RYH!%BN/.B.)#-#%()!(O#.)!O-A.H!(&H#-A/.H!I'.!
#(!#,.!-&H.)A.!(O!I.$%G-#%G.!$.E'/-#%()H!#,-#!H'NN($#!%#2!"A#%G%H#H!R,(!-$.!B.B&.$H!(O!#,.!6%G%/!+(A%.#K!
=.#R($0!H-%I!#,-#!#,.$.!-$.!H.G.$-/!$.A($IH!$./-#.I!#(!I%OO%A'/#%.H!%)!(G.$A(B%)E!A-H.H!(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!
(&#-%).I!O$(B!#,.!.PN.$%.)A.H!(O!G%A#%B!-IG(A-#.H!-)I!-A#%G%H#H!-A#%G.!%)!G-$%('H!$.E%()H2!!
4)!G-$%('H!$.E%()H!%)!4)I().H%-<!(&H#-A/.H!-)I! (&H#-A/.H!%)!%BN/.B.)#%)E!#,.! +.P'-/!:%(/.)A.!
6$%B.!d-R!5[De+!d-R9!,-G.!&.A(B.!N$(&/.BH!#,-#!-$%H.2!]($!.P-BN/.<!%)!=($#,! +'/-R.H%!-)I!J-H#!='H-!
[.)EE-$-!5=[[9<! /-R!.)O($A.B.)#!(OO%A%-/H!5"Dc9!I(! )(#!O'//K!')I.$H#-)I!#,.!H'&H#-)A.!(O!#,.! [De+!
International$Journal$of$Asian$Education$<!
^-%)')-!_-,-K'
1
<!D'HN%#-H-$%
2
<!+#.N%!")$%-)%
3
!
IJSSR$D-E.!2873!
d-R<!R%#,!-!O(A'H!B($.!%)A/%).I!#(!-NN/K%)E!N')%H,B.)#!#(!N.$N.#$-#($H2!+(B.!A-H.H<!.HN.A%-//K!#,(H.!
%)G(/G%)E!A,%/I$.)<!-A#'-//K!'H.!#,.!6,%/I!D$(#.A#%()!d-R!&.A-'H.!#,.!N')%H,B.)#!%H!B($.!H.G.$.!#,-)!
#,.![De+!d-R2!
a)!#,.!(#,.$!,-)I<!"DcYH!A()A.$)H!$.E-$I%)E!#,.!$.O'H-/!(O!#,.!D$(H.A'#($YH!aOO%A.!B-I.!#,.B!
$./'A#-)#!#(!'H.!#,.!$'/.H!I.$%G.I!O$(B!#,.![De+!d-R2! 4)!-II%#%()<! N-#$%-$A,-/!A'/#'$.<!H(A%-/!H#%EB-<!-)I!
O.-$! (O! N.(N/.YH! G%.RH! $.E-$I%)E! H.P'-/! G%(/.)A.! A-H.H! -$.! -II%#%()-/! O-A#($H! #,-#! A(BN/%A-#.! #,.!
H%#'-#%()2! _.)-! H#-#.I! #,-#! #,.! %)A(BN$.,.)H%()! (O! /-R! .)O($A.B.)#! (OO%A%-/H! -)I! #,.! /-A0! (O! N'&/%A!
-R-$.).HH!%)!N$(#.A#%)E!-)I!$.A(G.$%)E!G%A#%BH!-/H(!-II.I!#(!#,.!A(BN/.P%#K!(O!%BN/.B.)#%)E!#,.![De+!
d-R!%)!#,.H.!-$.-H2!
X.-)R,%/.<!%)!e-/%B-)#-)!-)I!D-N'-<!A'H#(B-$K!-)I!$./%E%('H!B.A,-)%HBH!-$.!H#%//!(O#.)!'H.I!
%)!$.H(/G%)E!#$-OO%A0%)E!A-H.H<!$.H'/#%)E!%)!).E-#%G.!%BN-A#H!()!G%A#%BH!I'.!#(!N-#$%-$A,K!-)I!H#%EB-2!4)!
X-/-)E!_-K-<!H(B.!%)G.H#%E-#($H!-$.!H#%//!$./'A#-)#!#(!'H.!#,.![De+!d-R<!.G.)!#$-)HO.$$%)E!A-H.H!#(!N(/%A.!
