!<959<?I;3<?>,03G9<?>,3O,"3P;?>,"59:;P5,?<F,1545?9P7%% G..-83UU@F881$1@AS5:@:8.@.=.,$<"$@AU%
!0""1 456,%$+22%
4#& %2"& .4#31'",& +,"-","#."& :"(02%(#0& '"%247Qk$7,5:SG@#,(% 1,9,11@:6% ."% .G,% -1"0#,/% 9"1/=#5.@":%
,]-#5@:,A% @:% .G,% -1,D@"=8% -515615-G(+"% .G,% 5@/% "9% .G@8% 1,8,51<G% @8% ."% <":A=<.% 5:% 5:5#>8@8% "9% .G,%
<"/-"8@.@":%"9%.G,%.,:5:.%/@]%Nc@1K=-%^%M59@`(%R**fON7<P"##=/(%R*i&O$%IG,%/"8.%@A,5#%N.,:5:.%/@]O%
5:A%.516,.%/51K,.U-".,:.@5#%<":8=/,18%058,A%":%.G,% <":8=/,1% -1,9,1,:<,%S,@6G.@:6% /,.G"A% @:%.G,%
IMQ!W[%\CB%<"//,1<@5#%51,5%E:%.G@8%8.=A>%Nd516%^%+.,>:(%2&RhO(%IMQ!W[%\CB%@8%.G,%#"<5.@":%<G"8,:%
."%A,.,1/@:,%SG,.G,1%"1%:".%.G@8%<"//,1<@5#%51,5%@8%5<<,-.50#,%@:%.G,%?58.%J5K51.5%#"<5.@":(%.5K@:6%@:."%
5<<"=:.% .G5.% IMQ!W[% \CB% @8% @:<#=A,A% @:% .G,% -#5::,A% <"//,1<@5#% 51,5% A,D,#"-/,:.% <5.,6"1>% @:%
%
METHODS)
IG,%<"/-515.@D,%8<5#,%@:%.G@8%8.=A>%=8,8%-1,9,1,:<,8%91"/%5%.,:5:.%<5.,6"1>%8<5#,%SG@<G%<5:%0,%
1,9#,<.,A%
=8@:6%
.G,%
/=#.@-#,
V1,8-":8,%
@.,/%
-1,9,1,:<,%
NB"G1:8.,A.%,.%5#$(%R*i'O%/,.G"A%$%E:%#@:,%[email protected]%,]-#5:5.@":% @:% 5% <58,% 8.=A>% 9"1% 5% 8G"--@:6% <,:.,1U<"//,1<@5#% 51,5(% 5% <"/-515.@D,% 8<5#,% @8% /"1,%
5--1"-1@5.,%
."%
=8,%
0>%
<":8@A,1@:6%
8.@/=#=8%
<"/-51@8":8%
0,.S,,:%
"0F,<.8%
[email protected]%
A5.5%
.G5.%
@8%
@:.,1-1,.,A%
@:%1,#5.@D,%.,1/8%5:A%G58%"1A@:5#%5..1@0=.,8%"1%15:K@:6%"1A,1%NB1=S,1(%R**lO$%
7=#.@-#,V1,8-":8,%-1,9,1,:<,%@.,/8%@:A@<5.,%.G,%-1,9,1,:<,%"9%.G,%.,:5:.%<5.,6"1>%8<5#,%G,#A%0>%
.G,%1,8-":A,
:.%5:A%
6,:,15##>%<":.5@:%/
=#.@-#,%<G"@<,8%
[email protected]%/"1,%.G
5:%":,%
5:8S,1(%8"%.G5.%
1,8-":A,:.8%
<5:%
-1"D@A,%
.G,@1%
-1,9,1,:<,%
5:8S,18%
[email protected]"=.%
0,@:6%
9@]5.,A%
":%":,% 5:8S,1%5:A% <5:% -1"D@A,% -1,<@8,%5:8S,18%NB1"S:(%R**2O$%
IG,%-1@/51>%A5.5%=8,A%@:%.G@8%1,8,51<G%<"/,8%91"/%A5.5%<"##,<.@":%.G1"=6G%`=,8.@"::5@1,8%."%
A,.,1/@:,%1,8-":A,:.8m%-1"9@#,8(%-"@:.8%"9%D@,S%5:A%588,88/,:.8%"9%.G,%."-@<8%15@8,A%@:%.G@8%1,8,51<G$%
41@/51>% A5.5% <"##,<.@":% S58% <511@,A% "=.% .G1"=6G% A@8.1@0=.@:6% `=,8.@"::5@1,8% A,8@6:,A% ."% A,.,1/@:,%
<":8=/,1% 0,G5D@"1% @:% 8G"--@:6% <,:.,18U<"//,1<@5#% 51,58% 5<<"1A@:6% ."% 8-,<@9@,A% <1@.,1@5% NE8/5@#% ?#V
QA#>(%2&&lO
