The Influence of Service Quality on Customer
Satisfaction and Its Impact on Repurchase Interests in Telkom Cell Products in Timor Leste
Carlos Soares Ribeiro1*, Diane Indiyati2
1*,2Telkom University Bandung, Indonesia
*E-mail: 1*[email protected], 2[email protected]
Keywords |
|
ABSTRACT |
Tangible,
Empathy, Assurance, Customer Satisfaction, Repurchase Intention,
Telecommunications Industry, Telecommunications Timor Leste |
|
Telkomcel's customers started to complain and lost their trust and their
customers got worse and worse. In order to take back the customer's trust, Telkomcel implemented two main strategies, namely the
Push Strategy and the Pull Strategy in its marketing activities. This study
aims to provide an overview of Specific Service Quality in three dimensions,
namely Tangible, Empathy and Assurance, Customer Satisfaction and Repurchase
Intention at Telkomcel Timor Leste,
and to determine the effect of service quality on Repurchase Intention with
customer satisfaction interventions at Telkomcel
East Timor. Based on the results of distributing questionnaires to 200 people
at several universities in Timor Leste such as UNTL
(Timor Loro Sae National
University), UNPAZ (Universidade Da Paz), UNITAL (Universidade de Oriental) and DIT (Dili Institute of
Business) ISC (Institut Unggul
Cristal) 200 students, lecturers and administrative staff on campus randomly
using a Likert scale and non-probability sampling techniques and purposive
sampling. SEM (Structural Equation Modeling) data analysis technique, with
the help of SmartPLS 3.0 software. |
INTRODUCTION
Telkomcel as one of the operators that competes in the
Timor-Leste telecommunications market, coupled with the Pandemic, of course
requires Telkomcel to change its marketing strategy.
In 2020, Telkomcel will still focus on the needs of
existing customers and will also continue to try to increase the customer base
(Telkomcel, 2020 and 2021). However, from the other
side, Telkomcel is also facing a pandemic, and the
Timor Leste government has launched a new regulation
regarding frequencies in Timor Leste, in 2021 which
is a critical year, because there is a reduction in several frequencies because
it is considered that there is no license yet. With this situation giving a
significant impact on Telkomcel, customers start
complaining and losing trust and customers are getting lower and lower, to take
back the trust of customers, Telkomcel applies two
main strategies, namely Push Strategy and Pull Strategy in marketing
activities, as follows:
According
to (Kotler, 1997) Repurchase Intention is a psychological aspect that has a
considerable influence on the attitude and behavior of repeat buyers as well as
a source of motivation that will direct someone to do what they do from the
other side (Rahardjo and Magnadi
2016). Repeat is customer behavior after purchase which was previously based on
satisfaction with the product. If the customer is satisfied then he will show a
higher buying opportunity in the next opportunity.
This is
supported by research (Bernarto, 2019) that
satisfaction has a positive effect on repurchase intention. If Satisfaction is
getting better, it will have an impact on increasing Repurchase Intention. then
the results of research from Hill et al. (2007); Reichheld
and Sasser (1990); Shahrokh et al. (2013); Tsai et
al. (2006); Zhou et al. (2009) which states that customers who are satisfied
with a service or product obtained or perceived will have a high tendency to
continue their relationship with a company that provides such satisfaction
compared to those who have a low level of satisfaction.
To
induce repurchasing behavior it must be supported by a physical (tangible)
product which from these conditions will lead to customer satisfaction and at
the same time motivate them to repurchase the product. This is supported by
research (Halima Tussaadia Ternate, 2020) that
tangible, Empathy, and Asurane has a positive effect
on Repurchase Intention in the coffee house business, so on
Consumer
satisfaction is an emotional reaction to experiences related to the specific
goods or services purchased, the retail establishment, or even patterns of
behavior (such as buying behavior and shopping behavior), as well as the market
as a whole. The cognitive evacuation process that compares perceptions (or
beliefs) about certain things, activities, or situations with personal values causes emotional reactions (or needs, wants, and desires).
"Customer satisfaction is a person's feeling of pleasure or disappointment
that occurs after comparing the perceived performance (outcome) of a product
with his expectations
According
to Kotler & Keller, (2009) that satisfaction is a person's feeling of
pleasure or disappointment that arises after comparing the performance or
results of a product that is thought of against the expected performance or
results. If performance falls below expectations, the consumer is dissatisfied.
If performance exceeds expectations, consumers will be very happy or satisfied.
