MEDIA RELATIONS AND
MINORITY GROUPS AN A SOCIOLOGICAL REGULATION (WAHABI'S EXISTENCE IN INDONESIA)
Hasan Sazali*, Idawati, Hota Sari
Faculty of Social and
Political Science, Universitas Islam Negeri Sumatera Utara, Indonesia
Email: [email protected]*
Article
Information |
|
ABSTRACT |
Received:
January 20, 2023 Revised:
January 30, 2023 Approved: February 21, 2023 Online: February 24, 2023 |
|
In the context of the right to religious freedom. Minority groups have
not received serious attention from the upper class, this is evident in the
many minority rights that must be fought for. Minority groups are often
overlooked or underrepresented in the media, most minority groups play less
of a role in television programs. Minority groups are often misinterpreted
through prejudices held by the majority. The position of the Indonesian mass
media as a social institution in relation to society is very important, where
the position of the media has a very power that can be considered to make a
better living society. The wahabi
movement is sometimes also associated with salafist groups referring to
salafist clerics (earlier Ulama), Wahabi or Salafi marking the movement of
Islamic conservatism. This movement is associated by some circles with
various radical movements, considering that its approach is often to
fictionalize or silence others, so the term Wahabi as a pejorative form, a
term that contains negative meanings. The study aims to find out relations of
media and minority groups to the existence of Wahhabism in Indonesia. Library research
method is used in this
study. From the findings in
this article which uses a literature study, the relationship between media
and minority groups in the existence of Wahabi, it can be seen that the media
has experienced media success in partiality towards minority groups. Wahabi
who feel part of a minority group, by building and establishing relationships
with the media, succeed in bringing about new changes, through the media,
their guidance as a minority group their rights are successfully fulfilled. |
Keywords |
|
|
Media Relations; Minority Groups; Wahhabism |
|
INTRODUCTION
As
the New Order regime fell, various important events occurred in Indonesia, one
of which was violence against minority groups. Minority groups have always been
in a weak position and have become natural targets of genocide and persecution.
In modern era which is considered as a period of relative tolerance and
rationality, we also witness that minorities are sometimes the targets of
discrimination and repression (Widiyanto, 2014).
Various acts of discrimination committed against minority groups have resulted
in violations of human rights and crimes against humanity. In the context of
the right to freedom of religion. Minority groups apparently have not received
serious attention from the top, this is evidenced by the many minority rights
that must be fought for. Minority groups are often neglected or
underrepresented in the media, most minority groups do not have a role in
television programs. Minority groups are often misunderstood through the
prejudices held by the majority, ethnic minorities are
generally portrayed in the media negatively so that the rights of these
minorities are ignored (Cho et al., 2012).
Media
is a tool used today. Through the media we can interact with other individuals,
there are various kinds of media for communication, this is of course adjusted
to the individual's ability to access the media. Media technology greatly
impacts the activities of practitioners and journalists in enhancing good
cooperative relations (McAllister &
Taylor, 2012).
The position of the Indonesian mass media as a social institution in relation
to society is very important, where the position of the media has a force that
can be calculated to bring society to a better standard of living. Media
relations or media relations are relations that are built and developed with
the media to reach the public to achieve individual or group goals. The general
objectives of media relations are: 1) increasing awareness of individuals and
groups, 2) changing public or societal attitudes, 3) encouraging actions that
support the interests of groups and organizations. The existence of the media
is now a necessity for society. As social beings, people must interact whose
capital is communication. Communication in today's modern era is very dependent
on technology, print, analog and digital broadcasts, as well as both fixed and
mobile telephones. As well as online connections are also increasing. So that
everyone's dependence on the media makes that person want to access the media
at any time to fulfill their information space. Media has been proven to have a
significant influence in the real world related to minority issues, such as
individual attitudes, the rights of certain groups, many research results of
scholars have described how the media and minorities cover issues related to
the same problem, this
issue becomes a hot topic of discussion (Bleich et al., 2015).