H#-#%()H!#,-#!-NN/K!(#,.$!/-RH2!4)!"A.,<!#,.!%BN/.B.)#-#%()!(O!H.$G%A.H!#(!O'/O%/!#,.!$%E,#H!(O!G%A#%BH!(O!
H.P'-/!,-$-HHB.)#!-)I!G%(/.)A.!%H!H#%//!O-A.I!R%#,!A,-//.)E.H!&.A-'H.!%#! H#%//!O(//(RH!i-)')!= (2T!(O!?3>T!
A()A.$)%)E!#,.!4BN/.B.)#-#%()!(O!c-)I/%)E!:%(/.)A.!-E-%)H#!Q(B.)!-)I!6,%/I$.)2!
X(G%)E!#(!6.)#$-/!\-G-!-)I!e'N-)E!6%#K<!J-H#!='H-![.)EE-$-!5=[[9<!N(/%A.!%)G.H#%E-#($H!H#%//!I(!
)(#!')I.$H#-)I!#,.!./.B.)#H!A()#-%).I!%)!#,.![De+!d-R2!4)!O-A#<!-!B()#,!-O#.$!#,.!N-HH%)E!(O!#,.![De+!
d-R<!#,.$.!-$.!H#%//!%)G.H#%E-#($H!R,(!I(!)(#!0)(R!#,.!.P%H#.)A.!(O!#,.!/-R2!4)G.H#%E-#($H!%)!#,%H!-$.-!H#%//!
)..I!-II%#%()-/!.G%I.)A.!#(!H#$.)E#,.)!#,.!./.B.)#!(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.<!-H!H#%N'/-#.I!%)!"$#%A/.!U!(O!#,.!
[De+!d-R2!
4)!X-/'0'<!#,.!_.E%()-/![.A,)%A-/!4BN/.B.)#-#%()!F)%#!5FD[@9!,-H!)(#!O')A#%().I!(N#%B-//K2!
[,.!Q(B.)!-)I!6,%/I$.)!D$(#.A#%()!"E.)AK!5DDD"9!H#%//!A()#$(/H!FD[@YH!(N.$-#%()H<!%)A/'I%)E!'H%)E!
G%A#%B!-HH%H#-)A.!O-A%/%#%.H2![,.!/-A0!(O!E(G.$)B.)#!H'NN($#!%)!#.$BH!(O!H,./#.$H!($!H-O.!,('H.H!-)I!#,.!
A(H#!(O!/%G%)E! O($!G%A#%BH!R,%/.!R-%#%)E! O($!/.E-/!N$(A..I%)EH!O'$#,.$!-IIH!#(! #,.!I%OO%A'/#%.H2! 6-H.H!(O!
H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.<! %)A/'I%)E!E$((B%)E! #,$('E,!()/%).! A,-#!$((BH<! R.$.!-/H(! $.A($I.I!%)! #,.! 7-/%!-$.-2!
F)O($#')-#./K<!#,.!N(/%A.!,-G.! )(#!)-B.I!#,.!N.$N.#$-#($H!-H!H'HN.A#H!-)I!H#%//!'H.!6,%/I!D$(#.A#%()!d-R!
=(2!;Vg?3>1<!)(#!#,.![De+!d-R2!
[,.!/-#.!.H#-&/%H,B.)#!(O!$.E'/-#%()H!I.$%G.I!O$(B!#,.!+.P'-/!:%(/.)A.!d-R!5[De+!d-R9!A$.-#.H!
')A.$#-%)#K!-)I!%)A()H%H#.)AK!%)!,-)I/%)E!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!A-H.H!%)!4)I().H%-<!A-'H%)E!G-$%('H!).E-#%G.!
%BN-A#H2![,%H!%H!%)!/%).!R%#,!#,.!(N%)%()!.PN$.HH.I!&K!Q%E)f(I%N'$(!5>TTV9<!R,.$.!#,.!A()H.`'.)A.H!
A-'H.I!&K!#,.!.P%H#.)A.!(O!-!/.E-/!G-A''B!()!#,%)EH!($!A()I%#%()H!#,-#!-$.!)(#!($!,-G.!)(#!&..)!$.E'/-#.I!
A-)! (AA'$!%)! /.E-/!')A.$#-%)#K! 5$.A,#H()L.0.$,.%I9!($! ')A.$#-%)#K!(O!/-RH! -)I!$.E'/-#%()H! %)!H(A%.#K!
R,%A,!R%//!O'$#,.$!$.H'/#!%)!/.E-/!A,-(H!5$.A,#HG.$R-$$%)E92!