These consumer expectations can be known from their own experiences when using
the product, the words of other people, and the advertising information
promised by the company that produced the product. (Nasruddin,
2023)(�Jurnal_Nasruddin.Pdf,� nd)
According
to Rangkuti (2018) consumer satisfaction is defined
as the consumer's response to the discrepancy between the previous level of
importance and the actual performance he feels after use. Whereas Kotler in Hamdani (2017) consumer satisfaction is the level of
feeling where a person states the results of a comparison of product
performance received and expected. Engel et al in Priyambodo
et al., (2012) revealed that consumer satisfaction is an after-purchase
evaluation in which the selected alternative at least produces results
(outcomes) that equal or exceed consumer expectations, while dissatisfaction
arises when the results obtained do not meet consumer expectations. From the
understanding -understanding above, it can be concluded that consumer
satisfaction is the difference in the gap between expectations before purchase
and the performance or results felt after purchase. (Nasruddin,
2023)
Physical
evidence (Tangible) is an ability in a product or company to provide excellent
service to all customers in a concrete way. In the sense that the quality of
the product can be felt in real terms by customers, not hallucinations, then
(in Tjiptono & Chandra 2016, p.163) indicators of
the tangible dimension are modern equipment, facilities that have visual
appeal, employees who look neat and professional , Materials related to
services that have visual appeal. (Tjiptono, 2016)
Empathy
is as a person's ability to understand targets or thoughts and feelings, see
situations from other people's perspectives, this is the ability to know other
people's wishes in certain conditions and situations. The results of the
respondents' answers show that a sense of empathy from administrative staff
such as the intention to serve the interests of students, a friendly attitude,
non-discrimination and respect for students, will significantly increase
student satisfaction. For this reason, it is necessary to increase student
service activities with a greater focus on the service side (Setiawan, 2021)
According
to Hamzyah (Empathy), namely giving sincere and
individual or personal attention given to customers by trying to understand
consumer desires. Every company is expected to have understanding and knowledge
about customers, understand customer specific needs, and have a comfortable operating
time for customers. (HAMZYAH, 2019)
Assurance
or Guarantee is the knowledge, courtesy and ability of company employees to
foster customer trust in the company. According to Parasuraman
in Lupiyoadi (2001) Assurance is the knowledge,
manners and ability of company employees to foster customer trust in the
company. Consists of components including communication, credibility, security,
competence, and courtesy, while
According
to Tjiptono (2007) Assurance includes knowledge,
competence, courtesy and trustworthiness possessed by employees, free from
danger of risk or doubt. (Rahardjo, 2016) Researchers
reviewing the ideas above can conclude that the better the knowledge, courtesy
of employees, and their trustworthy nature so that customers are free from
risk, it will further increase customer satisfaction because Assurance reflects
company competence, friendliness, courtesy to customers and its operation
safety.
In this
study, researchers only focused on three dimensions, namely Tangible, Empathy
and Assurance, but we know that there were several researchers before using
four dimensions and the results were significant, such as research conducted by
(Hamzyah) that: (1) Tangible variables have a
positive (6.757) and significant (0.000) effect on customer satisfaction or it
can be said that tangible has a positive and significant effect on customer
satisfaction. (2) The variable empathy has a positive (3.295) and significant
(0.001) effect on customer satisfaction or it can be said that empathy has a
positive and significant effect on customer satisfaction. (3)����������� The variable that has the dominant
influence on customer satisfaction is tangible (X2), this is obtained from the
beta value based on standardized coefficients, namely 0.523 or 52.3% compared
to other variables with the required significance.
However,
the results of this research were carried out at one of the PT. PLN (Persero) in Enrekang Regency, the
researcher wants to try to conduct research in the telecommunications sector,
namely the Telkomcel Timorleste
Company. Reliability of assurance (Assurance), empathy (Empathy), and tangibles
(Tangibles). One of the strategies that Telkomcel can
use to maintain its position in the Timor Leste
telecommunications market, is because researchers observe market situations and
conditions in Timor Leste. Therefore to find out how
much influence the three dimensions, namely Tangible Empathy and Assurance have
on (Customer Satisfaction) and (Repurchase Intention)
Of all
the dimensions of service quality, all have a positive effect on satisfaction.
However, of all the variables, only empathy has a positive and significant
effect on satisfaction. It can be interpreted that empathy in serving students
such as a friendly attitude and respect for administrative staff in serving
students will contribute to student satisfaction so that it increases
significantly. Furthermore, student satisfaction which increases significantly
for the attention and service provided by administrative staff will contribute
significantly to student intentions to do word of mouth.
The
desires of consumers are always changing. Entrepreneurs are required to conduct
a survey to find out what kind of product strategy should be used to develop
products that can be accepted by consumers. A new product development strategy
must be made that is able to survive and compete with competitors' product
types, so that the company can achieve its goals
Based on
his scientific study, Zungu & Mason (2019) said
that product development is not only important for the success of the product
but also is the key to determining the success of the company. The steps used
in product development are searching for and finding development ideas from
various sources after that think about the company's ability to carry out this development,
if the company feels capable then predict customer demand as the key to the
success of this development. Carry out the development process within the
company (functional specifications) then carry out production of the product
(product specifications). After that, review the design, carry out market
tests, as well as market introductions, and finally carry out periodic
evaluations for the product development process that is accepted by customers.
(Layla Hafni, 2020)
Of all
the activities carried out by a company, it will ultimately lead to the value
that will be given by customers regarding perceived satisfaction. The
definition of consumer satisfaction varies widely and will provide a broader
understanding, while some experts define customer satisfaction as follows:
According to Kotler in (Ang et al., 2012),
satisfaction is the level of feeling at which a person states the results of a
comparison of product (service) performance) is accepted and expected.
