International$Journal$of$Asian$Education$(%
U56-7871(%CE<%V5<38:"2(%)5/I3;7E3;3(%U3:7;%25:/7%>3;3/3874%
IJSSR$234,%2753%
0&J&$%A=="/E784%:"%E3:3%?/"-%:;,%M"/#E%9,3#:;%W/4387X3:7"8%RM9WT(%L8E"8,673%76%,NB,=:,E%:"%,NB,/7,8=,%3%
8":3.#,%65/4,%78%:;,%85-.,/%"?%B,"B#,%3??,=:,E%.<%E73.,:,6(%/76784%?/"-%Y$J%-7##7"8%78%0&&&%:"%3BB/"N7-3:,#<%
0*$'%-7##7"8%.<%0&'&%R2,/G,87(%0&*OT$%AEE7:7"83##<(%:;,%L8:,/83:7"83#%@73.,:,6%Z,E,/3:7"8%RL@ZT%38:7=7B3:,6%
3%65.6:38:73#%78=/,36,%78%E73.,:,6%-,##7:56%=36,6%3-"84%78E7+7E53#6%34,E%0&H[\%78%L8E"8,673(%B/"P,=:,E%:"%
4/"I%?/"-%*&%-7##7"8%78%0&*O%:"%*Q$0%-7##7"8%.<%0&J&$%L?%:;,6,%B/,E7=:7"86%;"#E(%L8E"8,673%I7##%/38G%36%:;,%
67N:;H;74;,6:%="58:/<%4#".3##<%78%:,/-6%"?%E73.,:,6%-,##7:56%=36,6%.<%0&J&%R2,/G,87(%0&*OT%
]36,E%"8%0&*'%]367=%9,3#:;%U,6,3/=;%RU76G,6E36T%E3:3(%:;,%B/,+3#,8=,%"?%E73.,:,6%-,##7:56%78%B,"B#,%
"+,/%*O%78%L8E"8,673%78=/,36,E%?/"-%O$[S%78%0&*[%:"%Q$\S$%K;,%B/,+3#,8=,%"?%@73.,:,6%>,##7:56%78%>3:3/3-%
^7:<%76%*$[S$%@73.,:,6%>,##7:56%I36%/38G,E%\:;%3-"84%:;,%*&%-"6:%="--"8%E76,36,6%78%)K]%^"--587:<%
9,3#:;%^,8:,/6%78%0&*[%R)K]%2/"+78=73#%9,3#:;%2/"?7#,(%0&*[T$%K;76%B/,E7=3:,%I7##%B,/676:%58:7#%0&0*%I;,8%
8"8H="--587=3.#,% E76,36,6% 65=;% 36% 6:/"G,(% ;<B,/:,867"8(%38E% E73.,:,6% -,##7:56% 3/,% 78% :;,% :"B% *&% -"6:%
="--"8% E76,36,6$% A=="/E784% :"% E3:3% "8% ;,3#:;% 6,/+7=,% ="+,/34,% ?"/% E73.,:,6% -,##7:56% 65??,/,/6% 78% 65.H
E76:/7=:6%38E%="--587:<%;,3#:;%=,8:,/6%78%M,6:%)563%K,8443/3%2/"+78=,%78%0&0&(%:;,/,%I,/,%O\(Q&Q%@>%
65??,/,/6$%K;,8(%78%0&0*(%:;,/,%I36%38%78=/,36,%78%@>%65??,/,/6(%83-,#<(%:;,/,%I,/,%Q'(JYY%65??,/,/6$%K;,8(%
78%]7-3%^7:<(%:;,/,%I,/,%'(O0'%65??,/,/6$%
K;,%78=/,36,%78%:;,%85-.,/%"?%@73.,:,6%>,##7:56%65??,/,/6(%-"6:%"?%I;"-%3/,%:<B,%0%@>(%76%/,#3:,E%
:"% 6,+,/3#% ?3=:"/6% 65=;% 36% ".,67:<(% ;<B,/:,867"8(% ?3-7#<% ;76:"/<(% 34,(% 4,8,:7=% ?3=:"/6(% 6-"G784% ;3.7:6(%
="865-784% 3#=";"#(% 3+37#3.7#7:<% "?% ;74;H=3#"/7,% ?""E6(%B;<67=3#% 783=:7+7:<% 38E% #7?,6:<#,% =;384,6% :;3:% =356,%
E73.,:,6% RZ3:7-3;(% 0&*OT$%@73.,:,6% -,##7:56% 76% 3% ;74;%=356,% "?% E,3:;(% ,6B,=73##<% E5,% :"% ="-B#7=3:7"86% "?%
E73.,:,6% -,##7:56(% I;7=;% "?:,8% =356,% 3:;,/"6=#,/"676(% ="/"83/<% ;,3/:% E76,36,% 38E% 6:/"G,$% ^#7,8:6% I7:;%
E73.,:,6%-,##7:56%;3+,%3%0HJ%:7-,6%;74;,/%/76G%"?%,NB,/7,8=784%;,3/:%3::3=G6%38E%6:/"G,6$%AB3/:%?/"-%:;3:(%
