Attribution- ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY SA
4.0)
Vol. 03, No. 11, November 2023
e - ISSN : 2807-8691 | p- ISSN : 2807-839X
!
IJSSR!!"#$%2851
!""#$%&&'()*(+,&-.*/0122&)3$$+*45)--*6217
This%work%is%licensed%under%a%Attribution-ShareAlike%4.0%International%(CC%BY-SA%4.0)
Juridical)Analysis)of)Settlement)of)Criminal)Excise)Cases)
Using)The)Principles)of)Restorative)Justice)
%
Iswan!Heru!Widarto!
&"'(%)*+,$-.+/".%0."%)*##12(%3*45*$.+"%
06"+27%+.'"*8$-19:;./14$*/<$."1*##12<"=<+4%
Keywords!
!
ABSTRACT!
Case%Resolution,%Excise%Crime,%
Restorative%Justice.%
%
The$ enforcement$ of$ criminal$ law$ in$ the$ Excise$ Law$ traditionally$
focuses$ on$ penalties.$ Still,$ since$ Law$ Number$ 7$ of$ 2021,$ PPNS$
Customs$ and$ Excise$ investigators$ at$ the$ Cikarang$ Customs$ and$
Excise$ Office$ can$ now$apply$the$principle$of$restorative$justice$in$
resolving$ criminal$ excise$ cases.$ This$ research,$ conducted$ through$
normative$legal$methods$with$a$case$approach,$aims$to$clarify$the$
concept$ and$ mechanism$ of$ implementing$ restorative$ justice$ in$
resolving$excise$criminal$cases$at$the$Cikarang$Customs$and$Excise$
Office.$ Results$ from$ September$ 2023$ reveal$ that$ the$ office$ has$
successfully$implemented$restorative$justice$ 106$times,$leading$to$
asset$recovery$of$Rp.$2,434,494,100.$The$benefits$include$a$decrease$
in$excise$violations,$with$only$a$1.9%$recidivism$rate.$In$conclusion,$
restorative$justice$has$been$effective,$prioritising$beneficial$justice$
efforts$and$increasing$state$revenue$while$deterring$repeat$excise$
criminal$acts.$
%
%
%
%
INTRODUCTION)
>+52"/+5*.%"*4%=-+6$.%+*%3*45*$.+"%"-$%+*=-$".+*#%?-56%@$"-%/5%@$"-<%3*45*$.+"%+.%2+./$4%".%/8$%
=51*/-@%'+/8%/8$%8+#8$./%=-+6$%-"/$<%A8+.%+.%B$="1.$%/8$%#5,$-*6$*/%./+22%=-$"/$.%6"*@%255C852$.%?5-%
C$-C$/-"/5-.% 5?% =-+6+*"2% "=/.(% '8+=8% ="**5/% $.="C$% /8$% C1B2+=D.% "//$*/+5*<% A8$% C$-C$/-"/5-.% 5?% /8$.$%
,+52"/+5*.% "*4% =-+6$.% "-$% /8$% C1B2+=(% 2"'% $*?5-=$6$*/(% 5-% #5,$-*6$*/% 5??+=+"2.<% A8$@% .85124% B$% -52$%
654$2.%?5-%/8$%=5661*+/@%+*%"=/+*#%"*4%="--@+*#%51/%/8$+-%41/+$.%".%#5,$-*6$*/%5??+=+"2.<%
E-+6+*"2% "=/.% +*% /8$% $F=+.$% .$=/5-(% .1=8% ".% /8$% =+-=12"/+5*% 5?% +22$#"2% $F=+."B2$% #554.% GHIEJ% 5-%
=51*/$-?$+/+*#%$F=+.$%./"6C.(%"-$%*5/%/55%61=8%5?%"%=5*=$-*%+*%.5=+$/@%B$="1.$(%+*%#$*$-"2(%/8$%C1B2+=%+.%
65-$%+*/$-$./$4% +*%B+#% C-5B2$6.% 5-%.+#*+?+="*/% =".$.%.1=8% ".%=-+6$(%/$--5-+.6(% =5--1C/+5*(%"*4% .5%5*%
GKLM3NKL&(%OPOQJ<%R$?$--+*#%/5%/8$%4$?+*+/+5*%5?%$F=+.$(%$F=+.$%+.%"%./"/$%2$,@%+6C5.$4%5*%=$-/"+*%#554.%
/8"/% 8",$% .C$=+?+=% C-5C$-/+$.% "*4% =8"-"=/$-+./+=.(%*"6$2@7% /8$+-% =5*.16C/+5*% *$$4.% /5% B$% =5*/-522$4(%
/8$+-% =+-=12"/+5*% *$$4.%/5% B$% 65*+/5-$4(% /8$+-% 1.$% ="*% 81-/% .5=+$/@% 5-% /8$% $*,+-5*6$*/(% 5-% /8$+-% 1.$%
-$S1+-$.%/8$%+6C5.+/+5*%5?%./"/$%2$,+$.(%T5-%U1./+=$%"*4%B"2"*=$%GV$26+(%OPWXJ<%T1-/8$-65-$(%+*%/8$%H+#%
3*45*$.+"*%Y+=/+5*"-@(%"*%$F=+.$%./"6C%+.%"%C"C$-%-+BB5*%'+/8%/8$%C-+=$%'-+//$*%5*%+/(%"??+F$4%/5%=+#"-$//$%
C"=Z.%"*4%.5%5*(%'8+=8%+*%/8+.%=".$%+.%+..1$4%B@%/8$%Y+-$=/5-"/$%[$*$-"2%5?%E1./56.%"*4%0F=+.$%'8+=8%+.%
C-55?% 5?% C"@6$*/% 5?% $F=+.$% 41/@% 5*% /8$% ."2$% 5?% =$-/"+*% #554.% .1=8% ".% =25,$% =+#"-$//$.% "*4% =+#"-$//$%
GE8"*4-"%\%[1?-"$*+(%OPWWJ<%
>+52"/+5*.%+*%/8$%$F=+.$%.$=/5-(%".% -$#12"/$4%+*%&"'%K16B$-%Q:%5?%OPP]%=5*=$-*+*#%L6$*46$*/.%
/5%&"'%K16B$-%WW%5?%W::X(%+*=214$%"46+*+./-"/+,$%"*4%=-+6+*"2%,+52"/+5*.(%5?/$*%-$?$--$4%/5%".%$F=+.$%
=-+6$.<%L=/+5*.%=2"..+?+$4%".%"46+*+./-"/+,$%5-%=-+6+*"2%5??$*.$.%"-$%-$#12"/$4%+*%/8$%0F=+.$%&"' (%"*4%/8$%
"CC2+="/+5*%5-%+6C5.+/+5*%5?%."*=/+5*.%5*%C$-C$/-"/5-.%+.%"2.5%./-"+#8/?5-'"-4%GK"/+5*.(%O PPOJ<%M"*=/+5*.%
+6C5.$4%?5-%$F=+.$% "46+*+./-"/+,$%,+52"/+5*.%="*% B$%"46+*+./-"/+,$%?+*$.(% '8+2$%=-+6+*"2% 5??$*.$.%"-$%
.1BU$=/%/5%."*=/+5*.%+*%/8$%?5-6%5?%C$*"2/+$.%"*4%+6C-+.5*6$*/%GT25-"(%OPW9J<%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% 8//C.7^^+U..-<-+4'"*+*./+/1/$<=5<+4^%
IJSSR!!"#$%2852%
R$.52,+*#% "% ,+52"/+5*% +*% /8$% "46+*+./-"/+5*% 5?% E1./56.% "*4% 0F=+.$% .1C$-,+.+5*% +.% ="22$4% =".$%
8"*42+*#(% '8$/8$-% "*% "46+*+./-"/+,$% 5-% =-+6+*"2% ,+52"/+5*<% !-5,+.+5*.% -$2"/+*#% /5% ,+52"/+5*.% "*4% /8$%
"CC2+="/+5*% 5?% 5-#"*+_ "/+5*"2% "*4% =-+6+*"2% ."*=/+5*.% "-$% *$=$.."-@% /5% C-5,+4$% "% 4$/$--$*/% $??$=/% /5%
+*4+,+41"2%C$-C$/-"/5-.%"*4%.5=+$/@%"/%2"-#$%GL-+$?(%W::`J<%
M$$+*#%/8$%+6C5-/"*=$%5?%./"/$%-$,$*1$.%?-5 6 %/8$%$F=+.$%-$,$*1$%.$=/5-%/5% 4 -+,$%/8$%$=5*56@(%".%
"%./-5*#%$??5-/%+*%$*?5-=+*#%/8$%0F=+.$%&"'(%=-+6+*"2%."*=/+5*.%C-5,+4$%6"F+616%=5$-=+,$%C5'$-%?5-%