Wahhabism
first entered Indonesia in the 1980s, the arrival of Wahhabism to Indonesia was
due to the main encouragement of the establishment of the LIPPIA institution (Institute
of Islamic and Arabic Sciences) which LIPPIA is a branch of Imam Muhammad Bin
Saud University, Riyadh in Indonesia. Then the LIPPIA alumni, after returning
from Arabiya studies, they conveyed their da'wah regarding salafi and wahhabi
teachings in the community where they live, LIPPIA itself was formed thanks to
funds from Saudi Arabia, apart from creating salafi wahhabi dakwah cadres,
Saudi Arabia also routinely provides scholarship assistance every year to
Indonesian students to study in Saudi Arabia. In Indonesia, the Wahhabi school
is growing and developing well, because the Indonesian government does not
question the existence of this school of thought (Aisha, 2022).
Thus, it is considered that media relations are very important in fighting for
minority rights to the existence of a group, the rights that can be asserted by
these minority groups are: (1) the right to internal restrictions, (2) the
right to external protection. Internal restrictions relating to rights that may
be granted by a group to its members aim to prevent the group from
destabilizing. Meanwhile, external protection relates to rights that may be
granted by a group to the wider community. It can be emphasized that the rights
of minorities in Indonesia are in the form of general rights of citizenship and
special rights as citizenship (Widiyanto, 2014).
In relation to this problem, what is discussed in this article is examining the relations
of media and minority groups to the existence of Wahhabism in Indonesia
METHODS
The
study in this article uses the library research method, which according to
Webster's New International dictionary research is a careful and critical
investigation and searches for facts and principles; a very clever
investigation to determine something. In library research, more than serving
the functions mentioned to obtain research data. The characteristics of the
author's library research are not going anywhere, except that they only deal
directly with materials and sources that come from the library. Strictly
speaking, library research only limits research activities to the process of
searching, collecting library collection materials without the need for field
research. The materials needed in this research are in the form of books,
journals, and library archives related to research problems, as well as
documentation, historical materials, collections, manuscripts, all of which
have been classified according to research needs.
The
steps taken in this study are: preparing completeness, primary and secondary
sources, in the form of materials related to the articles studied, in the form
of books and articles from international online journals, then developing a
framework by classifying the materials what is obtained is in the form of
online books and articles, reading and recording books and articles related to
the study problem under study to be summarized as needed material according to
the problem, finally followed by the process of analyzing data as the findings
of the study results concluding the study results in the form of findings.
Figure 1. Library Study Work Steps
RESULTS
In
analyzing the problems in this article, a theoretical conceptual framework is
developed which is used as a measurable, systematic, and objective analytical
tool to look at the relations of the media and minority groups towards the
existence of Wahhabism in Indonesia.
The
concept of media relations is media relations with all community groups, media
relations play an important role in development. Media relations function to
unite like-minded groups to articulate needs, put pressure on the government,
thus the function of media relations places the practice of public relations
with the government in achieving development goals (Taylor, 2000).
In a 1969 editorial in Television Quarterly, Communications scholar Cedric C.
Clark. (now known as Syed Muh M. Khatib) writes that minorities often
experience predictable stages of treatment in media portrayals, especially on
television. Clark suggests there are four stages of minority representation: (1) not
recognized, that certain minority groups are not recognized by the media, (2) mockingly,
certain minority characters are portrayed as stupid, silly, lazy, irrational,
or simply ridiculous, (3)
in egulations, certain minority
figures are presented as enforcers or managers of dominant group norms, and (4) respect,
the minority group in question is described as no different from other groups (Fitzgerald, 2010).
The
reform period gave birth to press freedom in 1999, the ministry of
information, Soeharto's state apparatus for media censorship, officially
facilitated media liberalization, this encouraged the rise of imported films,
literature, fashion, and music, which sparked a moral panic among many
organizations and activists Muslims who consider the representation of a
hedonistic lifestyle as a product of westernization and secularization. Media
liberalization makes the media a creative space for society, so that media
relations are now an important thing in the continuity of people's lives (Abdullah & Mohamed
Osman, 2018).
The
concept of a minority group is: etymologically a minority is the lesser part or
number, or the number that makes up less than half of the whole. Thus minority
people say that they are a minority because they are not part of the majority (Davis, 2009).