[,%H!G-E'.).HH!)(#!()/K!.P-A.$&-#.H!#,.!NHKA,(/(E%A-/!#$-'B-!.PN.$%.)A.I!&K!G%A#%BH!&'#!-/H(!
/(R.$H!N'&/%A!#$'H#!%)!#,.!f'H#%A.!HKH#.B2!:%A#%BH!(O#.)!O../!')H'NN($#.I!-)I!%)H.A'$.<!A-'H%)E!,.H%#-)AK!
#(!$.N($#!A-H.H<!R,%A,!%)!#'$)!A-)!%)A$.-H.!#,.!)'B&.$!(O!')A(G.$.I!A-H.H!(O!H.P'-/!-HH-'/#!57.E.)K!.#!
-/2<!?3?;92!
4)!#,%H!A()#.P#<!#,.!'$E.)#!)..I!O($!#$-%)%)E!-)I!H(A%-/%L-#%()!(O!/-R!.)O($A.B.)#!(OO%A.$H!5"Dc9!
&.A(B.H! G.$K! %BN($#-)#2! 6(BN$.,.)H%G.! #$-%)%)E! ()! #,.! #$-OO%A0%)E! /-R<! A(G.$%)E! /.E-/! -HN.A#H! -)I!
H.)H%#%G%#K! #(! G%A#%BH<! %H! ).A.HH-$K! #(! .)H'$.! .OO.A#%G.! A-H.! ,-)I/%)E2! 4)! -II%#%()<! #,.! N$(G%H%()! (O!
-I.`'-#.!$.H('$A.H<!%)A/'I%)E!,'B-)!$.H('$A.H<!&'IE.#<!-)I!O-A%/%#%.H<!%H!.HH.)#%-/!#(!H'NN($#!"Dc!-)I!
$./-#.I!%)H#%#'#%()H!%)!B-)-E%)E!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!A-H.H2!
4)! -II%#%()<! N'&/%A! -R-$.).HH! A-BN-%E)H! -/H(! )..I! #(! &.! N$(B(#.I! #(! $.I'A.! H(A%-/! H#%EB-!
-E-%)H#! G%A#%BH! -)I! H'NN($#! .OO.A#%G.! /-R! %BN/.B.)#-#%()2! [,%H! A-BN-%E)! A-)! ,./N! %)A$.-H.! N'&/%A!
')I.$H#-)I%)E! (O! #,.! %BN-A#! (O! H.P'-/! G%(/.)A.! -)I! #,.! %BN($#-)A.! (O! #,.! [De+! d-R! %)! N$(#.A#%)E!
G%A#%BH2!
4#!%H!-/H(!%BN($#-)#!#(!,-G.!-)!()E(%)E!B()%#($%)E!-)I!.G-/'-#%()!B.A,-)%HB2![,%H!B.A,-)%HB!
-%BH!#(!.)H'$.!#,-#!#,.![De+!d-R!-)I!%#H!I.$%G-#%G.!$.E'/-#%()H!-$.!%BN/.B.)#.I!.OO.A#%G./K<!%)A/'I%)E!
International$Journal$of$Social$Service$and$Research!! ,##NHCgg%fHH$2$%IR-)%)H#%#'#.2A(2%Ig!
IJSSR$D-E.!2874!
B()%#($%)E!"Dc!N.$O($B-)A.<!.G-/'-#%)E!#,.!.OO.A#%G.).HH!(O!#,.!#$-%)%)E!N$(G%I.I<!-)I!$.G%.R%)E!#,.!
H'%#-&%/%#K! (O! #,.! $.H('$A.H! N$(G%I.I2! Q%#,! #,%H! A(BN$.,.)H%G.! -NN$(-A,<! %#! %H! ,(N.I! #,-#! #,.!
%BN/.B.)#-#%()! (O! #,.! [De+! d-R! A-)! &.! B($.! .OO.A#%G.<! N$(G%I.! &.##.$! N$(#.A#%()! O($! G%A#%BH<! -)I!
H#$.)E#,.)!#,.!f'H#%A.!HKH#.B!%)!4)I().H%-2!
4)!-II%#%()!#(!R.-0).HH.H!%)!#,.!$.E'/-#($K!O$-B.R($0!#,-#!A-)!H#$.)E#,.)!%#H!%BN/.B.)#-#%()<!