C$5C2$%.1BU$=/% /5% $F=+.$%41/@% GM"-5+*.5*#(%OPOPJ<% V5'$,$-(%/8$%=-+6+*"2% C-5,+.+5*.%=5*/"+*$4% +*%/8$%
0F=+.$%&"'%"-$%/8$%2"./%-$.5-/%1.$4%/5%$*?5-=$%=56C2+"*=$%'8$*%"46+*+./-"/+,$%."*=/+5*.%*5%25*#$-%'5-Z%
5C/+6"22@%GV5B.5*%\%!"@*$(%OPOOa%b"-4$-(%OPOOJ<%
3*%8"*42+*#%$F=+.$%=".$.(%/8$%C-+*=+C2$%c$,$-@5*$%+.%$S1"2%B$?5-$%/8$%2"'c(equality%before%the%law)%
61./%B$%1C8$24%B@%$,$-@%5??+=$-(%$.C$=+"22@%E+,+2%M$-,"*/%3*,$./+#"/5-.%G!!KMJ% '+/8+*%/8$%Y+-$=/5-"/$%
[$*$-"2%5?%E1./56.%"*4%0F=+.$%GYdHEJ%'85%"-$%#+,$*%+*,$./+#"/+,$%"1/85-+/@%".%-$#12"/$4%+*%L-/+=2$%`%5?%
&"'%K16B$-%9%5?%W:9W%=5*=$-*+*#%E-+6+*"2%!-5=$41-$%&"'%".%"%?5-6"2%2$#"2%C-5,+.+5*%5?%/8$%E-+6+*"2%
E54$<%3?%/8$%2"'%+.%*5/%$*?5-=$4(%+/%'+22%8",$%*5%6$"*+*#%+*%C$5C2$e.%2+,$.<%M1=8%2$#"2%-$#12"/+5*.%'+22%4+$%
B@%/8$6.$2,$.<%V5'$,$-(%+/%="**5/%B$%4$*+$4%/8"/%+*%8"*42+*#%4"+2@%=".$.(%,+52"/+5*.%+*%/8$%$F=+.$%.$=/5-%
"-$%5?/$*%?51*4(%$.C$=+"22@%=-+6+*"2%$F=+.$%,+52"/+5*.(%'8+=8%-$S1+-$%5??+=$-.%/5% /"Z$%"//+/14$.%5-%C52+=+$.%
/8"/% .56$/+6$.% +#*5-$% /8$% C-5,+.+5*.% 5?% 2"'.% "*4% -$#12"/+5*.% "*4% C-+5-+/+_$% "% .$*.$% 5?% U1./+=$% "*4%
816"*+/@%GH14+"/-+%\%f3RLARLbLK(%OPOOa%M8"-C2$..%$/%"2<(%OPOOa%).6"*(%OPWXJ<%
A8$%"=/+5*.%5?%5??+=$-.(%".%6 $*/+5*$4%"B5,$(%"-$%5?/$*%="--+$4%51/% +*%8"*42+*#%=".$.%5?%,+52"/+5*.(%
'8+=8(%+?%.$$*%?-56%/8$+-%$??5-/.(%?12?+22%/8$%$2$6$*/.%5-%5??$*.$.%5?%"%=-+6+*"2%"=/%+*%/8$%$F=+.$%.$=/5-<%L*%
$F"6C2$%+.%/8$%8"*42+*#%5?%=".$.%+*,52,+*#%$F=+.$%=-+6+*"2%,+52"/+5*.%+*%/8$%?5-6%5?%C-5,+4+*#%?5-%."2$%5-%
.$22+*#%$F=+."B2$%/5B"==5%C-541=/.%GHIE%VAJ%+*%/8$%?5-6%5?%=+#"-$//$.%/8"/%"-$%*5/%"//"=8$4%'+/8%$F=+.$%
./"6C.%".%-$#12"/$4%+*%L-/+=2$%Xg%5?%/8$%0F=+.$%&"'(%'8+=8%+.%?51*4%/5%B$%="--+$4%51/%B@%/-"4$-.%+*%./"22.%
5-%Z+5.Z.<%N-%6"-Z$/.%/8"/%.$22%322$#"2%HIE%VA(%'8+=8%"-$%?$'%GE"*4-+Z"(%OPOWJ<%A8$%/-"4$-D.%"=/+5*.%8",$%
+*4$$4%?12?+22$4%/8$%$2$6$*/.%5-%5??$*.$.%".%-$#12"/$4%+*%L-/+=2$%Xg%5?%/8$%0F=+.$%&"'(%B1/%+?%@51%255Z%"/%
/8$%=5*4+/+5*%5?%/8$%.85C(%'8+=8%+.%.6"22%"*4%/8$%S1"*/+/@%5?%#554.%+.%*5/%2"-#$(%.56$/+6$.%/8$-$%+.%"%
?$$2+*#%5?%C+/@%4-+,$*%B@%816"*+/@%*5/%/5%C-5=$$4%=-+6+*"22@<%
3*%/8$.$%=5*4+/+5*.(%/8$%C$-C$/-"/5-%+.%1.1"22@%*5/%C-5=$..$4%?1-/8$-%=-+6+*"22@<%M/+22(%8$%+.%#+,$*%
"%'"-*+*#%"*4%#1+4"*=$%/5%",5+4%-$C$"/+*#%8+.%"=/+5*.<%V+.%#554.%"-$%6"4$%+*/5%M/"/$hE5*/-522$4%[554.%
B$="1.$%/8$%5??$*4$-%+.%1*Z*5'*(%".%-$#12"/$4%+*%L-/+=2$%``%5?%/8$%0F=+.$%&"'(%'8$-$%/8$%#554.%'+22%2"/$-%
B$%6"4$%+*/5%M/"/$hN'*$4%[554.%GHbKJ%"*4%"CC2+$4%?5-%HbK%4$.+#*"/+5*%?5-%4$./-1=/+5*<%3*%-$.C5*.$(%
5??+=$-.%'+22%+*$,+/"B2@%C-+5-+/+_$%816"*+/@%"*4%U1./+=$%$,$*% +?%/8$@%?$$2%/8"/%/8$+-%=85+=$%+.%+*=5--$=/<%3/%+.%
1*4$-./"*4"B2$%B$="1.$%/8$%$F+./+*#%=5*4+/+5*.%-$S1+-$%5??+=$-.%/5%45%.5(%=56C"-$4%/5%+?%/8$%=-+6+*"2%
C-5=$..%'$-$%/5%C-5=$$4%"==5-4+*#2@(%/8$%U1./+=$%.@./$6%'5124%=5*/+*1$%/5%+*,$./+#"/$(%C-5.$=1/$(%"*4%
$F"6+*$% +*% =51-/(% '8+=8% '+22% 12/+6"/$2@% -$?$-% /5% -$/-+B1/+,$% U1./+=$(% *"6$2@% U1./+=$% /8"/% +.% 5-+$*/$4%
/5'"-4.%-$/-+B1/+5*%+*%/8$%?5-6%5?%C1*+.8+*#%"*4%+6C-+.5*+*#%/8$%C$-C$/-"/5-%GL2+(%OPWWJ<%
A8$%4$,$25C6$*/% 5?%2"'%+*% ,"-+51.%".C$=/.% +.%,$-@%4$,$25C$4(% $.C$=+"22@%+*% 8"*42+*#%=-+6+*"2%
=".$.(% '8+=8% "-$% $*/$-+*#% "% *$'% $-"(% *"6$2@(% .$$+*#% /8$% 2"'% ".% 1/+2+/@(% =$-/"+*/@(% "*4% U1./+=$<% A8$%
"CC2+="/+5*%5?%2"'%C-+5-+/+_$.%/8$%B$*$?+=+"2%".C$=/.%5?%=-$"/+*#%C1B2+=%5-4$-%"*4%/8$%5BU$=/+,$.% 5?%/8$%2"'%
+/.$2?<%A8+.%2$#"2%=5*=$C/%+.%B$//$-%Z*5'*%".%/8$%=5*=$C/%5?%C-5#-$..+,$%2"'%<%R$=$*/2@(%/8+.%=5*=$C/%8".%
"2.5%B$$*%1.$4 %+*%/8$%=-+6+*"2%".C$=/(%*"6$2@%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=e,%'8+=8%$..$*/+"22@%-$./5-$.^-$./5-$.%/8$%
=5*4+/+5*%5?%/8$%C$-C$/-"/5-%"*4%,+=/+6%/5%/8$+-%5-+#+*"2%=5*4+/+5*%'+/8%.C$=+?+=%C-5,+.+5*.%GV".+B1"*%$/%
"2<(% OPWXa% !i-$_hd5-#$% $/% "2<(% OPOQa% f"21@5(% OPOPJ<% A8$% =5*=$C/% 5?% -$./5-"/+,$% d1./+=$% ".% "*% $??5-/% /5%
-$=5,$-%/8$%./"/$%25..$.%".%"*%"2/$-*"/+,$%/5%=-+6+*"2%$F=+.$%."*=/+5*.%8".%B$#1*%/5%B$%"==56654"/$4%+*%
&"'%K16B$-%]%5?%OPOW%=5*=$-*+*#%V"-65*+_"/+5*%5?%A"F%R$#12"/+5*.(%'8+=8%="*%B$%1.$4%".%"%B".+.%B@%
+*,$./+#"/5-.%+*%-$.52,+*#%=-+6+*"2%$F=+.$%=".$.%B".$4%5*%/8$%C-+*=+C2$D.%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%GL2.1Z"+/%$/%
"2<(%OPOPa%Y"-1.."2"6%$/%"2<(%OPW:a%b1*#"%$/%"2<(%OPOQa%M+*/"(%OPOOJ.%%
3*%"*%$F"6C2$%5?%-$.52,+*#%"*%$F=+.$%=-+6+*"2%"=/%B".$4%5*%/8$%C-+*=+C2$%5?%R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$(%
/8$%+*=+4$*/% B$#"*%'+/8% $*?5-=$6$*/%"=/+,+/+$.% +*%/8$% $F=+.$%.$=/5-% "#"+*./%/8$% 4+./-+B1/+5*%5?% 322$#"2%
International!Journal!of!Asian!Education!(%
3.'"*%V$-1%f+4"-/5
%
IJSSR!!"#$%2853%
A5B"==5%!-541=/.%GHIEJ%+*%/8$%"-$"%1*4$-%/8$%.1C$-,+.+5*%5?%/8$%E+Z"-"*#%E1./56.%"*4%0F=+.$%N??+=$%