Members of minority groups are different from other groups, depictions of
minority groups are more likely to be presented as different groups in customs,
behavior, completely with distinctive differences (Zhao &
Postiglione, 2010).
The
term minority refers to various definitions, where each definition regulates
policies on how to deal with minorities, in 1950, the UN Human Rights
Sub-Commission defined minorities as, a non-dominant group, in a population
that has and wants to preserve ethnic, religious traditions or characteristics or a stable language that is
very different from the others in a study revealed that discrimination is one
of the significant sources of identity threats that often motivate minorities
to avoid the majority (Saleem &
Ramasubramanian, 2019):
A
group of citizens of a State, constituting a numerical minority and in a
non-dominant position in that State, endowed with ethnic, religious or
linguistic characteristics distinct from the majority of the population, are in
solidarity with one another, mutually motivated, implicitly, by the collective
will to survival goal is to achieve equality with the majority in facts and
law. From this definition, there are several problems faced by minorities,
between the various types of minorities and the problems they face, such as
differences in the types of religious minorities that are different from the
problems faced by racial minorities, but basically the two problems faced by
these minorities are demanding the state to provide equality of minorities as
felt by the majority. In this case, achieving equality with the majority can be
interpreted as a reference to individual rights, without considering the
collective rights of minorities, and thus, such a policy of strengthening
individualism can deliberately violate what has been the main goal of
minorities to preserve their collective will.
There
are several types of minorities in the world, first: national minorities, such
as Israeli Arabs, who happen to be the majority in other countries. Second,
stateless national minorities, such as the Kurds in Syria and Turkey, who have
their own unique language aspire to establish their own State. Major religious
minorities, such as Sunni Muslims in India, who form the majority in other
states. The four minor minorities who happen to have their own State, such as
Jews, Russians, who feel affiliated with and even protected by the State of
Israel. Fifth, there are racial minorities, such as African-American minorities
in the United States and Europe, who face their own types of racial
discrimination. The six minor religious minorities, such as the Druze in Syria
or the Yazidis in Iraq (Halabi, 2020).
Media
diversity originates from cultural diversity and cultural practices, this
relates to small-scale specific empirical studies on the media or certain
minorities which are major issues in debate among society today, in this case
the media is directly involved in voicing minority rights. The results of the
study show that the fertility of minority groups assumes that often with
assimilation going on, fertility between the majority and the minority will be
covered. While the difference between the majority and the minority usually
occurs as a temporary phenomenon and is often interpreted in terms of the
social, demographic, economic characteristics of the minority group, it is this
difference that makes the rights of the minority neglected (Goldscheider &
Uhlenberg, 1969).
The
position of religious minorities, Muslim minorities numerically the status of a
small group/minority produces forms of identity that differ specifically in
their positioning in relation to the majority. In fact, without realizing it, the
minority position has had a lot of influence in contributing thoughts in the
fields of norms, religion, politics, economics, social and culture. The
influence of Muslim minority status on their identity and politics has been
established in scholarly work. Muslim national leaders began to reverse an
earlier process of religious change marked by a strong Wahhabi/ Salafi rebellion against the
established Sufi-based order. Since around the 1190s, Muslim and Islamic
identities began to change with Muslims identifying more closely with their
religion (Mihlar, 2019).
At
a glance Muhammad Ibn 'abd Wahhab was born in the Ujainah (Nejd) village, the
eastern region of Saudi Arabia, his father was a qadi, he obtained knowledge in
fiqh and other Islamic sciences, then he migrated to the Hijaz. In this country
Muhammad Ibn 'abd al-Wahhab obtained religious knowledge from the scholars in
Mecca and Medina. After a long time demanding that he return to his homeland,
and then teaching his understandings, especially regarding knowledge, it was
from here that he began to have many followers, many of whom came from outside
Ujainah, even though he received many challenges, including from his own
family. Because his teachings caused a lot of commotion, he moved to Dar'iah, a
hamlet where Muhammad ibn Sa'ud (King Faisal's great-grandmother) lived who had
accepted the Wahhabi teachings, and even became its protector and broadcaster.