#,.!/-A0!(O!A(($I%)-#%()!-B()E!G-$%('H!-E.)A%.H!H'A,!-H!$./.G-)#!X%)%H#$%.Hg"E.)A%.H<!/-R!.)O($A.B.)#!
-E.)A%.H<!#,.!_.E%()-/![.A,)%A-/!4BN/.B.)#-#%()!F)%#!O($!Q(B.)!-)I!6,%/I$.)!D$(#.A#%()!5FD[@!DD"9<!
/(A-/!E(G.$)B.)#H<!-)I!(#,.$!$./.G-)#!%)H#%#'#%()H<!%H!-/H(!().!(O!#,.!H%E)%O%A-)#!A,-//.)E.H!%)!(G.$H..%)E!
#,.!%BN/.B.)#-#%()!(O!#,.!$.E'/-#%()2![,%H!N$(&/.B!%H!O'$#,.$!.P-A.$&-#.I!&K!-!H,($#-E.!(O!H'NN($#%)E!
,'B-)! $.H('$A.H<! %)A/'I%)E! I%H-&%/%#K! -IG(A-#.H<! /-RK.$H<! B.I%A-/! N.$H())./<! NHKA,(/(E%H#H<!
NHKA,%-#$%H#H<! -)I! H%E)! /-)E'-E.! %)#.$N$.#.$H2! =(#! ()/K! #,-#<! -HN.A#H! H'A,! -H! &'IE.#! -//(A-#%()! -)I!
-G-%/-&%/%#K!(O!H,./#.$!O-A%/%#%.H!-/H(!I.B-)I!B($.!%)#.)H%G.!-##.)#%()2!
4)!#,.!$.H'/#H!(O!#,%H!H#'IK<!%#!A-)!&.!A()A/'I.I!#,-#!#,.!N-HH-E.!(O!#,.![De+!7%//!-)I!-/H(!#,.!
.H#-&/%H,B.)#! (O! $.E'/-#%()H! I.$%G.I! O$(B! #,.! +.P'-/! :%(/.)A.! 6$%B.! d-R! 5[De+! d-R9! .PN.$%.)A.I!
G-$%('H!(&H#-A/.H! %)G(/G%)E!-HN.A#H! (O!$.E'/-#%()<! A(($I%)-#%()!(O! %)H#%#'#%()H<!,'B-)! $.H('$A.H<!-)I!
G%A#%B!N$(#.A#%()2!"/#,('E,!#,.![De+!d-R!R-H!N-HH.I!-/B(H#!#R(!K.-$H!-E(<!%#H!%BN/.B.)#-#%()!%H!H#%//!
,-BN.$.I!&K!#,.!H/(R!O($B-#%()!(O!I.$%G-#%G.!$'/.H!#,-#!E'%I.!%#H!%BN/.B.)#-#%()2!
[,.![De+!d-R!/.E%H/-#%()!N$(A.HH!%#H./O!,-H!%)G(/G.I!I.&-#.!-)I!$.H%H#-)A.<!.HN.A%-//K!O$(B!#,.!
D$(HN.$('H!\'H#%A.!D-$#K!5De+9!O-A#%()!-)I!(#,.$!=haH<!R,%A,!A$.-#.I!H%E)%O%A-)#!/.E%H/-#%G.!A,-//.)E.H2!
[,.!B-%)!(&H#-A/.!#(!.H#-&/%H,%)E!I.$%G-#%G.!$'/.H!%H!#,.!/-A0!(O!A(($I%)-#%()!-B()E!G-$%('H!$./.G-)#!
%)H#%#'#%()H<!H'A,!-H!X%)%H#$%.Hg"E.)A%.H<!/-R!.)O($A.B.)#!-E.)A%.H<!FD[@!DD"<!/(A-/!E(G. $)B.)#H<!-)I!
(#,.$! $./.G-)#! -E.)A%.H2! 4)! -II%#%()<! #,.! /-A0! (O! H'NN($#%)E! ,'B-)! $.H('$A.H<! %)A/'I%)E! I%H-&%/%#K!
-HH%H#-)#H<!/-RK.$H<!B.I%A-/!N.$H())./<!NHKA,(/(E%H#H<!NHKA,%-#$%H#H<!-)I!H%E)!/-)E'-E.!%)#.$N$.#.$H<!%H!
-/H(!-!N$(&/.B!#,-#!-OO.A#H!#,.!.OO.A#%G.).HH!(O!%BN/.B.)#%)E!#,.![De+!d-R2!