GM+6"*1*#Z"2+/(%OPW`J<%L=/+5*%"*4%4$/$--$*=$%'$-$%/"Z$*%"#"+*./%b-%HM(%'85%'".%+*,52,$4%+*%/8$%+22$#"2%
4+./-+B1/+5*%5?%`(:`P%=+#"-$//$.%5?%$F=+."B2$%/5B"==5%C-541=/.(%".%-$=5-4$4%+*%/8$%!-55?%5?%L=/+5*%&$//$-%
GM!HJ%MH!hPWg^IHE<P9PXPO^OPOQ%4"/$4%T$B-1"-@%W](%OPOQ<%
3*% /8$% =5*/$F/% 5?% =".$% -$.521/+5*(% ,+52"/5-.% "-$% #+,$*% "*5/8$-% 5C/+5*% B@% L-/+=2$% gPH% 5?% &"'%
K16B$-%WW%5?%W::X%=5*=$-*+*#%0F=+.$(%'8+=8%'".%2"./%"6$*4$4%B@%&"'%K16B$-%]%5?%OPOW<%>+52"/5-.%="*%
.1B6+/% "% R$S1$./% ?5-% E".$% M$//2$6$*/% +*% /8$% T5-6% 5?% K5/% H$+*#% Y5*$% +*% /8+.% 5C/+5*<% 3*,$./+#"/+5*<%
V5'$,$-(%/8+.%61./%B$%"==56C"*+$4%B@%"*%"46+..+5*%5?%#1+2/(%"%=566+/6$*/%*5/%/5%-$C$"/%/8$%"=/(%"*4%"%
-$"4+*$..%/5%C"@%"%?+*$%+*%/8$%?5-6%5?%"*%L46+*+./-"/+,$%M"*=/+5*%5?%Q%/+6$.%/8$%$F=+.$%,"21$%/8"/%.85124%
B$%C"+4(%*"6$2@%RC<%WQ(:`:(PPP(%h<%
H".$4% 5*% /8$% =5*=$C/(% /8$% '-+/$-% '+22% ./14@% "*4% $F"6+*$% /8$% $F/$*/% /5% '8+=8% /8$% B".+.% 5?%
-$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%+.%"CC2+$4%5-%1.$4%+*%8"*42+*#%$F=+.$%=-+6+*"2%=".$.(%".%4$.=-+B$4%"B5,$%"*4%85'%/8$%
6$=8"*+.6%?5-%-$.52,+*#%$F=+.$%=-+6+*"2%=".$.%+.%B".$4%5*%C-+*=+C2$.%5?%U1./+=$%B@%/"Z+*#%/8$%$F"6C2$%5?%
/8$% =".$% "/% /8$% E+Z"-"*#% E1./56.% "*4% 0F=+.$% N??+=$% "*4% +/.% +6C"=/<% N*% /8$% 5/8$-% 8"*4(% 5/8$-% 2"'%
$*?5-=$6$*/%"#$*=+$.%8",$%+6C2$6$*/$4%/8$%=5*=$C/%5?%R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%GL _+_"8%$/%"2<(%OPOQa%Y"*+$2/(%
OPWgJ<%3/%+.%=5*/"+*$4%+*%-$#12"/+5*.%.1=8%".%/8$%M1C-$6$%E51-/%/8-51#8%+/.%U14+=+"2%B54+$.(%/8$%!52+=$%
"*4% /8$% L//5-*$@% [$*$-"2e.% N??+=$<% 0,$*% /8$% C-5,+.+5*.% 5?% &"'% K16B$-% WW% 5?% OPWO% =5*=$-*+*#% /8$%
d1,$*+2$%E-+6+*"2%d1./+=$%M@./$6%=2$"-2@%./"/$%/8$ %"CC2+="/+5*%5?%/8$%=5*=$C/%5?%R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%GLC-+2%
$/%"2<(%OPOQJ<%H".+=%R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%+.%5*$%6$/854%5?%2$#"2%.$//2$6$*/%=5*.+4$-$4%"4$S1"/$%B@%.$,$-"2%
#-51C.<% A81.(%/8+.%-$.$"-=8%1.$.%/8$%/+/2$7%cd14 +=+"2%L*"2@.+.%5?%M$//2$6$*/%5?%0F=+.$%E-+6+*"2%E".$.%H".$4%
5*%!-+*=+C2$.%R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%GM/14@%"/%E+Z"-"*#%E1./56.%N??+=$J<j%
%
METHODS)
A8+.%-$.$"-=8%1.$.%*5-6"/+,$%U1-+4+="2%2$#"2%-$.$"-=8%6$/854.%G2$#"2%"*"2@.+.J%B$="1.$%/8$%?5=1.%
+.% 5*%./"/1/5-@% -$#12"/+5*.%".% /8$% 5BU$=/%5?%./14@<% f+/8+*%/8$%?-"6$'5-Z% 5?%/8+.% -$.$"-=8(% *5-6"/+,$%
U1-+4+="2%2$#"2%6$/854.%"-$%1.$4%/5%./14@%/8$%"CC2+="/+5*%5?%-12$.%5-%*5-6.%+*%C5.+/+,$%2"'(%6 "+*2@%?5-6"2%
2$#"2%"1/85-+/+$.%.1=8%".% 2"'.(%-$#12"/+5*.%"*4%2+/$-"/1-$% /8"/%=5*/"+*%/8$5-$/+="2%=5*=$C/.%'8+=8%"-$%
/8$*% =5**$=/$4% /5% C-5B2$6.<% LCC2+="/+5*% 5?% /8$% C-+*=+C2$.% 5?% R$./5-"/+,$% d1./+=$% +*% 8"*42+*#% "*4%
-$.52,+*#%=-+6+*"2%$F=+.$%=".$.<%L.%"%45=16$*/%./14@(%/8+.%-$.$"-=8%1/+2+_$.%2$#"2%.51-=$%6"/$-+"2.%.1=8%
".%2$#+.2"/+5*(%=51-/%4$=+.+5*.%5-%4$=-$$.(%"#-$$6$*/.(%2$#"2%/8$5-+$.(%"*4%45=/-+*$.%5-%5C+*+5*.%5?%2$#"2%
$FC$-/.<% A8$% *5-6"/+,$% 2$#"2% ./14@% "+6.% /5% C-5,+4$% U1-+4+="2% "-#16$*/.% '8$*% /8$-$% +.% "6B+#1+/@(%
$6C/+*$..(%"*4% =5*?2+=/%+*% "%*5-6<%LC"-/% ?-56%*5-6"/+,$%6$/854.(% /8+.%-$.$"-=8% "2.5%1/+2+_$.%2+6+/$4%
$6C+-+="2% U1-+4+="2% 2$#"2% -$.$"-=8% 6$/854.(% 1.+*#% C-+6"-@% 4"/"% 5B/"+*$4% +*% /8$% ?+$24% /5% "*"2@_$% /8$%
8"*42+*#% "*4% -$.521/+5*% 5?% =-+6+*"2% $F=+.$% =".$.% "/% /8$% E+Z"-"*#% E1./56.% "*4% 0F=+.$% M$-,+=$% "*4%
3*/$-6$4+"/$%A@C$%M1C$-,+.+5*%N??+=$(%+*%"44+/+5*%/5%C-+6"-@%2$#"2%6"/$-+"2.(%.$=5*4"-@(%"*4%/$-/+"-@<%
%
RESULTS)
Analysis!of!the!Settlement!of!Tax!Criminal!Matters!with!Basics!Restorative!Justice%
LCC2+="/+5*%R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%3*%-$.52,+*#%$F=+.$%=-+6+*"2%=".$.(%+/%8".%B$$*%"==56654"/$4%+*%
&"'% 5?% /8$% R$C1B2+=% 5?% 3*45*$.+"% K16B$-% ]% 5?% OPOW% =5*=$-*+*#% V"-65*+_"/+5*% 5?% A"F% R$#12"/+5*.<%
V5'$,$-(%*5%/$=8*+="2%#1+4"*=$%-$#12"/+5*.%$F+./%?5-%+/.%+6C2$6$*/"/+5*%"/%/8$%!!%5-%!bI%2$,$2<%)*/+2%
*5'(%+*%3*45*$.+"(%/8$-$%"-$%.C$=+"2%-12$.%#5,$-*+*#%/8$%C$-?5-6"*=$%5?%d1./+=$<%3*%#$*$-"2(%/8$%-$.521/+5*%
5?% =-+6+*"2% =".$.% 45$.% *5/% @$/% $F+./^8",$% B$$*% $./"B2+.8$4(% "2/851#8% /8$-$% "-$% #1+4$2+*$.^C5.+/+5*.<%
d1./+=$%A8+.%8".%B$$*%-$#12"/$4%$FC-$..2@%"*4%+*%4$/"+2%+*%.$,$-"2%2$#"2%-$#12"/+5*.<%&$#"2%-12$.%-$#"-4+*#%
+6C2$6$*/"/+5*R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%"-$7%
1. Decree! of! the! Director! General! of! the! General! Judicial! Body! of! the! Supreme! Court! of! the!
Republic! of! Indonesia! Number! 1691/DJU/SK/PS.00/12/2020! concerning! Implementation!
GuidelinesRestorative!Justice!in!the!General!Court!Environment!