It was from this support that the teachings of al-Wahhab spread and became
stronger. Because a theoretical person he always develops his thoughts. And
finally in 1773 he and his followers were able to occupy Riyadh. And in 1787 he
died, but his teachings still live and take the form of a stream known as
Wahhabism. Al-Wahhab, the founder of the Wahhabi movement, is very prominent in
Saudi Arabia. He is an Islamic figure who was very influential by the religious
experience of Ibn Taimiya in particular and the Hanbali school of thought in
general. Therefore, it is not surprising that in his movement, he focuses a lot
on purifying the faith (Mangasing, 2008).
In
Indonesia the term wahhabi is used in an inappropriate way. While it can be
used for individuals and organizations that follow theological teachings and
Abd-Alwahhab, it is more general in a much broader sense for those who denounce
interpretations of Islam. Political change is only one part of a wider Islamist
agenda (Woodward et al., 2010).
The development of the Wahhabi Salafi group in Indonesia is supported by Saudi
Arabia through an international agency channeling donations to the group, so
that they can develop their understanding in various ways, one of which is by
establishing madrasas and mosques, with the aim that these madrasas will be
able to convey messages to all Indonesian audiences. about their movement, that
this movement is the first and foremost Saudi institution from which salafism
was transmitted to Indonesia. This is where Indonesian Muslims know this
movement (Jahroni, 2020).
Wahhabi salafi also formed Islamic foundations and media so that they could
easily inform various useful activities to the community, so that through media
the community would become more familiar with this movement.
Relationship between the media and
minority groups towards the existence of Wahhabism
Whether we realize it or not, the phenomenon of the fall
of the new order regime in May 1998 marked the arrival of an almost arbitrary
euporia of freedom. And for the media, this is the first time, for 30 years,
that the mass media has experienced almost unlimited freedom. Starting from
mainstream media and alternative media, appearing with those that carry
religious messages, from ekstream to elegant, all the expressions of diversity
are present to adorn the public and display the identity of its adherents. But the
representation of identity that appears in the symbolic order of the media must
sometimes be understood as a social construct or ideology that fights behind
journalistic practices or media performance. In the context of Islamic media,
the media plays an important role as a mouthpiece for alternative discourse as
well as a symbol of resistance to the dominant and hegemonic ideology. Any
information conveyed through the media will be able to change public opinion, .
The presence of new media not only brings change, but is also a challenge, one
of the existence of media ethics, such as there are various hate speeches
directed at minorities. For this reason, it is important for minority groups to
establish good relations with the media, because the media is considered
capable of being a place of defense and protection for minority groups. Based
on a number of literature studies that, minorities need to get protection
through the media in the form of establishing relations between the media and
minority circles, the wahabi movement is sometimes also associated with
salafist groups that refer to salaf clerics (earlier Ulama), Wahabi or Salafi
marked the movement of Islamic conservatism. This movement is associated by
some circles with various radical movements, considering that its approach is
often cendrung to fictionalize or silence others, so the term Wahabi as a
pejorative form, a term that cendrung contains negative meanings. Relations
with the media are not often classified as a management function in public
relations, establishing and maintaining relations with the media is a very
important activity, most texts on media relations show a positive relationship
between the media and minority groups as seen from the messages conveyed by the
media about minority groups proven information that is conveyed openly, and
armed with honesty so that the media is believed to be able to provide information on the existence of
minority groups to the Government.
Toberpihakan media towards the fate of the Muslim
minority, it has received full support that through the mediaside the
government has recognized the existence of various Islamic movements in
Indonesia that are in the minority group in this case felt by the Wahabi
movement, which demands the state to provide equality of minorities as
perceived by the majority. In this case, achieving equality with the majority
can be interpreted as a reference to the rights of the individual, without
taking into account the collegative rights of the minority, and thus, such a
policy of strengthening individualism can deliberately violate what has been
the main goal of the minority in order to preserve its collective desires. Thus
that the success of this claim of minority rights has been achieved which is
marked by the Existence of the wahabi movement in Indonesia.