"HN.A#H! H'A,! -H! &'IE.#! -)I! H,./#.$! O-A%/%#%.H! R.$.! -/H(! %I.)#%O%.I! -H! O(A'H! (O! -##.)#%()! #,-#!
)..I.I!%BN$(G.B.)#!#(!H'NN($#!#,.![De+!d-R!%BN/.B.)#-#%()2!4)!-II%#%()<!(#,.$!(&H#-A/.H!%)A/'I.!#,.!
/-A0!(O!N$(#.A#%()!-)I!H.A'$%#K!O($!G%A#%BH<!O-B%/%.H<!R%#).HH.H<!-)I!.HA($#H!%)!A-H.H!(O!+.P'-/!:%(/.)A.!
6$%B.H2!4)!O-A#<!#,.!N$(A.HH!(O!$.H(/G%)E!A-H.H!')#%/!#,.!@%H#$%A#!6('$#[email protected]%H%()!%H!(O#.)!)(#!%)!-AA($I-)A.!
R%#,!.P%H#%)E!N$(G%H%()H<!H,(R%)E!')A.$#-%)#K!%)!#,.!f'I%A%-/!HKH#.B2!
!
CONCLUSION$
4)!A()A/'H%()<!(&H#-A/.H!%)!O($B%)E!$.E'/-#%()H!I.$%G.I!O$(B!#,.![De+!d-R!-$.!)(#!()/K!/%B%#.I!
#(! /.E%H/-#%G.! -HN.A#H<! &'#! -/H(! %)G(/G.! ($E-)%L-#%()-/! A,-//.)E.H<! ,'B-)! $.H('$A.H<! -)I! G%A#%B!
N$(#.A#%()2! [(!.)H'$.! #,.!H'AA.HHO'/! %BN/.B.)#-#%()! (O!#,.! [De+! d-R<! H.$%('H! .OO($#H!-$.! )..I.I! #(!
%BN$(G.! %)#.$*-E.)AK! A(($I%)-#%()<! H#$.)E#,.)! H'NN($#%)E! ,'B-)! $.H('$A.H<! -)I! N$(G%I.! -I.`'-#.!
N$(#.A#%()!O($!-//!N-$#%.H!%)G(/G.I!%)!,-)I/%)E!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!A-H.H2!
!
REFERENCES-
")E$%-)%<!_2<!"&I'/-f%I<!+2<!j!+'R-$#%<!+2!5?3?;92!d.E-/!")-/KH%H!(O!6,%/I$.)!-H!:%A#%BH!(O!+.P'-/!:%(/.)A.2!
Journal"of"Social"Science<!45?9<!;S3k;T12!,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>321UZTTgfHH2G1%?2V1U!
")R-$<! X2! ^2! 5?3>>92! ]($B-/%H-H%! +K-$%l-#! 4H/-B! @%! 4)I().H%-C! D.)I.0-#-)! D/'$-/%HB.! D(/%#%0! @-/-B!
e.&%f-0-)!D'&/%02!Millah:"Jurnal"Studi"Agama2!,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32?3SSVgB%//-,2G(/>32%HH?2-$#>!
"$K-)%<!_2<! Q%I(I(<!Q2<! j! 6,-)I$-R-#K<! 62!5?3?>92!c(R! -IG.$H%#K!`'(#%.)#! -)I!($E-)%L-#%()-/! f'H#%A.!
$.I'A.! #'$)(G.$! %)#.)#%()! .BN%$%A-/! .G%I.)A.! O$(B! 4)I().H%-2! The" Journal" of" Asian" Finance,"
Economics"and"Business<!85U9<!>>Z>k>>S>2!
7.E.)K<!62![2<!"$H,-I<!c2<!6'B%)E<![2<!@,-$%R-/<!@2!e2<!]%H,.$<!_2!"2<!]$-)0/%)<!X2!@2<!\-A0H()<!D2!X2<!XAd-A,/-)<!
h2! X2<! +.-$/.<! _2! c2<! j! =.R/-)IH<! 62! 5?3?;92! +.P'-/! ,-$-HHB.)#<! H.P'-/! -HH-'/#! -)I! $-N.! &K!
A(//.-E'.H! %)! #,.!H'$E%A-/! R($0O($A.<!-)I! ,(R! R(B.)! -)I! B.)!-$.! /%G%)E!I%OO.$.)#!$.-/%#%.HC!
International$Journal$of$Asian$Education$<!
^-%)')-!_-,-K'
1
<!D'HN%#-H-$%
2
<!+#.N%!")$%-)%
3
!