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% 8//C.7^^+U..-<-+4'"*+*./+/1/$<=5<+4^%
IJSSR!!"#$%2854%
E56C2$/$% C-5,+.+5*.% -$2"/$4% /5% /8$.$% -12$.% "-$% $FC2"+*$4% +*% /8$% "//"=86$*/% /5% /8$%
+6C2$6$*/"/+5*%#1+4$2+*$.%?5-%d1./+=$%+*%/8$%#$*$-"2%U1./+=$%$*,+-5*6$*/<%A8$%C1-C5.$%5?%./+C12"/+*#%
/8$.$%/$=8*+="2%+*./-1=/+5*.%+.%/5%$*=51-"#$%5C/+6+_"/+5*%5?%/8$%+6C2$6$*/"/+5*%5?%M1C-$6$%E51-/%
R$#12"/+5*.(%M1C-$6$%E51-/%E+-=12"-.%"*4%Y$=-$$.%5?%/8$%E8+$?%d1./+=$%5?%/8$%M1C-$6$%E51-/(%'8+=8%
-$#12"/$.% /8$% C$-?5-6"*=$% 5?% d1./+=$% /5% -$?5-6% /8$% =-+6+*"2% U1./+=$% .@./$6(% '8+=8% ./+22% ="--+$.% "%
C-+.5*%.$*/$*=$<%
A8$%4$,$25C6$*/%5?%/8$%=-+6+*"2%.@./$6%*5%25*#$-%-$2+$.%5*%/8$%C$-C$/-"/5-<%M/+22(%+/%8".%2$4%
/5%/8$%"2+#*6$*/%5?%/8$%+*/$-$./.%5?%/8$%,+=/+6e.%-$=5,$-@%"*4%/8$%"==51*/"B+2+/@%5?%/8$%C$-C$/-"/5-%
5?%/8$%=-+6$<%A8+.%#1+4$2+*$%"CC2+$.%"*4%61./%B$%?5225'$4%B@%"22%4+./-+=/%=51-/.%+*%3*45*$.+"<%A8+.%
#1+4$2+*$%+.%1.$4%+*%-$.52,+*#%=".$.%/8-51#8%R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%+*%6+*5-%=-+6$.(%=".$.%5?%=8+24-$*%
+*%=5*?2+=/%'+/8%/8$%2"'%G4+??$-$*/J(%=".$.%5?%'56$*%+*%=5*?2+=/%'+/8%/8$%2"'%G456$./+=%,+52$*=$J%"*4%
*"-=5/+=.%=".$.%"*4%/8$%#1+4$2+*$.%$FC2"+*%+*%4$/"+2%/8$%2$#"2%B".+.%"*4%85'%/5%"CC2@%+/<%A8$%#$*$-"2%
=5*4+/+5*.% ?5-% =-+6+*"2% =".$.% /8"/% ="*% B$% -$.52,$4% 1.+*#% -$./5-"/+,$% U1./+=$% "/% /8$% ./"#$% 5?% /8$%
$F"6+*"/+5*%C-5=$..%+*%=51-/%"-$%6+*5-%=-+6+*"2%=".$.%'+/8%=-+6+*"2%/8-$"/.%".%-$#12"/$4%+*%"-/+=2$.%
Q`g(% Q]Q(% Q]:(% Q9g(% gP]% "*4% L-/+=2$% g9O% 5?%/8$% E-+6+*"2% E54$% '+/8% "% 25..% 5?% *5% 65-$% /8"*% 3YR<%
O(XPP(PPP(% h<% 3*% "44+/+5*(% "==5-4+*#% /5% /8+.% C-5,+.+5*(% -$=+4+,+./.% "-$% $F=214$4% ?-56% -$./5-"/+,$%
U1./+=$<%
2. Republic! of! Indonesia! Prosecutor's! Office! Regulation! Number! 15! of! 2020! concerning!
Termination!of!Prosecution!Based!on!Restorative!Justice!
A8+.% -$#12"/+5*% $FC2"+*.% /8"/% -$.52,+*#% =-+6+*"2% =".$.% B@% C-+5-+/+_+*#% R$./5-"/+,$% d1./+=$(%
'8+=8% $6C8".+_$.% -$./5-"/+5*% /5% +/.%5-+#+*"2% ./"/$% "*4% B"2"*=+*#% /8$% C-5/$=/+5*% "*4% +*/$-$./.% 5?%
,+=/+6.%"*4%C$-C$/-"/5-.%5?%=-+6+*"2%"=/.%/8"/%"-$%*5/%5-+$*/$4%/5'"-4.%-$/-+B1/+5*(%+.%"%2$#"2%*$$4%
?5-% .5=+$/@% "*4% "% 6$=8"*+.6% /8"/% 61./% B$% B1+2/% +*% /8$% $F$-=+.$% 5?% C-5.$=1/5-+"2% "1/85-+/@<% L*4%
-$?5-6%5?%/8$%=-+6+*"2%U1./+=$%.@./$6<%
3. Republic! of! Indonesia! State! Police! Regulation! Number! 8! of! 2021! concerning! Handling! of!
Criminal!Acts!Based!on!Restorative!Justice!
!$-C52%5*%8"*42+*#%=-+6+*"2%"=/.%'+/8%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%+.%"%C52+=$%./$C%/5%"44-$..%=-+6+*"2%
"=/.% B@% ?5=1.+*#% 5*% B$*$?+=+"2% U1./+=$(% U1./+=$(% "*4% /8$% +*/$-$./.% 5?% ,+=/+6.% "*4% C$-C$/-"/5-.% 5?%
,+52"/+5*.% /8"/% 45% *5/% ?5=1.% 5*% C1*+.86$*/<% A8$% "CC2+="/+5*% 5?% -$./5-"/+,$% U1./+=$% +*% -$.52,+*#%
=-+6+*"2%=".$.%+.%$FC2"+*$4%"B51/%/8$%-12$.%?5-%"CC2@+*#%/8$%C-+*=+C2$.<%d1./+=$%="*%B$%1.$4%+*%/8$%
+*,$./+#"/+5*%6$/854%"*4%+*,$./+#"/+5*% 5?%=-+6+*"2%"=/.%B@% K"/+5*"2%!52+=$%3*,$./+#"/5-.%G.C$=+"2%
=5*4+/+5*.J(%'8+=8%"-$%="--+$4%51/%+?%/8$@%6$$/%/8$%6"/$-+"2%"*4%?5-6"2%-$S1+-$6$*/.<%
R$.$"-=8$-.%"2.5%"..$..%/8"/%/8$%$??5-/.%5?%+*,$./+#"/5-.%".%?"=+2+/"/5-.%5?%,+=/+6.%G./"/$J%'+/8%
C$-C$/-"/5-.%=5*/+*1$%/5%6"Z$%6"F+616%$??5-/.%/5%"CC2@%/8$%C-+*=+C2$.%5?%R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$<%A8+.%
+*=214$.% 4+"25#1$^6$4+"/+5*% '+/8% /8$% C$-C$/-"/5-.% "*4% C-5,+4+*#% $"-2@% $41="/+5*% /5% /8$%
=5661*+/@% -$#"-4+*#% -12$.^."*=/+5*.% ?5-% $F=+.$% ,+52"/+5*.% ".% "% C-$,$*/+,$% 6$".1-$% ?5-% /8$%
=5661*+/@% *5/% /5% =566+/% /8$.$% ,+52"/+5*.% G'8+=8% ="*% ="1.$% C5/$*/+"2% 25..$.% /5% /8$% ./"/$J<% K5/%
*$=$.."-+2@%+66$4+"/$2@%?"=+*#%=-+6+*"2%C-5=$$4+*#.(%5?%=51-.$<%A8+.%+.%"%#554%65,$(%=5*.+4$-+*#%
/8$%6$/854%5?%R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$<%A8+.%$??$=/+,$2@%$6C8".+_$.%/8$%.$*.$%5?%U1./+=$%?5-%,+=/+6.%G./"/$J%
"*4%C$-C$/-"/5-.%"*4%.5=+$/@%+*%#$*$-"2%.5%/8"/%+/%="*%B$%?12?+22$4<%
A81.(%"==5-4+*#%/5%/8$%"1/85-.%5?%/8$%654$2%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%="--+$4%51/%B@%E+Z"-"*#%E1./56.%
"*4% 0F=+.$% N??+=$% 3*,$./+#"/5-.% /5% -$.52,$% $F=+.$% =-+6+*"2% =".$.% B@% -$?$--+*#% /5% L-/+=2$% gPH% 5?% &"'%
K16B$-%]%5?%OPOW%=5*=$-*+*#%V"-65*+_"/+5*%5?%A"F%R$#12"/+5*.%+.%"CC-5C-+"/$%B$="1.$%/8$%.$//2$6$*/%
6$=8"*+.6%/8-51#8%"46+*+./-"/+,$%."*=/+5*.%+*%/8$%?5-6%5?%?+*$.%+.%"2.5%4$$6$4%/5%B$%B@%/8$%$..$*=$%
=5*/"+*$4%+*%!"*=".+2"%G'8+=8%+.%/8$%2$#"2%+4$"2%5?%/8$%3*45*$.+"*%*"/+5*%"*4%./"/$J(%*"6$2@% 4$2+B$-"/+5*%