CONCLUSION
Whether
we realize it or not, media relations and minority groups in the existence of
Wahhabism, it seems that the media has experienced success in taking sides with
minority groups. Wahhabism who feel part of a minority group, in their success
in building and establishing relations with the media, Wahhabis as part of this
minority group are starting to be able to show success in bringing about new changes,
through the media of minority groups their rights have been successfully
fulfilled, namely, to get equal rights. with the majority without reducing and
being able to preserve their collective will. As evidence, the Wahhabi movement
pioneered by Muhammad Ibn 'abd Wahhab, who came from the Saudi Arabian region
in Ujainah, experienced, has experienced success in developing his ideas about
monotheism and has many followers, and it is seen that the existence of
wahhabis in Indonesia is growing and developing well, because the Indonesian
Government does not question this ideology. Even though it is still seen in the
media that minority groups have not fully gained a place in the media and are
still neglected, and minority groups are often misunderstood by the majority in
the media, with their success in building and maintaining good relations with
the media, minority groups will be able to regain their rights. their right to
return can be fulfilled.
REFERENCES
Abdullah, N., & Mohamed Osman, M. N. (2018).
Islamisation in the Indonesian media spaces new sites for a conservative push. Journal
of Religious and Political Practice, 4(3), 214–232.
Aisyah, M. (2022). Menelusuri
Misinterpretasi Antara Salafi Dan Wahabi Studi Analisis Pandangan Masyarakat
Terhadap Salafi Dan Wahabi Di Indonesia. Fakultas Ushuludin dan Pemikiran
Islam.
Bleich, E., Stonebraker, H., Nisar,
H., & Abdelhamid, R. (2015). Media portrayals of minorities: Muslims in
British newspaper headlines, 2001–2012. Journal of Ethnic and Migration
Studies, 41(6), 942–962.
Cho, M., Lee, J., & Im, J.
(2012). Media Frames and Ethnic Minority Women in Korea: Expanding a Generic
Frame in Minority Studies. Asian Journal of Women’s Studies, 18(4),
108–135.
Davis, D. E. (2009). Being in the
minority is my circumstance, not my identity. African Identities, 7(4),
491–494.
Fitzgerald, M. R. (2010).
“Evolutionary Stages of Minorities in the Mass Media”: An Application of
Clark’s Model to American Indian Television Representations. The Howard
Journal of Communications, 21(4), 367–384.
Goldscheider, C., & Uhlenberg, P.
R. (1969). Minority group status and fertility. American Journal of
Sociology, 74(4), 361–372.
Halabi, Y. (2020). Tiny religious
minorities and minority group rights: the case of the Druze community. Social
Identities, 26(6), 739–755.
Jahroni, J. (2020). Saudi Arabia
Charity and the Institutionalization of Indonesian Salafism. Al-Jami’ah:
Journal of Islamic Studies, 58(1), 35–62.
Mangasing, M. (2008). Muhammad Ibn
‘Abd Al-Wahhâb dan Gerakan Wahabi. Hunafa: Jurnal Studia Islamika, 5(3),
319–328.
McAllister, S. M., & Taylor, M.
(2012). Organizational influences and constraints on community college
web-based media relations. Community College Journal of Research and
Practice, 36(2), 93–110.
Mihlar, F. (2019). Religious change
in a minority context: transforming Islam in Sri Lanka. Third World
Quarterly, 40(12), 2153–2169.
Saleem, M., & Ramasubramanian, S.
(2019). Muslim Americans’ responses to social identity threats: Effects of
media representations and experiences of discrimination. Media Psychology,
22(3), 373–393.
Taylor, M. (2000). Media relations in
Bosnia: A role for public relations in building civil society. Public
Relations Review, 26(1), 1–14.
Widiyanto, A. (2014). Salahuddin
Wahid and the Defence of Minority Rights in Contemporary Indonesia. Al-Jami’ah:
Journal of Islamic Studies, 52(2), 271–307.
Woodward, M., Rohmaniyah, I., Amin,
A., & Coleman, D. (2010). Muslim education, celebrating Islam and having
fun as counter-radicalization strategies in Indonesia. Perspectives on
Terrorism, 4(4), 28–50.
Zhao, Z., & Postiglione, G. A.
(2010). Representations of ethnic minorities in China’s university media. Discourse:
Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 31(3), 319–334.