E73.,:,6%-,##7:56%=38%E,+,#"B(%=356784%G7E8,<%?37#5/,(%.#78E8,66(%38E%3-B5:3:7"8(%6"%:/,3:-,8:%8,,E6%:"%.,%
E"8,%7--,E73:,#<$%
^"-B#7=3:7"86% :;3:%?/,_5,8:#<% 3/76,%78% 78E7+7E53#6% I7:;%E73.,:,6% 78=#5E,%?"":% 5#=,/6%38E% I"58E6$%
@73.,:7=%?"":%I"58E6%,8="-B366%78?,=:7"86(%5#=,/6(%38E%E,,B,/%:7665,%E3-34,%:;3:%3/,%366"=73:,E%I7:;%.":;%
8,5/"#"47=3#%38E%+36=5#3/%7665,6%78%:;,%#,46%"?%:;"6,%65??,/784%?/"-%E73.,:,6%-,##7:56$%K;,6,%="-B#7=3:7"86%
3/,%B/7-3/7#<% 3::/7.5:,E%:"% B,/7B;,/3#%3/:,/<% E76,36,%R2A@T(% 3% ="8E7:7"8%3G78% :"%="/"83/<% 3/:,/<%E76,36,%
RI;7=;%78+"#+,6%.#"=G34,6%78%:;,%3/:,/7,6%65BB#<784%.#""E%:"%:;,%;,3/:%-56=#,T%38E%=3/":7E%3/:,/<%E76,36,%
RI;7=;%B,/:3786%:"%.#"=G34,6%78%:;,%3/:,/7,6%#,3E784%:"%:;,%./378T$%L8%:;,%=36,%"?%2A@(%:;,%3/:,/7,6%6,/+784%
3/,36%.,<"8E%:;,%./378%38E%;,3/:(%65=;%36%:;,%8,=G(%3/-6(%38E%3.E"-,8(%3/,%3??,=:,E(%I7:;%:;,%#,46%38E%?,,:%
.,784%:;,%-"6:%3??#7=:,E%/,47"86$%L8%2A@(%?3:%E,B"67:6%3==5-5#3:,%I7:;78%:;,%788,/%#3<,/6%"?%:;,%#,4%3/:,/7,6(%
/,65#:784%78%:;,7/%83//"I784$%K;76%="86:/7=:7"8%"?%:;,%3/:,/7,6%;78E,/6%.#""E%?#"I(%38E%78%6,+,/,%=36,6(%7:%=38%
="-B#,:,#<%".6:/5=:%.#""E%?#"I%:"%:;,%#,46$%K;76%="8E7:7"8%"?:,8%#,3E6%:"%B378(%B3/:7=5#3/#<%E5/784%B;<67=3#%
3=:7+7:<%#7G,% I3#G784$% Z5/:;,/-"/,(% 7:%-387?,6:6% I7:;%+3/7"56% ":;,/%6<-B:"-6(% 65=;%36% 6#"IH;,3#784%?"":%
6"/,6(%3%8":3.#,%:,-B,/3:5/,%E76B3/7:<%.,:I,,8%"8,%?"":%38E%:;,%":;,/(%38E%:;,%B":,8:73#%E,+,#"B-,8:%"?%
4384/,8,$%K;,6,%="-B#7=3:7"86%="8:/7.5:,%:"% B/"#"84,E%:/,3:-,8:%E5/3:7"86(%78=/,36,E%;,3#:;=3/,% ="6:6(%
,#,+3:,E%/3:,6%"?%E763.7#7:<(%/,E5=,E%_53#7:<%"?%#7?,(%38E%3%;,74;:,8,E%/76G%"?%-"/:3#7:<$%
L8%4,8,/3#(%:;,/,%3/,%?7+,%B/78=7B#,6%?"/%-3834784%E73.,:,6%-,##7:56%.<%:;,%0&&Q%@>%>3834,-,8:%
^"86,8656%78%L8E"8,673%:"%7-B/"+,%:;,%_53#7:<%"?%#7?,%"?%@>%B3:7,8:6$%W8,%76%B/"+7E784%;,3#:;%,E5=3:7"8%:"%
B/,+,8:% ="-B#7=3:7"86% I"/6,8784%:;,% 65??,/,/`6% ="8E7:7"8$% K<B,% 0% @>% E76,36,% =38% .,% B/,+,8:,E% .<%
78=/,36784%3%B,/6"8`6%G8"I#,E4,(%3::7:5E,6(%38E%6,#?H3I3/,8,66%78%-3834784%:;,7/%#7?,6:<#,$%2/,+,8:7"8%=38%
6:3/:% I7:;%"8,6,#?$% V37?585/-3X3;%R0&*[T% a,NB#378,E% :;3:% 3I3/,8,66% 76% 8,,E,E% ?/"-% I7:;78% :"% B/,+,8:%
E76,36,%38E%B/,+,8:%="-B#7=3:7"86%?/"-%:;,%E76,36,$%aL8%B/,+,8:784%:;,%-"/:3#7:<%38E%-"/.7E7:<%"?%@>(%6,#?H
=3/,%76%+,/<%8,=,663/<$%W8,%"?%:;,%-"6:%7-B"/:38:%36B,=:6%"?%6,#?H=3/,%76%6,#?H3I3/,8,66%R6,#?H3I3/,8,66Tb$%