?5-%=5*.$*.1.%5-%Z+*.8+C%"*4%"==5-4"*=$%'+/8%/8$%=8"-"=/$-+./+=.%5?%3*45*$.+"*%*"/+5*"2%2"'(%*"6$2@%/8$%
+*=21.+5*%5?%/8$%C-+*=+C2$%5?%Z+*.8+C<%
f8$*%$F"6+*$4%?-56%"%C8+25.5C8+="2%C$-.C$=/+,$(%/8$%$F+./$*=$%5?%"46+*+./-"/+,$%."*=/+5*.%+*%
/8$%?5-6%5?%?+*$.%=5*/"+*.%/8$%C-+*=+C2$%5?%+6C2$6$*/+*#%"%c'+*h'+*c%.521/+5*%G'+*h'+*J%"*4%*5/%$*4+*#%
International!Journal!of!Asian!Education!(%
3.'"*%V$-1%f+4"-/5
%
IJSSR!!"#$%2855%
1C%+*%"%k25.$h25.$j%.+/1"/+5*%G25./h25./J%5-j%'+*h25.$j%G'+*h25./J%".%4$.+-$4%B@%/8$%U14+=+"-@%B@%"=8+$,+*#%
?5-6"2%U1./+=$%/8-51#8%/8$%2+/+#"/+5*%C-5=$..%G2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%C-5=$..J<%0F"6+*$4%?-56%"%.5=+525#+="2%
C$-.C$=/+,$(%/8+.%".C$=/%+.%5-+$*/$4%/5'"-4.%/8$%=12/1-"2%-55/.%5?%3*45*$.+"*%.5=+$/@(%'8+=8%+.%5-+$*/$4%
/5'"-4.%?"6+2@%=12/1-"2%,"21$.(%C-+5-+/+_+*#%/8$%C-+*=+C2$%5?%4$2+B$-"/+5*^=5*.$*.1.%/5%-$.52,$%4+.C1/$.%
+*%"%.5=+"2%.@./$6<%
E1./56.% "*4% 0F=+.$% !!KM% +*,$./+#"/5-.% "2.5% 8",$% /8$% "1/85-+/@% /5% 5??$-% C"-/+$.% +*%
4+.C1/$^=5*?2+=/%/5%-$.52,$%/8$+-%=".$.%C$"=$?122@^"6+="B2@%/8-51#8%/8$%C-+*=+C2$%5?%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$<%
A8+.%+.%B".$4%5*%/8$%-52$%5?%+*,$./+#"/5-.%+*%$F$-=+.+*#% 4+.=-$/+5*%B".$4%5*%/8$%C-+*=+C2$.%5?%=-+6+*"2%2"'(%
*"6$2@%/8$%C-+*=+C2$%5?%C-5C5-/+5*"2+/@%"*4%/8$%C-+*=+C2$%5?%.1B.+4+"-+/@(%*"6$2@%/8$%"1/85-+/@%/8$@%8",$%
/5%="--@%51/%=".$%.$2$=/+5*(%'8+=8%'+22%=5*/+*1$%"/%/8$%?5225'+*#%./"#$.%+*%/8$%=-+6+*"2%U1./+=$%.@./$6<%A8$%
C5'$-%/5%.$2$=/%=-+6+*"2%=".$.%B".$4%5*%/8$%C-+*=+C2$%5?%C-5C5-/+5*"2+/@%-$S1+-$.%/8"/%+*,$./+#"/5-.%"-$%
*5/%C$-6+//$4%/5%1.$%8"-.8%6$".1-$.%+?%2+#8/$-%./$C.%"-$%.1??+=+$*/%/5%-$.52,$%/8$%C-5B2$6<%b$"*'8+2$(%
/8$%?5=1.%5?%.1B.+4+"-+/@%+.%2+*Z$4%/5%=-+6+*"2%."*=/+5*.%B@%",5+4+*#%8$",+$-%."*=/+5*.%+?%.5?/$-%."*=/+5*.%
"-$%"4$S1"/$%".%"%-$.C5*.$%/5%"%=-+6+*"2%"=/<%
M14"-/5%4$,$25C$4%/8$%C-+*=+C2$.%5?%C-5C5-/+5*"2+/@%"*4%.1B.+4+"-+/@%B@%C"@+*#%"//$*/+5*%/5%/8$%
?5225'+*#%/8+*#. 7%GWJ%/8$%S1"2+/@%5?%=".$.(%*"6$2@%=".$.%/8"/%8",$%2+//2$%.1B./"*=$(%6$"*+*#%=".$.%/8"/%"-$%
="/$#5-+_$4%".%*5/%=5*/"+*+*#%.1Bh.5=+"2%$2$6$*/.a%GOJ%E5*.+4$-"/+5*%5?%/8$%$??+=+$*=@%"*4%$??$=/+,$*$..%
5?%/8$%+*,$./+#"/5-e.%41/+$.(%=56C"-$4%/5%'8$/8$-%/8$%=".$.%"-$%=5*/+*1$4%/5%/8$%C-5.$=1/5-e.%5??+=$%"*4%
'8+=8%'+22%$*4%1C%+*%=51-/a%GQJ%/+6$%?"=/5-%G=".8%U1./+=$J%/8$%-$.521/+5*%5?%.56$%+..1$.%"*4%+*%=$-/"+*%
=+-=16./"*=$.(%'8+=8%'+22%B$%?$2/%"*4%8",$%"%B$//$-%$??$=/%?5-%/8$%C"-/+$.<%
L==5-4+*#% /5% /8$% "1/85-(% -$./5-"/+,$% U1./+=$% 6$=8"*+.6.% ="*% B$% +6C2$6$*/$4% +?% /8$@% ?12?+22%
.$,$-"2%B".+=%-$S1+-$6$*/.%?5-%.52+4%2$#"2%=5*.+4$-"/+5*.<%T+-./(%/8$%.1.C$=/%61./%B$%"%*$'%=-+6+*"2(%"%
?+-./h/+6$%5??$*4$-(%5-%*5/%"%-$C$"/%=-+6+*"2%G-$=+4+,+./J<% M$=5*4(%/8$%.1.C$=/%+.%$FC$=/$4%/5%"46+/%/5%8+.%
=-+6$<%A8+-4(%/8$%.1.C$=/%61./%.85'%-$65-.$%"*4%C-56+.$%*5/%/5%-$C$"/%8+.%"=/+5*.<%T51-/8(%/8$%.1.C$=/e.%
65/+,$%?5-%=566+//+*#%=-+6+*"2%"=/.%'".%/5%?12?+22%4"+2@%*$$4.%'+/8%+*.+#*+?+="*/%./"/$%25..$.<%T+?/8(%/8$%
.1.C$=/%61./%.1B6+/% "%-$S1$./%?5-% =".$%-$.521/+5*%+*% /8$%?5-6%5?%*5%+*,$./+#"/+5*%/5% /8$%V$"4%5?%/8$%
E+Z"-"*#%E1./56.%"*4%0F=+.$%N??+=$<%T+*"22@(%/8$%.1.C$=/%61./%C"@%"46+*+./-"/+,$%."*=/+5*.%".%"%?+*$%5?%
Q% G/8-$$J% /+6$.% /8$% $F=+.$% ,"21$% /8"/% .85124% 8",$% B$$*% C"+4<% H@% ?12?+22+*#% /8$.$% =-+/$-+"(% /8$% "1/85-%
B$2+$,$.%+6C2$6$*/+*#%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%6$=8"*+.6.%="*%B$%"*%"CC-5C-+"/$%"2/$-*"/+,$%?5-%8"*42+*#%
.C$=+?+=%=".$.<%
A8$%"1/85-%'5124%2+Z$%/5%$*=51-"#$%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%+*%-$.52,+*#%=-+6+*"2%$F=+.$%=".$.%"/%/8$%
E+Z"-"*#% E1./56.% "*4% 0F=+.$% N??+=$<% L.% ?5-% cC1.8+*#c% -$./5-"/+,$% U1./+=$(% A8+.% +.% B".$4% 5*% /8$%
=5*.+4$-"/+5*% /8"/%$F=+.$% =-+6$.% "-$%$=5*56+=% =-+6$.% /8"/%4"6"#$% /8$% ./"/$e.%?+*"*=+"2% .@./$6(%.5% +/%
'5124%B$% 65-$%5C/+6"2% +?%/8$% .521/+5*%'$-$% /5%-$=5,$-%./"/$% ?+*"*=+"2% 25..$.<%M5% /8"/%/8$% C"@6$*/%5?%
.$,$-"2% "46+*+./-"/+,$% ."*=/+5*.% +*% /8$% ?5-6% 5?% ?+*$.% B$=56$.% *$=$.."-@(% +/% +.% *5% 25*#$-% "% ?5-6% 5?%
C1*+.86$*/%/8"/%+/.%+6C2$6$*/"/+5*%="*%-$C2"=$<%
T1-/8$-65-$(% /8$%"1/85-% "2.5% $6C8".+_$.% /8$% $??$=/+,$*$..%5?% -$.52,+*#%$F=+.$% =-+6+*"2%=".$.%
B".$4%5*%C-+*=+C2$.%5?%U1./+=$%"/%/8$%E+Z"-"*#%E1./56.%"*4%0F=+.$%N??+=$(%'8+=8%+.%"%*$'%2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%
.@./$6% '85.$% +6C2$6$*/"/+5*% ="**5/% B$% .$C"-"/$4% ?-56% ?"=/5-.% /8"/% +*?21$*=$% "*4% B$=56$% "%
B$*=86"-Z%?5-%/8$%$??$=/+,$*$..%5?%/8$%C$-?5-6"*=$%5?%2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%$??5-/.<%L==5-4+*#%/5%M5$-U5*5!