According to Chandra, Hafni, Chandra, et al. (2019)
states that consumer satisfaction or dissatisfaction is the consumer's response
to the evaluation of the perceived discrepancy/disconfirmation between previous
expectations (or other performance norms) and the product's actual performance
that is felt after its use (Stefani, 2020).
METHODS
This
study used a cross-sectional approach to determine the timing and frequency of
data collection and processing. When data is collected at one time, processed,
evaluated, and conclusions drawn, this is called using a cross sectional
technique (Indrawti, 2015: 18). The population in
this study were students and lecturers and staff at 10 campuses such as UNTL,
UNPAZ, UNDIL, UNITAL, UCTL, IOB, CRISTAL, ICS, DIT, and ISJB in Timor Leste. This population is estimated at 17,621 people.
��������������� (Indrawati 2015: 164), the sample is people from the
population selected to participate in the research, namely from several
campuses so far Telkom has divided student SimCards
either to be observed, treated, or surveyed about what is being investigated.
The method used in this study is a stratified random sampling approach, meaning
that individuals from the population do not have the same opportunity to be
selected as a sample, regardless of that the researcher chooses several students
to be representative and the researcher uses a 5% margin of error whether they
have a chance the same or not. Meanwhile, the sample strategy for this study
was stratified random sampling. (According to Sugiyono
(2010) proportionate stratified random sampling is a technique used when the
population has members/elements that are not homogeneous and stratified
proportionally. The population of this study is modified based on the number of
subscribers or users of the Estudant Telkomcel simcar, namely students
and / I and lecturers and staff at 10 campuses in Timor Leste
who are using the Telkomcel SIMCARD for the first
time, therefore researchers assess the number of samples in this study to be
200 people, using the slovin formula as follows: n=N/
(1+N e^2) Where:
n = Number of Samples
N = Total Population
e = 7% fault tolerance limit
n=17.621/ (1+ 17.621 x 0.0049) =17.621/ (1+86.3429)=17.621/87.3429
= 201.7451 rounded up to 201
Based on
the results of calculations using the slovin formula,
the minimum sample for this study is 201 respondents. Respondents to this study
were people who had used Telkomcel products at least
once, and to reduce errors in filling out this questionnaire, the researchers
rounded up the number of respondents to 201 respondents.
RESULTS
Questionnaire question items are measuring
instruments (tools) that can test what the research objectives are, so all
statements in a questionnaire are required to measure their validity. Validity
indicates the extent to which a measuring instrument can measure something that
has been determined, so that the greater the validity of a measuring
instrument, the more likely the measuring instrument will fulfill its purpose
or be more oriented to what it should measure (Indawati
2015: 146) .
Validity
Convergent Test Results
Table 1.
Convergent Validity Test Results
Source: Primary data processed in 2022
From
the data table 1 above, it can be seen that the overall value of the loading
factor shows more than > 0.7 so that all of the research variables are
declared valid and can be continued in other research analyses.
Discriminant Test Results
��������������� Based on the Research Objectives
and Methodology Chapter, the initial PLS model in this case is as follows:
Figure 1PLS Initial Model or PLS Stage
��������������� Based
on Figure 4.3.1 above, there are 2 models in this structural model, namely:
1. The influence model of X1, X2, X3 on Y1. So Y1 as endogenous latent
variable, while X1, X2, X3 as exogenous latent
variable.
2. The influence model of X1, X2, X3 and Y1 on Y2. So Y2 as endogenous
latent variable, while X1, X2, X3 and Z as exogenous latent variables.
The constructs
or latent variables in this structural equation include: X1, X2, X3, Y1 and Y2.
Each of these latent variables has indicators or manifest variables in it. Based
on the PLS concept above, the results of the outer model analysis on your data
are as follows: The results of the analysis are as follows:
Figure 2PLS Initial
Model or PLS Stage
Table 2. Outer Loading
Source:
SmartPLS Processing Data Version 3
The
discriminant test results in table 2 present the results of the cross loading
calculation, which shows that the cross loading value of each indicator in the
service assurance variable is above the cross loading value of the other
variables. All values above the threshold are 0.7 so that the research
instrument is said to be discriminantly valid. The
results of obtaining Customer Satisfaction values are greater than 0.7
so that the research instrument is said to be discriminantly
valid. Whereas the Repurchase Intention variable indicator is above the
cross loading value of the other variables. The results of the acquisition of the
Repurchase Intention value above are greater than 0.7 so that the research
instrument is said to be discriminantly valid.
Reliability Test
��������������� Reliability is defined as
something related to the level of trust, reliability, consistency, or stability
of the results of one measurement. Reliability is one of the characteristics
that a good measuring instrument theoretically has a reliability coefficient
between -1 to +1, but a coefficient that is less than zero (0) is meaningless
because the interpretation of reliability always refers to a positive
coefficient (Indawati , 2015:155 ).