IJSSR$D-E.!2875!
(&H.$G-#%()-/!H#'IK!'H%)E!=c+!N(N'/-#%()*I.$%G .I!R.%E,#H2!British"Journal"of"Surgery<!1105>>9<!
>V>Sk>V?U2!,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3T;g&fHgL)-I?1?!
7.)#%G.E)-<!]2<!j!D-#-/-K<!D2!5?3??92![,.!%BN-A#!(O!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!%)!B%I*-I(/.HA.)A.!()!B.)#-/!,.-/#,C!
-! Fe! N(N'/-#%()*&-H.I! /()E%#'I%)-/! H#'IK2! The" Lancet" Psychiatry<! 95>>9<! SZ1kSS;2!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug+??>V*3;UU5??933?Z>*>!
7'HH<!@2!X2!5?3?;92!+.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!/-RHC!D(/%AK!%BN/%A-#%()H!(O!NHKA,(/(E%A-/!H.P!I%OO.$.)A.H2!Evolution"
and" Human" Behavior<! 445;9<! ?ZSk?S;2!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug\2J:adcFX7Jc":2?3?;23>233;!
6,-)<!72<!j!+-A,H<!62!\2!5?3?;92!4)#%B-#.!D-$#).$!:%(/.)A.!-)I!+.P'-/!:%(/.)A.2!Emergency"Medicine"Clinics"
of"North"America<!415?9<!;UTk;S32!,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug\2JX62?3?;23>233Z!
6,..0<!=2!=2<!7-)I#*d-R<!72<!j! +%)A/-%$<!+2!5?3?;92!D.(N/.!&./%.G.!H.P'-/!,-$-HHB.)#!-)I!I(B.H#%A! G%(/.)A.!
-$.! /.HH! ,-$BO'/! O($! R(B.)! %)! N(G.$#K2! Journal" of" Experimental" Social" Psychology<! 1072!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug\2\J+D2?3?;2>311Z?!
6$.HR.//<! \2! Q2! 5?3>392! _.H.-$A,! I.H%E)! N.)I.0-#-)! 0'-/%#-#%O<! 0'-)#%#-#%O<! I-)! B%P.I2! Yogyakarta:"
Pustaka"Pelajar2!
]$-)0/%)<!e2<!j!c.$.0<!h2!X2!5?3??92!+.P'-/!X%)($%#%.H<!:%(/.)A.!"E-%)H#2!Encyclopedia"of"Violence,"Peace,"
&"ConWlict:"Volume"1-4,"Third"Edition<!2<!;31k;>?2!,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug7TZS*3*>?*S?3>TV*
12333U;*Z!
c-0%B<!d2!=2<!+'H%-)-<!+2<!"$%O-<!]2!= 2<!]-,,-B<!"2!X2<! [.f-<!X2<!j!"&$ -,-B<!\2!5?3?392!DHKA,(/(E%A-/!A($$./-#.H!
(O! -)#%*H.P'-/! ,-$-HHB.)#C! @-#-H.#! (O! 4)I().H%-lH! h.).$-#%()! ^2! Data" in" Brief<! 312!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ugf2I%&2?3?32>3VT11!
c%.&.$#%H<!@2!5?3?;92!The"Routledge"International"Handbook"of"Sociology"and"Christianity2!
\.R0.H<! _2<! j! @-$#)-//<! J2! 5?3?;92! +.P'-/! G%(/.)A.2! Reference" Module" in" Biomedical" Sciences2!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug7TZS*3*;?;*TTTUZ*3233>>>*;!
d-A$(%P<!J2<!=-,B-)%<!42<!_.&'#<!@2<!j!]-)#()<!d2!5?3?392!=.R!B.-H'$.H!%)#$(I'A.I!&K!d-R!)(2!?3>S*Z3;!
$./-#%)E! #(! H.P'-/! -)I! E.)I.$*&-H.I! G%(/.)A.2! Revue" de" Medecine" Legale<! 115;9<! >33k>3U2!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug\2XJ@dJh2?3?323V233>!
d(E%.<! 62! c2<! a0'B'<! X2<! 6(./,(<! X2<! d('#.#<! X2! h2<! 7.$$K<! 42<! d'0().<! +2! a 2<!e%H'&%<! =2<! X'H(0.<!@2! e2<! j!
eK-B&-II.<!D 2!5?3?;92!+.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!H#%EB-!.PN.$%.)A.H!-B()E!$.O'E..!-I(/.HA.)#H!-)I!K('#,!