M5$Z"*/5(% X% G?+,$J% ?"=/5-.% +*?21$*=$% 2"'% $*?5-=$6$*/7% /8$% 2$#"2% ?"=/5-.% /8$6.$2,$.(% 2"'% $*?5-=$6$*/%
?"=/5-.(%?"=+2+/+$.%"*4%+*?-"./-1=/1-$%?"=/5-.(%=5661*+/@%?"=/5-.(%"*4%=12/1-"2%?"=/5-.<%A8$%?5225'+*#%"-$%
/8$%-$"2+/+$.%5?%?"=/5-.%/8"/%+*?21$*=$%2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/(%+*=214+*#%/8$%?5225'+*#7%
W< N'*%&$#"2%T"=/5-.%
A8$%E+Z"-"*#%E1./56.%"*4%0F=+.$%N??+=$%8"*42$.%=-+6+*"2%$F=+.$%=".$.%B".$4%5*%C-+*=+C2$.%
5?%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%"*4%8".%+6C2$6$*/$4%+/%B@%&"'%K16B$-%]%5?%OPOW%=5*=$-*+*#%V"-65*+_"/+5*%
5?%A"F%R$#12"/+5*.<%V5'$,$-(%+*%+/.%+6C2$6$*/"/+5*(%/8$-$%"-$%5B./"=2$.%+*%/8$%?5-6%5?%/8$%"B.$*=$%
5?% -$#12"/+5*.% #5,$-*+*#% /8$% C-5=$..% 5?% 4$/$-6+*+*#^C-+6"-@% =5*.+4$-"/+5*.% '8+=8% -$S1+-$%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% 8//C.7^^+U..-<-+4'"*+*./+/1/$<=5<+4^%
IJSSR!!"#$%2856%
+*,$./+#"/5-.% /5% "CC2@^*5/% "CC2@% /8$% C-+*=+C2$.% 5?% U1./+=$% +*% "*% $F=+.$% =-+6+*"2% =".$% "*4% -$2"/$4%
#1+4$2+*$.^+*./-1=/+5*.%?5-%+/.%+6C2$6$*/"/+5*(%.5%/8"/%+/%="*%=-$"/$%,"-+51.%+*/$-C-$/"/+5*.%.$$*%
?-56%/8$%2$#"2%?"=/5-.%/8$6.$2,$.(%/8+.%45$.%*5/%8",$%=2"-+/@%-$#"-4+*#%2$#"2!certainty<%A8+.%2"=Z%5?%
=2"-+/@%-$#"-4+*#%/8$%=-+/$-+"^-$S1+-$6$*/.%?5-%"%=-+6+*"2%$F=+.$%=".$%="*%B$%"CC2+$4%/5%C-+*=+C2$%
-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$(%'8+=8(%"==5-4+*#%/5%/8$%+*,$./+#"/5-e.%=5*.+4$-"/+5*(%'+/8%/8$%"CC-5,"2%5?%/8$%
V$"4%5?%/8$%E+Z"-"*#%E1./56.%"*4%0F=+.$%N??+=$(%6"@%*5/%=5*/+*1$^=5*41=/%/8$%+*,$./+#"/+5*%B".$4%
5*%/8$%C-+*=+C2$%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$<%L==5-4+*#%/5%b-<%Y54+%!-+B"4+(%/8$%"B.$*=$%5?%-$#12"/+5*.%+*%/8$%
?5-6%5?%+6C2$6$*/"/+5*%+*./-1=/+5*.%=5124%2$"4%/5%612/+C2$%+*/$-C-$/"/+5*.(%#+,+*#%-+.$%/5%451B/.%?5-%
+*,$./+#"/5-.%+*%/8$%"CC2+="/+5*%5?%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%/5%=-+6+*"2%"=/.(%$.C$=+"22@%/5%$F=+.$%=-+6$.<%M5(%
+6C2$6$*/"/+5*%6"@%5*2@%B$%2+6+/$4%/5%"48$-+*#%/5%/8$%=5*4+/+5*.%-$#12"/$4%+*%L-/+=2$%gPH%5?%&"'%
K16B$-%]%5?%OPOW%"*4%/8$%=5*.=+$*=$%5?%"*%+*,$./+#"/5-<%
O< &"'%0*?5-=$6$*/%T"=/5-.%
&"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%5??+=+"2.%"-$%#-51C.%'85.$%-52$%+.%/5%+6C2$6$*/%/8$%2"'%+/.$2?(%+*=214+*#%
2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%"*4%C$"=$%6"+*/$*"*=$<%N*$%5?%/8$%Z$@.%/5%.1==$..?12%2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%+.%/8"/%/8$%
6$*/"2+/@%5-%C$-.5*"2+/@%5?%2"'%$*?5-=$-.%C2"@.%"*%$..$*/+"2%-52$%+*%$*.1-+*#%/8"/%2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%
+*%.5=+$/@%="*%-1*%5C/+6"22@<%A8$-$?5-$(%/8$%.1==$..%5-%?"+21-$%5?%+6C2$6$*/+*#%2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%+.%
#-$"/2@%+*?21$*=$4%B@%/8$%S 1"2+/@%5?%2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%+*%+6C2$6$*/+*#%$F+./+*#%C-5,+.+5*.%/5%-$"2+_$%
.1B./"*/+"2% U1./+=$% B@% =5*.+4$-+*#% /8$% *5-6.% /8"/% "CC2@% +*% .5=+$/@<% !!KM% E1./56.% "*4% 0F=+.$%
+*,$./+#"/5-.%'85%"=/%".%+*,$./+#"/5-.%"/%/8$%E+Z"-"*#%E1./56.%"*4%0F=+.$%N??+=$%+*%+6C2$6$*/+*#%
/8$%C-+*=+C2$.%5?%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%8",$%4$65*./-"/$4%"*%"//+/14$%5?%65-"2%+*/$#-+/@%'+/8%$F=$22$*/%
C$-.5*"2+/@% "*4% 2"'% $*?5-=$6$*/% 6$*/"2+/@% +*% 8"*42+*#% $F=+.$% =-+6+*"2% =".$.% 1.+*#% "% B$*$?+=+"2%
U1./+=$% "CC-5"=8<% A8+.% ="*% B$% .$$*% ?-56% /8$% Z*5'2$4#$% "*4% 1*4$-./"*4+*#% 5?% +*,$./+#"/5-.%
-$#"-4+*#%/8$%=5*=$C/%5?%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%.5%/8"/%/8$@%="*%C2"@%"*%"=/+,$%-52$%+*%.$$Z+*#%/5%-$.52,$%
=".$.%/8-51#8%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%B".$4%5*%8",+*#%?122%"1/85-+/@%+*%=5*.+4$-+*#%$F=+.$%=-+6+*"2%=".$.%
B@%/"Z+*#%/8$%+*+/+"/+,$%+*%C-5C5.+*#%"*4%5??$-+*#%/8$%C$-C$/-"/5-.%"2/$-*"/+,$%.521/+5*.%/5%$F=+.$%
=-+6+*"2%=".$.<%
Q< T"=+2+/+$.%"*4%3*?-"./-1=/1-$%T"=/5-.%
[554%2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%?"=/5-.%61./%B$%B"2"*=$4%'+/8%"4$S1"/$%?"=+2+/+$.%"*4%+*?-"./-1=/1-$%
.5%/8"/%2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%="*%B$%"=8+$,$4%'$22%"*4%6"F+6"22@%B$="1.$(%'+/8%/8$.$%.1CC5-/+*#%?"=/5-.(%
2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%$??5-/.%'+22%B$%65-$%$F/$*.+,$%"*4%$??$=/+,$<%T"=+2+/+$.%5-%+*?-"./-1=/1-$%?5-%2"'%
$*?5-=$6$*/% "/% /8$% E+Z"-"*#% E1./56.% "*4% 0F=+.$% N??+=$% /8"/% .1CC5-/% /8$% +6C2$6$*/"/+5*% 5?%
-$./5-"/+,$% U1./+=$%B@%=5*41=/+*#%$F"6+*"/+5*.%"*4%4+"25#1$%'+/8%C$-C$/-"/5-.%+*%"%C"-/+=12"-%-556%
"/%/8$%E+Z"-"*#%E1./56.%"*4%0F=+.$%N??+=$(%'8+=8%+.%1.$4%?5-%"2/$-*"/+,$%6$4+"/+5*%C-5=$..$.%?5-%
-$.52,+*#%$F=+.$%=-+6+*"2%=".$.(%.5%/8"/%/8$@%="*%.1CC5-/%/8$%C-5=$..<%R$.521/+5*%5?%$F=+.$%=".$.%"*4%
.$,$-"2% +*,$./+#"/5-.% '+/8% /8$% .Z+22.% "*4% "B+2+/+$.% /5% +6C2$6$*/% -$./5-"/+,$% U1./+=$% B".$4% 5*%