Table 1Composite Reliability and Cronbach's Alpha Values
Source:
Data Processing SmartPLS Version 3 Average Variance
Extracted
���������������
Based
on the test results in table 3 the composite reliability value of the Assurance
variable was 0.895 with a Cronbach's Alpha
value of 0.843. On the variable Customer Satisfaction, a
composite reliability value of 0.911 was obtained with a Cronbach's Alpha value
of 0.870. on the Empathy variable, a
composite reliability value
of 0.880 was obtained with a Cronbach's Alpha value of 0.819. The Repurchase
Intention Variable obtained a composite reliability value of 0.913 with
a Cronbach's Alpha value of 0.872. the Tangible
variable obtained a composite reliability value of 0.920 with a
Cronbach's Alpha value of 0.883.
��������������� So it can be interpreted that
all the variables above are said to be reliable because the composite
reliability is greater than 0.7 and Conbach's alpha
is above 0.6, so the questionnaire can produce stable or constant measuring
results. From table 4.2.3 above, all variables with reflective indicators have
an AVE (Average Variance Extracted) value of more than 0.5. It can be
said that all of these variables are valid. Perceived risk and perceived
benefit variables do not use the AVE measure because they are formative
indicator variables.
After testing the outer model that has fulfilled,
then testing the inner model (structural model) is carried out. The inner model
can be evaluated by looking at the r-square (indicator reliability) for the
dependent construct and the t-statistical value of the path coefficient test.
The higher the r-square value means the better the prediction model of the
proposed research model. The path coefficients value indicates the level of
significance in hypothesis testing. Indicator
reliability aims to assess whether latent variable measurement indicators are
reliable or not. You do this by evaluating the results of the outer loading of
each indicator. A loading value above 0.7 indicates that the construct can
explain more than 50% of the indicator variance (Wong KK, 2013; Sarstedt et al., 2017).
Source: SmartPLS
Processing Data Version 3
Based on table 4.3.1. It can be seen that the
R-Square of the Customer Satisfaction variable can be explained by the
service quality variables namely Tangible, Empathy, Assurance of
40.40% and 59.60% influenced by other variables not used in this study such as Responsiveness,
Reliability and the model is classified as moderate. While the R-Square
value of the Repurchase Intention variable is 49.20%. it
shows that the Repurchase Intention variable can be explained by service
quality variables namely Tangible, empathy, Assurance of 49.20%
and 50.80% influenced by other variables that are not used such as Responsiveness,
Reliability
Therefore, it refers to the rule of thumb if the
value indicates an R-square model of 0.67 (Strong), 0.33 (Moderate) and 0.19
(Weak) (Chin, 1988) so this research model is classified as moderate. However,
the results from Table 4.3.1 show that, the two variables such as Responsiveness,
Reliability have a greater influence on the affected variables than the
factors or dimensions derived from the model studied.
Source: Taken from Outer Stage data
So based on the table of F Square values above,
the effect size that is small or negligible is the effect of X2 on Y1 and Y2.
The large size effect is the effect of X1 on Y1, while the other effects are
moderate.
Table 6. Fornell-Larcker Criteria
Table 6 Fornell-Larcker
criteria shows the AVE root value of each construct or variable. The AVE roots
are indicated by numbers marked in yellow in the table. The AVE root value is
then compared with the model's R-square value. It is known that the R-square
model has a value of 0.742. From table 4.17 it can be seen that the AVE root
score for each variable is greater than the R-square value. Thus all variables
are declared valid and can be used for further tests. Discriminant validity can
also be known from the cross loading score or cross validity where the
indicator value of a variable to the variable itself must be greater than the
correlation of the indicator to other variables. The cross loading score is
known from the calculation results using the PLS algorithm technique. Outer
Loading Table 4.2.2 Outer Loading calculation can be seen from the attachment
From the Outer Loading calculation results it is known that the indicators of
all variables are valid.
Table 7. Q2 Predictive Relevance
Source: SmartPLS
Processing Data Version 3
Based on table 7 above, it can be seen that the
variability of the Y1 Customer Satisfaction construct is 0.283.
Furthermore, the construct Repurchase Intention Y2 is 0.345. Therefore
it refers to the rule of thumb chin (1998) if the value of Q �2 >
0 then the model has predictive relevance so from these results it shows
that this model has predictive relevance.
Source: SmartPLS
Processing Data Version 3
Furthermore, measuring the path coefficients
between constructs is carried out to see the significance and strength of the
relationship and also to test the hypothesis. Path coefficients values range
from -1 to +1. The closer to the +1 value, the stronger the relationship
between the two constructs. A relationship that is closer to -1 indicates that
the relationship is negative (Sarstedt et al., 2017).
The results of the analysis at the inner level are as follows: (The calculated
T value of the loading factor and path coefficient).
Figure 3Calculated T
value from loading factor and path coefficient
And if
what is displayed is the p value of the loading factor and the path
coefficient, it is as follows:
Figure 4the p value of
the loading factor and the path coefficient
The
Output Path Coefficient as shown in the picture above is to see the magnitude
of the direct effect (DIRECT EFFECT) of
each independent (exogenous) variable on the dependent (endogenous) variable.