%)! 7%I%! 7%I%! $.O' E..! H.##/.B.)#<! FE-)I-C! i'-/%#-#%G.! %)H%E,#H! %)O($B.I! &K! #,.! H#%EB-! N(R.$!
N$(A.HH!O$-B.R($02!SSM"-"Mental"Health<!42!,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug\2++XXc2?3?;2>33?1?!
X%H,($%<!_2<!XAc-/.<![2<!h$..)<!d2<!a/H()<!_2!X2!e2<!j!+,-,<!D2!e2!5?3?;92!6()m/%A#*$./-#.I!H.P'-/! G%(/.)A.!
A()#%)'.H! %)! [%E$-K<! J#,%(N%-2! The" Lancet<! 4025>313Z9<! >3?;k>3?V2!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug+3>13*UZ;U5?;93>Z;1*S!
X()#E(B.$K<!62<!j!XA@(R.//<!d2!5?33T92!+(A%-/!).#R($0H!-)I!#,.!%)#.$)-#%()-/!H#'I.)#!.PN.$%.)A.C!")!
%)#.$)-#%()-/!A(BB')%#K!(O!N$-A#%A.n!Journal"of"Studies"in"International"Education<!13519<!1VVk
1UU2!,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>>ZZg>3?S;>V;3S;?>TT1!
X',-BB-I<! c2! 5?3??92! 4BN/%0-H%! 8'$%I%H! D.)E-#'$-)! c-0! e($&-)! [%)I-0! D%I-)-! e .0.$-H-)! +.0H'-/!
@-/-B!F)I-)E*F)I-)E!=(B($!>?![-,')!?3??![.)#-)E![%)I-0!D%I-)-!e.0.$-H-)!+.0H'-/2!Jurnal"
Surya"Kencana"Dua:"Dinamika"Masalah"Hukum"Dan"Keadilan<!95>9<!>k>V2!
=!\-B-/<!=2<!^'/-.,-<!J2<!j!+'N$%K -#%)<![2!5?3>T92!JI'0-H%!+.0H'-/!a$-)E![ '-!#.$,-I-N!")-0!I-)!_.B-f-2!
4)! Fakultas" Ushuluddin" UIN" SGD" Bandung! 5:(/2! ><! 4HH'.! >92! ]-0'/#-H! FH,'/'II%)! F4=! +h@!
7-)I')E2!
=(.$<!e2!F2<!6,-I%f-,<!+2<!j!_'I%-#%)<!J2!5?3?>92![,.$.!%H!)(!#$'H#-&/.!I-#-C!#,.!H#-#.!-)I!I-#-!-AA'$-AK!(O!
G%(/.)A.! -E-%)H#! R(B.)! %)! 4)I().H%-2! Heliyon<! 75>?9<! .3SVV?2!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug\2cJd48a=2?3?>2J3SVV?!
International$Journal$of$Social$Service$and$Research!! ,##NHCgg%fHH$2$%IR-)%)H#%#'#.2A(2%Ig!
IJSSR$D-E.!2876!
='$&-K-)%<!+2<!@.I.<!X2<!j!Q%I%-R -#K<!X2!"2!5?3??92!F#%/%L%)E!/%&$-$K!$.N(H%#($K!O($!H.P'-/!,-$-HHB.)#!
H#'IK! %)! 4)I().H%-C! "! HKH#.B-#%A! /%#.$-#'$.! $.G%.R2! Heliyon<! 85S92!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ugf2,./%K()2?3??2.>3>T1!
='$B-/-H-$%<!=2!62<!j!Q-/'K(<!Q2!5?3??92!JO.0#%G%#-H!F)I-)E*F)I-)E![%)I-0!D%I-)-!e .0.$-H-)!+.0H'-/!
@%!4)I().H%-2!Souvereignty<!15>9<!VZkUZ2!
D$-#%R%<! "2! 5?3>S92! e()H#$'0H%! $.-/%#-H! I-)! B.I%-! B-HH-! 5")-/%H%H! O$-B%)E! N.B&.$%#--)! dh7[! I%!
_.N'&/%0-!I-)!776!=.RH!B(I./!_(&.$#!=2!J)#B-)92!THAQAFIYYAT:"Jurnal"Bahasa,"Peradaban"
Dan"Informasi"Islam<!195>9<!V3kZ>2!