Z*5'2$4#$%5B/"+*$4%?-56%.5=+"2+_"/+5*%"*4%!OI!%-$#"-4+*#%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$<%%
g< E5661*+/@%T"=/5-.%
M5=+$/@%+.%/8$%$*,+-5*6$*/%'8$-$%/8$%2"'%"CC2+$.%"*4%+.%"CC2+$4<%A8$%C1B2+=%61./%"2'"@.%B$%
"'"-$%5?%/8$%2+6+/.%5 ?%/8$+-%-+#8/.%"*4%5B2+#"/+5*.%"*4%Z*5'%/8$%2$#"2%./$C.%/5%C-5/$=/%/8$+-%+*/$-$./.<%
A8$%=5661*+/@% +*%S1$./+5*%+*=214$.%C$-C$/-"/5-.%5?% $F=+.$%=-+6$.%"*4%/8$+-%?"6+2+$.<% 36C5-/"*/%
?"=/5-.%/8"/%="*%.1CC5-/%/8$%.1==$..?12%+6C2$6$*/"/+5*%5?%=".$%-$.521/+5*%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%"/%/8$%
E+Z"-"*#%E1./56.%"*4% 0F=+.$%N??+=$(% *"6$2@%/8$%'+22+*#*$..^-$.C5*.+B+2+/@% 5?%/8$%C$-C$/-"/5-%/5%
=56C$*."/$% /8$%,+=/+6%G/8$%M/"/$J%?5-%25..$.%/5%-$./5-$%/8$%.+/1"/+5*%/5%'8"/%+/%'".%B$?5-$%/8$%$F=+.$%
=-+6$%5==1--$4<%!-5,$*%B@%"=8+$,+*#%"%C$"=$%"#-$$6$*/%B$/'$$*%/8$%C$-C$/-"/5-%"*4%/8$%,+=/+6%
G/8$% M/"/$J(% /8$% C$-C$/-"/5-% .1B6+//$4% "% 2$//$-% -$S1$./+*#% "% .$//2$6$*/% 5?% /8$% =".$% '+/851/% "*%
+*,$./+#"/+5*%B$+*#%="--+$4%51/%".%/8$%C-+6"-@%=5*4+/+5*%?5-%/8$%$F=+.$%=-+6+*"2%=".$%/5%B$%-$.52,$4%
"6+="B2@<%R$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$<%%!1B2+=%"'"-$*$..%5?%/8$%2"'%+.%#$*$-"22@%8+#8(%-$.12/+*#%+*%/8$%C1B2+=%
=56C2@+*#% '+/8% ./"/1/5-@% C-5,+.+5*.<% A8$-$?5-$(% 1*4$-./"*4+*#% "*4% 2$#"2% =56C2+"*=$% '+/8% /8$%
International!Journal!of!Asian!Education!(%
3.'"*%V$-1%f+4"-/5
%
IJSSR!!"#$%2857%
+*,52,$6$*/%5?%2+/+#"*/.% '85%8",$%"*% 5C$*%6+*4%/5'"-4%2$#"2% -$?5-6%="*%=-$"/$%"% /-1$%.$*.$%5?%
U1./+=$<%
X< E12/1-"2%T"=/5-.%
3*%+6C2$6$*/+*#%/8$%.$//2$6$*/%5?%/"F%=-+6+*"2%=".$.%B".$4%5*%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$(%.5=+$/@%
51/.+4$%/8$%2+/+#"*/.%-$?2$=/.%=12/1-"2%,"21$.%'+/8%"%8+#8%=5*/-+B1/+5*<%A8$%C$5C2$%5?%H$Z".+%R$#$*=@%
"2'"@.%.1CC5-/%/8$%-$.521/+5*%5?%=-+6+*"2%$F=+.$%=".$.%/8-51#8%?"6+2@%=8"**$2.%'+/8%4$2+B$-"/+5*%
"*4%=5*.$ *.1.%/8"/%-1*.%'$22%"*4%'+/851/%5B./"=2$.<%L==5-4+*#%/5%b-<%Y54+%!-+B"4+(% /8+.%="*%B$%.$$*%
?-56%/8$%=5661*+/@D.%C5.+/+,$%-$.C5*.$%+*%$,$-@%.5=+"2+_"/+5*%"*4%=51*.$22+*#%"=/+,+/@%-$2"/$4%/5%
$F=+.$% C-5,+.+5*.% ="--+$4% 51/% B@% /8$% E1./56.% "*4% 0F=+.$% N??+=$<% E+Z"-"*#% 0F=+.$% B@% C-5,+4+*#%
C5.+/+,$%.1##$./+5*.%-$#"-4+*#%"CC2@+*#%/8$%C-+*=+C2$.%5?%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$<%A8+.%+.%-$2"/$4%/5%/8$%
,"21$%5?%5-4$-%"*4%C$"=$%+*%.5=+$/@<%A8$%5==1--$*=$%5?%$F=+.$%=-+6$.%8".%"%4+-$=/%5-%+*4+-$=/%*$#"/+,$%
+6C"=/%5*%C1B2+=%C$"=$%"*4%5-4$-<%A8$-$?5-$(%/8$%#$*$-"2%*$$4.%/5%B$%'+22+*#2@%+* ,52,$4%+*%$??5-/.%/5%
-$.52,$%=-+6+*"2%$F=+.$%=".$.%B".$4%5*%C-+*=+C2$.%5?% -$./5-"/+,$% U1./+=$% ".%"%C"-/@%'85%"2.5%*$$4.%/5%
B$%-$./5-$4%?5-%/8$%=5*.$S1$*=$.%5?%$F=+.$%=-+6+*"2%"=/.(%'8+=8%="*%+*4+-$=/2@%$2+6+*"/$%*$#"/+,$%
./+#6"%5-%2"B$22+*#%/5'"-4.%C$-C$/-"/5-.%+*%/8$%=5661*+/@%"*4%?5-6+*#%"*%1*4$-./"*4+*#%5?%/8$%
=5661*+/@e.%=12/1-"2%,"21$.%/8"/%*5/%"22%$F=+.$%=-+6+*"2%=".$.%61./%B$%-$.52,$4%/8-51#8%/8$%=51-/.<%
%
CONCLUSION)
H".$4% 5*% /8$% -$.12/.% 5?% C-$,+51.% -$.$"-=8% "*4% 4+.=1..+5*.(% +/% ="*% B$% =5*=214$4% /8"/% /8$%
"CC2+="/+5*% 5?% /8$% C-+*=+C2$.% 5?% -$./5-"/+,$% U1./+=$% +*% -$.52,+*#% =-+6+*"2% $F=+.$% =".$.% "/% /8$% E+Z"-"*#%
E1./56.%"*4%0F=+.$%N??+=$%8".%#5*$%'$22<%3*,$./+#"/5-.%$6C8".+_$%-$=5,$-@%$??5-/.%+*%8"*42+*#%=-+6+*"2%
$F=+.$%=".$.(%-$?$--+*#%/5%&"'%K16B$-%]%5?%OPOW%=5*=$-*+*#%/8$%V"-65*+_"/+5*%5?%A"F%R$#12"/+5*.<%A8+.%
"CC2+="/+5*%"45C/.% =-+/$-+"%?-56%/8$% -12$.%5?%5/8$-% 2"'%$*?5-=$6$*/%5??+=+"2.% /8"/%"-$% -$2$,"*/%/5%2"'%
$*?5-=$6$*/(%=5*.+4$-+*#%.5=+525#+="2%".C$=/.(%=+-=16./"*=$.(%"*4%/8$%+**$-%"//+/14$%5?%/8$%C$-C$/-"/5-<%
A8$%./"#$.%5?%=".$%8"*42+*#%+*=214$%-$=$+,+*#%/8$%=".$(%C-$2+6+*"-@%-$.$"-=8(%4$/$-6+*+*#%/8$%8"*42+*#%
.=8$6$(%"*4%-$.$"-=8+*#% .1.C$=/$4%,+52"/+5*.% 5-%+*,$./+#"/+5*.<%A8+.% C-5=$..%$*4.%'+/8% .1B6+//+*#%"%
R$S1$./%?5-%E".$%M$//2$6$*/%+*%/8$%T5-6%5?%K5%3*,$./+#"/+5*%?-56%/8$%C$-C$/-"/5-(%'8+=8%/8$%V$"4%5?%/8$%
E+Z"-"*#%E1./56.%"*4%0F=+.$%N??+=$%"CC-5,$.<%A8$%+6C"=/%5-%B$*$?+/.%5?%+6C2$6$*/+*#%/8$%C-+*=+C2$.%5?%
-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%+*=214$%"44+/+5*"2%./"/$%-$,$*1$%5?%3YR<%O(gQg(g:g(WPP(%h%"*4%C5/$*/+"22@%.",$4%./"/$%
-$,$*1$<%A8$%/5/"2%"..$/%-$=5,$-@%?-56%/8$%=".$%.$//2$6$*/%C-5,$.%/8+.<%3*%"44+/+5*(%/8$-$%'".%"%4$=-$".$%
+*%/8$%*16B$-%5?%$F=+.$%,+52"/+5*.<%L/%/8$%."6$%/+6$(%/8$%4$/$--$*/%$??$=/%'".%-$?2$=/$4%+*%/8$%C$-=$*/"#$%
5?%-$C$"/%$F=+.$%,+52"/+5*.%B@%/8$%."6$%C$-C$/-"/5-.%G-$=+4+,+./.J(%'8+=8%'".%5*2@%W<:l<%
%
REFERENCES)
L2+(% b<% V<% GOPWWJ<% Asas% Peradilan% Sederhana,% Cepat,% dan% Biaya% Ringan% Dihubungkan% dengan% Keadilan%
Restoratif% dalam% Lingkungan% Peradilan% Umum% di% Indonesia<% H"*41*#7% !-5#-"6% Y5Z/5-% 3261%
V1Z16hT"Z12/".%V1Z16%)*+,$-.+/".%!"4U"4U"-"*<!