1. Tangible and Customer Satisfaction
The magnitude of the parameter coefficient for the
Tangible variable on the Customer
Satisfaction Variable of 0.377 which means there is a Tangible positive
influence on Customer
Satisfaction Or it can be interpreted that the better the Tangible value then Customer Satisfaction will increase.
Increase of one tangible unit will also increase Customer Satisfaction by
37.7%. Based on calculations using bootstrap or resampling, where the results
of the Tangible estimation coefficient test for Customer
Satisfaction bootstrap results are 0.371 with a t-count value
of 4.791 greater than t-table (1.64) then the p-value is 0.000 <0.05 so
Accept H1 or which means a direct influence Tangible to Customer Satisfaction statistically
significant or significant . Judging from the previous research data by Caecilia Soares (2018) that:
Tangible has a significant effect on Customer Satisfaction. Because the
resulting t-count value of 9,004 is greater than t-table (1.64) with a
significance level of 95% and a confidence level of 5%. Based on this analysis
it can be concluded that the tangible variable as a dimension for strengthening
service quality at Telkomcel Timor Leste, from these results shows that the reduction in
frequency has an impact on customer trust decreasing from 95% to 37.7% meaning
that the tangible being studied here is the Student Simcard
part of (Mobile Network Operator (MNO) will have a direct impact on customer
satisfaction, especially students /I in Timor Leste
who use Telkomcel Student SimCards.
2.
Empathy and
Customer Satisfaction
The magnitude of the parameter coefficient for the
Empathy variable on Customer
Satisfaction of 0.103 which means there is no positive effect of Empathy towards Customer Satisfaction. Or it can be
interpreted that the Empathy value is getting worse then Customer Satisfaction will decrease.
Decrease one unit of Empathy will also reduce Customer Satisfaction by 10.03%. Based on calculations using bootstrap
or resampling, where the test results estimate the Empathy coefficient of Customer
Satisfaction bootstrap results are 0.103 with a t-count value
of 1.488 smaller t-table (1.64) then the p value is 0.137 > 0.05 so Accept
H0 is not significant or does not have a direct effect on Empathy on Customer Satisfaction is not significant
or not statistically significant. The results of this statistic show
that, meaning this SimCard student, telkomcel distributes it for free and with a data package
of $ 25 per month and free calls to fellow student simcards,
so the customer emapi will be higher and customer
satisfaction will also increase automatically.
3.
Assurance and
Customer Satisfaction
The magnitude of the parameter coefficient for the
Assurance variable on Customer
Satisfaction of 0.296 which means there is a positive influence of
Assurance on Customer
Satisfaction Or it can be interpreted that the better the Assurance
value then
Customer satisfaction will increase. Increase of one unit of Assurance will also increase Customer Satisfaction by
29.6%. Based on calculations using bootstrap or resampling, where the results
of the Assurance estimation coefficient test on Customer
Satisfaction bootstrap results are 0.296 with a t-count value
of 3.946 greater than t-table (1.64) then the p-value is 0.000 <0.05 so
Accept H1 or which means the direct influence of Assurance to Customer Satisfaction statistically
significant or significant . From these statistical results it proves
that Assurance has a significant impact on Customer Satisfaction ,
which means that, in the process of distributing SimCadr
students, Telkomcel does this formally, first making
an application letter to the university, and the university answers based on a
request from Telkomcel, and based on data - This
student data that Telkomcel distributes this SimCard is guaranteed not to be published because there are
already regulations that have been implemented by Telkomcel.
4.
Tangible and
Repurchase Intentions
The magnitude of the parameter coefficient for the
Tangible variable on Repurchase
Intention of 0.246, which means there is a positive influence on the
Tangible variable on the Repurchase
Intention variable . Or it can be interpreted that the better the Tangible
value, the Repurchase Intention will increase. Increase of one tangible
unit will
also increase Repurchase Intention by 24.6%. Based on calculations using
bootstrap or resampling, where the results of the Tangible estimation
coefficient test for Repurchase
Intention bootstrap results are 0.246 with a t-count value
of 3.284 greater than t-table (1.64) then the p-value is 0.001 <0.05 so
Accept H1 or which means a direct influence Tangible to Repurchase Intention statistically
significant or significant . Based on this analysis it can be concluded
that the tangible variable as a dimension for strengthening service quality at Telkomcel Timor Leste, from these
results shows that the reduction in frequency has an impact on Repurchase
Intention of 24.6% meaning that the tangible being studied here is the Simcard Student part of (Mobile Network Operator) MNO will
have a direct impact on Repurchase Intention, especially students /I in
Timor Leste who use Telkomcel
Student SimCards.
5.