$%IG,%-1"<,88%"9%[email protected]@0=.@:6%.G,%`=,8.@"::5@1,%S58%<511@,A%"=.%D@5%-,18":5#%/,8856,U61"=-%01"5A<58.%":%.G,%gG5.8Q--%5--#@<5.@":$%E:% 6,:,15#(%.G@8%1,8,51<G%=8,A%:":V-1"050@#@.>%85/-#@:6%5:A%
-=1-"8@D,%85/-#@:6%.,<G:@`=,8$%M,9,11@:6%."%1,8,51<G%#@/@.5.@":8%.G5.%G5D,%0,,:%-1,D@"=8#>%A,.,1/@:,A(%
58%S,##%58%<":8@A,1@:6%.G,%:,,A%9"1%A5.5%.G5.%<":.5@:8%A,/"615-G@<(%6,"615-G@<%5:A%0,G5D@"15#%58-,<.8$%
IG,%<G"@<,%"9%85/-#,%8@a,%@:%.G@8%8.=A>%1,9,18%."%\5@1%,.%5#$(%N2&R&O%SG@<G%1,<"//,:A8%5% 1,8,51<G%85/-#,%
8@a,%"9%R&&%N":, %G=:A1,AO%"1%/"1,$%IG=8(%@:%.G@8%8.=A>%.G,%:=/0,1%"9%85/-#,8%<"##,<.,A%S58%5%/@:@/=/%
"9%2&&%N.S"%G=:A1,AO%1,8-":A,:.8%SG"%/,.%.G,%85/-#,%<G515<.,1@8.@<8%58%/,:.@":,A%50"D,$%
IG,%5@/%"9%.G@8%1,8,51<G%@8%."%5:5#>a,%G"S%.G,%<"/-"8@.@":$%IG,%/"8.%@A,5#%.,:5:.%/@]%058,A%":%
.G,%<":8=/,1%-1,9,1,:<,%S,@6G.@:6%/,.G"A%@:%.G,%IMQ!W[%\CB%<"//,1<@5#%51,5%N[="%,.%5#$(%2&&fO$%IG,%
/,.G"A"#"6>% @8% .15:8#5.,A% .G1"=6G% .G,% =8,% "9% S,@6G.@:6% .,<G:@`=,8% 058,A% ":% '% N.G1,,O% -515/,.,18(%
:5/,#>%.,:5:.%<5.,6"1>%-1,9,1,:<,8%N@A,5#%.,:5:.%<5.,6"1>O(%<5.,6"1>%15:K@:6%-1,9,1,:<,8%N95D"=150#,%
.,:5:.% <5.,6"1>O(% 5:A% 8-,:A@:6% -"88@0@#@.>% -1,9,1,:<,8% N#@K,#@G""A% .,:5:.% <5.,6"1>O$% E:% .G,% ,:A(% .G,%
-515/,.,18% @:% `=,8.@":% 51,% <":8"#@A5.,A% @:."% 5% <"/-"8@.,% .,:5:.% @:A,]% SG@<G% @:A@<5.,8% .G,% .,:5:.%
<"/-"8@.@":%<":8@8.@:6% "9% .G,% /"8.%@A,5#% /@].=1,% "9%.,:5:.8% @:% "1A,1% "9%-1,9,1,:<,$% IG,% D5#@A@.>% 5:A%
1,#@50@#@.>%.,8.@:6%-1"<,88%@:%.G@8%1,8,51<G%=8,8%+4++%8"9.S51,(%SG@#,%.G,%<5#<=#5.@":%"9%:=/,1@<5#%A5.5%
N:=/0,18O%=8,8%9"1/=#58%@:%5%8-1,5A8G,,.%8G,,.%":%78$%8"9.S51,$%?]<,#%NE015G@/%^%d5#D,:(%2&&lO$%
%
RESULTS)AND)DISCUSSION
41@/51>%
A5.5%
<"##,<.@":%
S58%
<5
11@,A%
"=.%
0>%
[email protected]@0=.@:6%
`=,8.@"::5@1,8%
A,8@6:,A%
."%
A,.,1/@:,%
<":8=/,1%0,G5D@"1%@:%8G"--@:6%<,:.,18%5:A%<"//,1<@5#%51,58%5<<"1A@:6%."%8-,<@9@,A%<1@.,1@5%N;@::%^%
L"=D@,1,(%
R**bO
$%IG,%-1"<,88%"9%[email protected]@0=.@:6%`=,8.@"::5@1,8(%SG@<G%51,%/5A,%@:%d""6#,%;"1/%9"1/5.(%@8%[email protected]@0=.,A%
D@5%
-,18":5#%
/,8856,%
"1%
61"=-%
01"5A<
58.%
":%
.G,%
gG5.8Q--%
5--#@<5.@":$%
IG,%
1,8=#
.8%
"9%
.G,%
`=,8.@"::5@1,% "0.5@:,A% @:% .G@8% A5.5% <"##,<.@":% -1"<,88% S,1,% 58% /5:>% 58% 2&h%N.S"% G=:A1,A%5:A% 9@D,O%
1,8-":A,:.8$%