L2.1Z"+/(%R<(%H2$+=8(%M<(%f+24$(%!<(%M+*#8(%[<(%\%T52/"(%M<%GOPOPJ<%M1#"-@%4-+*Z%$F=+.$%/"F%C52+=@%C-5=$..%"*4%
+6C2$6$*/"/+5*7% E".$% ./14@% ?-56% M"14+% L-"B+"<% Food% Policy(% 90(% WPW]9:<%
8//C.7^^45+<5-#^WP<WPW`^d<TNNY!N&<OPW:<WPW]9:%
LC-+2(%I<(%M=8-"4$-(%M<%f<(%f"2Z$-(%A<%0<(%T-"*=+.(%R<%b<(%[2@**(%V<(%\%[5-45*(%Y<%b<%GOPOQJ<%E5*=$C/1"2+_+*#%
U1,$*+2$%U1./+=$%-$?5-67%3*/$#-"/+*#%/8$%C1B2+=%8$"2/8(%.5=+"2%$=525#+="2(%"*4%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%
654$2.<% Children% and% Youth% Services% Review(% 148<%
8//C.7^^45+<5-#^WP<WPW`^d<EV3&YmN)AV<OPOQ<WP`99]%
L-+$?(%H<%K<%GW::`J<%H"/".hB"/".%I$6"6C1"*%V1Z16%!+4"*"%Y"2"6%!$*"*##12"*#"*%I$U"8"/"*<%Makalah%
Seminar%Nasional%Pendekatan%Non%Penal%Dalam%Penangulangan%Kejahatan,%Graha%Santika%Hotel,%
Semarang(%2<%
International!Journal!of!Social!Service!and!Research%% 8//C.7^^+U..-<-+4'"*+*./+/1/$<=5<+4^%
IJSSR!!"#$%2858%
L_+_"8(% L<(% M1"-4"(% 3<% [<% f<(% \% b"-4+@5*5(% b<% GOPOQJ<% !-+*.+C% I$"4+2"*% R$./5-"/+?% Y"2"6% !$*#8$*/+"*%
!$*1*/1/"*% !$-Z"-"% !+4"*"% H$-4"."-Z"*% !$-"/1-"*% d"Z."% L#1*#% K565-% WX% A"81*% OPOP<%
JURNAL%HUKUM,%POLITIK%DAN%ILMU%SOSIAL(%2GOJ(%OgQnO`g<%
H14+"/-+(%L<%!<(%\%f3RLARLbLK(%V<%GOPOOJ<%Demokrasi%tanpa%demos:%refleksi%100%ilmuwan%sosial%politik%
tentang%kemunduran%demokrasi%di%Indonesia<%&CQ$.<%
E"*4-+Z"(%L<%!<% GOPOWJ<%INJAUAN%YURIDIS%TERHADAP%TINDAK%PIDANA%PENJUALAN%BARANG%KENA%CUKAI%
SECARA% ILEGAL% (Studi% Kasus% Putusan% Perkara% Nomor% 876/Pid.% Sus/2019/PN.% Mks)=% Judicial%
Review%of%the%Crime%of%Illegal%Sales%of%Excisable%Goods%(Case%Study%of%Decision%Number%876/Pid.%
Sus/2019/PN.%Mks)%<%
EVLKYRL(% 0<(% \% [1?-"$*+(% R<% GOPWWJ<% I"U+"*% $Z./$*.+?+Z".+% B"-"*#% Z$*"% =1Z"+% C"4"% 6+*16"*% -+*#"*%
B$-Z"-B5*".+<%BISNIS%&%BIROKRASI:%Jurnal%Ilmu%Administrasi%Dan%Organisasi(%16GQJ(%`<%
Y"*+$2/(%R<%A<%GOPWgJ<%!$*$-"C"*% R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%A$-8"4"C%A+*4"Z%!+4"*"%L*"Z%!$*=1-+"*%N2$8% L*"Z%
Y+%H"'"8%)61-<%Lex%et%Societatis(%2G`J<%
Y"-1.."2"6(%Y<(%I-+./+"U+(%H<%H<(%\%m1./+.+"(%Y<%GOPW:J<%Prospek%Pajak%Warisan%di%Indonesia<%YYAE%f5-Z+*#%
!"C$-%OPW:<%
T25-"(% V<% M<% GOPW9J<% I$"4+2"*% R$./5-"/+?% M$B"#"+% L2/$-*"/+?% Y"2"6% !$*@$2$."+"*% A+*4"Z% !+4"*"% Y"*%
!$*#"-18*@"%Y"2"6%M+./$6%!$-"4+2"*%!+4"*"%Y+%3*45*$.+"<%University%Of%Bengkulu%Law%Journal(%
3GOJ(%WgOnWX9<%
V".+B1"*(%&<% R<(%V"64"*(%b<(%b"-2+*"(%b<(%\% H"-1.(%)<%b<%GOPWXJ<% R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%M$B"#"+%!$6B"8"-1"*%
M+./$6%!$-"4+2"*%!+4"*"%H$-4"."-Z"*%))%K5<%WW%A"81*%OPWO%A$*/"*#%M+./$6%!$-"4+2"*%!+4"*"%
L*"Z<%USU%Law%Journal(%3GQJ(%`gn]W<%
V$26+(%b<%GOPWXJ<%I5*.$C%I$"4+2"*%Y"2"6%T+2."?"/%V1Z16%Y"*%T+2."?"/%V1Z16%3.2"6<%Mazahib<%
V5B.5*(%d<(%\%!"@*$(%H<%GOPOOJ<%H1+24+*#%-$./5-"/+,$%U1./+=$%.$-,+=$.7%E5*.+4$-"/+5*.%5*%/5Ch45'*%"*4%
B5//56h1C% "CC-5"=8$.<% International% Journal% of% Law,% Crime% and% Justice(% 71<%
8//C.7^^45+<5-#^WP<WPW`^d<3d&Ed<OPOO<WPPXXX%
b"-4$-(% 3<% Y<% GOPOOJ<% b"CC+*#% -$./5-"/+,$% U1./+=$% "*4% -$./5-"/+,$% C-"=/+=$.% +*% =-+6+*"2% U1./+=$% +*% /8$%
R$C1B2+=% 5?% 3-$2"*4<% International% Journal% of% Law,% Crime% and% Justice(% 70<%
8//C.7^^45+<5-#^WP<WPW`^d<3d&Ed<OPOO<WPPXgg%
b1*#"(%H<(%M8+B+"(%L<%[<(%\%N*.561(%0<%GOPOQJ<%LCC-"+."2%5?%I$*@"D.%$F=+."B2$%#554.%6"*"#$6$*/%.@./$6%
1.+*#% +*/$--1C/$4% /+6$% .$-+$.% "*"2@.+.7% L% =".$% 5?% =+#"-$//$.% "*4% =+#"-.% $F=+.$% /"F% -$,$*1$<%
Preventive%Medicine(%167(%WP]gP9<%8//C.7^^45+<5-#^WP<WPW`^d<m!b0Y<OPOO<WP]gP9%
KLM3NKL&(%H<%!<%V<(%\%KLM3NKL&(%H<%!<%V<%GOPOQJ<%BC8*<%Retrieved%March%3rd<%
K"/+5*.(% )<% GOPPOJ<% Basic% principles% on% the% use% of% restorative% justice% programmes% in% criminal% matters<%
)*+/$4%K"/+5*.%K$'%m5-Z<%
!i-$_hd5-#$(% Y<(% L25*.5hR54-o#1$_(% 3<(% L--+"#"4"h>$*$#".(% b<(% \% L-+p5hb"/$5(% 0<% GOPOQJ<% R$./5-"/+,$%
6$/854.% ".%"% ./-"/$#@% ?5-%/8$% C-$,$*/+5*% 5?%,+52$*=$%"*4%B122@+*#% +*%C-+6"-@% "*4% .$=5*4"-@%
.=8552.% +*% b$F+=57% L*% $FC25-"/5-@% ./14@<% Heliyon(% 9G]J<%
8//C.7^^45+<5-#^WP<WPW`^d<V0&3mNK<OPOQ<0W9O`]%
M"-5+*.5*#(%d<%0<%GOPOPJ<%!$-"*%!$*@+4+Z%!$#"'"+%K$#$-+%M+C+2%G!C*.J%Y"2"6%A+*4"Z%!+4"*"%H$"%Y"*%E1Z"+%
b$*1-1/% )*4"*#h)*4"*#% K5<% W]% A"81*% OPP`% A$*/"*#% I$C"B$"*"*% Y"2"6% I".1.%
!$*@$21*41C"*<%Lex%Et%Societatis(%7G]J<%
M8"-C2$..(% &<(% I$-.8"'(%A<(% \% f+22+$(% A<% E<% GOPOOJ<% L..5=+"/+5*.%B$/'$$*% ./"/$h2$,$2%-$./5-"/+,$% U1./+=$%
C52+=+$.%"*4%6$*/"2%8$"2/8%"65*#%'56$*%.1-,+,5-.%5?%+*/+6"/$%C"-/*$-%,+52$*=$<%SSM%-%Mental%
Health(%2<%8//C.7^^45+<5-#^WP<WPW`^d<MMbbV<OPOO<WPPP9X%
M+6"*1*#Z"2+/(%q<%GOPW`J<%L*"2+.+.%V1Z16%A$-8"4"C%!$*$-"C"*%R$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%4"2"6%I$=$2"Z""*%
&"21%&+*/".<%Skripsi,%Universitas%Hasanudin,%Makassar<%
M+*/"(%b<%GOPOOJ<%&$#"2%!-5/$=/+5*%?5-%E-+6+*"2%d1./+=$7%L%H55Z%R$,+$'%rR$./5-"/+,$%d1./+=$%4+%3*45*$.+"D(%
L86"4%M@8"-+2%m1*1.% MV%"*4%Y-%3-.@"4%Y"8-+%MV%bV(% [1$C$4+"(%H5#5-%3*45*$.+"(% OPOW(%WgO%
C"#$.(%3MHK%:]9h`OQhXXOXh:9hQ<%Lex%Scientia%Law%Review(%6GOJ(%X`WnX`:<%
International!Journal!of!Asian!Education!(%
3.'"*%V$-1%f+4"-/5
%
IJSSR!!"#$%2859%
).6"*(% L<%V<% GOPWXJ<% I$."4"-"*%81Z16%6".@"-"Z"/% 4"*% C$6$-+*/"8% .$B"#"+%?"Z/5-%/$#"Z*@"% *$#"-"%
81Z16%4+%3*45*$.+"<%Jurnal%Wawasan%Yuridika(%30GWJ(%O`nXQ<%
f"21@5(%H<%GOPOPJ<%Penyelesaian%Perkara%Pidana<%M+*"-%[-"?+Z"<%
%%
Copyright!holder:!
3.'"*%V$-1%f+4"-/5
!
GOPOQJ
!
!
First!publication!rights:!
3*/$-*"/+5*"2%d51-*"2%5?%M5=+"2%M$-,+=$%"*4%R$.$"-=8%G3dMMRJ%
!
This!article!is!licensed!under:!
!
!
%