Empathy and
Repurchase Intention
The magnitude of the parameter coefficient for the
Empathy variable on Repurchase
Intention of 0.117 which means there is no positive influence on the
Empathy variable on the Repurchase
Intention variable . Or it can be interpreted that the value of Empathy is
getting worse then Repurchase
Intention will decrease. Decrease one unit of Empathy will also reduce Repurchase Intention by
11.7%. Based on calculations using bootstrap or resampling, where the test
results estimate the Empathy coefficient of Repurchase
Intention bootstrap results are 0.117 with a t-count value
of 1.589 smaller t-table (1.64) then the p-value is 0.113 > 0.05 so Accept
H0 is not significant or which means there is no direct influence of empathy to Repurchase Intention is not significant or
not significant. The results of this statistic show that, it means that
this SimCard student, Telkomcel
distributes it for free and with a data package of $ 25 per month and free
calls to fellow SIM Card Students, so the emapi of
customers will be higher to request or request and the spread of information on
the distribution of Simcar is also fast from students
one to another student is also fast, so the demand for student SimCards will increase accordingly.
6.
Assurance and
Repurchase Intention
The magnitude of the parameter coefficient for the
Assurance variable on Repurchase Intention is 0.203, which means
that there is a positive influence on Assurance on Repurchase Intention. Or it can be
interpreted that the better the Assurance value then Repurchase Intention will increase.
Increase of one unit of Assurance will also increase Repurchase Intention by
20.3%. Based on calculations using bootstrap or resampling, where the results
of the Assurance estimation coefficient test on Repurchase
Intention bootstrap results are 0.203 with a t-count value
of 2.767 greater than t-table (1.64) then the p-value is 0.006 <0.05 so
Accept H1 or which means the direct influence of Assurance to Repurchase Intention statistically
significant or significant . From the results of this statistic proves
that Assurance has a significant effect on Repurchase Intention,
which means. the process of distributing student SimCadr,
this is Telkomcel doing it formally, first making an
application letter to the University, and the university answered based on a
request from Telkomcel, and based on the student data
that Telkomcel did the distribution of this SimCard guaranteed it will not be published because it already
exists regulations that have been implemented by Telkomcel.
So from this process requests for student SimCards
each period run well, and efficiently.
7. Customer Satisfaction and Repurchase Intention
The magnitude of the parameter coefficient for the
variable Customer Satisfaction on Repurchase Intention is 0.318,
which means there is a positive influence on Customer Satisfaction on Customer Satisfaction. Or it can be
interpreted that the better the value of Customer Satisfaction then Repurchase Intention will increase. An
increase in one unit of Customer Satisfaction will also increase Repurchase
Intention by 31.8%. Based on calculations using bootstrap or resampling,
where the test results of the estimated Customer Satisfaction coefficient of Repurchase
Intention bootstrap results are 0.318 with a t-count value
of 4.839 greater than t-table (1.64) then the p-value is 0.000 <0.05 so
Accept H1 or which means the direct effect of Customer Satisfaction on Repurchase
Intention is statistically significant or significant . So based on
statistical results that Customer Satisfaction has a very significant
influence on Repurchase Intention, which means that. In this
three-dimensional study, one dimension is not significant for Variavel Y1 and Y2, meaning that empathy does not have a
direct impact on these two variables because what is examined here is a student
SimCard with a tag of $25/month and free calls to
fellow SimCard students, so customers always empathetic
to telkomcel products. And two other dimensions have
a significant influence on the variables Y1 and Y2, meaning that the tangible
and assurance variables directly affect the two variables. When there is
a reduction in frequency, it will have an impact on customer satisfaction and
by itself customer interest in repurchasing Telkomcel
products will also decrease.
Table 9. Hypothesis Conclusions
Source: Taken from Inner Stage data processed by
researchers
CONCLUSION
Based on the results of
the research and discussion that has answered the formulation of the problem
regarding the influence of Service Quality in this study, researchers only take
three dimensions of Servqual, namely Tangible, Assurance,
and Empathy for Repurchase Intention with Customer Satisfaction as an
intervening variable in Tekomcel products in Timor Leste, so it can be concluded as follows: (1) The
results of the Tangible estimation coefficient test on Customer
Satisfaction bootstrap results are 0.371 with a t-count value
of 4.791 greater than t-table (1.64) then the p value is 0.000 <0.05 so
Accept H1 or which means a direct influence Tangible
to Customer Satisfaction statistically
significant or significant . Based on this analysis it can be concluded
that the tangible variable as a dimension to directly influence service quality
at Telkomcel Timor Leste,
from these results shows that the frequency reduction has an impact on trust of
37.7% meaning that the tangible being studied here is the Simcard
Student part of (Mobile Network) Operator) MNO will have a direct impact on
customer satisfaction, especially students /I in Timor Leste
who use Telkomcel Student SimCards.