_.%IK<! @2! J2<! 7-'B/.$<! J2!_2<! j! [.BN/.<! \2! _2!5?3?;92!+.P'-/! G%(/.)A.! -E-%)H#! H.P'-/! B%)($%#K! R(B.)! %)!
+[JXC! 6(BN(')I! &-A0/-H,2! Social" Science" and" Medicine<! 3382!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug\2+a6+64XJ@2?3?;2>>U;UU!
+',<!\2!5?3?;92!c'B-)!_%E,#H!-)I!6($$'N#%()!%)!+.##/%)E!#,.!"AA(')#H!(O!#,.!D-H#C![$-)H%#%()-/!\'H#%A.!
JPN.$%.)A.H!O$(B!#,.!D,%/%NN%).H<!+('#,!e($.-<!-)I!4)I().H%-2!Bijdrag en"Tot"de"Taal-,"Land-"En"
Volkenkunde"/"Journal"of"the"Humanities"and"Social"Sciences"of"Southeast"Asia<!1795>9<!U>kST2!
['$).$<!J2<!6.$)-*['$(OO<!42<!=K-0'R-<!_2<!=,.)E-*6,-0-$%H-<![2<!X'A,.BR-!=,.$.$-<!62<!D-$0 .H<!\2<!_'I(!
=-)E-#%<!D2<!=.)E(B-H,-<!72<!X(K(<!_2<!j!@.G$%.H<!e2!5?3??92!_.O.$$-/!(O!H.P '-/!G%(/.)A.!-E-%)H#!
A,%/I$.)C!c(R!I(!A,%/I$.)!-)I!A-$.E% G.$H!'H.!-!O($B-/!A,%/I!N$(#.A#%()!B.A,-)%HB!%)!c-$-$.<!
^%B&-&R.n! SSM" -" Qualitative" Re search" in" Health<! 22!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug\2++Xi_2?3??2>33>S1!
Q%E)f(I%N'$(<! +2!5>TTV92!D.)E-)#-$!I-)! "H-H*-H-H!c'0'B!"I-#<!A.#-0 -)!0.C!>;2!Jakarta:"PT"Toko"Gunung"
Agung2!
Q%HB-K-)#%<!82!]2<!ald.-$K<!D2<![%/&'$K<!62<!j![f(.<!82!5?3>T92!6,%/I!H.P'-/!-&'H.!%)!4)I().H%-C!"!HKH#.B-#%A!
$.G%.R! (O! /%#.$-#'$.<! /-R! -)I! N(/%AK2! Child" Abuse" and" Neglect<! 952!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ugf2A,%-&'2?3>T2>313;1!
Q%HB-K-)#%<!82!]2<!ald.-$K<!D2<![%/&'$K<!62<!j![f(.<!82!5?3?>92![,.!N$(&/.B-#%L-#%()!(O!A,%/I!H.P'-/!-&'H.!%)!
N(/%AK! -)I! /-RC! [,.! 4)I().H%-)! .P-BN/.2! Child" Abuse" and" Neglect<! 1182!
,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ugf2A,%-&'2?3?>2>3V>VZ!
8.B-).<! _2! J2! c2<! j! +(00-$K<! =2! 5?3??92! +.P'-/! "HH-'/#g@(B.H#%A! :%(/.)A.2! Obstetrics" and" Gynecology"
Clinics"of"North"America<!495;9<!VS>kVT32!,##NHCggI(%2($Eg>32>3>Ug\2ah62?3??23?23?3!
8.)#$%K-)%<! "2! 5?3?;92! >3! 4)! -)#%A%N-#%()! (O! N.$.))%-/! A()#.H#-#%()C! D$(E$.HH! -)I! A,-//.)E.H! #(! )-#%()-/!
/-RH!-)I!&K*/-RH!A()A.$)%)E!H.P'-/!G%(/.)A.!-)I!H.P'-/%#K!%)!#,.!$.O($B-H%!.$-2!Gender"Equality"
and"Diversity"in"Indonesia:"Identifying"Progress"and"Challenges<!>SV2!
!!
Copyright$holder:$
^-%)')-!_-,-K'<!D'HN%#-H-$%<!+#.N%!")$%-)%!5?3?;9$
$
First$publication$rights:$
4)#.$)-#%()-/!\('$)-/!(O!+(A%-/!+.$G%A.!-)I!_.H.-$A,!54\++_9!
$
This$article$is$licensed$under:$
$
$
!