(2) The test results of the estimation coefficient of Empathy towards Customer
Satisfaction bootstrap results are 0.103 with a t-count value
of 1.488 smaller t-table (1.64) then the p value is 0.137 > 0.05 so Accept
H0 is not significant or does not have a direct effect on Empathy on Customer Satisfaction is not significant
or not statistically significant. The results of this statistic show
that, meaning this SimCard student, telkomcel distributes it for free and with a data package
of $ 25 per month and free calls to fellow student simcards,
so the customer empathy will be higher and customer satisfaction will also
increase automatically. (3) Assurance estimation coefficient test
results against Customer
Satisfaction bootstrap results are 0.296 with a t-count value
of 3.946 greater than t-table (1.64) then the p-value is 0.000 <0.05 so
Accept H1 or which means the direct influence of Assurance to Customer Satisfaction statistically
significant or significant . From these statistical results it proves
that Assurance has a significant impact on Customer Satisfaction ,
which means that, in the process of distributing SimCadr
students, Telkomcel does this formally, first making
an application letter to the university, and the university answers based on a
request from Telkomcel, and based on data - this
student data that Telkomcel distributes SimCards to students and lecturers at the university, this
data is guaranteed not to be published because there are already regulations
that have been implemented by Telkomcel. (4) The
results of the Tangible estimation coefficient test on Repurchase
Intention bootstrap results are 0.246 with a t-count value
of 3.284 greater than t-table (1.64) then the p-value is 0.001 <0.05 so
Accept H1 or which means the direct influence of Tangible Variables to Repurchase Intention statistically
significant or significant . Based on this analysis it can be concluded
that the tangible variable as a dimension for strengthening service quality at Telkomcel Timor Leste, from these
results shows that the reduction in frequency has an impact on Repurchase
Intention of 24.6% meaning that the tangible being studied here is the Simcard Student part of (Mobile Network Operator) MNO will
have a direct impact on Repurchase Intention, especially students /I in
Timor Leste who use the Telkomcel
Student SimCard. (5) the test
results of the estimation coefficient of Empathy towards Repurchase
Intention bootstrap results are 0.117 with a t-count value
of 1.589 smaller t-table (1.64) then the p-value is 0.113 > 0.05 so Accept
H0 is not significant or which means there is no direct influence of empathy to Repurchase Intention is not significant or
not significant . The results of this statistic show that, it means that
this SimCard student, Telkomcel
distributes it for free and with a data package of $ 25 per month and free
calls to fellow SIM Card Students, so the emapi of
customers will be higher to request or request and the spread of information on
the distribution of Simcar is also fast from students
one to another student is also fast, so the demand for student SimCards will increase accordingly. (6) Assurance estimation
coefficient test results against Repurchase
Intention bootstrap results are 0.203 with a t-count value
of 2.767 greater than t-table (1.64) then the p-value is 0.006 <0.05 so
Accept H1 or which means the direct influence of Assurance to Repurchase Intention statistically
significant or significant . From the results of this statistic proves
that Assurance has a significant effect on Repurchase Intention,
which means. the process of distributing student SimCadr,
this is Telkomcel doing it formally, first making an
application letter to the University, and the university answered based on a
request from Telkomcel, and based on the student data
that Telkomcel did the distribution of this SimCard guaranteed it will not be published because it
already exists regulations that have been implemented by Telkomcel.
So from this process requests for student SimCards
each period run well, and efficiently. (7) the test results of the estimation
coefficient of Customer Satisfaction against Repurchase
Intention bootstrap results are 0.318 with a t-count value
of 4.839 greater than t-table (1.64) then the p-value is 0.000 <0.05 so
Accept H1 or which means the direct effect of Customer Satisfaction on Repurchase
Intention is statistically significant or significant . So based on
statistical results that Customer Satisfaction has a very significant
influence on Repurchase Intention, which means that. In this
three-dimensional study, one dimension is not significant for Variavel Y1 and Y2, meaning that empathy does not have a
direct impact on these two variables because what is examined here is a student
SimCard with a tag of $25/month and free calls to
fellow SimCard students, so customers always
empathetic to telkomcel products. And two other
dimensions have a significant influence on the variables Y1 and Y2, meaning
that the tangible and assurance variables directly affect the two
variables. When there is a reduction in frequency, it will have an impact on
customer satisfaction and by itself customer interest in repurchasing Telkomcel products will also decrease.
REFERENCES
Agusman, DM (2019).
The Influence of the Dimensions of Service Quality and Customer Satisfaction on
Repurchase Intention of Customers of Rocky Plaza Hotel Padang. Advances in
Economics Business and Management Research, 401.
Arsyanti, NM (2016).
Analysis of the Influence of Product Quality, Service Quality and Product
Diversity on Customer Satisfaction and Their Impact on Repurchase Intentions
(Study at Shopastelle Online Store, Semarang).
DIPONEGORO JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT.
Bernardo, I. (2019). Effect of Website Design
Quality, Service Quality, Trust and Satisfaction. Indonesian Journal of
Management, Page; 88.
Bernardo, I. (2019). The Effect of Website Design
Quality, Service Quality, Trust and Satisfaction on Repurchase Intention (Case
Study: Tokopedia.Com). Indonesian Management Journal.
Cendriono, N. (2018).
The Effect of Service Quality on Dawet Jabung Repurchases Seen From Customer Satisfaction as a
Mediating Variable. Journal of Accounting and Tax.
Chandra. (2020). Service Quality, Consumer
Satisfaction,. Jl. Sokajaya
No. 59, Purwokerto: Cv Irdh.
Dr. Teddy Chandra, SM (2017). Service Quality,
Consumer Satisfaction, and Consumer Loyalty: A Theoretical Review. Indonesia: Cv Irdh.
Dr. Teddy Chandra, SM (2020). Service Quality,
Consumer, Satisfaction, and Consumer, Loyalty: Theoretical Review. Malang: Cv Irdh.
Firmansyah, A. (2017).
Marketing Globalization (Marketing Globalization). Yogyakarta: Publishing Group
Cv Budi Utama.
Halima Tussaadia
Ternate, FN (2020). Analysis of the Effect of Service Quality on Consumer
Repurchases. Journal of Tambusai Education.
Hamzyah. (2019). the
Effect of Responsiveness, Tangible, and Empathy on Customer Service
Satisfaction at Pt. Pln (Persero)
in Enrekang Regency. Journal of Profitability Faculty
of Economics and Business, Hal: 131,132.
Indriana, S.
(2021/2022). The Influence of Service Quality, Marketing Mix, and Customer Satisfaction
on Repurchase Intention at Supermarkets (Case Study of Proposed Improvements to
Griya Pahlawan. Proceedings
of Dissemination of Fti.
Irma, A. (2020). The Influence of Tangible and
Responsiveness on Customer Satisfaction at Garuda Plaza Hotel. Faculty of
Economics, State University of Medan (Niagawa).
Jessica, A. (2017). The Influence of Reliability,
Responsiveness, Assurance, and Empathy on Flosland
Consumer Satisfaction. Journal of Management and Business Start-Up.
Kamal, RI (2022). The Effect of Service Quality on
Repurchase Intention through Customer Satisfaction at Q-Life Clinic Surabaya.
Journal of Economics and Business.
Kotler, P. (20216). Marketing Management. London:
Pearson Education.
Layla Hafni, SS (2020).
Service Quality, Consumer Satisfaction,. In SM Dr.
Teddy Chandra, Service Quality, Consumer Satisfaction, (Page. 117 - 120). Jl. Sokajaya No. 59, Purwokerto, New
Villa Bukit Sengkaling C9 No. 1 Malang: T Cv Irdh.
Martha, L. (2022). The Influence of Tangible, Emphaty, Responsiveness, Assurance, and Reliability on
Customer Loyalty at Hotel Bunda Padang.
Multidisciplinary Scientific Journal.
Mensah, I. (2018). Effects Of
Service Quality And Customer Satisfaction On Repurchase Intention In
Restaurants On University Of Capecoast Campus. Journal
of Tourism, Heritage & Services Marketing.
Nasruddin. (2023). the
Influence of Service Quality on Customer Satisfaction in Go-Jek
Services in Palopo City. Journal of Nitro Financial
Banking Management (Jmpkn), E-Issn
2620-7524, P-Issn 2620-780x, p;30.
Purbohastuti, AW (2020).
Increasing Interest in Buying Shopee Products Through.
Journal of Applied Business.
Purbohastuti, AW (2020).
Increasing Interest in Buying Shopee Products through
Celebrity Endorsers. Journal of Applied Business, 45.
R. Nur Budi Setiawan, SP (Volume 18, No. 4, October 2021). Service
Quality, Student Satisfaction and Word Of Mouth. Journal of Business
Management, Hal; 535.
Rahardjo, R. (2016).
Analysis of the Effect of Service Quality. Diponegoro Journal Of Management.
Resti, IM (2021). Customer
Satisfaction, Service Quality, Product Variants, and Product Quality. Journal
of Business Management.
Ricky, R. (2016). Analysis of the Influence of
Service Quality on Customer Satisfaction Premier Auto Detailing Semarang.
Diponegoro Journal Of Management.
Ritonga, HM (2018).
Marketing Management, Concept & Strategy. In ME Fikri,
Marketing Management, Concepts & Strategies (Page 2). Bandung: Isbn 978-602-0746-18-0.
Setiawan, RN (2021).
Service Quality, Student Satisfaction and Word Of Mouth. Journal of Business
Management, Hal; 535.
Soares, C. (2018).
The Effect of Service Quality on Repurchase Intention with Customer
Satisfaction as Intervening. Telkom University, 63.
Stefani. (2020). Service Quality, Consumer
Satisfaction. In SM Dr. Teddy Chandra, Service Quality, Consumer Satisfaction,
(Page 43). Jl. Sokajaya No. 59, Purwokerto:
Cv Irdh.
Suyani, YE (2021).
Personal Selling and Buying Interest in the Insurance Industry. Journal of
Business Management I.
Telkomcel. (2020 and
2021). Annual Report AR. Indonesian: Telkom.
Tjiptono, F. (2016).
Management, Customer Satisfaction. CV Andi Offset.
Wibowo, SE (2013).
The Effect of Perceptions of Service Quality on Repurchase Intentions at Gramedia Bookstores, Yogyakarta. Economic Journal.
.